Base my reviews off what you pay: *Place was pretty packed but had no issues getting a table. This place is a deli. Price - $30 (appetizer, entree, beverage (free refills), tip) Food - 4/5 - solid food, huge amount. Service - 3/5 - solid, nothing beyond. Ambiance - 3/5 - typical diner feel. Overall - 3/5 - solid diner and that is all it is. Food tasted like a diner, got diner service, and diner vibes. Only thing worth noting is you will get a massive amount of food. Ordered fish and chips and received a pretty size-able salad along with it, 5 pieces of fish, not to mention the additional pasta salad and other small sides (pasta salad was pretty bad IMO). Overall if you are hungry and looking to eat diner food, this is a good stop. Aside from that, nothing worth going out of your way for. Best Dish - nothing to note read more

This is a pretty solid diner at the intersecting borders of Farmingdale, Lindenhurst & W. Babylon. It doesn't get too crowded on weekends and you can usually get a parking spot in the lot surrounding the restaurant. We've been here usually late Saturday morning for brunch and breakfast is served all day. Whether you're looking for some bacon & eggs, omelets, pancakes or a cheeseburger deluxe, you'll find it on their expansive menu. There's even a whole page of chicken sandwiches! Since this is a Greek diner, you'll also find gyro & souvlaki, along with 2-3 soups of the day and they rotate depending on the day of the week. If they have any of my favorites, Cream of Turkey, Split Pea or New England Clam Chowder, I'll always get a cup of soup to start. The daily lunch specials include a variety of different sandwiches and wraps, as well. You can't wrong with a burger deluxe, complete with lettuce, tomato & French Fries. Feel free to ask to substitute home fries, curly fries or sweet potato fries. If I'm in the mood for breakfast, even in the afternoon or evening, I like over easy eggs on corned beef hash with the yolks running over the hash, along with sides of home fries and toast. My wife will usually go for an omelet and she'll get a Farmer's, Western or customizes her own. She likes to get grits as her breakfast side instead of home fries. And if I get a sandwich or burger, she usually steals my pickle O.o, but I secretly stash the bonus onion ring for myself. read more

See all

They become VERY Expensive . They are under new management and it went to there heads. The food was good but now I don't know. Forget About It !!!!!!! read more

Infinity Diner - Eddie Spadaro - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

They were very welcoming. The waitress was very nice as well I got the western omelette with American cheese added comes a home fries and a side of toast. We also got the French toast with sausage and an over medium egg.I will definitely come back! read more

Infinity Diner - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Ordered three food items. Was only served two. That's fine - maybe I did not need 3 items? One of the items was spinach pie (Spanakopita). The Spinach & feta filling was very good. The Filo dough shell was spoiled, tho. When I told the server, he then told the head server, who then started a loud fight with me, & would not credit the cost for the item. She then told me she was taking photos of me, & calling 911! I still then left a 20%+ tip on the remainder of my bill, which I paid in cash. Also note: the Spanakopita was only $10. Was it worth all this plus a 1-star review? Nice work, everyone ! read more

One of the best diners I have ever been to!!! They gave us a pasta salad for free as an appetizer and it was delicious I tell you! The right amount of zing healthy and fresh! The carrots in it were delicious with just the right amount of crunch! Our waitress was a fairy godmother type of a woman. She definitely deserves a raise as she enticed me to add fries to my order! My curly fries were cooked perfectly and tasted delicious and savoury. Oh and the burger I ordered was the Soho mushroom burger. It was the most delicious and juicy burger I have ever tasted and this is not an exaggeration! Owner if you see this review can you please tell me your secret! - Super yummy coffee, very fresh lettuce, tomato and cole slaw with great service - Coffee and soda refills kept coming! read more

Infinity Diner - Free Pasta Salad -04/05/2024 - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

Best diner ever! Been coming here all my life and the staff is the most friendly group of people. The food is great and it's perfect no matter the time of day. I'll come here forever! read more

The service was very good but the food was horrible. I ordered the Lumber Jack and the pancakes were thin and rubbery, the bacon was of poor quality and tasted bad. The home fries were plain and had zero flavor. I took one bite of the sausage link and left the rest. It did not taste good either. My friend got an omelette with avocado and cheese, and he left half of it stating that it did not taste good at all. My photo was after I decided to put it and myself out of its misery but you can see the bacon, thin pancakes and home fries as described earlier. read more

