If you are coming to Montclair for a haute cuisine or a trendy cocktail, you'll want to drive right by Tierney's. In this authentic Irish-American bar generations of the Tierney family continue to serve generations of locals. It remains decidedly un-pretentious while serving top-flight bar food and keeping the bar, kitchen, and bathrooms clean. Oh, about the ladies's rooms, some experience with yoga will be helpful in using the facilities with their inexplicably shallow toilet stalls. High points include: * They pour a nice Guinness. * A cornerstone in the thriving Montclair music scene. * A tasty (if limited) menu that won't empty your wallet. read more

It is a lively place on a Friday. It is loud and a big crowd. The parking lot stays mostly filled, so if you don't get there early you will have to circle around for parking. It is definitely loud inside. We had a table but still had to keep going to the bar for drinks. They did bring the food out, but they never came back to clear the paper plates or check on us. Even after we left and other people sat where we were, the dirty paper plates and napkins were still on the table. It took about 40 minutes for the burger. Fries were also ordered. They were thick and kind of dry even though they were covered in cheese. I would pass on those next time. The meat of the burger was pretty good. The cheese was melted on the bun, not the burger. They were busy and looked to have only 2 bartenders so there was some waiting for drinks etc. read more

See all

Tierney's is one of the few dive bars in a sea of modern and fancy places in Montclair, which makes it unique and fun. When I first visited here I was shocked by how busy it was: the bar was packed, many groups were scurrying around trying to find an open dining table (it's self seat), it was very loud, and it was very hot. There were no open tables, so we sat at the bar, ordered a drink, and kept our eyes peeled for an opening. Tierney's doesn't have a cocktail/drink menu, so you're best ordering a beer or a simple cocktail, like a vodka-cranberry. They do pickle-backs and have a good selection of whiskey, so we did one of those. We finally got a (very sticky) table after 25-30 minutes of searching. Not soon after we sat, a very drunk college-aged man told us he needed to sit down with us because he wasn't feeling well. We let him but he passed out 10 minutes later and fell off his chair, face first onto the floor. He bled everywhere from his nose and had to be escorted out by his also very drunk friends. Maybe not a typical day at Tierny's per se, but definitely speaks to the divey nature of the vibe. While the ambiance at Tierny's is not necessarily my speed, the food is undeniably fantastic. The wings are THE BEST wings I have had in a very long time, maybe ever. The batter is so crispy and the meat is so juicy. They're served with blue cheese and buffalo sauce and are absolutely addicting. The onion rings are also phenomenal and they make a very nice burger. I think about the wings often honestly, and they're a craving of mine. The wings keep me coming back, despite the long quests for a table, sticky seats, and the drunk patrons. read more

Tierney's Tavern - Wings - Irish Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

We came to Tierney's on football Saturday so the place was packed. Thanks to our bartender who recommended sitting on the other side of the bar as there would be a gaggle of football fans arriving shortly. When you want a good burger simply made, this place is consistently on point. Further, get the onion rings as they have them down to a science. Any time we come to Montclair this place is a must. read more

See all

Always a great local DIVE TO ENJOY. Hardwood bar, good bartenders, and the smallest kitchen that you can imagine. One of the best burgers around. You have try the amazing onion rings as well. A nice crowd and they have live music upstairs. read more

See all

BEST CHEESESTEAK! This is totally your basic sports dive bar. The bartenders were great and attentive with awesome personalities. Definitely a staple in Montclair. I heard their burgers are great too. I'll have to try next time! read more

Tierney's Tavern - Cheesesteak - Irish Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Best little dive in town. I found this place in a snow storm, almost 40 years ago. BEST burgers and whiskey in town. Thankfully still not too gentrified by the yup yups. Our last escape from the transplants. lol read more

