This little food joint was the perfect location to stop and go. Traveling from Cañon City, Colorado to Salt Lake City, Utah and it was the best food we had all weekend! Great Staff, very friendly and opened to give suggestions on food. BEST Sweet Potato Fries I've ever had! The sandwich of the day was the Perfect Spicy Crispy Chicken Sandwich like no other...with so much flavor. My husband had a breakfast burrito and said it was the best burrito he's had in his life! Loved the vibe it had and we were so glad they had a public bathroom around back with Koala Care for us to change our baby! read more

See all

Outstanding chicken sandwiches in the mountains, dubbed America's highest fried chicken. I was on a men's trip and we were staying near Fairplay. We stopped here twice. Both times I ordered their Original Chicken sandwich. Each time we visited, it was busy. Limited parking, a line, sparse seating. The staff was friendly and attentive, personable and calm under pressure. The orders kept coming and they kept steady hands on the fryers pumping out consistently good food. This chicken sandwich was the best I've had. Large, all white meat, quality chicken. It was perfectly fried with a thinner breading. It didn't over power the meat but complemented it. The only topping this sandwich needs is pickles. They were thicker than normal, fresh, crunchy and juicy. The honey butter and fresh toasted bun rounded it all out. The side of fries were good too, crunchy and flavorful. If you're near Fairplay and looking for a good meal, go here. I'd go back. read more

Otto’s - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

See all

A nice little Oasis in the middle of the mountains. Was visiting for a buddies wedding and I had to drive there from Denver. Half way there I was starving and ran into this place. Everything is amazing including the people . It's one of those laid back hippie joints that you barely see anymore. I mean that in the best way possible They do a mean chicken sandwich and I left happy :) simple enough read more

Wow! What a roadside surprise!!! Food was fantastic, service was fast and friendly and you could tell everything was made from scratch!! Something for everyone! read more

See all

Went here to try their fried chicken sandwich and the reviews are well deserved. The colossal Cajun fried chicken was giant, perfectly crispy and had a great sauce and soft bun. Can seem pricy for $17.95 without fries but like I said is massive. The service was fast and friendly. You order at a counter but there's seating inside including high chairs, booster seats and colouring for kids read more

Otto’s - Colossal Cajun fried chicken - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Fairplay can be such an unassuming drive through town, but I promise this place is worth the stop. Jam packed of delicious sandwiches, lots of options including vegan choices, there is without a doubt something for everyone. We took recommendations from the worker and landed ourselves with a basket of Cajun fries, the Otto's special chicken sandwich and the cheesesteak plus a large selection of dipping sauces for the fries. Everything was incredible, great portions and flavor, truly not a negative to remark about. Staff was friendly and attentive, vibe easy going, walk up and order and pick a seat, plus outdoor patio space. Will certainly be back read more

Otto’s - Cheesesteak, Otto's special chicken sandwich, Cajun fries. - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Spectacular sandwiches at 9500 ft in the Rockies! We were staying near Fairplay for a few weeks this summer/fall and had seen Otto's but never actually stopped there. This time, we made plans to have one dinner there and it was absolutely worth it. I had the Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich, all the way with their serrano slaw and blue cheese dressing and my wife had the Classic. The chicken is absolutely that - a fried whole chicken breast - no marinade, no special flavors - just chicken. No surprises, no "weird" tastes - and the menu is diverse enough that you can find something to match your tastes and appetite, from basic to "everything," as our order shows. There's no skimping on the toppings or flavors. The sweet potato fries were a very nice surprise - they were thicker cut vs. the thing, shoestring types you so often get elsewhere. They had a crisp outside, soft inside and kept their heat well. The hashbrown - both a side and a topping - was perfectly crisp. Now it's someplace that when we're back to Fairplay we'll probably hit again, especially to try to he breakfast burritos others rave about. read more

See all

We came in the biggest snow storm of the year. We were welcomed warmly with some of the friendliest service I've had in a while. They had crayons and coloring sheets for the kids. The food was as wonderful as the service. The breakfast burrito was baller! Just a perfect stop! read more

Otto’s - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

5 stars for their bacon, egg, and cheese biscuit sandwich! We popped into Fairplay for a quick breakfast while staying in a nearby town and I'm so glad we stopped at Otto's. It's an order-at-the-counter type of place with several tables to dine at and the people working there were very friendly. Their breakfast biscuit sandwich was one of the better breakfast sandwiches I've had. The biscuit was super flavorful and moist, didn't crumble apart when biting into it, and was perfectly stuffed with gooey cheddar cheese, fried egg, and crispy bacon. I don't believe it's on their main menu, but for $8 it was such a nice surprise. A place I'd come back to again and again. read more

See all

This unassuming restaurant was crowded with regulars but the line moved quick. Great flavors but the original was a bit underwhelming. Definitely go for the spicy for some great chicken. read more

This place is a MUST stop on a road trip. The chicken sandwich was delicious and the employees were so incredibly nice.

