We hosted a Wedding Welcome Dinner at Moonshine Modern Supper Club to kick off our son's wedding weekend, bringing together family and friends from near and far. From our very first conversation, Vic was easy to work with, offered helpful advice, and made the entire planning process simple and stress-free. Communication was clear, decisions were easy, and we felt completely supported throughout. The food was outstanding from start to finish. The appetizers were delicious and beautifully presented, dinner was excellent, and the desserts were fantastic -- and the warm chocolate chip cookies are a MUST. Our guests are still talking about them! The staff was friendly, professional, and personable all evening. Service felt attentive without ever being intrusive, and everything ran smoothly. The décor and atmosphere are upscale, modern, and fun, with a youthful energy that made the night feel festive and special. We are so grateful for such a wonderful experience and would absolutely recommend Moonshine for any celebration. read more

One single drink , that is all we had at this place . We arrived around 3pm on a Saturday afternoon , to my surprise the place was completely empty and I was wondering why since it was a beautiful sunny Saturday afternoon . I soon realized why . Sat at the bar and the bartender hands us the drink menu , no greetings , no good afternoon . The kind of thing you would expect from a bartender since they would want to keep you at the bar . We each grabbed a drink and that was it . They must train their staff to be more welcoming and pleasant . We left after one drink because the vibe was just dead . Do not recommend . read more

MoonShine Modern Supper Club - Wine Bars Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

I had my bridal shower here and it was a 10/10 experience! Victor and his team were so helpful and kind through the entire process! The space was large enough to hold all of my guests with tons of extra space! Highly recommend hosting any event here; plus the food was amazing! read more

See all

The ambience of this restaurant is definitely cute. Would be great for date night. The service however, was very slow. Our waitstaff was very sweet and very kind, everything just took forever. I felt the food was extremely bland and I didn't finish it. My colleague felt the same and ultimately I would not go back. I got the Arepa sliders and felt there was really no flavor and I needed hot sauce. All they had I believe was Tabasco. For dinner I have the salmon and I just couldn't get through it. It was so bland I couldn't take it. read more

MoonShine Modern Supper Club - Grilled Salmon - Wine Bars Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

My husband and I came for dinner with a reservation on a bustling Saturday evening. I could tell that it was very busy since it took a while for the server to stop by the table and the water was served in wine glasses. I ordered The Red Wedding (hendricks gin, tart cherry juice, apricot liquor, lemon juice, prosecco, glitter, maraschino cherry, flute) which was delicious but was served about 1 minute before the entrees so there was not much of an opportunity to enjoy it. For my entree, I had the short rib served with cheesy grits and collard greens. I enjoyed the grits and greens, but the short rib was overcooked and not tender. My husband's burger tasted delicious and made me wish that I ordered it instead. For dessert, we had the creme brûlée, which was served a couple of minutes after ordering it. At first I was surprised at the quick service, but then I was underwhelmed since the dish was completely cold. It seemed as if it was sitting out for a while, so that was disappointing. Since my husband and I had different experiences, I would be open to returning and hope that we both get to enjoy a delicious meal. read more

See all

Bustling and vivacious! It's a struggle finding food in the suburbs that compares to restaurants in New York City proper, but this place does a great job with the overall vibe, menu variety, and fresh ingredients. It's easy to make reservations and there's a fun bar area for grabbing a drink and hanging out. Their menu includes standard bar "staples" like hamburgers and mozzarella sticks. It includes more Mediterranean dishes like deliciously-flavored guacamole mixed with pomegranate seeds and chopped olives. And it has a great dessert menu such as baked cookie dough mixed with vanilla ice cream on top, among other items. The staff seem to work hard for serving the food on-time despite the bustling nature of having many customers dining in. The salmon dish tasted great, coupled with Parmesan-flavored couscous and grilled vegetables. The guacamole also tasted delicious. even though the combination of pita chips and tortilla chips felt awkward. Overall, it was a great dining experience and would highly recommend visiting this spot. read more

See all

Came here for a brunch, prix fixe menu is reasonably priced with a nice selection. Ordered white and red sangria, enjoyed both but would've preferred less ice. Service was a tad slow and there seemed to be a lack of communication between our two servers. But otherwise, I'd definitely come back here and would like to try out their dinner selections. read more

