New ownership! Great food and Great owner! Owner is always there making sure everything is perfect!

My local spot thats always on point. Huge portions. Awesome food. The family that runs Infinity are warm and welcoming. The service is always friendly and beyond helpful. They are fine tuned. Most recent meal was grilled salmon over spinach salad and it was pefectly cooked and fresh... Infinity is perfect any time...Turkey burger with sauteed onions and sweet potato fries. Yum!! Hubby loves the french dip....Delicous coffee and breakfast too...this diner never disapoints. read more

Infinity Diner - Grilled salmon over spinach salad. - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

in looking for a comfort food kind of dinner. We came to Infinity. its a bright clean diner. we were quickly seated at a nice booth (place was filled) with in seconds a basket with rolls bread sticks and butter was on the table along with a bowl filled with noodle veggie salad really fresh and tasty! Friendly enough server but sadly my french toast was just not good I cant place it maybe the bread maybe too much greasy egg mixture but the slices looked way better then the taste. I am always searching for decent comfort food ~service here excellent ~food just eh read more

Infinity Diner - French toast - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Well done infinity Diner first time in this wonderful place was greeted warmly with pleasant and friendly hostess waitress and staff. The food was delicious and served perfectly. This was a pleasant experience and will definitely be back again. Highly recommend this place to everyone looking for a great diner read more

Very solid old-school diner. Just beware it can get really busy on the weekends, but it's definitely worth the wait.

Best diner around, tried the others but always go back to Infinity diner. Fast and friendly service. Great burger

Your classic NY diner. Food here is pretty solid. Owners and staff are all very kind. It's a great neighborhood place that stays busy and has a warm vibe. read more

I've never tried the food. Nope, I haven't. But when I want to treat my brother, despite the 1800 mile distance, I order food for him from Infinity on GrubHub. He absolutely LOVES their food. He gets the build your own omelette, bagel with cream cheese and lox, and a large coffee to go. Every time. Doesn't need anything else. These folks do it right. The food is always fresh, hot and delicious. You ask for extra ketchup, they give it to you. You ask for extra creamer, they give it to you. I'm just jealous I never get to taste the food myself! Would highly recommend for takeout/delivery. Great place! read more

I used to absolutely LOVE this Diner. Now I primarily just go there for brunches since I've noticed changes. The waiting staff has declined over the years it seems. Or maybe it's just the day time. Even caught a couple eye rolls when my friend was ordering and the waitress didn't seem to understand what she was saying when reading it straight from the menu. This is my 2nd experience with this waitress. Both times was quite disappointed. But that's not really my biggest complaint. You are always greeted with a warm welcome and a nice send off. My biggest upset was the Caesar salad. It used to be my all time favoriteee. The chicken keeps changing and changing and now is completely different. And now the DRESSING!? Ugh! Big disappointment. I'm finally at the point that since now that my favorite menu item is completely different I have no reason to come back. I will be finding a new spot to brunch. =( truly makes me sad. That salad has been the bomb for over a decade. This is my honest opinion.... read more

Have never had a bad experience with the service or food. Conveniently located, parking is good.

Friendly staff and good food , great atmosphere, good diner food and more. Good times for friends and family

Food was good service was excellent would definitely go back we all had a wonderful breakfast they certainly didn't skimp on anything bacon piled high and plenty of refills on drinks server was very nice as was the owner who was on hand to make sure all went well read more

Great Food, Fair Prices, Good Portions Friendly Staff I've come here for Breakfast and Dinner not dissatisfied at all

Food is always great as is the service!! Been going here for years, will keep going for years!

To Infinity and beyond... Excellent diner, newly remodeled and opened, this was the old Blue Star diner. The service is top notch: quick, efficient and pleasant. The parking lot is huge and wraps around three of the four sides of the place. The food was terrific - was here for breakfast and had a vegetable omelet that was loaded with yummy veggies. The coffee was at my fingertips as my ass was hitting the seat - a BIG plus for me in particular. Definitely going back. read more

First time at infinity diner and it was great. First off the service was phenomenal and so was the food. We both got the Matzo ball soup and it was great matzo and we also got the gyro platter it was just as great. A great diner overall, highly recommend ! read more

Just a visitor not a regular but quick service, huge delicious portion. Husband even enjoyed split pea soup. Clean. Unique decor friendly staff. Really good experience. Would stop again. They even have juke boxes. read more

Infinity Diner - Turkey Panini and the best onion rings in the world - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Surprisingly clean friendly service Food served quickly Prepared to order Great choices read more

Infinity Diner - Part of menu - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Mmmm. Manhattan sandwich Service was excellent, food was delicious, and the waitress was an absolute doll! Wish i lived closer to this place.!! read more

Another fine dining establishment . Diners have excellent food. Please give this restaurant a try read more

Outstanding food! Been here on average of every 3 weeks with my mother! Mom can't get enough of the Filet Scampi! For me, the wraps, paninis, burgers, salads....everything I've eaten here is made to order and served by a great staff! KUDOS to ALL!!!!! read more

Infinity Diner - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

Service is great. We had Kathy waiting on us. Very pleasant very accommodating. Food was mediocre. Omlet overcooked and under seasoned. Home fries seemed like leftover from breakfast with hard burned pieces and also completely under seasoned. Hubby enjoyed his more. Had a Belgium waffle. Lightly crisp and tender in the middle. Although his food was served on a plate that had multiple big chips. Would have rated 2 stars if not for the great server. Was really hoping for a great diner. read more

Infinity Diner - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Great food! Cooked perfect and great portions! Friendly and nice staff! Had the scallops - perfect!!

