Definitely above-average pub food with a casual, yet classy, ambiance. Far from a hole-in-the-wall. Appetizers of calamari and nachos were very good. Calamari was surprisingly fresh, crispy, and flavorful. The nachos had a wood-fired taste and were cooked well. The maple Buffalo wings were unique and well-balanced. Our Tipperary burgers were excellent, well-sized, and flavorful. The drink selection was diverse and craft beers were well-represented. Mike, our server, was attentive, kind, and courteous. Will definitely be back. read more

I was looking for a decent restaurant for lunch while visiting relatives in the Montclair area. A friend from the area recommended Eagan's. Great recommendation! We had fried calamari, thick cut fries, chicken wings, bangers and mash and fish tacos. Everything was excellent. Our server was fantastic. I would go back again...and again. read more

A charming Irish spot that's good for drinks and happy hour (3-6pm, Monday to Friday). They have an outdoor area and a deceptively large interior with a beautifully carved wood bar. For drinks, I started with a yummy cocktail then enjoyed a $4 Tullamore Dew shot of really smooth Irish whiskey. For a chaser which wasn't really necessary, I shared an okay $5 Bar Pie and pretty good $5 Fries with a Blue Moon on tap. While the bar crowd was really friendly and staff was pretty friendly, we had to look for service a few times. There's a small parking lot behind it off of Label St., metered parking on Walnut St. and municipal parking a couple blocks away on Willow St. I really don't like to worry, so I just ubered it from work. I'd definitely come here again with friends for drinks and a good time. read more

See all

Nice ambiance, great drinks and decently good bar food. Giving this four stars because of the service here. The waitress Maxi was great and gave us great suggestions. Also, the bartenders are nice and quick with service. Recommend stopping by if you're in Montclair area read more

See all

Make reservations!! Staff is super helpful, following all Covid-19 precautions. The food is great. You are not coming here for a fancy meal, but a solid one. The fish tacos made with pan seared cod were hands down amazing!!! Fish and chips was good, I mean it's hard to mess up a piece of fried fish. Beers were cold!! Fun place to come with friends!!! read more

Egan & Sons - 'Chip Shop' Fish & Chips - Gastropubs Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Always solid service with a wide choice of meal types and sizes to please a group. More healthy options than others in its category. We sat inside in back at a sunny table but when it's warm outside is the move. And they're open all week. read more

Great place and services. Just like a traditional pub in the yo would recommend it to anyone visiting Montclair. read more

Egan & Sons - Draft bear - Gastropubs Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Definitely a fun place to grab a drink and meet new people. Very non-pretentious. Service is quick and friendly. Food, I'd have to try something else. I wasn't crazy about neither the chicken fingers, nor the sweet potato fries, but will try the wings next time. I heard they're good. read more

Food was good and prompt. Cozy atmosphere and nice decor. No big ice cubes for drinks though.

The drinks and food are good! Love the Pear Martini, shrimp taco's and truffle fries.

We love this place. I live nearby and we chose Egan's for our first dinner out post-COVID. It was so fun waiting in the beer garden for our table with the outdoor DJ. The weather was perfect, the service was exemplary as always and it was also pretty romantic. One of our favorite restaurants. Get the calamari and the wings! read more

Egan & Sons - Gastropubs Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

I've been coming here for YEARS. It's actually quite surprising I'm just reviewing now. Came in recently for happy hour with friends after work. Service was great: friendly, prompt and welcoming. The happy hour prices were good- definitely worth stopping in. It seems the thing that always has me coming back is the aesthetic. Egans has such a nice/laidback/upscale type of vibe all wrapped into a nice bar and restaurant. I'll keep on returning as I have for years . read more

See all

Used to be one of the favorite go-to places for me and my husband. We were there last week, and the steak tacos were terrible - dry meat, glopped with mystery sauce. I chalked it up to a bad night, but went again last night with a friend, and cod tacos were also glopped and had no flavor, pea soup was watery, and my roast cauliflower was not up to par with what I've had at Egan's in the past. The servers are great, the ambiance is lively, but what about the FOOD??? read more

