We're in the area staying at a hotel nearby and this came up well-reviewed with decent prices. We were very pleasantly surprised with delicious food, good prices, great drinks, great service with kind a waiter/bartender relaxed but cozy atmosphere, and an incredible dessert (the lemon cake). This is clearly a locals spot and I wish it was local to me, I'd be here all the time. If you're in the area or visiting it, this is the spot to hit! Just note that there's a lot of little upcharges such as extra for more tomato on the burger or sweet potato fries. read more

See all

I've been here twice and everytime it's been great. This time around I met the owners and they were amazing!!! They are patient and helpful. I trusted them and they did not upset. Drinks were amazing and the food that they suggested was on point. Definitely will come here again cause it gives you that homebase feeling... this bar should be your go to and not plan b read more

The food was amazing. And the people that work there are soo nice!!! Great bar in Suffern

Create your own food and have a great experience must try and as a plus the name is funny

I never wrote reviews but I was staying at a hotel nearby and wanted to get food and a beer. Place wasn't busy I had to stand up and walk to the bar to get a beer. No one ever came and asked if I wanted another. Never got a food menu and I was the only one sitting at a table. I came here for the good reviews and was completely disappointed and left after I finished my one and only drink. I guess if you're not a local don't come here your service isn't wanted read more

Was super hungry after going to Woodbury commons and couldn't find a place near there with a kitchen open past 9 so we came here. Service is very nice but slow so be prepared to wait. Crowd was very nice and a good atmosphere. They have a pool table also which was cool. The dumplings here were pretty expensive at $10, they were good but definitely tasted the same as the ones I get in the frozen bags. The wings here were ok, pretty standard sauces. The Reuben here was very tough meat. I wouldn't order that again, tater tot's were banging best part of the meal for sure! read more

Despite the intermittent country music, this place was a savior for some great food after a late plane ride in. They were a bit understaffed and the guy was great about it. The hot Buffalo Wings were spicy but still great dry rub underneath - some of the best I've ever had. read more

Plan B - New American Near Me - Suffern, New York

See all

We stumbled upon this little funky bar/restaurant driving back to Virginia from a visit up north. We planned on going to Warwick, but the spot we wanted to go was closed, so this was literally our Plan B. We needed to ease nature, and we were suffering - so it was appropriate that we stopped in Suffren NY. We breezed into this somewhat dingy little joint and grabbed a hamburger and a couple beers. We were tickled that the restrooms were dubbed "Donnie" and "Marie" with autographed pictures of the sibling Osmonds on the doors. They were surprisingly clean. While we waited for our grub, my hubby enjoyed ping ponging his eyes from one TV to the next, catching snippets of the NFL footballs games being broadcasted. It was a hoot watching him shift from the Giants/Eagles to the Patriots/Jets his head turning back and forth like he was watching a tennis match! We sat at a high top near the casual bar which was filled with sports fans, good 'ole boys and beer lovers. I could almost hear someone call "Norm!" We also had a nice view of the pool table and the game that was being played. They also had dart boards, lots of neon signage, murals, a charging station and a jukebox. This was a cool, local pub that was comfortable and welcoming. Our burger was delivered with a slight smile and it was hot and tasty. The buttery brioche bun was lightly toasted and delish. The fries were piping hot, crispy and yummy. The little side of Cole slaw was fresh and tangy. All and all a really good All American meal in a chill atmosphere at a decent price! I'm really glad Plan B came through for us!! For this type of earthy, small town sports tavern, it hit all the marks! It's the only game in town and it quelled our "Suffren"! read more

See all

Old bar. Went looking for great wings. I'd give them a 5.5 out of 10. Food was a little pricier than I expected. Macaroni with tomato sauce on kids menu was $12 with nothing else. Small apple juice bottle was $4.50. read more

This place is meh. If ur looking for drinks at night go here. Unfortunately I was looking for dinner and it does say it's a restaurant on Yelp. Well after about 6its a bar that happens to have food. If ur expecting that, you'll be really happy. If ur restaurant focused you might want to look elsewhere. read more

Plan B - New American Near Me - Suffern, New York

Go to there website they have specials on certain days. The wings are good and large .

Exactly as other reviews say! Great local favorite with good atmosphere, service, drinks, and INCREDIBLE food. We ordered double mozzarella sticks because they were so good. My partner excitedly said the "steak and cheese was so great she didn't even need ketchup" which is an incredibly high honor from her. One star off because, as other reviews say, a little expensive. No regrets though, would absolutely go again! read more

Good local bar with good food offerings. The beer selection is on point and the staff seems fun. Only been a couple of times, but the times we were there, was a fun environment. Would probably try again in the future. read more

Dive bar environment with good food. One of our go to spots to sit at the bar and hang out

We stopped in for Sunday brunch over Memorial Day weekend. They advertised a bottomless mimosa on Facebook which was a deciding factor for us to visit Plan B for the first time. We opted to sit and eat at the bar and were promptly greeted by Nick & Andy. We ordered two bottomless mimosas, Eggs Benedict, and the Charbroiled French Toast with a side of bacon. Food was all delicious, we really enjoyed it! They have a TouchTunes jukebox which allows you to DJ the venue from your barstool on your phone. We had the pleasure of meeting and having nice conversation with the owner Fletcher and Paula just prior to leaving. He was really nice to have conversation with and has done a great job shaping Plan B to his expectations. Inviting and friendly atmosphere from the moment you walk in. Stop in to give it a try, we will certainly be back! read more

