I have a deep history with Halcyon and will always be my go to spot in Montclair. Back in my coaching days Halcyon was a frequent stop after scouting a game. I've always found it comfortable and quality with excellent service and food. Having a raw bar doesn't hurt either Went for a New Year's Eve dinner and as always everything was excellent. Usually a filet or paella guy, but went with the short rib ragu and it was excellent. The French onion soup was extremely flavorful and I'm guessing a hint of brandy. A game winning touchdown and love all the peeps at Halcyon read more

See all

Lovely intimate restaurant with a solid menu. Wait staff could use a little pick me up. No one had a smile and most didn't look happy to be there. However, the food is for sure on point. Worth a try for sure! read more

See all

My son and future daughter in law :) Recommended Halcyon! Made reservations. Party of 4. Great ambiance! Love the photography by GEORGE DIEBOLD!! Stunning works of art! Restaurant is beautifully decorated. Service was exceptional. Our Server Tara H was awesome! Knew menu well and able to make recommendations! Thank you Each dish was delicious! Cocktails so good!! Dessert was amazing! Street metered parking read more

See all

Halcyon is a stylish restaurant with nice (if not always attentive) servers. Overall I'd rate the restaurant three stars but when you consider the prices. The butter crab roll was the best dish we had. The tuba tartare was as plain as it gets. The miso soy salmon was decent but over cooked. We asked how the chef recommended the salmon and the server said medium. We debated whether to go with medium rare but decided to stick with the servers recommendation. It ended up coming out well done. The paella was full of seafood, chicken and chorizo but short on flavor. I doubt I'd return. read more

When you want fresh seafood in a nice restaurant, this is where you need to dine. Staff is very attentive and the perfect atmosphere for dining. read more

See all

This is a cute little fancy place in Montclair, perfect for celebrating a special occasion. We love seafood and enjoyed all our dishes. I recommend the salmon crudo, grilled octopus, and the ceviche special for apps. For entree we shared the seafood paella, which was loaded with clams, mussels, shrimp, and chorizo. There were a bit too many peas, however . Overall, nice experience. read more

Halcyon - Salmon crudo, grilled Octopus, ceviche - Seafood Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Here for dinner celebrating a birthday .the place is beautifully appointed ,the service was outstanding, and the food was delicious and beautifully prepared and presented. I would definitely return to try more of their dishes. read more

See all

Second time visiting this fine establishment, sitting at the bar with Fizz and Steve serving us great drinks and first class service with a friendly, professional vibe. There are some really nice seats besides the bar (windows seat with comfy couches and seats), but we usually enjoy the bar for the banter and other patrons. The food is delicious and every dish we have had has been perfect. Coconut shrimp roll is our favorite. Unusual combo that works perfectly. Grilled oysters (second favorite for me, not so much for my better half who avoids them...lol), scallops perfectly prepared, octopus, and fish tacos round out our experience so far. Some unique entrees that we look forward to experiencing in our future visits await. This place is a great venue and the service is icing on the cake. read more

Had lunch at Halcyon in Montclair and really enjoyed the crispy tofu bowl. The tofu had a great crunch, the rice was filling and everything felt fresh without being heavy. Portions were solid, service was friendly, and the space has a nice vibe. Would definitely order this again. read more

Halcyon - Crispy Tofu Bowl - Seafood Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Came here on a Sunday with my husband. We had reservation and they took us right away. It may take you a little bit of time to find street parking so make sure you plan for that. We ordered a rainbow roll as an appetizer which was delicious. that was probably my favorite part. My husband got the filet mignon, which he enjoyed, and I got the paella, which was also great. I like how portions were perfectly sized. They didn't skimp out on the seafood either which happens a lot at other places. The spicy margarita was tasty. I got the chocolate covered strawberries as a dessert, which was a nice way to end the night. Overall, a nice date night location. read more

