Came here with family and we all enjoyed! We each got a different type of omelette, Cobb, Ruben, broccoli and cheese, cheddar cheese, plain and someone also ordered pancakes. Everyone stated how great everything tasted! I ordered the Cobb omelette which had bacon, avocado and cheddar and it was delicious! Omelettes were severed with a choice of potato; tator tots, fries or home fries. We all basically had one of each and again, all delicious! Coffee was great too, and never empty. Our server (I wish I got his name!) was great! Bathrooms were also very clean. Our only complaint was the small parking lot. read more

We had swim lessons down the road and went and had a full blown diner feast here and it did NOT disappoint. Mozzarella sticks, chicken & fries (everyone was stealing fries), California burger, Philly cheesesteak panini, chicken francese, and TWO shakes (iced coffee + Oreo, the kids fought over that one ). Fresh, delicious, and the staff were so kind. Bonus: they do character pop-ups too! Heard Woody from Toy Story AND Moana are stopping by, keep an eye on their page, the kids will love it. 10/10, perfect stop if you're near the park or library! read more

See all

Great diner! Love stopping here when I am on Long Island. Good food, service, great diner feel. Had a fantastic omelet and we also had a panini sandwich. read more

See all

Wow what a great place! A group of us (5 people) went last Sunday and had a great time! Excellent service and we all loved our food. The "Avocado Delight" that I got was so picturesque and delicious read more

Farmingdale Diner - Avocado Delight (avocado toast with burrata!) - Diners Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

The food was not that great The mash potatoes were awful Whatever they are putting in them Is horrendous! The brisket was ok not great! Then we tried something else still not great! The service was impeccable! The Ambiance was so beautifully done I was truly amazed by the Beauty. Maybe what you need is a really good cook or chef! read more

If you get an order to go, they charge you a higher price, 50 cents more for each item to cover the cost of the tin pan. There's nothing on the menu advising you of this extra charge. You also need to double-check your order because I ordered the Herb Crusted Salmon salad, which was supposed to be over baby spinach with feta cheese blueberries, of which none was included. They gave me plain grilled salmon over a regular iceberg salad, which is not what I ordered or paid for! So disappointed read more

Farmingdale Diner - June 2024 - Diners Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Omelette was good, hash browns good, fries good...burger good but a bit greasy for me. Service was pleasant, coffee very good. A strong three stars but I'll only be back if in the area, there are better diners. read more

Okay, now I love this place, i wouldn't change anything about it. That was before they changed their french fry recipe. I have a medical condition called PKU, where I can't break down protein like everyone else. I've eaten at this diner for as long as i've been in farmingdale, and at most restaurants, french fries are usually the only things i can eat when going out because of it being gluten free and lower in protein. Their fries were the only things i was able to eat there, but I can't anymore because the fries are coated in some sort of breading, which is dangerous for me to eat. I know many other people who are disappointed with this, and especially others who are gluten free or have extremely strict dietary restriction/requirements. It's really sad that I can't eat here anymore when places i can eat at are so scarce. The fact that the recipe change wasn't made known to us was very disappointing as well. No harm is meant from this.. I just wanted to put it out there. read more

Large portions, fast service, very friendly staff and entered any questions we had directly

Picked up dinner to go last night and it was so worth not having to cook. The California paninis were delicious, and the chicken was cooked perfectly and super moist. The burgers were cooked to perfect medium and not overdone, even with a 10 minute ride home. The fries were still crisp and not soggy. Just really, really good food with generous portions. I'm eating the other half of my panini for dinner tonight. read more

First time dining here. the reason we came was for the special characters they have for young kids. My son had an absolute blast and I think it's really great idea they do this. However, it did become extremely crowded and bit overwhelming the place isn't that big to begin with. Staff and waiter were great and food was just okay. I was disappointed when they brought my kids chicken tenders and fries out they ONLY gave 3 medium size chicken tenders I mean for 13 Dollars they can at least give 5 or 6. Place could use a little updating. read more

This place has been on my radar for a long time, it's a nice place, clean and well lit, the service was excellent, our server was friendly and attentive, the food was very good, I had the corned beef hash with sunny side up, it was good, and we also had a BLT w/avocado, it was very good read more

See all

Food was amazing. Served hot and in timely fashion. Special events for the kids. Is great. They ask to go there all the time to see the characters. Employees are always sweet and accommodating. read more

Very clean, good service. Came here after spending time at LI National Cemetery. Had the gyro deluxe platter. Classically delicious. The moussaka was authentic and hot. Recommended by many. read more