While visiting friends on the East Coast over the holidays, they brought me to Tierney's Tavern to enjoy a pint and some late night bar food. When we arrived, the place was pretty full, but we managed to find a few spots at the bar. The bartenders were all very kind and attentive, especially Ethan. We ordered our pints and placed a food order for some chicken tenders and french fries. These were no frills but just good old-fashioned chicken tenders and french fries comfort food. After a couple pints, we put some music on the jukebox and livened up the atmosphere. The vibes were great and this was just a fun spot to hang out with friends and enjoy a pint or two. Or three. read more

The pub's overall ambiance is warm and inviting. Wood paneling and dim lighting, creating a cozy, neighborhood-bar atmosphere. The service is attentive and friendly, with the staff providing prompt and knowledgeable recommendations. Good selection of local craft beers on tap, offering a wide range of styles to pair with the menu. In summary, Tierney's Tavern delivers a fun dining experience read more

See all

They know how to pour a Guinness and that's all I need! The bartenders are sweetie pies. Love it here

You don't need my review to tell you how good Tierney's is.....80 years in business, 5th generation working behind the stick ( bar); There should be a pub like this is every town. Huge parking lot in back; They sell package goods to go; Upstairs is open Thurs-Sunday and often has live music. ( available to rent for parties) Tables outside ( in rear) weather permitting. But downstairs is where it all happens. Slightly dark, loud, lots of wood, booths, and plenty of seats at a large wraparound bar. All kinds of cool, kitschy decor. Good jukebox. Plenty of classic old school working man beers on drafts ( domestic & foreign) & some craft beers as well mostly in cans or bottles) The little grill in the little kitchen serves some great bar grub ( but expect a good wait on a busy night). Chicken fingers, burgers, fries, all sorts of hot & cold sandwiches. Not a big menu but it's enough to get the job done. I had the "off the menu", Buddy Burger which has onions soaked in a special sauce when grilled, served on a poppie seed bun. ( of course I made it a cheeseburger. It's a really great burger and has been on the press ( media) Great onions rings., fries....and oh yes....plenty of cold beer. Good crowd. Seemed people from all ages hang there. Families having dinner too. Bartenders are cool & good pub-tenders. read more

See all

A group of us were in town for a work trip and a decided to go here for a drink after our meeting. Friendly bartenders, generous pours, and chill vibe. read more

About as old school as it gets. Friendly bartenders in a real tavern atmosphere. All drinks reasonably priced with good pours. Limited but good bar food menu. If I lived closer I'd be here all the time. Wife permitting! read more

Lou'd and boisterous sports bar with good friendly energy. 2 pints of Guiness, a pint of Harp and a Buddy Butger, sans the usual Kaiser roll because they were out. read more

See all

Service is friendly & great, decent bier selection, food is good & fairly priced. Very relaxed atmosphere.

Regular good old fashioned neighborhood Irish pub with great bands that play upstairs. They have a really good sound system upstairs, a rather large stage area, high tops, a full bar upstairs (and down) & upstairs restrooms as well. I had a burger downstairs & they do have great burgers that taste like you made them on the grill in your backyard. Their fries were crispy on the outside & soft on the inside. Check out the LDE (Lance Dance Experiment) if you like to dance to old soul, R&B, disco hits with a killer guitar player & amazing horn section. Tip, stairs to upstairs bar/music are STEEP. They have a parking lot in the back. Also some outdoor back patio seating. read more

See all

This local spot is a comfy dive bar with everything you need for a good night. Pitchers of beer, paper plates, tons of tvs, and delicious greasy food is all you need to have a good time. Yes, the parking lot is challenging but don't let that stop you from coming by alone or with a big group. read more

See all

I've been living in Montclair for nearly four years now, and had heard wonderful things about Tierney's. Well, a few weeks ago I decided to take the plunge, and am I glad I did. In a world of Smashburgers it was heavenly to harken back to a time when I was served a juicy, delectable burger just the way I ordered it. Bloody rare! And boy, it was Bloody good! Dripping down my chin, every bite was sheer bliss that I didn't want to end. The sautéed onions on the burger were done perfectly and there was NKN. No Ketchup Necessary! A side of beer battered onion rings were the perfect accompaniment. I will be back to Tierney's again...and again. Just thinking about Tierney's brings tears of joy to my eyes. Where have you been all my life? Lucky for me, right down the block. read more