Plan B - Bottomless Mimosas - New American Near Me - Suffern, New York

Met up for double date night here. I'll preface this with we are foodies so expectations are always high. The setting is awesome, a typical Irish Pub/Dive Bar feel. Bar tender was nice, knew her stuff however asked for a credit car to start a tab with two other people in the place as if we were gonna ditch in the tab, even telling her we were there to have dinner. No biggie. While waiting for friends to arrive we started looking over the menu mentioning items we might want and they were out of two outta 4 items we wanted. Sit down to the table and order apps and when served they told us they only had half orders left (took it off the bill which was nice). Then meals came and was awful. Felt as if they went shopping at local grocery freezer section and either microwaved or fried the food. Bill time came and they couldn't push us out fast enough, not ever asking if we'd like more cocktails. I hate posting bad reviews, as I like to give everyone the benefit of the doubt but will not be back here. read more

Good local joint. Owner is lovely to chat with. Good food and cold beer in downtown Suffern.

Wings were to die for . My margarita was delicious . I did sit inside at the bar , there is outdoor seating available. Masks are required and being forceful and keeping up with all the covid requirements. read more

Plan B - Margarita with teriyaki wings - New American Near Me - Suffern, New York

Pleasantly surprised by the great food. Beloved Dive bar vibe,great music taste, sweet staff, funny tidbits scattered through the space. Will def return next time I'm in town. read more

Loved it here. We are new to the area and needed a quick bite to eat late at night. Bartenders were awesome and very relaxed atmosphere. We got wings and a Rueben, both were huge portions and very good. Only downside is we weren't expecting the higher prices for somewhere that had a move dive bar type atmosphere. Happy hour seems to have great prices though, so will definitely go back then. read more

I had my baby shower at Plan B and it was awesome! Mr. Fletcher and the crew were super accommodating at every step of the way. The food was amazing and all the guests enjoyed it. The staff was so very friendly and kept everyone fed and happy. The price for the event was very reasonable as well. I suggest this place for an event. And they're pretty cool if you just want to hang out. read more

Some of the best wings we have had. Burger was great also. This is our go to spot for a late night drink and wings!

I can't remember the last time I had this much fun at a pub. The staff was really friendly and the crowd was amazing. Everyone made you feel like you were home. Free pool free darts free games great happy hour. Third-pound Burger fries fried egg cheese bacon. $13. Numerous types of Craft ale on tap. read more

See all

this is so good, i am the sober friend so i'm not just saying this, these were some of the best wings i've ever had. the nachos? were LAYERED. there was a layer of cheese, pico, jalapeños, then more chips and another layer, very thoughtfully made. our waiter was SO nice despite the fact that we were quite a big bunch and though he said they were understaffed; everything was very timely. 10/10 would recommend read more

Not sure I even know how to begin...other than to say WOW! Traveling on a Thursday night late, looking for something lite to eat and a few drinks. The hotel provided a list of places to stop within NJ...but at 1130pm-12am places where already closing. Yelped a few places and found one 1 1/2 miles away...Plan A wasn't working...so Plan B it was! They where open till at least 2am and my beautiful wife and I decided why not. We went in and sat at the bar, ordered some drinks and the nicest bartender heard our story of our long day travel. "Sam" turned on the best customer service experience for a restaurant I've had. He turned the fryers back on for us to make us some wings and empanadas. He made us feel welcomed and understood our plight of being hungry after traveling half the night. to Sam! Thank you for treating us like family! So here's the part in my review about the food and place I'm going to absolutely rave about! The wings were absolutely delicious. It had great flavor, it was moist and delicious and it was done the way we like...just a little extra crispy. However the empanadas were "slap your momma" good! Man O' Man...the first bite was like knowing you have discovered maybe the best first bite you'll ever have up till that moment!! They were crispy and filled with great flavors of savory and spicy meat...but wait...there was a sweetness factor. They put a banana in it. That was a difference maker and a big difference it made. That empanada went from good to absolutely amazing when you took that bite. The food was so good that before we left the next day my beautiful wife and I decided to grab lunch. Thank goodness we did. The owner "Fletcher" was there as well as the cook "Steve". We had laughs and we heard stories of two amazing people lives. Fletcher is one cool owner with a history lesson of his remarkable life. Steve came out to make sure our food was good and had some time to chat with us about his remarkable life's journey. These two are doing what they want to do how they want to do it! This isn't a "Plan B" stop...this should be your plan a if you want great atmosphere and amazing food. Fresh and done right! Great Job Fletcher....I'll see you again soon! read more

Hanif is amazing l, very funny and friendly. The food is also top notch, burger was very tasty. Will definitely come back again, hiking was Plan A and then Plan B was here. read more