We stopped here to get BLTa to take with us on a backpacking trip and they were excellent! Service was very friendly and quick too. read more

Otto’s - BLT - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Best Chicken Sandwich out there. Sauce is chef's kiss . Great service. Fries with Cajun are a must-do add. Plan this stop on your way out to Salina. Heck - make it a day trip. It's THAT good. read more

Saw great reviews so decided to try this place out. Ordered the original chicken sandwich, the cowgirl fries and the sweet tarot cinnamon fries- the fries are huge!! Just be warned!! Can share between 3 people!!! The sandwich itself was decent. We also custom ordered a kids steak burrito for our dogs- out dogs loves them. Very friendly people and accommodating. read more

See all

We really liked Otto's! They are fast and delicious. Definitely recommend the breakfast sandwich with bacon. Good drip coffee too!

Had the Philly Cheesesteak. Quite close to a Philly Cheesesteak from Philadelphia/South Jersey. Will stop at Otto's again. read more

Good cuban and special hot sub. Perhaps pricy, but good food. Sunny day, mountains! read more

Breakfast for the win here in this super positive space! Stayed in Jefferson but drove through this town on the way to Breckenridge/Idaho Springs. So happy we stopped. Open on a Monday (thank you!) which is always a challenge to find. Great vegetarian choices for my one. Cheese quesadilla for the picky one. Plenty of options for the rest of us. I was so torn on what to order-famous chicken sandwich or the breakfast burrito. Ordered the burrito, filled me up for the entire day!! I'll have to try the sandwich on another adventure. read more

See all

Still dreaming about their spicy chicken sandwich. Perfection. Spice mild & flavorful, coleslaw, perfectly crispy chicken & dripping with homemade ranch. Sooooooo good. Service was great & fast - friendly order at the counter & they bring the food to you. Spot for filling water at the counter was perfect before our hike. Outdoor picnic tables or a few tables inside that can seat 4 at a table. We were a group of 7 so we sat outside. Bathroom out back. Small parking lot. There was a consistent line the whole time - I can see why! read more

Otto’s - Spicy chicken sandwich & basket of fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Yes, the chicken sandwich is excellent. So are the fries. Be prepared for a queue and to wait a bit for your food. Everything is made to order. The 3 Otto's hot sauces are very flavorable. The service is very friendly. There is plenty of seating. - paper napkins - no beer read more

All things considered, the best chicken sandwich I've had! another in my group said the same about the Philly Cheesesteak. This spot is great. I bought a bottle of the "Creole" hot sauce. The only nitpick I could give is the lack of umberella outside at the picnic tables. Incredible food! read more

If you are in Fairplay and don't eat here you are a fool. Best sandwiches and fried chicken.

The vegan burrito here is good. It's got a lot of different components. Wasn't too spicy even with the jalapeños. Surprised to actually feel like I got an actual fully conceptualized vegan meal in Fairplay. I'm going to eat this burrito approximately another 1,000 times. read more

Otto’s - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

See all

The food was so delicious! Stopped in for breakfast and had the breakfast burrito, honey chicken biscuit and mountain cristo. So glad we ate here! Service was top notch! read more

Fiancé is gluten free so we had to stop and try it out. We got the original chicken sandwich and everything from the chicken, the bun and the pickles were sooo good. Cant wait to try more stuff from there because everything looks good. Just wish we lived in fairplay so we could eat there more. read more

Otto’s - Original chicken sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Huge breakfast sandwiches. Great staff who are super friendly. Worth a stop if you go through Fairplay

This place is an epic must-visit in the quirky town of Fairplay. The chicken sandwiches lived up to the hype and the staff was very cool. Dogs are welcome on the patio and they were even given treats with owner approval. It was a nice crowd patiently waiting and we spoke to some cool families while we ate and waited. We definitely look forward to a return on our next trip through the area. Flavor was good on the Cajun style sandwich, fries were great and it was BIG portions, piping hot. What's not to love? Parking is tough, so come early or wiggle in somewhere. read more