Had an amazing time here celebrating my mom's retirement. The restaurant was able to accommodate us on a very last minute situation. However, the smile of my mom's face made it all worth it. The food was amazing. That ambience was very welcoming. Can't wait to be back here. I just heard about this place recently and I can't wait to try more items on the menu with my family. read more

See all

Food was average Drinks were not good at all Service was so-so we got forgotten by the waitress Ambiance was great read more

This is a cute go to spot for pretty much any occasion, food is great drinks are on point an the vibe is good too

We booked restaurant for a rehearsal dinner this past Friday. We had tons of people coming from out of town (120) and they gave us the whole downstairs and bar area. It was basically a 3 hour cocktail hour. Lots of pass arounds and open bar. The food was delicious. They were well staffed so the drinks were flowing and nobody left hungry. Great job! read more

We hpsted a birthday party for 60 guests and the food and service were outstanding. We reserved the main dining area for 3 hours and Victor and Sam were extremely cooperative and accommodated our every wish. Many of our guests said that they would return for future meals. The room ambiance was excellent and set up to accommodate our sitting arrangements. read more

Me and my girlfriend stopped in recently to grab a drink and an app after enjoying the day in the nearby towns. Upon entering the music was blasting but one of the waiters came over and asked me if it was too loud after seating us and I said, yes, a bit too much and he turned it down. That was nice of him considering I couldn't hear myself think. lol. It's a vibey spot and everyone there seemed happy to be working there. Our waiter was kind and his service was great. I ordered us a bottle of sparkling water to get started and then The Red Wedding cocktail for me and a Rumbunctious for her. They were both super tasty. We also ordered the crispy sticky calamari and it left little be desired in the tasty department. It was not crispy, but more like soggy. I had no idea it came with sauce all over it instead of on side or I would have told him to put the sauce in a condiment cup. The service was great, the atmosphere was great, the drinks were great, but the food we opted for wasn't. I'll be back again, but rest assured I will not get that fried calamari again. Enjoy :) read more

See all

Cocktails amazing. Wine list ok but not impressive. Service started well but died out after appetizers. And they were at less than 50% capacity on a Saturday night. Very very loud disco music. We asked to have it turned down 3 times. We were a party of 6 and they tacked on 20% "large party" gratuity to the bill. We sat so long after entrees that no one wanted desert, but they looked interesting. Food was good but moderate portions. read more

Top 3 WORST burger I've had in my life. Took a long time to come out of the kitchen on a Tuesday night at 9PM. I could forgive this if a quality burger was provided but the meat was over season and dry (asked for medium but beyond well done with burnt char marks on them burger and bun). Ate at the bar and bartender didn't ask me once how the burger was - which I would have happened told her. Manage expectations if you come here, especially as of May 2025 this establishment has a strong rating above 4 stars. read more

Service was great last night, but the food and cocktail left me disappointed. The tuna tartare had the consistency of my cat's wet food. I like when tuna is chopped a little rougher, this was really like a puree of tuna. The avocado was equally over puréed and together it was just mushy on top of mushy. My recommendation would be to fix the texture.. the three chips weren't nearly enough for the amount of tartare. They should be bigger or give you a few more crackers to eat the tartare with. The cocktail was so strong and imbalanced it tasted like our pathetic attempts at cocktails in college. Too strong, no clue what we were doin, ratios off. That's what my drink tasted like. I wouldn't get a drink there again, nor get the tartare. Perhaps the other dishes are better. My dining companion had what was essentially an old fashioned which came in a martini glass, which seemed a bit peculiar. Stick to classics. Ambiance was nice , but there were only two tables (ours included) dining in the main dining room on a Thursday night. Maybe they are busier on weekends read more

MoonShine Modern Supper Club - Branzino - Wine Bars Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

The space is nice with modern decor. Mid size rooftop. They have a DJ on Thursday and weekends nights. The drinks are good. Here's where it's has gone south... when I first started going there the food was and had flavor.. the last two times that I have gone here... the food wasn't good... either not seasoned well and not fully cooked through (wings). I don't know if they have new kitchen staff, but something has to give. It's definitely a date night spot. I'm hoping the next time I visit, the food is better. read more

