Food is great, menu is varied. We had a waiter named Connor, very attentive without being overly so. Will definitely ask if he's working the next time we go. Food was great, got the steak and shrimp for two ($110), came with 6 baked clams casino, large shrimp, large steak. No room for dessert! And the bartender makes a great manhattan! read more

Our waitress was wonderful. So cheerful and kind. Short ribs were good and the house salad was great. Loved my lemon drop too. They were packed on a Saturday night. Recommend reservations!! read more

Another great meal, worth the drive from Rochester. We had the surf and turf special for two again. The lobster tail was huge. The perks of the stuffed clams and garlic bread are nice touches. Salad was fresh, steak cooked perfectly and baked stuffed potato was delicious. The cost is reasonable for what you get. All staff courteous and efficient. read more

The food was exceptional. The service was great. The ambience was perfect for a party of nine. The drinks were a little bit small that could've been a little taller. We had double lobster dinner both me and my husband and it was phenomenal and our party said the steaks were perfect. read more

Let's start by mentioning that I have been to Danny Sheehan's many times over the past 5 years or more, and I keep waiting for them to impress me, but they just don't. Service is always impressive. I'm often in there for a family dinner; a larger group which can often be difficult to manage, and the servers are always on the ball, friendly, and willing to go the extra mile. Unfortunately I consistently find the food they put on the table is just way overpriced for how absolutely mid-level it is. Steaks are unimpressive. Seafood often over-cooked and rubbery. The product and price-point are in conflict with each other. Remember, 3-stars is good. They're hitting singles, and their wait staff steals a base or two, but they're certainly not hitting home runs. read more

Delicious Steaks with just the right amount of marbling that are seasoned and grilled to perfection so the juicy tenderness

Very reasonable pricing and the service was excellent. No wonder the place is always packed with customers. Many options to choose from on their menu. Lobster and a steak for $50.00 You won't find that anywhere else in Buffalo. The steak was good the lobster was could water and cooked perfectly. Many deserts to choose from and they were delicious read more

My mother in law took us here for my birthday. It's a little old fashioned but elegant. My husband had steak. It was a big cut so he was able to take some home for leftovers the next day. She had a steak sandwich. I had the horseradish encrusted salmon with au gratin potatoes. The "crust" included a lot of bread crumbs. It was a little too thick so it didn't really create a crust, and I didn't pick up any horseradish. I scraped most of it off, but the salmon itself was really thick and tasty. The potatoes were cubed instead of the thinly sliced potatoes I expected. Next time I'd stick with mashed potatoes or maybe fries. They surprised me with a wonderful cheesecake including a candle for my birthday. I didn't use the raspberry sauce it came with, but that was a nice touch, too. Good wine list, but I wish they included some local offerings. read more

Danny Sheehan's Steak House - Horseradish encrusted salmon - Steakhouses Near Me - Lockport, New York

See all

Danny Sheehans serves up great meals. Outstanding service, delicious food. I'm going back!

Amazing!! The service and food were awesome! We love this place! The food is worth the prices!

A stop at Danny Sheehan's is like stepping back in time. A traditional steakhouse offering a variety of options (where else can you order frog legs???). Service was very good for our party of five (5), which included two (2) kids. We did have a slight issue with the temperature of the veal Parmesan, but it was addressed and an entirely new entree prepared. read more

This place has some pretty decent food. Its a bar restaurant combo. Main dining area was in the back. Plenty of parking in the private lot attached. The dining area itself was homey and warm. Decor is a bit stale and the silverware had some foggy smear on it. My cloth napkin had a dry food chunk on it which was kind of gross. The waitresses were both quite nice and took time to explain specials and answer questions. We got the veal parm with pasta and the chicken sandwich. Both were decent but the flavor didn't match the cost. Items were quite expensive. The value just doesn't justify a return visit from us, but there seemed to be regulars there, as waitresses addressed some patrons on a first name basis. If you are in the area, check it out and let us know! We were also told all the chefs were in the kitchen watching the Bills game, which the servers apologized for the noise they were making. Bills must have scored some goals. Didn't bother us though, but the food could have been better. The marinara for example didn't have much seasoning or flavor at all. read more

Danny Sheehan's Steak House - Veal parm - Steakhouses Near Me - Lockport, New York

See all

Have always loved Sheehan's. I've been a regular for many years and never a bad meal. They also were amazing and accommodating for a funeral banquet. The Ennis family are great! read more

This place did not disappoint! My friend and I both ordered $29.95 filet mignon special. It comes with choice of soup, salad, 8oz filet, choice of potato, and garlic bread (can have plain bread as well). I wasn't a fan of the mashed potatoes but everything else was phenomenal! The steak was cooked as asked and nice and tender. read more

Danny Sheehan's Steak House - 8oz . Filet Mignon - Steakhouses Near Me - Lockport, New York

They were the only restaurant that would take reservations on Friday. We had a table for 8 and the food and service were great !!!

