Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Install the Yelp app
    Continue your search on the app. It’s easier!

    Eataly - Short Hills

    2.9 (182 reviews)
    Closed 8:30 am - 10:00 pm
    Updated 3 weeks ago

    Order Eataly - Short Hills Takeout or Delivery

    Eataly - Short Hills Photos

    EATALY - SHORT HILLS ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Trendy
    Upscale

    Recommended Reviews - Eataly - Short Hills

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Louis G.

    It is not our first rodeo here and they have a lot to offer. We had a track meet nearby and decided to grab some lunch beforehand. A nice Margherita Romano thin crust and delicious. The service for takeout was awesome. The interior is immaculate and very modern look and atmosphere.

    appetizers
    Hank C.

    Stopped in the restaurant area (Eataly Ristorante) - the table tops are small and they gave the four of us a small one by the bar. The burrata was good, and the funghi wasn't bad though a little on the tasteless side (needed a bit more pepper or salt, it was really just grilled in some olive oil and parsley). Salumi e Fromaggi was a charcuterie board - cheese was good, grapes were dusty. The calamari was far overcooked as they had a new person working on it and it was served far later than the rest. Bruschetta romana was very good, though.

    Steph R.

    Service was top notch , restaurant was elegant, pasta was definitely fresh and made to order. Food was okay. Enjoyed the calamari could skip on the bread. Wine was perfectly paired with the dish. I'd probably visit again for desert and to try the pizza.

    imported olive
    Gerard S.

    Eataly is paradise for foodies. Overflowing with Italian food imports from pasta to organic sodas and everything in between. Incredible assortment of Italian cheeses and meats perfect for your next charcuterie board and prepared foods for nights where you don't feel like cooking. Not quite as good as being in Italy... but close.

    Warren B.

    Lunch was charming. From the moment that we walked in, many of the staff welcomed us. The room is broad and painted in calming latte colors denoting peacefulness. The windows look outside making the already large room feel limitless. There is a full bar spinning Milan esque spritzers and Negronis along with carefully prepared martinis at lunch. It's very European. Bread is served and it's delicious. Warm from the oven, it comes with a dollop of ricotta cheese and sturdy olive olive oil, a pat of butter sliced into triangles and a splash of the above mentioned olive oil alone. It was well baked and sliced into manageable coins. We drank a bottle of sparkling water and my guest had a perfect latte. My guest had a Caesar salad with chicken. The salad was gorgeous. Not too much dressing. The chicken flavorful and sliced for easy eating. The greens came perfectly washed and carefully arranged. I ordered a delicious dish chosen from the carbonara menu which intrigued me deeply. I chose a classic version of the rib warming dish. The creamy sauce, napped onto a tangle of the just to the tooth pasta. A tube pasta in this case. The bacon was crunchy and the higher than usual Parmesan cheese offered a funky counterpoint and made me smile. Our waitress worked with confidence and she knows the menu! Lunch couldn't have been nicer. I'm dying to savor the Pizza next time!

    Pesto/Shrimp
    Vishal P.

    We came here during the summer when they had a price fix summer special. The service was slower than we expected and it too terribly crowded. Our server was friendly. The food was only okay to be honest. My pasta/pesto/shrimp was like they didn't any salt at all. And there was no salt on the table. The bill for 3 people on the price fixe was over $200. Seems over priced for what you'd get. I'd give it another shot off the full menu I suppose but its a hard sell for me. There is a market in front of the seating area if you want to buy some Italian wine or groceries.

    coffee menu
    China D.