See all

I went to Halcyon for brunch with my friend and I enjoyed myself. The ambiance was amazing. The restaurant has is so inviting. The outside has vines and flowers around with some lighting that lights up at night. It's very enchanting. The food was amazing. Jeff our waiter was outstanding. He was warm and friendly and he knew the menu very well. He even told us the special for the day. He also gave great recommendations. I love my guavallini, so delicious. My friend had the Amore Mio. That has champagne, raspberry and Limoncello. We ordered the special seafood quesadilla which including real fresh crab meat, shrimp and lobster meat. I have never had a quesadilla stuffed the way these were. So mouthwatering, flavorful and delicious. I also had the chicken and waffles. Hands down some of the best chicken and waffle ever. The chicken Jeff our waiter explained boneless chicken breast deep fried with two waffles. The chicken was drizzled woth sweet chilli sauce. I just loved the sweet chilli sauce on the chicken just the right amount of sweet and heat. The food was so good I could have picked the bowl. Brunch was amazing I could have ordered some more food. This place was definitely worth coming to. I plan to be back for the other specials while they are still around in season. read more

See all

Food and experience were wonderful. Had drinks in the lounge first. The octopus was the best I've ever had. Highly recommend.

Stopped here as an in between spot from where I was coming from to where I would be headed. I had been here once before with a group of friends and had a good time. The decor and atmosphere is nice and chill. Music not overpowering; you can hear people talking. This time I sat at the bar. The bartender was a bit abrupt and unfriendly to start. I was deciding on my drink order and he came by curtly asking what I wanted. I replied with "I haven't decided yet." He walked off. I decided to order the same thing I did last time to eat, the smoked salmon plate. This time however, the salad looked a bit wilted and the cooked portion of salmon ( you get a smoked portion and a cooked portion) was overcooked. It was dry and hard to cut into. On top of that, the bartender was quite rude to another patron sitting near me. Telling her "You came in with an attitude." When she attempted to bring his behavior to his attention. I thought that was highly unprofessional. No matter what you and a customer disagree about, you don't say something like that. All in all, it could have been a better 2nd experience without that type of service/interaction I witnessed. In all fairness, the other bar helper was sweet and friendly. Would I come back again??? Not sure. Food was just ok this time. Unfortunately because I heard great things about this place as well as had a fairly good first time here. read more

See all

The perfect espresso martini exist here! SO GOOD! it's not too sweet or overpowering. It's mixed just right. Chill vibes only! read more

See all

This place just gets better as it ages with time. Iliana and Marshall are wonderful people running and outstanding restaurant. DaVinci still holding down the bar brings me joy. You can come here for after work drinks, a birthday dinnner, a lively private party, or an intimate romantic experience. Also great during brunch season. In the summer the patio is the place to be. read more

See all

My friend and I made a reservation for 2 on a Saturday afternoon, but found that the restaurant was not very busy at the time. Halcyon is beautifully decorated as the holiday decorations remained up and lived up to the expectations of what I saw on social media. The interior is a bit upscale and there is a nice intimate atmosphere. We ordered the eggs benedict, huevos rancheros, and smashed potatoes as a side. The mains were beautifully presented, but we were a bit underwhelmed by the smashed potatoes. We found the poached egg in the eggs benedict to be overcooked with solid whites, although the rest of the dish was delicious. The huevos rancheros were pretty good in my opinion. We did regret ordering the smashed potatoes as they seemed to need to be cooked a little longer and were not very impressive. read more

Great drinks, great food, great service! The place is really well decorated. I find the espresso martinis here to be the best I've tried in all of Montclair. Even if I'm out for dinner elsewhere, I'll definitely stop in for one here. read more

Halcyon - Espresso Martini - Seafood Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Went to Halcyon for Martini Hour and ended up staying longer than planned. Drinks were solid, not rushed, and the atmosphere was lively but still comfortable enough to actually talk. It felt like a nice step up from a typical happy hour without being stuffy. Definitely a good spot to stop in for drinks before dinner or to catch up with friends. read more

Halcyon - Espresso Martini - Seafood Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Ambience is really inviting and romantic! The martinis and cocktails are delicious. Service was excellent - attentive but not overbearing. Our food ... hit and miss. The truffle fries were very good with delicious lemony dipping sauce. The edamame was soaked in sesame oil overpowering everything else. Blackened Fish tacos were good but I'd say it needs heat, not very flavorful. Overall great place for date night. read more