Infinity Diner - Home fries, thin pancake and poor quality bacon. - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Stopped in for breakfast and the experience was just ok. Service was friendly and attentive but the food was only so-so. Coffee was hot but bland, omelette lacking in the flavor department as were the home fries. Not awful, just not memorable. Prices were very reasonable though, so for a quick bite in this area you could definitely do much worse. read more

Super large portions. Quick service. Friendly/attentive staff. Have been coming here for over 10 years when I'm on Long Island. It's my grandma's favorite diner. I love all of their greek food so much (salad, spinach pie). My grandma loves all of their dinner specials, which are very affordable given the portion sizes (3 pork chops at once!). I'll be back for as long as my grandma wants diner food :) read more

This is a so so diner. Some of the food was good, some was completely inedible. The service was slow, but it was very busy. We had: - Turkey Burger - good - Chocolate Chip Pancakes - good - Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap - so so - Chicken Souvlaki Pita - inedible. The chicken was reheated and had a gelatinous chewy consistency. It also needed a ton of salt. Next time we are in Long Island, I don't think we will eat here. read more

The staff here was very friendly and the service was very good. The vibe is fun with oldies music playing. Prices were very reasonable. Our food came out exactly how we had ordered it and everything was delicious. We loved it all and will definitely be back! read more

The food is absolutely rancid . We came as family of 5 and only two of us were able to eat our food . No one ever asked how it was . We called waitress over to table and she was very rude . Too much to text . Quick add the bathroom is worse then Penn station read more

Tried again. Just NOT consistent and the owner DOESN'T want to hear about it. Such a disappointment. I thought this might be a great place to eat. Not going back again. read more

See all

Pretty good diner, but closes way too early for a typical diner, good service and did enjoy the ambiance - my typical 3 stars for a diner

Love this place I came here often, food is great, service is great, parking is always available, and get seated quickly.

Did takeout for them. Prices are great. They give you so much food. I got the turkey dinner it could have fed more than one person . Came with two sides, and a soup and for 4 dollars more you can do a dessert.. which I did lol . Will be ordering from them all the time. Old school original diner , how it should be! read more

This diner has been in business a very long time. It use to be called The Bon-Ton diner in the 60s.and after they remodeled it they changed the name but under the same management. I have had broiled lamb chops and steaks that were cooked perfectly and they also have a large breakfast selection,I just love their breakfast sausage and corned beef hash. So if you're in the area an give them a try.they will treat you just like family. read more

See all

Things have changed since the new owners took over. The food is not even close to what it used to be.

Horrible food!!! I had ordered a lot of food from here , having company wanted something fast and good ! Well, t-bone steak was like an old piece of rubber, chicken so dry , roast beef couldn't even chew ! Not to mention the baked potatoes with old bacon pieces on them !! I called to explain to the owner n he was absolutely rude, told me to call door dash about it, and than hung up on me !! What a waste of money and time !! read more

Waited long time for order to be taken and then get check. As for the food: omelets were brown on the entire outside mushy on inside and tasted like grease. I could not eat mine the bus boy took it away. Spoke to the owner on the way out and she did not even flinch as she rung us up and charged us full price. Despite the fact we do go there for dinner. read more

This place is a diner that most people, I hate to say go to after a funeral service. The service was friendly. The food I found to be horrible. I was really looking forward to some comfort food, not the case. The Greek dressing really wasn't Greek. My Greek salad had one grape leaf and 3 olives. I was stealing my daughter's french fries that were ok... I wouldn't recommend or go back.I almost forgot how the coffee was like mud! 5 creamers and it was still black. How does a diner have horrible coffee. Starbucks is across the street BTW! read more

See all

Went there last weekend for the first time. Some of the orders in our party included French Onion soup, Eggs w/Corned Beef Hash and a Grilled chicken wrap. The soup: very watery and bland--no flavor. It was bad. Won't order that again here. The wrap: very dry chicken with absolutely no flavor either. It was so bland, salt and pepper was dumped on it but that didn't help. a few bites of it was eaten and we didn't bother to take the rest home -what a waste. The fries that came with the wrap were good. Lastly the eggs/corned beef .--Excellent! Cooked perfectly and delicious. I'll give this place another try with other dishes but if just eggs are good here, it's not worth the diner prices you pay. Also, Friendly attentive staff. read more

See all

We went here after having a funeral to go in nearby Beth Moses Cemetery. We spoilt the shrimp salad special, coffee and chicken noodle soup. It was nice to be in a diner again after such a long tome. They were following all the Covid rules. read more