    Of course they put an Eataly here after I moved away! Anywho, we finally got to try it during some holiday shopping this weekend. Note we did not go to the restaurant, so this review is only for the market and pizza counter. They did a nice job with a small space and definitely recreated some of the vibes from the more extravagant NYC locations. Panetone prices in the market were outrageous but i bought one anyway. I'm a sucker what can I say. We got two sandwiches and four slices of pizza for two adults and one toddler. Definitely too much food but we wanted to sample a lot! The trecolore pizza was my favorite because it was slathered in stratchiatella with fresh arugula on top. The cotto sandwich with bright yellow tomato was to die for even if the bread was a little tough. The mortadella was a disappointment because it felt mostly like eating foccacia with whifs of filling here and there at the edges but the center was packed. The soppresata pizza was forgettable and I didnt care for the margherita. And look, we ate every bite but with the prices they are charging my judgement is higher! Next time I would only grab one slice or one sandwich to share. The coffee counter looks fabulous though and I would love to try the frozen espresso drinks!

    Seafood linguine
    Eli M.

    The slice of Soppressata was pricey, but very good! Didn't need any pepper flakes because of the spicy salame. Ordered bolognese pasta. The portion for the price is very small like in Italy. The fresh pasta was delicious. Nothing like freshly made pasta. The bolognese was very good, and it was not salty. The texture of fresh pasta is completely different from boxed dried pasta. I loved it. The seafood linguine was very good. A minute less would have been better for the pasta. The linguine was more of a boxed pasta. But it was delicious. You need to order at least a 2 course meal because of the smaller portion. This is really overpriced pasta and pizza. But you are in Short Hills Mall. Long line during Black Friday. It was good to try. Overall I would come back.

    Misto Bosco Pizza
    Portia D.

    I had the special 2 course restaurant menu. Very lackluster. The food on the regular menu is so much better. I had it last year as well. It has not gotten any better. The butternut squash bruschetta was strange...the ricotta and bread was good, but the combination of all 3 was odd. I had the pasta with mushrooms as the main. Boring. I took it home and I'm going to add sausage and more seasoning. The best things were the tiramisu and wine flight-which aren't special menu items. Eataly-please do a special menu that is not vegetarian forward and somewhat similar to your original menu. Service was good-appreciated that! I would stop in again for wine, but nothing off any special menu.

    Dessert

    Went for a late bday dinner after mall closed and it was phenomenal... lasagna and pollo alla milanese were both delicious. Drinks were good and service was very fast

    Caprese and Zucchini Pizza
    Cara S.

    Eataly offers foor below average for Italian food, but above average for mall food. Just as the other reviews have stated, this is overpriced, so-so Italian food. While it's the best food option in the Short Hills mall, I still won't be rushing back unless I happen to also be shopping near there. I ordered the eggplant panino, the caprese panino, and the zucchini pizza. I was REALLY excited to try the zucchini pizza, however it was not very flavorful and I found it to be very heavy and oily. The caprese panino was similarly lackluster, and I make better ones at home. The eggplant panino was very delicious but the bread seemed deep-fried, and the whole sandwich oozed oil with each bite I took. Overall it was decent for a quick mall stop, but the prices did not reflect mall food prices. However, the service was lovely and the man behind the counter was very helpful and patient, even after we changed our order last- minute. The seating area is also very cute, and makes you feel like you could be in an Italian cafe.

    Polpette
    Rob D.

    The restaurant was decent and the food was good. The service was good however the hostess station is in an awkward spot if you approach from the parking lot. The store is good and has an ok selection. It's a bit narrow and the staff is stocking while you shop so that makes it more cramped. They do have take away food areas and cooking classes.

    Entrance to the market from inside the restaurant
    Blanca C.