See all

Best sweet potato fries in Colorado. Great surprise for a people who like really good food. In the middle of nowhere is a food truck and the food is awesome. read more

Really great place. Love the vibe for sure. Everything is fresh and the employees are kind and helpful. One of our favorites is of course the original chicken sandy, regular fries. The house sauce is the real winner and their pickles are the real deal. Only downside is parking is not great, if you wanna eat there not too many places to sit (we usually take ours Togo) and it's pricy. However that's to be expected unfortunately in a mountain town :( Finally 5% discount if you pay cash!! Kudos Otto's!!! In a sadly cashless society we love to support a business that still values a cold hard dollar :) read more

Absolutely delicious! Chicken, cheesesteak, boneless wings, fries - regular and sweet potato, and one incredible vegetarian burrito! Great service and cute little place! read more

Otto’s - Boneless wings and slaw. - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

See all

Otto's is always great. Breakfast burritos at any time of day, yummy fried chicken sandwiches, good fries. Love it! Otto's also does a solid takeout business, and you can call ahead for it. It can be a little crowded around dinner time on weekends, so plan accordingly. read more

A reliable little stop in Fairplay. The waiter was pleasant and the Bacon Breakfast Burrito was tasty...washed it down with a good cup of coffee. A little pricey, but it was a tasty breakfast! read more

The food here is INCREDIBLE, amazing fried chicken sandwich. It's definitely on the pricier side is my only note but love stopping here whenever I'm driving 285 read more

Chicken was crispy and flavorful. The fries were a great buy. Definitely will be coming again. Super cool atmosphere and super cool that is the highest fried chicken in America. Service was super good and quick. read more

Otto’s - Crispy chicken sandwich with a side of fries. - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Best fried checked sammie ever! The hot honey chicken is out of this world good! It's so fresh, you can tell it's all handmade - no pre-packaged, frozen chicken here. So nice to have a must-stop in Fairplay! read more

Otto’s - LOL - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

A small place with a big taste! You order up at the counter and they have a few tables inside as well as outside for seating. It was our first time and so we naturally ordered a little bit of everything. We tried the Otto's special chicken sandwich and oh my gosh, you have to try it. Full of taste. We had the Philly cheese steak and it was a little different from what were use to, a hint of sweetness but nonetheless it was good. Now let's talk about the hot honey boneless chicken wings... mouthwatering. Until now I thought I didn't like hot honey but they proved me wrong. We had the hot honey chicken sandwich too and of course it was delicious. Fries were fried just perfectly. We ordered the BLT but by this point I was too full, however my brother said it was the best BLT he's had. Beverages come separately and sold in bottle/can ( no fountain drink). Kids menu is available and the portions are large. I have a 7 year old who could only eat half his cheese quesadilla. Staff were supper helpful and friendly. The place was clean, bathroom is located outside and around the corner. read more

See all

People are very friendly. I got the cheesesteak and Cajun fries. Service quick and was great. Weather was great sat outside at a picnic table with my dogs. read more

Otto’s - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

See all

Best chicken sandwich of my entire life. And my whole family feels the same way about it. I've got two teen boys - which is basically the same as eating with a professional food critic and they were both stoked on the food. Also the customer service was outstanding. The guy who took our order was so cool and welcoming. Well done yall. read more

Great place for sandwiches, and they serve breakfast all day. We were a little surprised at the average $15 price for a sandwich without fries in such a small basic spot. But our pastrami sandwich was amazing and the side of fries yummy. There are a few tables inside and also outside. The chef came to ask if we enjoyed our food and was super friendly! read more

See all

I have to say I was not expecting this quality of food in the middle of nowhere Fairplay. I had the Hot Strami sandwich and it was magical. The pastrami was a little spicy and had absolutely zero fat in it! The meat to bread to coleslaw ratio was perfect! The fries were hot and crispy! The menu was much more diverse than I had anticipated. I wanted to try so many things but I'm happy with what I ate. Be prepared to spend a small fortune for this food. A sandwich, French fries and can of soda cost me $27. Despite the price, the place was packed. It's a small building with seating for 15-20 people maybe? And the parking is very minimal but aside from that it was a very good meal. read more

Otto’s - Hot Strami and fries! - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado