The name "cuttthroat" is very fitting to the attitude of this restaurant. The kids oatmeal was definitely targeted towards kids with the most immature of palettes. The mushroom and Swiss omelette was exactly as described. There was a lovely view of the highway brought the bustling sounds of cars to your table as you ate. Overall, I left feeling more full and a little more depressed than I arrived. read more

Buddy and I were looking for a breakfast place to meet one morning on the way to a camping fishing trip. Arrived 7am. Many people coming and going from restaurant.. looks sma but very spacious inside.. small town feel which I love.. lots of locals which I love.. staff was great folks was great! This place going on our list to stop next time through.. glad we found it. read more

Cutthroat Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bailey, Colorado

It wasn't terrible, but it wasn't great either. First of. The silverware and cups were dirty and didn't seem to have been cleaned properly. The salt shaker was old since it was rocked up inside. The food was bland hence I had to add extra salt. The service was good that's why I gave it 3 stars instead of two. We sat out on the patio where there were many flies on our food. There was a dog with a patron and when it shaked the dirt off it's fur it created lots of dust particles that I'm sure landed on people food. The only thing good was the French Toasts. read more

See all

A local recommended this place! Looks so cute and homey on the outside... it looked packed, but we were sat and attended right away! They work quick and in a great manner. We were iffy on going in because other local places weren't very accepting of outsiders/tourists. But the Cutthroat Cafe welcomed us warmly and made us feel at home. Everyone talked to us, gave us recommendations on what to do locally, gave us some history on the town, and helped us really enjoy our meal. The food was great!!! The cook (and person in charge i believe) made us Mickey Mouse pancakes once he found out we are from FL. He came out and greeted us soo kindly.. as well as every single person working there! Also, the green chile smother they put on the eggs is one of a kind. All in all, an amazing place and way to start your day when visiting or just passing by. Thanks for your kindness Cutthroat Cafe! read more

Cutthroat Cafe - Mickey pancakes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bailey, Colorado

I've only been here for breakfast but the food has been good (this said I'd recommend they serve real butter with pancakes vs. margarine or whatever it was); nice staff; appreciate that they open nice and early (5am). read more

Perfect spot for a quick breakfast or lunch. Everyone at our table of 6 cleaned their entire plates! I had the "Reel Deal" with pancakes and it encompassed everything to make an ideal breakfast dish. The staff was really friendly and accommodating. I would stop here again if I'm ever passing through! read more

Cutthroat Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bailey, Colorado

See all

If you don't mind listening to old men ranting about carrying guns in their back pocket - and using the "n" word in every sentence-l enjoy your breakfast and join them- otherwise STAY CLEAR! When I complained to server was told "they are regulars and think they can get away with it"... apparently they did! Won't go back- EVER!!!! read more

Bottom line: small town vibes with good food and service. We'd go back! A group of 6 of us stopped here for breakfast on our way to Crested Butte. Everyone was very friendly, service was quick and the coffee was good. Our table got the smothered breakfast burrito (a fan favorite topped with green chili), hot beef sandwich and a potato skillet ( can't remember the nane) and all were delicious. read more

The food is a great value for what you get on the plate. The ownership is local and very friendly. The wait staff are always nice and punctual. The atmosphere is very inviting. I have loved eating here for many years. I definitely recommend cutthroat café for all your dining needs. read more

Great local cafe in Bailey with lots of food choices for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Our family of 4 ordered chicken tenders which were delicious, a french dip which was large and filling and a grilled cheese that my son LOVED! Each came with a large serving of fries. I wish they had been salted, they would have tasted even better. Great friendly service! read more

Outstanding grilled cheese -- and KIDS LOVED IT (so did adults). Friendly service, nice outside dining, and marvelous food. Everything was delicious. 8-year-olds said the grilled cheese was best ever. Adults loved the burgers, omelets and fish and chips. Can't wait to pass thru this town again for another meal!! read more

