En route home from a day trip to Long Island with my family, we were starving and in search of a good restaurant nearby. Fortunately the Infinity Diner was recommended to us and immediately upon seeing the '50s trolley car inspired exterior, I knew we found the right place. As soon as I opened the menu, I was amazed at how vast a selection there was, but I knew I wanted something from the breakfast side. Unfortunately, they were out of pumpkin pancakes, but I got french toast instead, and it definitely hit the spot. Our waitress was also very friendly and accommodating, so that was definitely a plus, as you don't find that in many diners today. My chances of returning here are slim, but should I end up in this part of Long Island again, I'll know where to eat! read more

Great diner, very quick and friendly service. Food comes out quickly, great place to grab breakfast or lunch. The food is typical diner food but overall good quality. And if anyone reads this from Infinity you guys really need to marinate your skirt steaks. I order steak and eggs all the time and the steak is just OK, could be much better if you marinate all your skirt steaks. They come out more tender and more flavorful and less dry. read more

Good food and very generous portions! Place was very busy when we went so that's always a good sign !

The best. My husband and i are regulars here. After moving to the area we tried almost every diner close to home. This by far had the best food, Friendly/good service and the portions are huge. Their omeletes are delicious! They have awesome lunch specials with soup/salad/sandwiches-small portion combos. If you ever want gravy fries, the gravy in this place is out of control! Good gyros and greek salads. Now that im a regular i've noticed lots of their customers are regulars. With so many diners in long island, having a regular clientele says a lot about a place. read more

My BF teased me the other day for going out of our way to visit this diner. We were going food shopping and there was another diner on the way there. No way, I said, there's only one diner in town, and that's Infinity! Delicious food, generous portions, friendly, attentive staff. It's not unusual to be seated by the owner himself, and have him bring you a glass of wine :-) Prices are reasonable. They let you share a dinner, which is more than enough food for two people, especially with the complimentary pasta salad, bread, salad (they will split your salad for you, no kidding they will put it in two bowls!!), and dessert thrown in. You simply can't beat it! read more

My mom and I stopped in on a trip up from Virginia. The food was disgusting. I ordered a veggie omelet with egg whites and my mom ordered the turkey wrap. My omelet was so over cooked that I only ate 1/8 of it. The vegetables were cut badly and did not taste fresh, it was as if they just threw it together last minute. My mom's wrap was soggy and poorly flavored. I wound up getting violently ill from my omelet. My mom's wrap made her nauseous the rest of the day. I would have given this 0 stars if I could. read more

I really like this place. The staff is awesome. Service is great. I Bring my family here, they are always smiling no matter how big the mess. My boys just can't eat without making a huge mess, even at home. However, for some reason every now and again my meal isn't very good at all. This baffles me.. How can my eggs Benedict be wonderfully delicious one day and horrible the next. First time this happened I thought it was just a spoof. I eat here enough to realize it's some random thing here. Whatever it is, I still come here. read more

Been coming here for decades, food is great, portions large, prices are affordable, what more can you ask for.

The place could do a lot better if they concentrate on fewer dishes and upgrade some recipes. We had lunch here and everything that we tasted was bland. Only soup was good according to one person in our group that tried it. After the meal, we all felt very tired and heavy even though we did not consume an excessive amount of food. That was kind of weird. The prices were reasonable and staff was accomodating. I would probably not be back here though unless absolutely out of options. read more

I arrived on Sunday at lunch time after attending a burial ceremony at a local cemetery and the place was packed. I informed the owner that we would be a party of twelve. He advised me that as soon as some tables cleared out he would get us seated. The food was excellent restaurant quality and the service was great. I only wish they were located upstate New York so I could eat there more often. read more

Stopped for breakfast. We loved the bright colorful interior, and the restaurant was impeccably clean. Our waiter was friendly and prompt. The food came quickly, and the portions were generous. Breakfast potatoes were homemade and fresh. Great experience, and we will stop there again! read more

The best diner I know in terms of food quality, value and service. Parking is poor but that's my only complaint. I live in Dix Hills. My choices are Olympic, Premier and Dix Hills. Kills all but Premier in food quality. Premier's food may be a little better but it's much more expensive. If you're a carnivore, try the london broil. Always perfect. Fish and chips will reset your expectations for the dish. Fresh fillets fried to order. No frozen fish cakes. read more

They just got a spruce up! New chairs tables booths etc. Place is spotless clean. Great food and coffee. Staff is super friendly. Owner Tony shows appreciation to regulars. Good breakfast selections. Includes seasonal pancakes like pumpkin. Turkey bacon...egg beaters. read more

After marrying my high school sweetheart in a last minute ceremony, our group of about 12 needed a place to celebrate. Our officiator lived in West Babylon and we found this diner. We thought "the Infinity diner!?! That's perfect, we'll last forever!". At my now reception dinner, my family and friends ordered just about everything off the menu. My hubby had a bacon cheeseburger, I had french toast, our parents had huge pasta dishes, and we toasted with chocolate milkshakes. At the end, the waitstaff offered us a slice of lemon meringue pie- a piece of which we froze and had a year later . This little place inadvertently became a huge part of my wedding day and an awesome kick start to what has been a successful marriage. Everyone was so nice and understanding of our large last minute group and they really helped us celebrate. Thank you! read more

Great menu. Tasty food for a great price. Never walked out hungry. Staff is pleasant. Favorite dinner in town. Family loves it.