Why such a fine fish restaurant as Halcyon seems to have low visibility in a town like Montclair is beyond the scope of this reviewer, but I'm here to witness that Halcyon is one of those places where everything is done right, from the signature cocktails and wines to the crab cakes and red snapper (I would have ordered all the menu offered but brought only one stomach). The strawberry-rhubarb crisp was truly a pleasure. Attentive service and lively atmo, too. Would I go back? I'm already planning my next visit. read more

Food is delightful Staff amazing Ambience crowded but not Noisy and yes the reason for the crowd is because the food is amazing the bar is also a relaxing option and yes they seat you quickly even with a big crowd the staff manage to always accommodate read more

This place is pretty big and every area has is it's own vibe. Downstairs is split between a sports bar area and a cute date spot while upstairs is more elegant. They serve cocktails so for Montclair that's a win (most places don't have a liquor license). The food is decent so overall a solid spot. read more

Halcyon - Burger - Seafood Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Had a reservation for two on a Thursday night. There is parking in the back behind the main entrance of the restaurant and street parking in the front. The restaurant is nice and the host was friendly. We ordered fried calamari, croquettes and the fish tacos to start. The calamari was good but our favorite were the croquettes. They were really good. The fish tacos were alright I only ate one because I was not a fan. We also ordered sushi which we also thought wasn't very good. It tasted fresh but bland. We eat sushi often and this is not the place to go to for sushi. Cocktails were well made the first round we ordered but tasted different for the second round which was odd. Unfortunately, I am in a rush to return and if I do it would be for the apps and maybe drinks. read more

See all

Came for brunch with friends and fam. The place is decorated sooo cute! I could definitely see someone hosting a shower of some sorts here, that's how cute and cozy it is inside. The host and waitress were both friendly and attentive. Now for the food. So we got the crab cake starter to share and the truffle parm fries, both were 10/10. Every time I go out for brunch, I always have to get the chicken and waffles. So that's where they lost a star unfortunately lol. The waffles were way too soft for me. Add on syrup and it just becomes a soggy mess lol. On top of that, the menu did NOT say that the meal comes with a sweet chilli sauce drizzle. That totally threw me off when it came because that's something I would've asked for on the side, only because all my fruits were in the chilli sauce too and that's not for me. Everyone else enjoyed their meals, especially the croissant French toast, also 10/10. Burger was average (but I'm biased because I am a big burger girl lol). Expresso martini was also very yummy. I'd come back to try something else! read more

See all

Came here for dinner with friends and it was amazing! We ordered a lot. The plates that stood out in my mind were: seafood pizza, fish tacos, lamb, octopus, paella, and mussels. They were delish, on point, fresh, and amazing I will definitely come back to this place again in the future to hang out and enjoy its delish cuisine! : ) read more

See all

We've come back here over & over. Beautiful restaurant with amazing cuisine. Great staff! Highly recommend this place.

I've been in years !! Like fine wine it's has aged well . The meal choices ample . Brunch could use a bit more selections. The portions are comparable for price point . Everyone equally enjoyed their meal .My bartender that day kept missing the mark . How can a classic like Cosmo go wrong ? I had ordered two cocktails both fell flat . Stick to the wine . read more

We went to try this place with friends. First we were seated at an unsuitable table next to the bar with uneven seats. We asked to move and they accommodated us. I started with oysters: Blue Point; Dixon Point; and Beausoleil. All refreshing and yummy. Everyone else started with a Caesar salad which they enjoyed. I got the Paella which was good but a bit small in portion size. Our group ordered the miso salmon, halibut, and tuna entrees. They enjoyed these as well. The cocktails were excellent. Gin N Juice was simply delicious and I could have drank a gallon of these. Halcyon days was also a hit. For dessert I had the sticky date pudding which was outstanding. Other desserts ordered weee chocolate mousse and a meringue tart. They were also tasty. My only complaint was service was a bit lacking and the AC was not cooling it off inside as we were all a bit sweaty. read more