    I had read reviews saying Eataly in the Short Hills Mall was overpriced, but honestly, we didn't feel that way at all. It felt like your typical restaurant you'd expect in a mall setting--nice, bustling, and fairly priced for the area. The restaurant is accessible either through the outside parking lot by the Bloomingdale's entrance or from inside the mall. We didn't have a reservation on a Sunday afternoon and waited about an hour, which worked out perfectly as it gave us time to do some shopping. The staff was very accommodating. We had a stroller with us, and the hostess kindly suggested we leave it at the front since my granddaughter could use a high chair. We were seated at a table for four in a cozy little corner--perfect for dining with a baby. Our waitress, Asia, was wonderful. She was patient and helpful, especially as my daughter and I were sharing dishes. We started with the calamari and fritti (zucchini fries). Both were absolutely delicious! The zucchini looked just like French fries--long, thin, and crispy--but with a much lighter and tastier bite. The calamari was small, tender, and perfectly cooked. My husband ordered the Pollo alla Milanese, and the bite I had was fantastic--crispy on the outside, juicy inside. My daughter and I shared a Caesar salad. The dressing was lighter than usual, but very flavorful and refreshing. For our main course, we ordered a calzone, which unfortunately was the one miss of the meal. It took quite a while to arrive (we had to ask twice), and when it did, the ends were piping hot, but the center was cold. It reminded me more of a flat stuffed pizza than a traditional calzone. The flavors were good, but the execution was lacking. If it were cooked more evenly, it would have been excellent. One fun highlight was their Italian version of Coca-Cola--adorably small glass bottles that added a charming touch to the meal. Attached to the restaurant is Eataly's market, which was a treat in itself. You can pick up anything from gelato to fresh produce and specialty Italian products. We left with a few different pastas and jars of marinara sauce. We'd definitely recommend dining here if you're in the area--just maybe skip the calzone unless you can confirm it's been cooked thoroughly. Everything else, from the food to the service to the ambiance, made for a lovely experience.

    Very meaty. My husband would have like more cheese. House-made Lasagna, Pork & Beef Ragù alla Bolognese, Béchamel, Grana Padano

    See all

    19 days ago

    Helpful 9
    Thanks 6
    Love this 12
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Katey G.
    2073
    878
    3925

    21 days ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    27 days ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Hank C.
    2031
    4635
    14730

    2 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Rob D.
    1751
    546
    4911

    6 months ago

    Helpful 7
    Thanks 3
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0
    Helpful 3
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 2
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Erica N.
    3
    102
    108

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 7
    Thanks 1
    Love this 5
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 7
    Thanks 4
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 13
    Thanks 4
    Love this 11
    Oh no 1

    5 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 3
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Vic C.
    0
    22
    0

    29 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of David K.
    0
    96
    162

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Page 1 of 5

    Eataly - Short Hills Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Eataly - Short Hills

    Restaurant Serenade

    Restaurant Serenade

    3.9
    (285 reviews)
    0.6 mi
    $$$$

    Each selection was beautifully decorated and presented, followed by a most enjoyable delicious meal!read more

    This was a high-end spot with innovative menu options. The place was nicely decorated for the…read moreholidays. The service was appreciated, and the food came out very fast. The starters came out three minutes after we placed them, which was odd. They start the meal off with a choice of one of their breads. I went with the focaccia, and it was tremendous. It was soft with a tomato flavor on the outside. For starters, the octopus ($24) and cauliflower steak ($20) was ordered. The octopus came grilled with potatoes, preserved lemon, and Niçoise olives. This was solid. The octopus was tender and flavorful. The potatoes were tasty as well. My only issue was the amount of olives as there were only two present. There was a very strong lemon flavor too. I liked it, but at times, it felt like too much. The cauliflower steak had a lemon-soy emulsion, tomatoes, cucumbers, and capers. The cauliflower was perfectly cooked and there appeared to be a lot of butter used here. The tomatoes, cucumbers, and capers were a nice addition to complement the cauliflower. For an entrée, I had the tuna ($44). It came with haricot verts, avocado, coconut sticky rice, and a soy-ginger vinaigrette. This dish was very good except the tuna. The flavor was good, but it was not very tender and was a tad overcooked. The sticky rice was the highlight here along with the vinaigrette. I also tried the lamb dish that came with delicata squash, Brussel sprouts, potato gnocchi, and a romesco sauce. This was great. The lamb was cooked to a perfect medium rare while the gnocchi and squash were creative additions. For dessert, the warm chocolate tart ($15) was ordered. It came with pecan crust, praline, and vanilla ice cream. I never saw a pecan crust with a chocolate tart and I enjoyed it. The chocolate tart was gooey while being very rich, but light at the same time. The vanilla ice cream was definitely needed. Will I go back? I would.