Everything you want and expect in a diner. Juicy burger, crisp fries and excellent cole slaw. Overall excellent value. read more

Farmingdale Diner - Swiss cheeseburger deluxe - Diners Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

We went to this diner for decades with my in-laws and it was always good. We came back to town for a funeral, had breakfast there (arguably the easiest meal to make) and it was awful. The eggs were runny, omelettes undercooked (one accidentally had noodles in it-- not sure how that happened at 8am) and the hash browns were more onion and pepper than potatoes. We didn't complain at the time because we honestly didn't think it would help. We paid the bill and just got out of there with most of the food still in the table. These are obviously different owners. They're advertising meals with Disney characters to try to attract families with little kids, but they need to focus on improving their food and not gimmicks. read more

Still great service!! Still one of my families go to spots. I'm home sick and the matzo ball soup is pretty much all I can consume so thank you! Delicious read more

Farmingdale Diner - Char Broiled Pork Chops special - Diners Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

The outside of this diner looks a little dated. The inside, like an old fashioned diner is clean. The prices were extremely high compared to other local diners and the food was average, with the portions on the smaller size. There is an up-charge for everything and they only have breakfast specials during the week. We ordered Lox, Eggs and onions with egg whites, turkey bacon, Spanish omelette and rye toast. I added a small tomato juice (which was very expensive), the price was at least $15 more than their competitors, and honestly not worth it. The Spanish omelette was watery and leaked all over the plate. The home fries were good. The toast, a little burnt. The LEO was average and nothing to run back here for. The turkey bacon was very good. The staff was very friendly and the coffee service is better then most local diners. The same breakfast we've had in local diners came to about $32-34. My bill here was $52. read more

See all

Great food, Great service the waitesses are very friendly and accommodating. The dinner has been all redone inside it has a warm cozy appeal. Highly recommended. read more

Farmingdale Diner - Dinning area - Diners Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

We stopped by on Christmas Eve for a late breakfast. We ended up getting some OJ, pancakes, avacado toast and a Italian omelette with home fries. I thought the pancakes were really good and so was the syrup which didn't taste like that normal diner syrup. The Italian omelette with home fries was good and had a good amount of meat, cheese and tomato in it. The avacado toast on the other hand was just blah and could've used some flavor to it. Service was good and place was clean. Would go back if passing by. Parking lot is small. read more

See all

The best Fountain Diet Coke on Long Island.!! The staff is always so friendly and the restaurant is kept very very clean. There specials are reasonable and delicious. read more

A BLT with avocado is pretty simple, right? No way they could f@ck that up, right? WRONG!! They were out of sourdough so I ask for toasted rye. I got a soggy sandwich with mushy tomatoes, brown rotten avocado, wilted, brown lettuce and bacon. And a puddle of coleslaw. This place used to be great. Their prices are out of control ($35 salmon anyone?) and it feels rundown and dirty. Do yourself a favor and go a little further down the road to Empire diner. You'll thank me later. read more

Terrible . Over cooked eggs and burnt bacon, dry turkey club, and the Bloody Mary grosssssss for 15$ . This was the biggest waste of 85$ for breakfast ! Parking was just as bad read more

Farmingdale Diner - Bad bad and bad - Diners Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

We have been to this diner for a couple of their character theme days, and both times the staff was extremely nice and welcoming. We were at the last Mickey Mouse one and I thought it was cute they gave the kids a coloring book and cupcake. Mickey and Minnie were very interactive and made multiple trips to our table. We enjoyed our food, the milkshakes were delicious, and my daughter loved seeing the characters! read more

Ever since moving to Farmingdale, this has been my to-go diner. Food and service are great! read more

See all

Let's begin with showing up to the diner for one of the themed Saturday mornings to meet the characters. We showed up with two children and three adults and were shoved into a booth. We wanted more of a theme to occur, like maybe part of the menu? Decorations? Grasp the attention of the kids. They attempted to put it on the tv but it turned into Sophia the first and sonic (both not the theme). Even play the music of the theme?!? Anything?! Ok now let's get into the characters... when you walk up toward the kids please don't play with your masks and body suits and show off your neck or make it look as if you're about to take the head of the costume off because us as parents would've had a heart attack and the kids would be traumatized if they saw, so word of advice. Don't touch the costumes - and to the staff stop talking to the people in costumes (it's who we came to see, and be in character mode). Staff wise our server rocked, food wise pretty damn tasty. Sorry I didn't start with that but figured I'd give the bad news first. read more