Came in for Cheeseburger with caramelized onions Fries Chicken wings And let me tell you... this burger is more addicting than cigarettes. Best burger I have had in awhile... The burger itself though deserves a Noble Peace Prize. I will be back. read more

Came here yesterday for the first time after hearing good things. Tierney's has an old school, dark Irish pub feel to it, which is exactly my style. Lots of televisions for sports and an upstairs as well. I had a couple bloody mary's which were made very good, as well as several beers. The service was good, and overall had a fine experience. I was not expecting much from the food, but was pleasantly surprised when the wings came out and were some of the best I've had in recent memory. I also had a cheeseburger which tasted great as well. Very affordable and will definitely be returning soon! read more

This was by far the BEST burger my partner and I have had out at a bar/restaurant. Just delicious and juicy and did I say delicious. Spent the afternoon on a Saturday and the bartenders were great and friendly. Locals were super friendly too. Drinks were very good. Barstools so comfortable. Will be back for sure! read more

We came on a Sunday afternoon to try cheeseburgers that were highly rated on NJ.com. Not too crowded but this was before football season had started. Big interior with parking. Bartender took our order and was very friendly. (I don't know why I am surprised when the bartenders are so nice in these taverns and my husband and I are on our "tavern tour to find the best burger" but so far, they have been.) We had 2 cheeseburgers with fries and onion rings. These are thick burgers and I ordered mine med. Would probably order them med-well next time as they were thick and mine was a little under what I like. Onion rings and fries were both good. Everything felt cooked to order and was nice and hot. I would definitely try again. read more

Old tavern with a good bones and feel. Had a bacon Swiss burger and onion rings. Burger was excellent. Huge burger, fresh ground, perfectly cooked (medium) on a hearty roll with a good portion of cheese and nice crisp bacon. For $14 it was excellent value. The onion rights were also very well executed. Crispy but not too greasy. If you're on the hunt for top burger joints, definitely check this place out! read more

Amazing Buddy burgers and fries!!! The service guys were friendly and helpful! Ambiance well you have to see for yourself very very old school Irish pub. read more

As long as I been in Montclair, this was my first time here. All this hype about the burger; figure I would try out for myself. I must be missing something because I really don't know what the hype is about. The bartender was cool and the one gentleman I spoke to while I waited, but not my spot. read more

Thank you Tierney's for creating a good space for my friend's band and other bands to get together and perform. Managers and staff are friendly, and same with the crowd. Service was quick for a busy Saturday night. So what are the drawbacks? Parking is a mess, especially around the 7-8 PM hour, with a lot you can't maneuver around. Upstairs is not wheelchair accessible, with steep steps. As someone with a past history of knee problems, I made sure I held on. Staff still made my friend pay a $10 cover charge, and she is his fiancé, and didn't ask for proof, just wouldn't accept her predicament. Ambience needs an update, especially the old and filthy tiles and carpet. The upstairs bathroom, contains two extremely tight stalls, where it was impossible to move around, let alone address feminine needs. The Shirley Temples I had were okay, just nothing to write home about. If my friend's band was playing again, I will go back and just focus on my friends and the people, because the bar is not that impressive, at all. read more

3 stars because it has friendly service and wasn't horrendous. That being said, for a place that's marked as cheap, one cheese steak that's on the menu for $12, and one Blue Moon, ran me $20+. You can get better in bigger portions elsewhere. I found out after the fact that the cheese steak and the burger are build your own, so you can't assume that the cheese steak is going to come with peppers? The decor isn't bad, but for someone who loves bars, I just didn't regard this as a place I'd be itching to come back to. Best wishes to it, and I don't think you would terribly regret going here, the service is quick and friendly, but it just wasn't a visit that had me saying to myself, "Man do I wanna come back here." read more

