went with my husband a few weeks back and I have to say it was less than subpar. The only thing that made it worthwhile was our beautiful server Gabriella she made sure we had an amazing experience and I am so grateful for that. I've been back since and when I saw she wasn't there we left expeditiousl. I don't recommend this to anyone but thank you Gabriella for showing us the best time!!!! read more

Had a great meal and good service! I will definitely be dining here again. Why not 5 stars you ask? I don't know, I just didn't feel like it, you sound like my wife, leave me alone.... Something seemed familiar about the menu and then I found out the same owners own the Spinning Wheel, another of my favorite places to eat. Ignore the "Diner Snobs", this place is good - two thumbs up! read more

$34 for a chicken Caesar salad and a bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich with a side of potatoes is absolutely uncalled for. I will never stop into this business again. What a complete rip off for bland, mediocre food. read more

Pretty good food, service is questionable. Waitresses are rarely kind, and hardly check in to see of everything is good.

Went for brunch today, the dining room was full as it was the first time I darkened the doors of Flemington-Raritan Diner. Wife ordered eggs, hash browns, fruit cup and wheat toast. I had eggs, sausage, bacon and pancakes. Nothing here hard to fix yet the hash browns were missing some brown color (not cooked enough) and the wheat toast was cooked too much (burnt). As for the pancakes, light and fluffy they were not, they were heavy and doughy. Sausage and bacon, cooked to perfection. Paying was interesting. Walked up to the counter with my credit card and bill in my extended hand and the guy says "are you ready?" Really? What happened to How was your meal? or Hi, everything OK/how are you? Ps. To all the cheeseburger reviewers, I agree, not much taste in between that bun. read more

I've never had a bad meal here and fast service. Good coffee is always a true mark of a good diner and they have the best.

Food is very good but beware when you do take out. They leave stuff out of your bag and by the time you get home, it's just not worth the trek to get what you're missing, such as side salads, breads, dressings, etc. check your bags thoroughly before you leave! I don't think it's done on purpose but it's also not fair to the customer to not get what you paid for. read more

I'm liking this new diner, close to home, clean and typical diner menu. The soups are not outrageously good, which disappoints if you like the traditional Jersey diner soups... barley, pea soup, lentil... but they are okay. The burgers were good, the chicken salad sandwich and corned beef... all good. Definitely diner food, don't go out on a limb for the fancier meals, that's just my 2 cents. The breakfasts were very good. We liked the Benedict Style eggs over the potato pancakes with the ham.... got that more than once. YUMMY. I hope that this place keeps up with the clientele. People around here have become spoiled by having some fine choices for food, both quick eats and finer meals... so if this place doesn't remain CLEAN and keep up with the staples, burgers, sandwiches, SOUPS, breakfast... could be problematic down the road! But for today... happy with this diner. Give this place a try... read more

We are glad this has opened, we love the original in Washington, NJ and this is just as good. The matzoh ball soup is terrific, my husband is addicted to the Greek Salad, our kids love the turkey dinner. Friendly, good table service too. read more

Everything was delicious...soup, chicken parm and chicken avocado wrap. We will def stop here when we are in the area again. Great service too read more

I honestly believe that people never venture out far enough away from town to experience what food is SUPPOSED to taste like. This place is in the running for absolute worst diner that I have ever had the misfortune to find. The place was clean..I'll give them that. But the food is always bland, lukewarm and dried out. The wait staff is always too preoccupied talking and giggling amongst themselves. They would rather do that than attend to the customers. I've given this place five or six tries but it always ends in major disappointment. My advice would be to drive past this diner and give something else a try. Even a dumpster would yield a better meal. read more

Chicken cheesesteak and split pea soup were great! Staff always friendly, great service.

Always a consistent meal and the amount of food you get for the price is a great but. I never leave that place anything but stuffed and I'm usually taking something home. Never usually a wait for a table and if there is, they have you seated within 15 mins. Service is always great, good is delivered fast, but not too fast. My go to diner of choice in the area. read more

I have to say, every time I go to flemington diner I always ask myself why I came again after promising I wouldn't. I miss the old management, it's definitely gone down hill. I went around 645 with my father, it was busy but there were plenty of open tables. We were told there would be a 10-15 minute wait for two. The restaurant wasn't full. Being 9 months pregnant with high blood pressure, we asked if we could be seated at an open table. The lady at the hostess desk - I'm assuming the owner stated "were backed up and there's a wait, the waitress won't get to you, you're going to have to wait a bit". I'm so pregnant I don't even have ankles at this point Still blows my mind there was a wait with open tables, they weren't short staffed. As soon as I mentioned leaving and going to Clinton Station Diner to my dad, we were seated. The food was subpar again today. My raviolis looked like a dish I could've made at home with marinara on top, no mozzarella cheese for $13 My dad had the Annandale burger and was pleased with it. read more

Classic Diner with huge menu. Everyone can find what they like. Very accommodating for our large group and fast service.