Great food and friendly service! We go there all the time . They give good portions and everything is always fresh

I'm a local and I come here almost 3 times a week. I order a select few dishes and haven't been disappointed since. Ownership and staff are very friendly read more

Nope, I swear they put A-1 sauce in the french onion soup. I have been ordering for years from them and that is a horrible and cheap move. It tasted so tangy and was inedible, I just ate the cheese. Ordered meatloaf as well; which was disgusting, gravy was lumpy and tasted like same base of the soup. Need to find new diner. read more

The dining room was clean and our server was friendly. My friend got the potato skins which were bigger than expected and I got a greek wrap with curly fries. Our food came out quickly and tasted great! I especially liked the curly fries. We shared a strawberry shortcake (their cake slices are pretty big), but we weren't the biggest fan of it - the cake was too crumbly. Overall, we had a great dinner and will probably be back. read more

BBQ chicken wrap delicious! Real good chicken quesadillas also Fried calamari better than most too. Highly recommended read more

Always a great meal here and they have the friendliest staff that are always attentive to your needs. The owner and his family treat all customers like they are family and me and my family always leave satisfied and feeling good. Keep up the good work especially during these trying times. read more

Wow this place is bright! A total primary color overload. It is like being inside candy corn. To be completely honest, there was not much else to be grumpy about. The pot roast came out in a large portion, with a small football-sized potato pancake. I did not know whether I should eat it or throw for a first down. It was tasty though, fried crispy with creamy potato inside. The lamb shanks were also tasty. In fact it was the best shank I have had since Sing-Sing. Another large portion with all of the accessories, soup, potato, vegetable. Super tasty and Grumpy was able to take some home too, a rare occurance. So bring sunglasses and dont sit in the second to last booth in the back. There is a spring popping out that women hate. read more

We're new to the area and found a great local diner in infinity. My husband and I had burgers and our 2 year old had Mac and cheese. Everything was fresh and delicious and the chickpea pasta salad was a nice surprise on the table. The portions were large (even for a kids meal). We will definitely be back to try more! read more

Infinity Diner - Kids ice cream - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Amazing place. Just what a diner should be. The owners and staff gave us a warm welcome, the decor is beautiful and I had my first Egg Crème! I had an omelette and my wife had the Lox eggs Benedict. The food was amazing and the service was absolutely wonderful. Thank you for a great experience! read more

Lost one star because my omlet and potatoes where lacking a little flavor... Only two people and three workers but took a little bit to come take our order, or maybe I was just super hungry :-) . Waitress was very nice who served us wish I remembered her name! My Lox and cream cheese bagel was great and I enjoyed the Clam Chowder Red. My mom had corn beef and hash and she said she really enjoyed the hash.... Really nice deco and lots of parking. We Came all the way from Monterey Cali and I would give it another try for sure...Thanks for the good Service for a particular critic, LOL! read more

See all

Worst dining experience of my life. Picked up a avocado burger, chicken Caesar wrap, and French onion soup. The French onion soup went bad and had a stale foul taste to it, the burger had gigantic slices of avocado on it with nothing else no cheese etc., and the chicken wrap was so soggy we couldn't even eat it. If your hungry I'm looking for a good diner pass this one by. read more

Stopped in here while traveling to Long Island for a funeral service. We decided to meet up with other coworkers here before heading over to the service. It was early when we got there and the place was pretty empty. We grabbed a nice booth and ordered our breakfast. Pretty much everyone got the same thing... two eggs over easy with well done home fries and toast. Everything came out quickly and was just like we asked for it. The staff at the Infinity Diner were very accommodating and pleasant to dine with. If I am ever back in that area I will definitely stop back in here. read more

It is with such pleasure that I posted this review. My family experienced such kindness friendliness and delicious food at this diner. The owner of Steve and Kathy were so welcoming. Melanie the waitress was exceptional. The food was great. It was the first time our whole family was together and it really was a joy. To the entire staff at the infinity diner we say thank you thank you thank you! read more

Absolutely love their food! I order breakfast for pick up for the most part but times I have enjoyed other meals dining in, I'm very satisfied. Staff and owner are extremely friendly and welcoming. read more

Service was good. Food was good, even though I ordered my burger medium and it was well done. I wasn't too happy with the cake I ordered for desert, because didn't taste too fresh. It's like it had been sitting in the display for some time. I probably should have gotten something else or nothing else. read more

The food is pretty good...however, the service leaves a lot to be desired. The waitress that I had today (and I've had her before), is a very nasty person. My food came out incorrectly- not the way that I ordered it. When I called her over to say that it wasn't how I ordered it she told me "yes, it is." When I said, no it isn't and showed her she made a nasty face at me - did say a word, and in a huff grabbed the plate and took it back. When it came back out, it was still not correct but in the same attitude as before...she just dropped the plate in front of me and walked away. There are plenty of other diners that you can go to that have good food and servers that aren't nasty and rude. My advice is to go somewhere else. I will not be coming back here. read more

My husband and I absolutely love this diner!! The food is always delicious and the staff is amazing. The Mac n cheese is probably the best I've ever had. I always find it amazing how the owner and his sons seem to know everyone that steps inside of the building. I highly recommend this diner, they will surely treat you like family the second you walk in the door! read more