Plan B - Big Ass 1/2LB burger - New American Near Me - Suffern, New York

My husband and I decided to try this restaurant because we were looking fo a new restaurant in our area, and the menu looked interesting We decided to share braised shift ribs, with mashed potatoes and grilled Brussel sprouts as well as a chicken tender appetizer. My husband called to order based off the menu online. A few moments later they called back to inform him that the braised short ribs were actually not an entree., but accommodated our original order. Perhaps the restaurant should update its online menu. At first glance the beef portion appeared on the smaller side, but once we cut in we realized that it was more substantial. The short rib was decent, but nothing special. The chicken tenders were dry and over cooked. Maybe hamburgers are a better choice. read more

Yesssss!!!!!!!! Amazing!!!!! The atmosphere was nice and it was clean. Mike was our waiter and he was so nice and service was quick, we got there at like 7pm on a Saturday night. I'm going to be honest looking at the menu it wasn't a big menu I wasn't sure what to expect. We started with chicken dumplings and they came with a sauce and we also got the chicken wings with jack Danielle's bbq sauce. My husband got the burger and I got the prawns on Texas toast (they have an appetizer portion and an entree) with Alfredo pesto sauce and since I got the entree it came with a salad that was very good. We got to meet Steve the chef and he was so sweet checked on us to make sure the food was ok. Such a great night will definitely be going back!! read more

See all

Fun place, good food Typical bar fair but good. Fun atmosphere! The do trivia some nights and have good drinks read more

We went for restaurant week in our area. This is a neighborhood dive bar but the restaurant week menu looked pretty awesome so we thought we would go for it. There is a large bar and a dining room that also includes a pool table and dart board. So yes it fits the bill as a dive bar. The restaurant week menu looked good. My partner enjoyed the ravioli appetizer. My steak was tasty but not tender. The folks here are very nice and friendly. I have to admit that, throughout the meal, I kept looking at the sliders being served to other tables (from the regular menu), perhaps a sign that when in a dive bar, stick to the dive bar menu!! If you want a drink, a conversation, some sliders, and maybe a game of pool... check it out. read more

See all

I suppose there is a reason behind the name of this establishment as it would not be my first choice at all. I met a friend there and it took nearly 20 minutes to be asked if we wanted a drink. It was not by any means busy. There were only two people playing table bowling and four other people at the bar who had already been served and a couple sitting at a high table behind us and two people playing pool. Getting a drink in under five minutes should have been easy considering there were two bartenders behind the bar at the time who seemed to be more interested in chatting with the presumed regulars and each other. We did not feel welcome in the least. Just when we were ready to show ourselves out after 20 whole minutes of being ignored, we were finally acknowledged; so, we acquiesced to stay for a single round and quickly left. First impressions are rather important but even as a plan b venue... my friend and I will go through at least half the letters in the alphabet before succumbing to Plan B for a second time! read more

If your looking for drinks that are on point, great service and a quick game of pool, get to Plan B. This joint is consistently professional and we are lucky to have them in our town. It has a small town family vibe that makes you feel welcome! read more

Chill place. Bartender was awesome! Steph made my 1st visit great! Thank you Plan B! Chocolate layer cake was yummy

The very best French Toast ever! I believe it's only available for Sunday brunch. Correction.. I read they serve brunch Saturday and Sunday. Can't wait till next weekend to have it again read more

Went to Plan B after a great hike at Ramapo Valley Reservation. We had our dog with us and looked for places that had outdoor seating...check. Luckily, we were in time for brunch and ordered bottomless mimosa at a fantastic price of $12. She had the French toast and I had scrambled eggs with lox, cream cheese bagel and fatter tots! Waitress brought out a bowl for my doggy and she was very attentive. Definitely will go back after another hike. read more

Stopped in here with a friend on a whim and it's your classic locals spot. The kitchen wasn't open but they did offer some basic food options like pizza and wings. Ordered some food items and can't complain. read more

Plan B is Suffern's (and neighboring towns) local watering hole. The food is surprisingly awesome, and the drinks are always cold and delicious. Brandi, Kev, Tiff, Will know what the hell they're doing. And Carlos chefs it up with the best of them in the back. So B COOL or B GONE :) ..I also hear the boys are back in town often at this joint.. but you didn't hear it from me.. read more

Stopped in because of all the face book ads,food sounded very good,got there about 5:30 PM on Friday ,a couple of guys were playing pool ,it sounded like they had been there all afternoon drink ing,every time they missed a shot ,every one sitting down eating could hear the F word flying across the room,unfortunately they were missing a lot of shots,Besides the entertainment the food was pretty good,the staff (bar manger,the manger and our waitress-bartender)constantly check in to make sure we were doing okay read more

In the past the sandwiches were quite good, but they seem to be hit or miss. The bigger issue is that some of the customers make the experience less than welcoming. Not sure why they would allow drunken loudmouths to occupy a spot at the bar. read more

Stopped in to have a bite to eat and a drink. Ordered fried pickles, orzo mac & cheese, and a cheesesteak. The mac and the fried pickles were on point! The cheesesteak was not. Haven't found a good cheesesteak outside Philly. read more

Plan B - Orzo man n cheese and fried pickles - New American Near Me - Suffern, New York