Service was excellent, food was terrific, employees were polite Mountain People as were most of the customers. Local ambiance made everything that much better. Highly recommend to others and have been back several times on my own. Do yourself a BIG favor, give it a try. read more

This was our second stop at the cafe. The first time it took us about 2 hours to get our food and we said we'd never go back. We gave them another chance yesterday and it took us 1 hour and 45 minutes to get our mediocre meals. My husband's cheeseburger was about the size of a 50 cent piece. His burger was delivered first and he was finished before I got my salad and my son got his sandwich. The waitress at one point told us we had 10 minutes left before our food was served....we timed it, it was 25 minutes after she said 10. I see a lot of great reviews so perhaps breakfast is what you need to order but be prepared to not get anything done for the day. read more

The locals gather & eat here Plenty of breakfast options n good eats Friendly atmosphere Time well spent read more

Not impressed with the proportion size or the quality of food. The food seemed way over priced for what was given. We think food out of a food truck tastes better than here. read more

This is an incredible restaurant with excellent service and high food quality. It is clean and welcoming. I look forward to another visit.

Very good local place - character! Breakfast options are resonable in price/portion Staff is friendly , owner is very nice Hash browns are great Good stop to break up the drive to or from the High Country read more

It is not an eye catching place, as the facility is across the street. But the food and service is always great. It has a very warm personality to it that is very difficult to get and even harder to keep. I live up here and am VERY pleased this is only a 10-12 minute drive away! Thank you to everyone that is there for making it such a great place! read more

Stopped here for a late breakfast. There was a car show with music, so we sat on the patio. Lots of food at a good price. I had a Reel Deal breakfast with everything. I am stuffed! Heading to the car show to walk it off. :P read more

We were out for a little drive and found ourselves hungry...and in Bailey. We saw the Cutthroat Cafe and noticed that they had outdoor seating, which was what we were looking for since we had our dog with us. Things are different these days, so you are asked to read the menu before entering and order at the counter. They would then assign a table to ensure social distancing. It worked fine and we even bought T-shirts! Service was very friendly and on point, they even provided water and a bowl for the dogs that were on the patio. The food was excellent and portions plentiful. We both had the Longhorn and were both very happy with our meal. The place was also very clean, and all tables and chairs were thoroughly wiped down between customers. This is how it should be anyway, but these days it is especially important and seeing it was appreciated. Staff and customers were all wearing masks except when eating, so that was great as well. If you find yourself in Bailey, give this place a shot! Great food and even better people! read more

My daughter and I stopped in for lunch after we visited The Sasquatch Outpost and were NOT disappointed. You could tell this was the spot the locals came to, for good reason. Food was plentiful, delicious, and well-priced. Not too long of a wait, even though they were busy. The servers were super friendly, prompt, and their busser was attentive, as well. We will definitely be back! read more

We stopped in our way out of town from Denver for the weekend this past Thursday and we were pleasantly surprised. The food was delicious and the two ladies running service were fantastic! We will definitely be back! read more

I came to Cut Throat Cafe to read a bit and enjoy some pie. The owner was yelling at one of his employees for a solid 10+ minutes in the middle of the cafe because the kid had bailed on a shift on their biggest day of the year. However, if you want to chew a 17-year-old kid out and treat him as a subhuman, please do it out back instead of displaying cruelty in front of the patrons. I wish that kid had stood up for himself and walked out. If I hadn't already ordered, I certainly would have. Which would have saved me from eating some pretty terrible pie. The only things saving this cafe from a one-star review are the friendly waitstaff, the fellow customers, and fish-joke decor. read more

This is an updated review. For those of you who haven't stopped there for lunch or dinner, I will definitely say it's worth your effort. Their "Longhorn Burger" is the burger which will make burger fans pant out its name at night. It's a burger smothered in their homemade green chili with lots of added cheese and onions. Sinfully delicious! This burger is the one reason why I don't complain if I miss their cutoff for breakfast. It's solidly good for a Southwestern burger connoisseur. If you are there early and wanting breakfast, you really can't go wrong with their breakfast menu. They serve it until noon during the week and 2pm on the weekends. So, why four stars and not 5? Well, while their breakfasts and Longhorn Burger are great, some of their other food is less so. I'm remarkably unaccustomed to chicken fried steak coming with anything other than homemade cream gravy. The brown gravy it comes with is "meh." Many of their other dishes are not as good as what I consider "home style" but it IS the joint for breakfasts, burgers and maybe a pie for dessert. It may not be fancy but is a good, friendly place that gets a solid 4 stars for having this quality in the mountains. read more

I like this place and would happily give it another star or two, but a breakfast place that does not have real butter, anywhere, even if you ask the kitchen and are willing to pay extra for it, just won't get my business. The Cut Throat Cafe needs butter, plain and simple. This guy does not do margarine on his pancakes and toast. The food is tasty, but c'mon people, give us what we need... butter is truly healthier for living humans anyway... the body knows what to do with it. read more

Ok so we got there after 2 hours in 285 traffic! Yuck! And I was so disappointed because we arrived there at 2:10pm and breakfast was over at 2pm. I asked the waitress to make sure and she said yes. then lo and behold, Chip's head (I think it was him) pops over the wall and says last call for breakfast! WAHOO! Breakfast is my fave! I got french toast which was totally yummy. i think the secret is in the bread. 2 eggs over easy and hash browns. 9 yo got biscuits and gravy which he said was "da bomb." hubby got a french dip which he said was pretty good for being in the middle of nowhere. and they took CC. only 4 stars because service was a little chaotic and i hate when i ask for an extra plate for my 2yo and they bring that plate last. anyone with a toddler knows how fun they are when they have to sit and watch everyone else eat while we wait for their plate. maybe i should start asking for it ahead of time. read more

I went to the Cut Throat Cafe on my way to fish just outside Bailey, CO. It was a very cute, hometown diner! The food was delicious and I really got the homecooked feel. I got the half order of the "Reel Breakfast" which was basically everything you could want in a breakfast - eggs, bacon, ham, and sausage, smothered in cheese, on top of hash browns. Yum! read more

Great comfort food - closed down for short while due to a fire... The owner Chip is fun to chat with and he always has a good story and laugh. read more

We took a roadtrip to Fairplay one Saturday morning and on our way back hit the Cut Throat Cafe for some lunch. I liked the simplicity of it - good location and also the option to have breakfast up to 2:00 PM on a Saturday is a good thing. One of the BEST grilled cheeses I have had in a long time. Gooey, cheesy, buttery goodness with crisp edges on the bread = BIG YUM! The french fries were also crisp and thinner than the usual fry. My husband rocked the fried chicken sandwich - 2 large chicken strips in a bun with lettuce, tomato, pickles and mayo. Looked really good! Service was also super chill and friendly. We'll hit the Cut Throat again on our next trip up or down the mountain! read more

My daughter's name is Bailey, so we made an obligatory drive out to this town ONLY for the purchase of a "Bailey, Co." t-shirt and a couple cool photo ops with her in front of the city sign. so we were happy to wander into The Cut Throat Cafe and find yummy, home-made food at a super-reasonable price. Thick, juicy well-prepared burgers are the highlight here, as is the green-chili sauce that tops the open faced Longhorn Burger. really delicious and less than seven bucks. it's a no brainer. word at the counter was that breakfast is the main draw at cut throat, and as i recall, it's served all day--which is a bonus to any diner, in my mind. the desserts are all homemade and looked simply stellar, but we'd already gotten a craving for malt shakes from the little gift shop / soda shop across the alley, so we meandered over there and were happy with our chocolate malts. still, if i find myself in Bailey again, i'm going for the pie. thumbs up. read more

The Owner does not treat his employees properly and it's A dirty enviroment from the greasy menus to the in kempt floors, I was sitting in at the counter one day and listened to him yell at an employee over the phone because he didn't come in to work because a family issue showed up last second read more