See all

You are beyond hungry and pretty much anything would do, accept eating here. The staff and service are both perfectly fine however it is the quality of food that is unacceptable. My son ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a roll, how can that go wrong? Put slices of Kraft "cheese food" on it...! Gross. Looks like plastic. He could not eat it. The roll was not fresh and my bagel was not either, clearly not from a nearby bagel shop but perhaps a freezer. Potatoes tasted like they were either from yesterday or perhaps a can. Supremely disappointed, never again. read more

I am very disappointed in this restaurant I've been coming in for years. Food was amazing. I ordered something from Uber food wasn't up to standard. I ordered a Texas burger with fries, lettuce and tomatoes. The lettuce was wilted then I ordered the cake the chocolate cake it was soggy very disappointed I give it one not even a star read more

The food is great. Been going there since they've been opened. The staff is always polite

I've been here a few times this year. I usually have a bacon cheeseburger. I'm very satisfied with the quality and size of the burger. Very tasty. I like that they include a pasta salad, pickles and very edible cole slaw. Service is hectic at times but fairly attentive. I wish that Infinity was closer to my home. read more

Very nice diner. Has a good selection of food. Service is ok, friendly and quaint atmosphere. Regular person's eating establishment.

As far as diners go Infinity is 4.5 stars. Food is always very good, service is lightning fast, and the entire staff is friendly. Price is very reasonable compared to other diners in the area. read more

I always recommend this Diner, not only for the amazing food but for the Skaliotis Family, 5 stars food read more

Infinity Diner - Breakfast can't better that this ! - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

Ive always had it as a takeout and they've always satisfied. Service is quick the food taste great and the ambience is second to none.

We like the food from here we always get the staples, cheeseburger deluxe with mozz fries and gravy. Also chicken fingers. Fast quick service and always very nice read more

This is one of the best diners on Long Island. Portion sizes are so large, you get two meals out one plate! Service is always fast and friendly, regardless of how busy they are. Ambiance is loud but private if you are sitting in a booth. My recommended meal is the seafood stuffed flounder. Comes with two sides. And make sure to get their signature dessert - rice pudding. It'll make your eyes cross it's so good. read more

This place used to be a go to. Ever since the pandemic it's gone downhill. Quality of food is not the same; particularly the meat and the fish. Some of the long time staff don't seem to be there anymore and the ones that are clearly don't enjoy or prioritize service anymore. I've given them so many chances but there are so many other diners with better food and waitstaff who don't hate their lives. read more

We were in need of a quick lunch so we went here. The service was great. Our food came out fast and hot! I had the 3 cheese quesadilla with onion rings. My husband had an egg white omelette. If we are in the area, again we'd surely go back. read more

Infinity Diner - 3 cheese quesadilla w onion rings - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

New ownership! Great food and Great owner! Owner is always there making sure everything is perfect!

My local spot thats always on point. Huge portions. Awesome food. The family that runs Infinity are warm and welcoming. The service is always friendly and beyond helpful. They are fine tuned. Most recent meal was grilled salmon over spinach salad and it was pefectly cooked and fresh... Infinity is perfect any time...Turkey burger with sauteed onions and sweet potato fries. Yum!! Hubby loves the french dip....Delicous coffee and breakfast too...this diner never disapoints. read more

Infinity Diner - Grilled salmon over spinach salad. - Diners Near Me - West Babylon, New York

So far my husband and I have come here twice. The portions are huge and the staff is very friendly. When you first walk in you automatically get a bread basket and some cold pasta with chick peas and olive oil as a complimentary meal starter. You are also asked if you want a complimentary glass of wine. The first time we came it was pretty busy so our waitress didn't come by very often, but the second time we came the waitress and the hostess both made sure our meals were okay and kept asking us if everything was okay. The bread was great it was worth the calories! I'm trying to stay away from bread and keep my bread and carb intake limited. If I choose to eat a piece of bread now it needs to be good since I'm not having it so often. My husband said the bread was good from the bread basket and he was right. I got spinach pie the first time we came here, and the Arizona salad without the chicken the second time. The salad was huge, they gave me extra cheese and extra walnuts when they found out I don't eat meat. I ate some salad at dinner, then I ate some the next day after that I had to throw it away because salad doesn't last long in the fridge before it starts getting soggy. My husband had the chicken parm twice. Definitely a top diner! read more

See all

Very solid old-school diner. Just beware it can get really busy on the weekends, but it's definitely worth the wait.