Their happy hour is probably one of the best in NJ. Drinks were strong, food was good, and wasn't ridiculously priced. Very affordable, and the staff is super nice. Can't wait to visit again! read more

This place was frequented by a few friends so we decided to come here for a get together lunch. It was very packed for a 2 pm Saturday afternoon but we were seated within 15 minutes. We were seated into the snug which is the perfect and cutest area of the restaurant in my opinion. It feels private and it wasn't too loud. We all ordered something different but everyone loved their picks which included falafel platter, truffle fries, wings, calamari, cheeseburger, and lamb burger with sweet potato fries. I had the fish and chips and in my opinion, it was one of the better ones I have had. The fish came in a huge portion and had a nice crispy batter. The fries were good but it would have been nice if they were a tad crispy but that's just personal preference. The mushy peas I didn't care for but I dont like peas anyways. We were all happy with our orders and would definitely come back. read more

Egan & Sons - Fish and chips - Gastropubs Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Came in Saturday afternoon for lunch. The decor is somewhat rustic with copper antique lights hanging from the ceiling. I decided to sit at the bar. There are several TVs for viewing in the area. Ordered the Mexican fish tacos. I was under the impression I was going to get the same fish tacos served in the adjoining restaurant Halcyon (same owners). These tacos had less fish, spicier and were served on soft shells. These tacos were fair. The tacos in Halycon have lots of fresh cod and are served in hard shells. Ordered the Sticky Toffee Pudding with caramel sauce for dessert. Now that's a dessert to write home about!!!! The male bartender was particularly nice. Sorry, I didn't catch your name. The restaurant is good for people of all ages. Just to mention, outdoor seating is available. Egan and Sons share a back parking lot with Halcyon. Street parking is available too. Rating 3.5 Stars. read more

See all

Went for the Zach Bryan listening event.. the vibes were immaculate on the back outdoor seating patio. Pretty sunset, cool breeze and some string lights - what more do you need! However the food was just not the best :( tried a few apps and those weren't bad- Mac n cheese, wings and toasties. We all got sandwiches and salads for our main and just were disappointed - maybe we will try again but not rushing back read more

Only went here for drinks. They were reasonably priced. 10$ for vodka club and 5-6$ beers. Plenty of space. One of the favorite local bars in Montclair. Went there on a weekday so it wasn't busy at all. Bartenders were very attentive. read more

See all

I have been here twice now in a matter of 3 weeks and do not even live close. The first night we were here we had the most amazing service and server. Conrad was spectacular. He was attentive, knowledgeable and just all around terrific. I have never had better service anywhere than we did that night. The food is outstanding. I'd been dreaming about the maple buffalo wings and that is why we went back this past weekend. Food was just as great. Service was pretty lousy unfortunately. Our waiter disappeared for about 20 minutes, leaving us with empty glasses both water and beverages - while we were trying to eat. The food is so great and the assortment of beers on tap is a beer lover's dream so I will definitely be back. read more

Location, location, location! When I tell you the outdoor seating area is no joke, I'm not lying! I did some research on restaurants in the Montclair area that offered outdoor seating and Egans & Sons was one of the top choices. I was greeted by a bartender and eventually pointed in the direction of where I'll be dining. Egans offers several setting styles for a party of 2 to much larger parties. Once seated, it's a 2 hour dining limit. So be ready! Egans offer a digital menu which was dope. I ordered the fish sandwich with a side of sweet potato fries. The cod fish was flakey and the beer battering took it over the top. I wasn't a fan of the buns. It was dried out. My fries were okay. It needed some seasoning. Overall if you wanna get out the house, Egans is the place! read more