Excellent meal. Excellent service. A little difficult to get the steak doneness exactly right, but not far enough off to send back. When a special request was made that the server thought could not be accomplished she told us, rather than taking the request and disappointing us. I would eat here again. read more

Danny Sheehan's Steak House - Menu page 2 - Steakhouses Near Me - Lockport, New York

See all

I haven't been here in a few years, but this place is excellent. Just outstanding. It was one of my parent's FAVORITE places to go on the not so frequent occurrence of them going out to dinner. I came here with my siblings a few years ago while in town to commemorate them and the sale of my parent's house after my Mom passed away, and it was simply excellent. read more

Absolutely amazing dinner in Lockport, NY. Definitely worth the drive (about 25 min) from our Niagara Falls hotel. Arrived at 5pm on a Friday night and parking lot was pretty empty so there was a slight bit of concern... had made reservations which is for sure a must if any later... by the time we left about 6:30pm, there was not a seat in the house and the bar area was packed with locals waiting for a table! The Yelp reviews knocked this one out of the park as it is how we found this gem. For our meals, we ordered the NY Strip and Shrimp, two Surf and Turfs (6oz filet & 8oz lobster), and a Land and Sea (10 oz prime rib & 8 oz lobster). All four meals were spot on... deliciously tender meat... and the lobsters were cooked to perfection. Shout out to the cook... who by the way, was very helpful and pleasant when he took my reservation over the phone at 12:30pm while he was obviously cooking my prime rib ! The entire staff was great... Maddie our server and the bus boys who constantly refilled our drinks. I began the meal with a tasty cup of French Onion soup and a nice house salad; then we all capped it off with cheesecake and peanut butter pie... incredible from beginning to end. Thank you to Danny Sheehan's Steakhouse for the best meal on our trip. We will definitely return when we make it back to Niagara Falls with the grandkids. read more

Danny Sheehan's Steak House - Outside entrance - Steakhouses Near Me - Lockport, New York

This is my new special occasion dinner place. It's a bit pricey but our food was Excellent. My husband got the steak and lobster combo. Top 2 best Steak possibly #1. I had the seafood plate, huge scallops and everything was cooked right. I wasn't a fan of the au gratin but Everything else was Delicious! I highly recommend. read more

Danny Sheehan's Steak House - The most delicious Steak and Lobster. - Steakhouses Near Me - Lockport, New York

Wonderful food, exceptional service and beer is fresh from the tap and cold!. Fast service and enjoyable! read more

See all

First time going there on a weekend. Sat in the back room (looks like it might open up to an outdoor patio Atmosphere: Feels like a more traditional converted house type of older restaurant I grew up going to. Bar area is small but with the extra room in the back, has enough seating. Clean Service: Honestly, the service should be their selling point. They had 2-large groups (20+ ppl) during the time we were there and yet our server was exceptionally attentive (even took the time to explain the different salts) and the food was timely. Previously working in a kitchen, I actually am not sure how they pulled this off Food: Ordered the veal and seafood platter. Veal was cooked very well and the lobster in the seafood platter was noticeably fresh Overall: Worth the little bit of a drive out of the way, looking forward to going back and trying the steak read more

Our meal here was so disappointing while being very expensive. The onion rings were hard as a rock. We asked for a fresh order but were told they were "all out." This was at 6pm on a Friday...all out? My friend dined at another table and was served onion rings after we returned ours. Our salads looked like they were pulled out of the garbage - wilted with Romaine leaves that had turned pink. My broiled seafood platter was delicious and fresh but lukewarm and the green beans were actually cold. My dining partner had liver and onions and it was burned and dry - inedible. read more

As always this is one of the top steak restaurants in America. I don't know know how they do it. If you like Prime Rib this is the place.

Great meal from start to finish. I started with a Harp's draft beer. Salad with bleu cheese crumbles 12 oz Filet, baked potato, garlic bread. Strawberry cheesecake. Our service was great. Our waitress "Amber" was on top of things all night. I had kinda a special order with my steak. I wanted it slightly cooked more than medium but less than medium-well. I was done perfectly. One of my top ten steaks ever. You must get the cheesecake, no matter how full you are....get it. It's great. Thanks Danny's. We will be back read more

Dinner was AMAZING!! ALL is the items we ordered were DELICIOUS!! The waitstaff are super attentive, friendly and accommodating. It's pretty small inside but cozy!! Overall a wonderful dining experience. Will ABSOLUTELY return. read more

Worst service ever. Booked a party for 25 people on a Friday night after my father's wake. We arrived on time, and nothing was ready. They tried to seat us separately, but could only accommodate about 12 of us. The rest would have to wait another 40 minutes. We ended up leaving, but many of our party were elderly and hadn't been fed. Others were from out of town, and didn't know where else to go. It was a disaster! read more