Stopped there after a lacrosse tournament. Excellent food. Excellent service. Very Nice dining area.

Always a good diner experience no matter whether it's lunch or breakfast or dessert. Staff has always been friendly and food comes quickly. My favorite lunch special is the portabella turkey burger, which comes with soup and fries. The split pea soup is my fave, and the fries are consistently amongst the best in town IMO. read more

The food is highly overpriced. $45 for breakfast for 2. $4 just for 10oz of not fresh Oj is just ridiculous. The food was terrible my med well steak was burnt to a crisp the scrambled eggs were gooey on the inside. The home fries were all very burnt. The toast had enough butter to kill a man. All in all everything was terrible and over priced. Told the cashier how bad it was and they said we should've told the waiter that dropped the food and didn't return till he brought the check. Not that we had time to wait another half hour for them to remake both meals with the hopes it would be better. All in all terrible experience and we will never return again. read more

This diner shines during Breakfast. Everything I've tried has been excellent. The matzo ball soup is a take out must.

Let me start by saying the place is decorated very nicely. Now for the food. It's a typical diner fare with typical diner menu. My wife and I both ordered the open faced roast beef sandwich with gravy. Figuring we're in a diner in New Jersey it should be safe. Well. No. The roast beef was luke warm at best. The gravy was not traditional brown beef gravy, but more of an orange colored gravy that was tomato based with a hint of cinnamon. When they came by to see how things were, we were both honest and told them that we were less than pleased. They immediately offered to replace our meals with something else and adjusted the bill accordingly. I stayed with the sandwich. Karri opted for a chili cheeseburger which she really enjoyed. Bottom line. The roast beef sandwich is not recommended (unless you don't mind a tomato based orange gravy with a hint of cinnamon). The service however, was top notch and they went out of their way to make sure we were satisfied. They've earned a repeat visit next time we are in the area. read more

Second time we've been since new owners. Wasn't great last time. This time -- Not good. I ordered a salad. I expected the chicken to be grilled or atleast fresh. It was a frozen chicken patty--and it was dry to boot. The walnuts on the salad were stale. The dressing came in a packet. The salad was $18. I will not be returning or recommending. This NJ DINER won't be making any best of lists for sure. read more

We went Friday night before the dinner rush. We ordered brisket and a steak. Both were cold with cold baked potatoes and elementary cafeteria looking vegetables. We had two waiterss/waitresses (assuming one was in training). When we got our food that was the last time we saw our waiter for 20+ minutes. Had to eventually call them over for the check. Explained we never recieved a side order and the waitress just left and came back explaining the meals did not come with it even though we explicitly made it a separate side order. Service off wait staff and the manager at the time were rude and did not seem interested in our thoughts. We've been coming to this diner since it opened and has been overpriced for mediocre food. read more

I'm not generally sold on diners, but this one is a treasure. No matter what we order, it's always delicious and timely, including the mixed to order root beer. Very happy to have this place in town. read more

Why 3 stars- we eat here at least 3-4 times per month. Always dinner and never a disappointed meal. Most meals are better than expected. Tonight we arrived and had noticed some changes A new fancier menu, a new ice cream bar, and slightly higher prices for the same daily specials. We had a very nice waitress. So why 3 stars-- on dinner specials - no free dessert anymore, and no more salad and soup, just one or the other.. very disappointed.. and then the check arrived and for the 2 of us with tip - $51 We used to enjoy coming here for very good food and an all inclusive dinner and never spent more than $35-40 with tip. So now we are at $50. At that price they are now in a category with far more competitive restaurants . read more

My mom and I came here just when they opened their outside seating during COVID-19. We started with a basket of bread that included fresh bread, bread sticks, and seeded flatbread crackers. I ordered the Calamari and fra diablo sauce with pasta on the side. The calamari was lightly breaded, which I like. I really enjoyed having both foods together, and the sauce was great too. My mom had a ribeye steak, medium rare, cooked to perfection. She had sauteed green beans with garlic and onions, and candied butternut squash, which were both very tasty. Each meal included a salad on the side. I had a caesar salad with homemade croutons, and my mom had the Greek dressing, and her salad included peeled cucumbers, sliced radishes, and tomatoes. We topped it off with some of their delicious homemade ice cream. Our server, Lisa, was top-notch, and extremely professional. We had a wonderful dining experience, and plan to come back soon. read more