See all

Good place for food, drink, and socializing. Seems like a lot of young professionals frequent this area, particularly on Friday and Saturday nights. One downfall is the bar area can be quite tight when they are busier. You might have to plow through people to get from the front to the back. The servers do get annoyed (understandably) when they have to zigzag around you We tried the calamari, jumbo lump crab cake, and the Mediterranean lamb burger. We were quite happy with the calamari and lamb burger, both were tasty and the burger cooked medium was done perfectly. The lump crab cake was kinda bogus. There was no lump crab meat, it was all shredded and could've been imitation crab meat for all I know. The cake even tasted too mustard/mayo like with very little crab taste. I thought about docking this place another star for that, particularly since the crab cake doesn't come cheap, but Egan's usually consistently delivers. I wrote them about their crab cake, so let's see if they respond. read more

See all

Went here on a whim with friends a couple times to get pizza. The pizza is always good and last time we went they had a special mushroom pizza that we enjoyed. I did have some serious food envy of my friend who got a chicken pot pie that was to die for. We demolished the leftover crust. I would go back just for the pot pie...the server was attentive even though it was almost like a club in there with someone's birthday party happening. read more

See all

I've been here a few times now and my experience here has always been pretty good. They have friendly bartenders and staff and they serve decent bar food. Contrary to how it seems on the outside, it's pretty spacious, nicely decorated and they're always very accommodating. While prices seem a little high here, it's to be expected in the area. However, I think it's a great spot for happy hour and I enjoy the casual but lively atmosphere here so I'll definitely keep coming back read more

See all

This was my third time here but first time actually ordering food. Drinks were great, I asked for something sweet and our waitress suggested either a pear martini or the neighbor au pair, which is what I ordered and was simply delicious. My boyfriend ordered the maple old fashion, which he said was perfectly made.The cottage pie was tasty, I just wish it had bigger chunks of veggies inside. The buttermilk fried chicken sandwich was nice and crunchy and the fries were good as well. They offer indoor and outdoor dining, all staff wore masks and gloves, staff cleaned tables in between guested being seated and every table was separated. Definitely give this place a visit! read more

See all

Great environment, friendly staff. Food just okay. I started my review bc it was a cute little place but then my food came and I wasn't super impressed so I put this review off for 2 months I probably wouldn't have written one at all but I use my own reviews to remind myself what places I like and which ones I don't. read more

Egan & Sons - View from the bar - Gastropubs Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I come here a lot, I never had a bad experience here. Service is spectacular, I get my drinks within seconds especially sitting by the bar. Everyone is friendly and easy going it's always a pleasure Dining here. You can't go wrong with anything on this menu. Busy weekend nights are also fun their choice of music is always on point :) Love love love this place!! read more

See all

I love Egan's, the bar area is very cozy, the bar tenders friendly and mix a great cocktail. I love the various bar pies, and the outdoor seating is great too. read more

See all

Came here with my husband for the first time last Thursday. Plenty of outdoor seating in the back. We waited maybe 30 mins for a table. It was quite busy and thought we would have to wait longer. Indoor seating was busy too. We ordered oysters to start and then moule frites and the crab cake. Food was so good!! The oysters tasted so fresh and the crab cake portion was generous. The only complaint I have is of the outside bartender who shoved his nose into the mixer (to sniff it?) before making my margarita. It was so gross. And for some reason the drink was $17 for a house tequila whereas the specialty drinks on the menu were no more than $12. We situated with our drinks at the seating area and at one point glanced over at the bartender... we saw him shove his nose into the mixer again before making someone else's drink! Why dude?? I'm personally not ordering a drink from him ever again. I still tipped...smh. read more

This is a place I hit up several times over the summer months. The food here has not let me down ever. Maple wings, burgers. I usually stick to bar staples and am always pleased. The patio is a great place to sit and drink and socialize when the weather gets nice. Beer, cocktails, food, and a relaxed ambiance. Sounds like a plan. Go and ENJOY!!! read more

Egan & Sons - Gastropubs Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I've been to Egan and Sons several times. Each time have loved the food. I'm not a big fan of this restaurant for some reason, has nothing to do with service or the quality of the food, the times I have been here it has seemed crowded. I am familiar with the area and know that most places do get crowded, but here for some reason I feel claustrophobic. I do love Halcyon next door though ;-) read more