Here we are day 30 of being safe at home. We decided to take out from Sheehan's for my parents anniversary. The food was so good! My mom got steak, au gratin potatoes, garlic toast. My brother and dad got a seafood platter with fries and au gratin potatoes. They both said their food was great! We also got an order of onion rings and stuffed clams( they are gross in my opinion!) I got as usual the chicken Dijon with fries. It's good but the chicken was a little bit tough tonight and my French onion soup was forgotten. I forgive them because we had a huge order and plus they are working their tails off and during curbside pick up (a plus!!) during an unknown time. read more

Danny Sheehan's Steak House - Chicken Dijon, French Fries, onion rings and garlic toast. - Steakhouses Near Me - Lockport, New York

I ordered the broiled seafood platter, and I have to say it was the worst meal I have ever had. Everything was overcooked and just not good at all. This was my first time eating anything from this restaurant and I won't ever eat here again. read more

It took us about a half an hour to drive there, but it was well worth the money! I got the prime rib, salad, home fries and garlic toast. It was extremely good!!! I will definitely be back again!! Everyone was very nice and welcoming. -We went for our wedding anniversary dinner. read more

Staff was attentive and friendly but that's where it ends. One of the worst meals I have ever had when dining out at a more pricey establishment. Shameful that a steak house would serve a cold filet. When I say cold I mean cold, not even slightly warm - same for my potato. I understand they were busy, however, cold food is never acceptable. I have no idea how they've stayed in business so long??? read more

This is our favorite Special Occasion Spot! Everything from Service to delicious food! Steaks are Wow! Pork chops-absolutely Yummy! Sides are awesome and very good Poutine! read more

It's always good day when I come here for dinner lol. Absolutely the best steak and lobster tail you can get in Lockport. Definitely my go to place when it comes to steak. read more

See all

We had our small company party there last night. What a lovely dinner. The filet was delightful. The staff all seemed to be working together. Our whole party enjoyed themselves. Would definitely recommend. read more

Looking for something different than the hustle and bustle of Amherst/Clarence restaurants on Transit Road? If so, the relatively short drive to Lockport is worth the trip. Somewhat off the beaten path if you are not familiar with Lockport but easy to find. Don't let the outside curb appeal fool you but if you are expecting to find glitz inside, this probably isn't the place for you. If you are looking for very good quality food, at very reasonable prices and well trained friendly servers, then this IS the place for you. Inside surroundings are basic. Food? Large well thought out menu. Surf and turf for two was excellent. It included two six ounce fillets, two eight ounce lobster tails, clams casino, salad, garlic toast, and potato for $85. An amazing bargain! Drink prices are low and save room for desserts, they too are inexpensive, generous portions and a great way to finish a meal. read more

Wow this place was top notch! Everything that we ordered was delicious! Great quality steaks and seafood at half the cost of some! They have great options for sharing and meals for two Salad dressing was prob the best I ever had But steak and lobster will be the reason I go back read more

I have only been to this place twice. The staff is really nice and attentive. I would give them five stars based off of the service they provided. Unfortunately the food was where we ran into sort of an issue. Both times I had the fish fry which I enjoyed. We ordered stuffed mushrooms, stuffed peppers and corn fritters for starters. The corn fitters were not done (goopy) in the middle, the mushrooms had very little flavor. I also had the French onion soup which had absolutely 0 flavor whatsoever! I wouldn't want to bring a girl here on a date or a family member here as the food seems to be inconsistent. However this is just my opinion as the place was packed so they seem to have many patron customers. read more

Very cozy steak house. Plenty of menu options and specials. I enjoyed my food very much. I would love if you could order a crab leg side cluster ro accompany a steak meal. The peanut butter cheesecake was amazing , ordered a slice to go! Staff very courteous read more

See all

Birthday dinner here tonight, was a nice experience. It is definitely steakhouse prices and venue but it was totally worth it. Great steak and salads. The fries were certainly frozen, and it did take quite awhile for the food to come (almost an hour). However the wait staff was incredibly nice and very helpful. read more

Danny Sheehan's Steak House - Steakhouses Near Me - Lockport, New York

Had my birthday dinner this March. The wait for our meal was almost 45 minutes. Seven of us. Ordered the prime rib and it was so tough, my friend ordered the prime rib sandwich and it also was tough. Another ordered fish, it was undercooked and sent back. Didn't order another meal because of the wait. My husband ordered broiled fish and it looked like a Swanson frozen entree. The other meals were not at all good. Won't be going back. Too bad, it use to be a nice restaurant. read more

Best Steak house around! My family and I frequent here often and have never had a bad meal or service. The food is amazing and reasonably priced & the staff is always friendly and accommodating! read more

Danny Sheehan's Steak House - Homemade Cheesecake - Steakhouses Near Me - Lockport, New York