Never had such a hard time getting a beer in an Irish bar! About a dozen on tap including the required Guinness & Bass plus crafts like Firestone and Victory. Settled on a black & tan, true Imperial pint very fairly priced at $6. Menu is basic, large hot sandwiches just $9, add a well-done side of French fries only $3. But I wouldn't call Tierney's a dive bar, it's a wide-open well-lit large space with a tiny kitchen, more of a big neighborhood place for locals. Parking in back if you're lucky. Vegetarian rating 1 star for the 1 option, grilled cheese, maybe add a side of macaroni salad? But as much as I like the feel of the place, you sure gotta be patient, we had slow & grumpy service here. Maybe if you wear rugby gear the service improves?? read more

Tierney's Tavern - Hours - Irish Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Been a regular for 25 years. Takes one bad experience... WARNING: don't try to bring your officially licensed therapy dogs, lest the bartenders you've known for years turn into complete pricks about handling the situation in an entirely inappropriate and threatening manner. Nice knowing you, Tierney's... thanks for the memories! read more

Tierney's Tavern - Therapy dogs - Irish Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

What can you say about Tierney's? It's everything a classic bar should be and more. And the burger is fantastic! Great place and a must visit. read more

Fun place, fully stocked bar with many whiskies and bourbons. Simple menu-good cheesesteak, good fries. Bar was busy and staff were still giving good service. I'll go back for sure. read more

They are lucky is a tavern, and customers are drinking. The bergers are gross. Serverd on paper plates with a pickle. No frills in this place. I have to give 1 star for the fries. read more

It's a beer bar with burgers and a juke box. Simple. Relaxed vibe. Friendly bartender.

Great food but unfortunately their website phone number voicemail is not set up and you cannot call them and leave a message.

After you've tried all the trendy bars in Montclair, you'll keep coming back to this throwback bar. Why? Because there's parking in the rear, cheap beer, cheap bar food (which is surprisingly good) and you may just catch a friend playing in his band on the 2nd back level. This is the Rutts Hut and PizzaTown USA of the bar scene. It's been here before your birth and will be here long after your death. Beer selection is good, not super trendy but you don't want it to be, and liquor of every type you'd expect in an Irish Pub. Call some old friends, order a burger and fries and don't forget the Guinness! read more

See all

Best burgers in NJ and all the food is very good. Good selection of beers, bartenders are good people. Took some friends there last night before a college lacrosse game, they all loved it. I've been going there for 40 years, never disappoints. read more

I miss Tierney's a whole lot. They have really good burgers, phenomenal onion rings, and all kinds of delicious beverages. They also have AMAZING live entertainment. I can't wait to get to go back and enjoy Tierney's again - after all of this scary virus business blows over ... Last thing. One time, while I was hanging out at the bar, I'm pretty sure that I saw a bear - who had antlers - give a polka-dot balloon to an ocelot that he was sitting next to. I really hope that those crazy kids ended up happily ever after ... read more

Only went once.. irish pub nothing special..not a big beer list.. their burger was good but not boom burger or stuffed burger.. ill go again if im out on the town.. #Marknowz read more

Nothing special here. Just a bar with bar food. Not my neighborhood, if it was I would probably find myself hanging out there. They used to have an open mic upstairs a while back which was a draw for musicians. Don't know if it's still going on. read more

Some of the bartenders are cool, bouncers are kind, on Thursday night one bartender was such a jerk. I sat down for a second to use my phone to Uber home in a place I knew was being held for people to come back and I was ready to get up as soon as I saw them. the bartender was just not a nice guy tho. I respected him though cuz I am also a bartender and left asap cuz it seems that's what he wanted. Just didn't appreciate the treatment. If you young and looking for a cool bar this is not the right place. I only give 2 stars because of that one specific person. read more