Been wanting to come here for so long. Finally made it here. It was crowded earlier in the evening. But as evening passed it got better. It is a loud place. With the music and the crowded it can be tough to hear each other. The service at the bar was quick and friendly. read more

Found it more comfortable on the high tables and a nicer environment with great service. The crab cake and chicken wings (extra crisps as requested) were excellent. The fish and chips were good (I could have eaten more chips but I am probably better off for having the small portion they serve). The mushy peas was such a sad tiny weeny portion she kindly gave me a second one. Really was TINY portion though!!!! The mussels were over cooked and not juicy plump pieces but shrivelled, perhaps they were not steamed but roasted? Whatever they did, it isn't an option we would repeat. We will come again to try something different as we had a good feeling about the place. read more

See all

Amazing atmosphere! Great food at reasonable prices. Ate here 2 nights in a row on a biz trip. Will definitely be back!

We did a family dinner here and everyone was very pleased. The drinks are also nice. Overall this is a cozy bar with a family atmosphere. Clean utensils and polite service. read more

Mother's Day 2023 What a complete disappointment. The food was really bland. No flavor to be found. I ordered the cod tacos, my daughter the sliders and my son the steak tacos. I tried theirs as well. Probably the worst food I've ever eaten. $70 down the drain. Never again. Horrible. read more

Recommended by a friend and we tried it a few night ago. The cocktails we ordered were mediocre at best being generous here. (Dark and stormy and Manhattan)! Another was made incorrectly as well with ice when it shouldn't have. They didn't offer a substitute for the bad quality of drinks. Food menu lackluster- truffle Mac and cheese and falafel platter were nothing to write home about. Probably a bit too much truffle oil poured over the pasta. They should probably stick to American pub fare and add a few more vegetarian friendly items on the menu besides the Mac n cheese! Also when we entered the place girl at the desk was like how can I help you ... a bit of profiling like we were lost or something and didn't know where we were going or belong. Rude! read more

I used to like this place but it was awful awful my last visit. I got a chicken sandwich. My immediate reaction is that's not very much chicken and such a huge bun. I took one bite and spit it out. It was rubbery and Gamey. When the waiter came by and realized I hadn't touch my food he didn't even acknowledge it. At that point I ripped the chicken apart and gave it to my dog. However even the ripping of the chicken sceeved me out because the chicken was that bad and I haven't been able to eat chicken since. It's nice that the outdoors is dog friendly but it was a super hot day and they didn't even give the dog water. The cocktail I got was small and expensive for what it was. This was a never going back experience. read more

Always excellent food. Love that they have my favorite beer Boddingtons on tap, which very few places do. Outside area is exceptional on a nice night. Highly recommend. read more

Great atmosphere with good service and food. A really good selection of beer on tap. It does get very crowded on weekends .

Egan's is a step above your typical Irish bar. The decor is industrial chic and I believe the beautiful bar was imported from Ireland. I'm a particular fan of the low-lit lanterns over the bar. If you are lucky enough to snag a spot at the bar, rejoice: it doesn't happen often on a Friday or Saturday night due to the large crowd Egans attracts. Drink prices are high for relatively weak pours, but that's to be expected in Montclair. There is an extensive beer and wine list. For a group of ten, we reserved a high top on Saturday night. Service was inattentive; water refills were so sparse that we finally just asked for a pitcher for the table to serve ourselves. Upon receiving sparkling rose (which came in a 187ml bottle), the server oddly asked if I wanted her to pour it in my glass or if I wanted to. I've never been asked this question - usually the server just pours it and asking put me in an uncomfortable position. Food is hit or miss. I loved my salmon with Brussels and butternut squash (properly cooked, nice roast on the veggies), but my friends were less enthusiastic about the sliders and nachos. The bar pies looked like a solid bet if you're looking for a late night nosh. read more