When you are here, Chip and his staff make you feel like family. The prices are amazing, and food is very good, and their green chili is some of the best in all of Colorado. The best part is they serve breakfast all day, and their breakfast is the best thing about this place. If you are passing through Baily, this is the place to eat. Or if you live in Baily as some of my family does, then this is where you go. While the food is very good, this is not a fancy gourmet restaurant, its more of a greasy spoon, but if you are in the mood for greasy spoon type food, the Cutthroat Cafe is heads and tails above the rest. read more

Nothing fancy but reasonable food. Cheap With good service. I would not call this place a go to restaurant but it is good enough for a bit of cheap fair on a road trip. read more

We'll, if you want some down home cooking, a big ole cup of bottomless coffee, and a very friendly waitstaff, this is the place for you! Nothing fancy, but this is Americana! I had the chicken fried steak (pork) with great mashed potatoes and white gravy. My wife had the Husky Burger with fries and it was perfectly cooked. Will gladly come back! read more

The daily special was steak and eggs. Sounded good, so I tried it. Meh. Although the service was friendly and prompt, my food was nothing to call home about. I had to ask for water, which wasn't refilled. The coffee was nothing special, also never refilled. I ordered my steak medium rare and eggs over easy. Both were over-cooked. I couldn't even identify the cheap cut of meat on my plate. The hash browns were decent, not quite browned enough, though. They did get the toast right. All that being said, my buddy said his biscuits and gravy were good. The prices were astonishingly reasonable. The dining room was bustling with locals during our whole visit. Maybe it was just bad luck on my end, everyone else there seemed to be enjoying their food. If I were in the area again, I'd give it another shot. I wanted to love this place. Maybe, if there is a next time. read more

Cute country cafe in the mountains;-) Friendly service, filling food and great prices!!! Stop in for breakfast and lots of coffee refills. read more

Cutthroat Cafe - Breakfast Menu - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bailey, Colorado

I was driving back to Denver from Breckinridge with my wife & 2 kids & as it was 2 PM & we hadn't had lunch we decided to stop & eat. The restaurant has a lot of covered outdoor seating, but as it was raining & windy we decided to eat inside. The diner had 2 other seated parties & was filling take out orders as well. The cafe looks like it used to be a home that has been converted to a diner. We were seated immediately by a very sweet young lady who told us it was her 2nd day on the job. We ordered "typical" diner food ( cheese burgers with fries, etc.) within 10 minutes after being seated. Our drinks came out within 5 minutes. We then proceeded to wait 45 minutes to get our food! Our waitress refilled my Coke 5 times & after 20 minutes I started asking her to check on the status of our order. When our food finally came out at 3 PM, after I asked for napkins & silverware, we were able to eat. The food was served hot, so it hadn't been made and then forgotten. The quality of everyone's dish was like you'd expect from a good diner. It just took forever to get it! read more

It's a nice local diner. Anything you try will be decent, cheap prices too. Nothing froofroo, so don't expect it. Whether you are local or live "down the hill", you're welcome. Chip's French Toast is tasty. Or try the cheeseburger with homemade green chili. The cinnamon buns are homemade & big with whipped butter. With a cup of coffee, it's breakfast itself. If they're busy, the staff might not be perfect. But they're good people who care. Respect begets respect. Mostly local clientele, which is why you won't hear anyone complain. Unless Chip comes out to visit! Afterward, walk down the street to the Knotty Pine & have Barb make you a latte or other special coffee. Or stop by before you hit the Cuthroat for good Bongo Billy coffee. Bailey is like Mayberry in the mountains, so eavesdrop on some local topic hashing. read more

Stopped here on the way back into Denver. Once our order was placed the waitress never checked in with us again until she brought our food. My husband's plate included FIVE french fries. Only FIVE french fries. We were never offered refills or asked how things were. Food and service was subpar at best. read more

Great breakfast, great prices and all the comforts of home cooking. The staff makes you feel like family. Favorite of many Locals, including my husband and myself! read more

Cutthroat Cafe - Hearty breakfast ! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bailey, Colorado