We came here for an early dinner on Saturday. The service was fast and friendly. The main entrees tasted delicious except for the salads. Overall, we liked it and would come back if we're in the area. read more

Farmingdale Diner - The New Yorker Panini - Diners Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Worst diner experience ever!! Way overpriced and the food wasn't even good! Spent $51 on 2 omelettes without any potatoes; I was told the English muffin jacked the price up!! And they got my omelette wrong to begin with and I got a tasteless omelette on the 2nd try!! Stay away!! read more

Today was our first visit for the Mario event. They made the event so special for the kids with Mario coloring pages for the table, Mario balloons for the kids, rings/crowns, and a free milk shake for the kids. The characters were so sweet and came around multiple times and took pictures! We will for sure be back for more character events!! Not only was the experience great, the food was excellent! We all enjoyed our breakfast! All the staff were so nice and were so attentive even with the large crowd! read more

Food was great. A lot of food. Wound up taking most of it home. Service was amazing i must say. HOWEVER this dbag wound up talking on his cell phone the whole damn time sitting in a booth solo and it was beyond annoying Dude take your call elsewhere no one else needs to hear your life story much less me. THanks. read more

Great breakfast, rueben omelet, peach pancakes and mimosas. Service was very attentive and reasonable prices. Great job and meal. read more

This place is DIRTY! I was looking for a restaurant to go with friends from out of town close to where they would be saying. Unfortunately, I was deceived by all the good reviews so I am writing this HONEST review to warn other potential patrons. Upon walking in, you can see that the place isn't cleaned often. The bench I was sitting on looked dusty/grimy. The waiter brought me coffee and there was something orange (a carrot peel? something else?) towards the top of the cup, betraying the fact that the cup was NOT WASHED or at least not washed thoroughly enough for service to a person. I informed the waiter and he argued with me, asking me to show him the dirty spot! Eventually he gave me a new cup of coffee. Before this telling discovery, I made the huge mistake of ordering eggs at this filthy establishment. Since then, I've had stomach upset and several restroom visits....something tells me the eggs were either not stored properly or not cooked properly. STAY AWAY. read more

I ordered a pizza, burger and what I was served was a regular burger with mozzarella cheese with a side of the cheapest marinara sauce I've ever had. I cannot believe that I had to pretty much make my own pizza burger at my table. You can tell no love put into preparing my food. I ordered a calamari to go for my fiancée to bring her something and I couldn't believe the amount of calamari they gave me. As I am writing my review, I'm eating the calamari and it's soggy, if you look at how many pieces they gave me I only received 14 calamari rings, and I paid I believe $12.50 for this. The burger was mediocre. The best thing about my plate was the waffle fries. Good thing I ordered a Coke. the service was OK. In this place, you have to pay on your way out and the Greek owner or whoever he was couldn't help, but rush me out telling me to write any number on the receipt and snatching it out of my hand, we look each other in the eyes for maybe five seconds I couldn't believe how I was treated on my way out. The ambience of the restaurant itself is a regular degular diner it looks like any other one I've ever been to, but definitely would not be coming back here. The only reason I don't give it a lower rating is because it's a place that you can go to get something at decent to eat that's open till 12 around this area but definitely wouldn't recommend this place to anybody. This is a last resort type of place try not to go here. read more

See all

Rancheros omelette is one of the best I have ever had! Front desk lady always welcomes us with a smile and new management that acquired this diner (since after pandemic) is really doing an amazing job with service and cleanliness. read more

My husband and I stopped by for breakfast this morning. I ordered eggs over easy, bacon and fries. The eggs were a good size and were cooked over easy not overdone. The bacon was crispy and the rye toast was also crispy. My husband loved the poached eggs over corned beef. We will Go back there. read more

Thanksgiving at a DINER??? Never thought it would happen to me... and my family as well, but it did. My work schedule, my wife's & even my son's made it impossible to have a home-cooked meal this Thanksgiving. We found ourselves at The Farmingdale Diner on Hempstead Tpke in Farmingdale. Upon entering, it smelled very good, just like a Thanksgiving should smell. Just like grandma's house. We were not disappointed with the menu. The turkey was moist. The stuffing was not out of a box like at home. It was cooked from scratch with apples, rasins, and cornbread. Yams, broccoli, soups, pies cappuccinos, and more. Everything was delicious. The server made us feel welcome, and we had a good time with him. He suggested things from the extensive menu that I did not even see the first time through. We are back again tonight to have more of the top shelf food that they serve. Not just a diner. The new owners come from a catering background, and it shows. I was happy to see that I can take out a large meal with all the trimmings for when we have guests over the house. I will happily take the compliments for the food! My food has just been put on the table, and that will conclude this review. This is our new go- to place! read more