Good diner with a lot of healthy options. Breakfast is my fav meal and the portion sizes are large!!!! :)

Great Diner! Owner is very nice, never a bad experience, great food, reasonable prices and always greeted with a friendly attitude!

Def my favorite diner!! As soon as you walk in the door the owner greets you immediately with a smile. Seating is quick and always fabulous service. Love the complimentary bowl of pasta salad! Have never ordered anything that wasn't great, from breakfast to dinner selections. Huge menu and fair prices. Their take out is delish also. Been going here since they opened. Always leave there with a smile read more

Not sure how they make money at this place. The portions were gigantic and good diner quality. Loved the complimentary pasta salad and wine. Everyone was pleased with their dish from the 2 year old to the 70 year old. The service and friendliness is extraordinary. read more

The Infiniti Diner is a roll model for other Diners & Restaurants. This very well run restaurant is a tribute to the management for its cleanliness, service & quality of food served to customers . My wife and I travel 25 miles several times a month to have Lunch in this friendly atmosphere. I would easily rate this as the one of the best Diners on Long Island. read more

Good solid diner fare. Nice staff, clean and well decorated.

Great local diner. Always fast service for breakfast or diner. Clean . I love the chicken here. My favorite is the chicken souvlaki dinner , so tender. They also always give a little house made pasta and chick pea salad when you sit for dinner, delicious start . read more

Great diner with a super friendly and attentive staff! I love their gyro platter and they make the best Greek dressing. I could drink that stuff! read more

Fresh food, good portions, and friendly service. I noticed a child receiving a lollipop from the owner on the way out. This seems to be a very popular spot with the locals, and that doesn't surprise me. In today's world of average diners, this one stands higher than the rest. Keep it up, Infinity. read more

Fantastic breakfast and coffee and the owner and staff always treat you great. I went here recently with a friend for her birthday. I didn't tell the waitress but she overheard me talking about it and automatically came and said happy birthday and gave her cake! They are all always so nice here! read more

We come here when in the area and always enjoy the food, the service and the experience. Friendly faces at the front desk too, I give them five stars! read more

Love this diner!!!!..I have been here at all hours & the food is consistently good, the service friendly and the portions great. They are always pleasant and the soups are terrific!!! read more

We stop here every time that we stay nearby for a show at Nikon Jones Beach. The meals are quality diner food and the service is good very friendly. The place isn't too big but we've never had to wait long. Definitely recommend it! read more

Great diner. A lot of selections. Good wheelchair accessibility and they were very nice when we came in to help us with a good table. The wait staff was very friendly and couldn't be more accommodating and helpful. Portions were a nice size. Clean diner - they came several times to our table to clear away things. read more

Food was ok but overpriced. $11.50 for a spinach omelet and $9 for a turkey wrap w no side. What happened to diners where you used to get soup, salad, entree, desert and coffee for one low price? read more

Amazing diner! Go-to spot for my family and friends. Big fan of the burgers and mozzarella sticks. Extremely friendly and attentive, love this place! read more

Food was tasty and abundant, fast service, clean, pleasant decor. Added to my bookmark list. read more

When it comes to eggs and burgers, diners, for the most part, are sure to please. Not this place. I ordered a cheese omelet and specifically asked the server to not have it well done or brown. I also asked for fries instead of home fries because I had a weird craving for some dunked in brown gravy. When the omelet arrived, not only was it brown but it was flat like a crepe and then folded. Not only did It taste awful but there wasn't any cheese. I nicely told her that the eggs were overdone and that the kitchen forgot the cheese. She said she'd make me a new omelet and went to remove my whole plate. I stopped her and I said that I still wanted to pick on my fries while I waited. The new omelet arrived and this time it was oozing cheese, undercooked on the inside (slimy) and brown on the outside AND flat like a crepe. Have you ever experienced anything less than a fluffy omelet at a diner? Diners are pros at making eggs! Adding insult to injury, they charged me $2.25 for the brown gravy (of which I barely used because it was just ok)- Upon check out, I nicely told the gentleman at the cash register all of the above and his comment to me was that the brown gravy was listed on the menu! Who would knowingly pay $2.25 for a small half cup of brown gravy? He didn't take it off the bill. The fact that the kitchen made awful omelets he should've at least comped the gravy. I won't be back to this place! read more

The infinity Diner is my favorite Diner. It's located on 109. The food is absolutely delicious the owner of the place is always smiling. There used to be a girl named Shannon that works there she was really good waitress one of my favorites. read more

Ugh I hate when my omelette is over cooked. I felt like I was eating pieces of the grill. The service was very quick but the downside to that was the waitress brought out the bill without asking if we wanted anything else - really would've liked at least 1 refill on my coffee . I felt very rushed between that and the signs posted that there is a time limit for dining at the tables. read more

All around a great diner. Excellent service, good food, and large portions to go with it. Would definitely go back again.

My single favorite diner on the island. Great staff, good food, and stupid massive panninis.

Great food, menu, service! Best diner in the area! Will definitely go back.

My favorite diner. They have great food, great atmosphere and the owners are so great! I recommend coming here anytime!

My husband and I love this diner. Even when busy we get sat pretty quickly. Whoever is at the register is always friendly and jokes with our daughter. The prices are good and always given more food than can finish (yeah leftovers)! While parking can be difficult sometimes, that just means lots of people like to eat there. read more