My first time at MoonShine was on a Friday night with a group of 8. I had been referred by a friend who highly recommended it, especially for a girls night. The praise included a diverse menu and affordable, interesting cocktails. Enough said! The signature cocktail menu was extensive, and if you can't find something you'll enjoy, the bartenders can probably make you anything you want. There is separate bar and bar seating from the dinner/meal service, which backed up the drink orders on a Friday night. Definitely plan to order your drinks first while you check out the food menu. We ended up getting a variety of bar bites and appetizers to share, with some entrees including the cajun chicken, burgers and chicken sandwiches. The sandwiches were all great, and the table lived the burratta, calamari, and shrimp cocktail appetizer! We wished we had room to taste more of the menu!The only negative comment on the food was the caesar salad dressing does not include anchovies, and instead is included on top as a garnish. Avoid if it's not to your taste. Aside from the surprise of the caesar salad, everything was delicious, and very well cooked. The ambiance was beautiful and swanky, without being over the top. It definitely felt like an elevated evening, and was so much fun for the group! read more

See all

What a fantastic date night spot....have been meaning to come to try for awhile now..for food and the dj..but I can never stay up late enough lol! As soon as you pull up you feel the sexiness of this place..dark..mysterious..perfect lighting... drinks were on point..dirty martini and old fashioned...my husband had the parmesan wings and loved them.. I had the short rib over mashed w broccolini...super fork tender.....just delish. My boys had the burger and chicken sandwiches...both raved about them. I really wanted to try the bread pudding but I could not breathe..lol boys passed too which was a first..def be back!....loved our server too! read more

See all

I'm only giving a 2 star because the sangria was good!!! Went to brunch with 14 other women (professionals, moms, execs) celebrating a wonderful birthday event for my cousin. The menus was pre fixe $35 brunch. Service was slllloooooowwwwwwww. I mean we were the largest party in the middle of the restaurant you would think there would be a designated wait staff for drinks and food. Nonetheless we waited talked and waited. The food was subpar. Not as good as I wanted it to be. Just not enough of it in my opinion. Sangria was great. The birthday girl left very disheartened because two of her gifts were missing and she believed the staff stole it. Probably won't be back. I don't have any pics of the food. Sorry read more

Service was awful. We had two waitresses disappear, and had to flag down another to order dessert (it was a birthday). My couscous was a solid and the bronzino was still in its skin. A whole anchovy was dropped on the Caesar salad. The third waitress seems good so far but who knows if she will disappear also. One star only because of waitress number three. Also the table next door reeks of pot. read more

Stopped in for happy hour before our 7:30 show at the Papermill. They have a lovely happy hour with 1/2 appetizers and drink specials. We tried the whipped ricotta, prosciutto arugula pizza, garlic parmesan wings and the burger. Everything was great! The burger was cooked to temperature and the fries were crispy. The whipped ricotta was topped with pistachios, pomegranate and served with sourdough toast. I really loved the vibe in the bar area. Our server was very friendly and made our experience memorable. Thank you. read more

See all

Sunday brunch delicious! I've been there several times for brunch and never disappointed.

Came back to Moinshine recently and enjoyed my meal better than last time! We came for a weekday happy hour which was until 6pm. The happy hour had both food and drink items included. We started with the prosciutto and arugula flat bread which we all liked. I really liked my Caribbean chicken! The sauce was sweet and spicy, and I loved the addition of the avocado and plantains. read more

See all

I only came again because a friend was hosting a birthday afterparty here, but it was every bit as awful as I remembered maybe worse. The food was disgusting. My plate looked and tasted like it had been reheated three times. It was oily, mushy, and with a weird sour odor that honestly made me lose my appetite. One bite was enough to tell it wasn't fresh. The drink situation was just as bad. This place clearly doesn't care about their customers or their reputation. It's filthy, poorly run, and serves food I wouldn't feed to anyone. I wouldn't recommend it to my worst enemy. Total embarrassment of a restaurant. read more

Party size: 11 people I was initially excited to try this place for the sheer fact that they have the balls to offer a prix fixe menu at only $35. Which must mean they're pretty confident in their food. I was utterly and completely disappointed. The time it took us to complete our meal was 3 hours. The waiters never came regularly, the courses were served in intervals of 30-45 min it felt like. You'd finish your first course and be left waiting almost an hour till your second course. We asked for some of our dishes to be packed in to go containers and they never made it back to our table. The food was mediocre and the waiter messed up our check even after confirming with us twice to confirm items. This place is disorganized and quite frankly puts out mediocre food. The servers are clueless and the kitchen didn't even look like they were trying to rush orders out. Do yourself a favor and skip this place and go anywhere else. read more