Halcyon - Paella - Seafood Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

I really enjoyed my visit here. First and foremost reservations seem essential. You can make them Online or call. The restaurant is beautiful! Very spacious with two bars, one upstairs and downstairs . Before going I thought it would be more of a lounge but it is truly a restaurant with couches and of course people can sit at the bar downstairs and order drinks. Food was very good. I ordered the blacked tacos as a meal and I was very full. Lobster Mac and cheese was also good. I would definitely visit again. Also for my dessert I had the coffee and it was amazing. Fresh and hot. read more

See all

First time here and I wasn't disappointed at all. The decor(inside and outdoor) is absolutely stunning and very modern. The service was good and our waitress was friendly too. She recommended we try their sangria, which was extremely refreshing. Especially, on a hot summer day. I would definitely come back!! read more

See all

Halcyon always has tasty oysters, fresh and served with a very tasty Mignonette sauce. We enjoy sitting in the dining room, away from those horrible twig branches taking up precious table room. My favorite is the egg flat bread, very filling and delicious. Servers are usually attentive, sometimes forgetful. read more

See all

Crowded and noisy on a Saturday night, but good food served by a prompt and attentive staff. My wife said her cosmo was very good. Beet salad and tomato/burrata salad were also very good. My pork chop (special) was cooked perfectly, and my wife was happy with her Icelandic cod. Our friends both ordered paella and both seemed happy with it. Expensive, even for Montclair, but at least they don't charge for bread. No parking lot, and street parking is quite limited, since there are several other restaurants, cafes, and bars on this portion of Walnut Street -- but a couple of blocks to the east is the Walnut Street train stop where you can park in the evening in the non-permit spaces. We will try to come back on a weekday evening when it is (hopefully) less crowded. read more

Here's the deal It's. 3.5 star review ... The interior is very nice! The atmosphere on the first floor is a great place to sit. Unfortunately we got seated on the 3rd flow which seems to be more of a place for private events (just an opinion ) Service was very attentive Tuna tacos were very good Calamari was chewy and lacked any flavor Salmon dish order by others was solid ! The Cod special was very nice! Loved the broth !! However the veggies underneath were inconsistent (some mushy some raw or just blanched Parking is very tough (welcome to Montclair) I'd def try again. But I recommend asking to be seated on lower level where there seemed to be a better vibe/ atmosphere. read more

The girls and I decided to meet up and get drinks and dinner. When I arrived I parked on the street nearby. I walked in and the really nice hostess sat me with my party. The girls slowly started to trinkle in. Our server was Ani and he seemed to be bothered every time we asked for something. One of my friends spoke to one of the managers, Chris, earlier about seating and she said he gave her a hard time. She asked the server about seperate checks because she has done it many times there before. The server said he had to ask the manager, Chris, because they didn't do that. She asked to speak to him and he came over and he said they never spilt checks. She proceeded to tell him they done it many times before and he pretty much lied to her face and made her feel like she was wrong. Not ok. We then proceeded to order drinks. I started with wine which was good then red sangria and that was not good. I sent it back to get an LIT and that too was not good but I sucked it up and drank it anyway. The girls ordered many things and they pretty much didn't really care for their food. The truffle fries was probably the hightlight of the night. The place is pricy I will say that as well and I am not sure why. All in all I didn't enjoy my time and will not come back. read more

See all

Good food and atmosphere, slow service This seems to be a trendy spot with a good selection of menu items (seafood, meat, flatbread, sushi, etc). The calamari was tasty with breading that fell off the squid upon pricking...a little expensive though ($16). The Cornish hen with polenta and haricot verts was great (the truffle mushroom sauce helped to moisten the hen). The fish tacos were good as well. Portions aren't huge but they do seem to take some care with the food. We waited a long time to get our food (from ordering, over an hour) though we did get the calamari first. If you're not in a super hurry then it should be fine. There's street parking only, with some two hour parking on a cross street (Friday night). Apparently they also have a 30 minute grace period for reservations which is nice. read more