    Photos
    Entry
    Entry
    Blueberry cobbler
    Blueberry cobbler
    View of Chatham

    See all

    View of Chatham
    Library Lounge

    Library Lounge

    4.8
    (6 reviews)
    56.7 mi

    Library Lounge at Skytop Lodge feels like stepping back in time in the best possible way…read more From the moment you walk in, everything slows down. Dim lighting, big comfortable leather chairs, bookshelves lining the walls, a fully stocked bar, and historic photos throughout the space create a classic lodge vibe that feels timeless without being stuffy. It is cozy, polished, and incredibly relaxing. The staff is knowledgeable and clearly takes pride in what they serve. The craft cocktails are well made and thoughtful, and if you prefer beer, there are solid options there too. As a bourbon lover, I especially enjoyed their private barrel pick served neat, a real treat and easily a standout pour. This is a perfect pre-dinner or post-evening stop, we have done both, and it works beautifully either way. Dress is slightly casual but leans upscale, and while pricing is a bit higher than average, it feels completely worth it for the setting, quality, and experience. We sank into the chairs, talked story with friends, and lost track of time, which really says it all. If you are anywhere near Skytop Lodge, make sure this is on your list. Plan extra time, you will want to linger.

    Beautiful Place. Not sure why it has no rating on Yelp. Its must see if your at Skytop! Great…read moredrinks and light fare. Beautiful and relaxing lounge style room. Fireplaces and cozy sitting areas. What more could you ask for?

    Photos
    Interior Pic
    Interior Pic
    Back room
    Back room
    Omg. This band.

    See all

    Omg. This band.
    Millburn Standard

    Millburn Standard

    4.3
    (406 reviews)
    3.2 mi
    $$$

    Absolutely loved it!! The first time I visited, I ordered the steak tacos, which were super…read moreflavorful. A tad greasy but I still enjoyed them. On my second visit, I tried the blackened shrimp and corn cakes, and that dish alone inspired me to finally leave a review. Every ingredient was so vibrant and delightful, with flavors that complimented each other beautifully. The sweet corn cakes combined with the heat of the shrimp and the creamy avocado were perfect. The various textures made each bite even better. My friend also loved the american waygu burger. The place was pretty packed around 4:30 pm on a Saturday, but service was still pretty quick. Our waitress was also super sweet and attentive. Definitely one of the best dinners I've had in the area. Amazing spot!!

    Lovely neighborhood restaurant with an inventive menu and cool riffs on classics and specialty…read morecocktails and mocktails. My nephew who lives nearby treated us to an al fresco meal recently while visiting for a family event. My pulled pork smashed burger was everything you want in a packed meat sandwich, with an onion ring and tangy sauce on the brioche bun. The sweet potato fries and a refreshing mocktail to drink made for a perfect meal. Sweetie ate a pasta bolognese (I think) which looked and ate good, and drowned it with a nice glass of red wine. It was packed on the Friday night we visited, with folks lined up for seating, or to hang at the bar and enjoy the bar scene. No reservations. Our late dinner worked fine as the mostly millennial and Gen-Z crowd started thinning shortly after we arrived. Millburn has always been a draw for neighboring townsfolk in search of a meal out. I remember this foodie town from 25 years ago, when its pizza, kosher and diner offerings were top notch. It seems to have upgraded its food scene several notches since my last visit so many years ago. Pure nostalgia for me which made for a very flavorful evening. TOP TIP: Street parking in this part of town is a hassle and the local cops keep a sharp eye for illegally parked cars and inebriated drivers. So park further away from the center of town where you are more likely to snag a legal spot on a busy night.