The servers were very kind and the food came in a timely manner. Their warm drinks (specifically caramel macchiato) were even better than I had expected! This is one of my family's favorite places to come especially on a cold winter day. read more

Since this restaurant opened you have been able to split checks at the front desk. On a recent visit I went to the front desk and asked to split a check, and the lady at the desk proceeded to YELL at my group for not asking the waiter to split it sooner. I understand if there was a change in procedure, but there is absolutely no reason to yell at customers. I have never seen that staff member working before, so maybe it's an issue with new staff, but regardless, I hope the restaurant takes some kind of action in this. read more

Very clean diner , reasonably priced breakfast ,fast service, accommodated my request politely! Friendly waitress and staff. Will return!

This once very good diner has become not so good. On a recent trip our meal was really pretty lousy. I won't be going back here. As I was leaving the manager asked how was everything,? When I told him not so good, he really didn't seem to even care. There are much better diners around. I guess maybe they changed ownership. read more

Stopped on our way home from vacation. Service was very yuck and attentive. Food was good - fairly typical diner food. Large portions, giant menu, home style. read more

I've been coming here roughly once a month for the past two years when visiting family in the area. Until recently, I always enjoyed it. Within the last month, they changed their entire menu. Some of my favorite menu options (chicken cordon bleu wrap) are no longer offered. They also increased the prices. The salads are an average of $15 which I think is way too expensive at a diner. I ordered banana pancakes as I was here for breakfast. They came out cold and had a hair baked into it. I'm not sure what happened to this place, but the quality went down a lot and yet the prices went up. I'll be going to another diner from now on....probably Spinning Wheel in Readington or the Clinton Station Diner. read more

Best breakfast place in Flemington, NJ! Very nice people! Soo many choices to choose from and everything is equally good! The coffee menu is really good as well. You also get seated pretty quickly. I've never had to wait for a seat even when it's packed. read more

We've been going to the Flemington Raritan Diner for years, and we have always had the most warm and welcoming experience. We are truly treated like family. Make sure you meet Steve when you're here. We've seen Steve walking to each table ensuring diners are enjoying their meal and providing wonderful customer service. Along with consistently delicious food, he is the main reason we keep coming back. This diner is quintessential New Jersey. read more

Great food. But their portions were a little bit excessive. I recommend this as both a diner and restaurant, so definitely come if it is an option. read more

Classic dinner with a well mannered staff. Food is basic and good but a little to salty. Interesting pricing: they add a cup of soup on a wrap sandwich for a total of 9.99. So if you break it down the normal wrap should be around 7.50 so the cup of soup is 2.50? Rather steep for a cup of soup. Wraps and burgers came with a huge amount of fries, that's good. Dinner is nothing to write home about but it's also not a place to avoid. read more

Sitting at the diner with the hubs. Did not enjoy the gravy on the open face roast beef sandwich. But the sandwich itself and the mashed potatoes were very good. When our waitress came by to check on us, we did tell her we didn't like the gravy, and she offered us a replacement meal. The manager (or owner?) came over and offered us dessert and any replacement meal. They were so nice and sweet. I would go back again, absolutely. We didn't take them up on dessert, but it all looked so good! read more

Beautiful diner but the service and food just didn't quite measure up. When I think of diner I think family friendly, but this is not a place I would bring my young children back to. The food is overpriced and our waiter was not attentive or friendly. read more

The outdoor seating was nice. It's hard finding an area with such good food and outdoor accommodations that work in this time and yet this place did it. Loved the staff, the service and can't wait for my next trip down read more

Visited on July 9, 2018 with 35 people! We were in between games at Diamond Nation Ball Park. Wow !!! This diner is absolutely fantastic. All of our food was really good. We had everything from waffles, omelets, sandwiches, burgers, salmon and Greek platters. Everyone loved everything they ordered. Huge portions!! Everything was homemade. Our server was super efficient and really on the ball. The food was hot, fresh and fast. We didn't wait long at all for such a large group. It was very clean too!! We highly recommend. Thank you Flemington Raritan Diner for taking such good care of us. read more

They've streamlined their menu a bit which is a good thing. But their salads are over priced. The average salad is $14 or $15.00 and is basically a chicken or salmon salad with variations on vegetables. The Greek salad is $13.99 and to add a protein is more expensive than the other salads. It doesn't add up... I would stick to the main entrees or lunch items since the salads aren't that great and they are a rip off.. read more