Service awful Servers disappeared Pasta dish cold Friends fish came out with skin & head on read more

We hosted my sister's 40th birthday upstairs in the loft area and had THE BEST TIME!!! The staff was stellar from start to finish, super attentive to our needs and were sure the event went off without a hitch! Our guests enjoyed the food and drink so much!! Moonshine Supper Club was honestly the best place we could've imagined to host our party! Thank you again so much for all!! 5 stars :) read more

Really enjoyed a belated birthday dinner here. Our mixed drinks were both very good (and satisfyingly strong, unlike some places). The Caesar salad we split was well made (although it would have been more elegant if they'd split it for us). Both of us really enjoyed our entrees and the dessert we also shared. Dim space -- needed phone lights to read the menu., but enjoyed the low light for the meal. Overall I can say excellent food and drinks, a night-out ambiance, and company I enjoy. Looking forward to our next visit. read more

An amazing hole in the wall in Millburn, another great restaurant, hidden away that needs to be discovered! The specials are absolutely incredible both containing ropa Vieja yum! After visiting the Turtle Back Zoo in the morning, we decided to stop by at this hole in the wall spot just a few mins away from Zoo. The atmosphere was vibrant and fun in the bar seating area. Service was energetic and decent. The food was quite good and really tasty. The appetizers are an excellent choice. Try the Whipped Ricotta and Mediterranean Guacamole. The main dish of veggie fajitas with eggs and cheese were served over spicy collard greens and rice on the side. Now for the show stopper! The rum raisin bread pudding did not come to play. It was equal parts soft and crunchy. Served hot, with the vanilla ice cream for balance and just when you think it can't get any better you bite into a caramelized pecan with ice cream and you're in heaven. The food was great, our waiter who checked on us often was awesome and very knowledgeable and I will definitely be back over the summer when we visit the Turtle Back Zoo. read more

I had a really lovely experience at the Sunday brunch here! The food was absolutely wonderful, and the servers were so friendly and attentive. It truly made for a warm and inviting atmosphere that I really appreciated. read more

Came here for a friends birthday brunch and it was such an amazing deal! It was $35 for a prix fixe brunch menu and it was so difficult to choose between options. You can pick 3 from either a drink, appetizer, entree, or dessert. I got a Bellini, mac & cheese, and the short rib & egg fajitas. All the food was incredible. Everyone at the table loved all their food. The service was great. They were accommodating of someone who was vegan which was nice. For a table of 10 we were out in 2 hours which was perfect timing. read more

See all

Disappointing from start to finish. The restaurant reeked of cleaning solution, the bathrooms were unkempt (ironically), and the worn high-top table--like the entire bar area--looked neglected. The Korean Tuna Sashimi was a bland, cold slab of fish with no dipping sauce and an uninspired scoop of rice. It tasted off, and when I sent it back, I was interrogated instead of accommodated. My replacement cheeseburger took ages, leaving my friend to eat alone. No apology, no check-in. Non-alcoholic options? None--unless you count a begrudgingly offered Heineken 0.0. For a place that markets itself as upscale, this was amateurish. Indifferent service, tired atmosphere, and nothing like the polished image online. Won't be back. read more

First off I've come here a few times but never sat in dining room. I've only been to the bar area. Today was a nice change of pace as I joined a friend. Our waiter was so nice and personable. He really spent the time listening to us and assuring us of what we would like from the menu. The dining area is a nice chill, quiet vibe which I love because it gives time for conversation. We ordered and I must say when the food came, it did not disappoint. Flavorful, hot and presentation was gorgeous. Had a great time there! read more

See all

Celebrated our 1st grandchild and his parents at a Baby Shower in the Loft area with 30 people. What a great experience working with Victor! Plan an event at Moonshine (I had never been there) so that was nerve wracking, but Victor was kind, patient, and honest! He answered all my silly questions & there were no hidden costs. The day of the event went great! JoJo and staff members were attentive, helpful, and professional. We had our own bartender, even if we mostly drank Mocktails... they were made to perfection. I was afraid that it would be dark as the website pictures did not do the lighting justice. Food was great and plentiful! read more