    Photos
    Interior angle
    Interior angle
    Truffle fries, Philly, cheesesteak, sliders, loaded baked potato
    Truffle fries, Philly, cheesesteak, sliders, loaded baked potato
    Blood Orange Paloma

    See all

    Blood Orange Paloma
    Black Sheep Bar And Provisions

    Black Sheep Bar And Provisions

    4.4
    (81 reviews)
    6.3 mi

    LOVE the vibe here. It's cozy but upscale. The lighting is perfect, and the happy hour even…read morebetter. I'm commenting solely on our happy hour experience. My colleagues got the lobster roll + champagne and I got the "sliders" with a side of truffle fries. They had happy hour prices for drinks as well, so we got a few glasses of wine and cocktails. The happy hour prices are a great deal. Especially the lobster roll + champagne!! Service is very quick. The staff attentive despite the crowd. The sliders were the biggest (pleasant) surprise. They were HUGE. Almost the size a full size burger. One of the owners stopped by and laughed that it was the only size buns they had --- but it's seriously such a great + tasty deal! Honestly would come back for these happy hour sliders alone! Overall we had a great time here. Haven't tried any of their main dishes, but judging from happy hour alone, this place is one to return to.

    1st time here as 'Black Sheep,' I used to come here routinely when it was 'Rosie's.' Small to…read moremedium venue with an upscale feeling vibe, but you can still be casual here and not feel judged. No parking out front, parking around back and a cut through to the front. Service was friendly and at a good pace. We had the Lobster Roll & Butcher's Cut Grilled Cheese, which the cheese changes periodically so ask before ordering. We also upgraded the frittes to the Rosemary which comes with rosemary on it & a garlic aioli dipping sauce. Everything was amazing! Mad it took me so long to come back. We also had the Mai Tai, so good we ordered 2 each. Worth the stop!! Grades: Lobster Roll: A Butcher's Cut Grilled Cheese: A+ Rosemary Frittes: A

    Photos
    Black Sheep Bar And Provisions
    Beef cheek
    Beef cheek
    Black Sheep Bar And Provisions

    See all

    VintEdge Wine Bar and Lounge

    VintEdge Wine Bar and Lounge

    4.2
    (105 reviews)
    17.7 mi

    This is a combo review of 2 visits. As they were both FIVE STARS you'll be okay…read more Visit one: Last month I was feeling frisky ::meow:: after a work event at the courthouse and wasn't ready to go home. I literally said to myself as I drove around Somerville that I wish there was a wine or cocktail bar for...mature people like myself to chill at. So I looked up wine bars and boom - VintEdge was right down the street. I came in around 9pm, picked a comfy seat by the window, and ordered. Can you believe I had never had an espresso martini until that evening?? So my first was a pumpkin espresso martini. Well I may have had 2. And another drink. Ahem. The service was great, not fussy, and I wasn't rushed even as we approached last call. Visit 2: having heard about my great experience there alone, my cousin arranged to meet me there last week. Or so she thought. Through a series of mutual miscommunications, I was here at the crib waiting for her, while she was at the wine bar waiting for me. Once we figured that out, she got us some food to go and we ate here at home. Verdict: -excellent seating options - stools, couches, chairs -food is so so good. Tartare, truffle fries. Fig jam pizza -drinks include awesome bottles and seasonal takes on old favorites This could be my new spot.

    HIGHLY RECOMMEND! I was pleasantly surprised by VintEdge and it ended up being one of my favorite…read moreeateries so far this year! The outside is unassuming but on the inside, it feels like a classy, upscale restaurant with a casual ambiance. On a Saturday evening, there were still several tables open inside and outside and seating at the bar. The drinks were amazing. My fave was the lychee martini. The food was also simple yet delicious. Can't wait to come back and try more of their menu. The staff were busy but still polite and attentive.

    Photos
    Pasta bolognese
    Pasta bolognese
    Mocktail
    Mocktail
    Margarita flatbread

    See all

    Margarita flatbread

    Eataly - Short Hills - pizza - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...