See all

Halcyon is that fancy spot in town that you take family or friends to impress or celebrate something. This is so, particularly when you look at the menu which consists mostly of seafood fare. Directly next door to Egans, it's inexpensive and more casual counterpart was jam packed on a warm evening so we were able to squeeze into Halcyon after some convincing of the hostess. My impressions of Halcyon are ...not bad. The Jumbo crab sushi wasn't bad. The Edamame appetizer had some nice spice to it and the special flatbread was also pretty good, both seem a bit overpriced though. What went wrong was the curry cauliflower appetizer. Beyond the mediocre presentation it was laughably bad. It was like someone took the bagged frozen cauliflower from my freezer, heated it up, spread some tahini on a saucer and brought it out. not to mention it was hardly enough for a single person to enjoy, let along 2 or 3. Avoid this and save $10. My steak tacos were good as was my Halcyon Days drink, the recommended cocktail here. The outdoor seating was nice and the waiter we had was pretty knowledgeable about menu...except for that cauliflower. So overall Halcyon is just alright. That's it's problem though just alright for a $$$ is not good. 3 drinks, 3 apps, an entrée and a sushi roll was well over $100. $21 for steak tacos? Again, good, but there are a few places I can think of that has that (or fish tacos) comparably good and half the price. If you're looking to impress your group Halcyon will do the trick but everything I had here, though ok, I've had cheaper and about as good or better. read more

See all

It was such a beautiful warm day that my friends and I wanted to go out and enjoy the Friday night. Of course it was very busy in the area and Egan and Sons was packed so we went next door to Halcyon. Never having been here before, I wasn't sure what to expect. However, the food and drinks were all pretty good, and the service was very friendly too. I would certainly come back here to enjoy some drinks again, although the food is a little on the pricey side. I shared a few things including the cauliflower and the daily flatbread. We really liked the flatbread as it had cheese and salmon on it, almost like a pizza. Unfortunately the cauliflower was extremely small. Barely enough for 1 person and it cost $9. Kind of ridiculous. But the sushi I got really made up for it as the jumbo crab and sauce on the outside was so good. I gobbled it up! The outdoor setting they have in the back was beautiful as well. Plenty of tables and nice lighting under a big tent. I can see this place being very popular throughout the summertime. read more

See all

Halcyon is that fancy spot in town perfect for brunch. . Directly next door to Egans, this spot has nice decorations inside. My impressions of Halcyon is ...not bad. The Jumbo crab cake was meaty which I liked . What went wrong in our visit was the service . The server was inattentive she barely went to our table and was not as friendly as other servers seem to be. read more

Halcyon - Desserts - Seafood Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I came here on a Friday night with some friends. It's a very pretty place with nice decor and ambiance but I'm not sure I would visit again. I expected to food to be incredible for the price point but it was underwhelming. The drinks were also decent but nothing stood out. We ordered the colossal crab cake for an entree but it was puny! The paella rice was also hard and the crab roll was just okay. The lamb was probably the best thing on the menu. Overall, it's a nice spot but I do not think I would recommend to my friends if asked because quality and pricing did not match. read more

See all

This is a special occasion type of place for us. Anniversaries, birthdays, etc. For 2 adults ordering 2 drinks each, 1 appetizer & 1 entree each, then sharing a dessert ... we spent $265 including a 22% tip. The entrees were the stars of the show ... filet mignon & ahi tuna. Both cooked perfectly; medium & rare, respectively. The accompaniments were divine as well - a black rice with so much flavor for the tuna. It was superb! Caramel apple ice cream was great! (Even though it's not made in house) drinks from the bar were creative & delicious. Waiter was incredible - knowledgeable & very professional; didn't know one of the answers to my questions about the ingredients. Instead of lying or trying to pull off some answer, he simply said he was not positive & returned with an incredible presentation of a bottle & my respect! We left satisfied to the fullest & appreciative of a sweet gesture of 2 glasses of champagne by our waiter for our anniversary. Bravo! 5 stars! read more