See all

Bartender recommended DEPARTED SOLES BREWING PHILOSO RAPPER beer since I told him I like local beers. They are in Jersey City. ABV 8%. It is so smooth but hitting me hard. The ambiance is very dark in here. Very hard to read menu. I had to use a flashlight on my phone. I also ordered a Moonshine Burger Med-rare. Burger was juicy but don't think it was med-rare. Pommes frites were cooked perfectly but a lil too salty. The service is a bit slow but not rushing. Definitely a nice hangout for a beer and bar food. I'll come back and I do recommend. read more

See all

Moonshine is a good vibe is the DJ is there the mood is right and the bartender are pretty good.. the food was good to I enjoyed the wings

When I think of a supper club, I think of high quality, freshly made food. Unfortunately the food was anything but. The food was mediocre at best. While the portions and price were good - the quality of food simply wasn't there. The meal started with an appetizer of garlic parmesan wings. They were fine. No complaints there. They weren't great but they weren't bad and they were flavorful. The lobster eggs benedict entree had poached eggs that were overcooked. Instead of having a soft center, the yolk was almost entirely cooked. The lobster was likely canned or packaged given the dry qualities of it. The potatoes that came with it were very oily and lacked taste with maybe one or two peppers thrown in. I'm not sure if it was meant to be some sort of hash but some potatoes were cut but there were almost entire small potatoes mixed in. The creme brulee was obviously sitting in the fridge and the exterior sugar layer wasn't warmed up at all. It was a fairly big portion and the taste was ok. The flourless chocolate cake was dense and dry. It was very chocolaty but the denseness of it was just too much. Service was good. Water was refilled without asking and any asks were immediately acted on. Server was polite and attentive. If you value a good amount of food for a good price, this is a good place to go, especially these days with how much restaurant food costs. But if quality is more your thing, I would skip the place. read more

Something happened and we didn't get our food for over an hour. When we asked for things to go because we had to leave the server was incredibly rude and told us it was our fault that we had to wait over an hour for the food. I opened my food, it looked THROWN in, salad tossed over so all the crunchy bits were on the bottom, like roll had like 2 pieces of lobster. I was ready to just get over it, but this was the worst lobster roll I've ever had in my whole life. the bread was so stale I didnt eat it and, for some reason the lobster looked like it was cooked on a flat top. read more

I wanted to share my recent experience at MoonShine Modern Supper Club in Millburn NJ so others are aware. I celebrated my birthday brunch there with a party of 15 amazing friends and family. The food and vibe seemed great at first, but what happened afterward left me deeply disappointed and hurt. Early in the brunch, I received a beautiful gift--a bottle of Marc Jacobs perfume--which I placed in a small Macy's bag by my seat, tucked near a plant. As more guests arrived, I received additional gifts, and everything stayed together in that same spot. Around 6:15-6:30 PM, we began wrapping up, and my brother came to help carry everything to my husband's car. Once we got home is when I noticed the bag with the perfume was missing. I immediately called the restaurant. (I'm just 12 minutes away), and they checked but said it wasn't there. My husband and I drove back right away, and by then the area had been cleaned. No one claimed to have seen anything. We were the only group sitting in that section, which raised concerns. I asked if they had security cameras and was told the owner, Victor, was the only person who could review the footage. I called back on Tuesday when they reopened, and Victor assured me he would check the cameras and get back to me by Wednesday. He never called. I had to follow up again Wednesday evening. That's when things got frustrating. First, Victor told me the footage didn't show anything because of the camera angle. When I asked if I could review it myself (since I knew what to look for), he changed his story, saying the footage was too blurry. I pressed again, and his tone shifted--he became loud and aggressive, eventually yelling, "The cameras don't record! I can't see anything, so there's nothing I can do for you!" and hung up on me. I went back in person to speak to him, but Victor refused to come out. Instead, he sent two staff members to talk to me. I expressed my disappointment and frustration--by then it felt like my bag had been stolen and there was no accountability. One of the staff admitted the cameras do record but suggested maybe they weren't working at the time (contradicting everything Victor had told me). I have never felt so disrespected and dismissed by a business owner. It's disheartening to be treated this way, especially after choosing this place to celebrate a special occasion. I will never return, and I encourage others to think twice before dining there. A simple moment of kindness and transparency could have gone a long way--but instead, I left feeling hurt, frustrated, and deeply disappointed. read more