Neat little diner...pleasant courteous and fast service...attentive but not overbearing. A delicious breakfast, eggs, potatoes, link sausage, juice and a pleasant surprise, it came with a little home made corn muffin "appetizer" read more

The food is good but what a rip off. I was charged 9.95 for two pancakes on the side Then another 3.23 service charge for credit card. Never going back even though it's close to home read more

We had the nicest waiter! Super friendly! Had eggs, sausage and well done fries... it was delish!

Hi friends, welcome to the Farmingdale Diner. My favorite Diner on Long Island has had a change of ownership. It's no longer owned by Steve and staffed by his 4 Brothers. I've been here 6 times since their change of hands. Mostly my visits are for breakfast, as it's just about still the best meal anywhere. I have noticed some changes in the dinner service and aviance however. I really love my Long Island Diner and I'm very small business-friendly. That being said, I also have a responsibility to my yelpers. I can't have a previous 5-star review describe this venue when it's no longer appropriate. I can still very much recommend the most wonderful breakfasts here. This relaxing experience has not changed. The breakfast is still top-notch, the sausage and ingredients have not changed. I pair my eggs with their delicious Hollandaise sauce (+$2). There's a higher level of hospitality and service that I'm accustomed to here during breakfast. My dinner experience Sunday night's experience was different than any I'd had. Sitting down, I immediately noticed the difference. Usually Billy sits me at the booth in the corner, knows exactly what I want & brings everything to the table without a word needed. It was uncomfortable being a stranger now in a place I have visited hundreds of times. You now must ask for the extras that are included with your meals, because they are no longer automatically provided. After a few minutes I noticed I was not asked if I wanted the complimentary glass of wine and I was not given my bread basket, I was not given my side dishes of beets, coleslaw or the garbanzo beans. When I asked for these items, my servers response was .."oh you want that? I don't know if they do that anymore". I told my server that these items were mandatory. She searched for them for a little while and I believe opened some fresh cans for me. A chill ran down my spine! These are the included amenities expected by "EVERYONE", all of your regular customers are accustomed to these automatically included with your dinner specials for many years. They would include a basket of bread, complimentary glass of wine, pickled beets, chilled pasta and beans, coleslaw, pickles. (Check my previous photos) These complementary items, were traditionally brought without customers having to uncomfortably ask for them. Usually there's a wait line for Sunday night dinner. I was able to park and immediately, sit down without waiting. Now I know why. Just a few months ago this place was packed. Now it's empty of the regular customers. In 6 months, I can't believe they went downhill so quickly. I called Farmingdale Diner before rewriting my review and was hung up on 4 times? That was a first. How can your struggling restaurant be so comfortable hanging up on their cu$tomers? There's never a second chance to make a first impression. Hire & maintain a professional greeter to be the voice and first impression of your business. They handle telephone calls, respond to social media, coordinate deliveries. I made suggestions to help return the positive experiences here. I didn't recognize the taste of my Caesar salad from different greens and dressing. Please don't change anything. Stick what with what has worked many years. Please conduct a retraining of your evening Staffing. Don't let the Busboys noisily Clank dishes in back of your customers while bussing the tables. Put a towel on top of the tray, it helps to muffle the noises. Recognize your regular customers and lavish the attention on them that they're accustomed to here. Low-cost UV light traps will capture the flies that now land on the food. Train the staff not to be loud about issues, so your customers can't hear. Make sure the Bread Basket comes with hot, fresh pieces of bread. Please bring back the delicious breadsticks. When a glass of wine is included with the meal, please ask your customers if they would like it. Don't make us have to ask for what was included. The appetizers included need to be immediately brought to the tables without the customers asking. Don't have me have to get up after my meal is over and search for my check. My waitress was very aware of my displeasure as I mentioned the frequency of my former visits (200+) several times. Curiously, she didn't offer apologies or any dessert to compensate. I never saw her again at the conclusion of my meal. Thanks for offering me compensation in the future. Stopping back, for breakfast at Farmingdale Diner a few days later, everyone was so apologetic concerning my poor experience. Breakfast was wonderful as always and they simply would not accept my money or even write me a check for my meal in compensations. It seemed my poor experience may be narrowed to the actions of a new server. I am grateful this kind action earned an extra star returned to their review. read more

See all