It's been a nearly two years since I last updated my string of reviews for this Costco. However, a recent turn of events has caused me to particularly appreciate their extreme dedication to customer service and the degree to which they stand behind the products they sell, regardless of who is at fault.
You may recall my earlier review concerning an Oxi-Clean stain-removal product that actually caused a worse stain--coincidentally on a Kirkland polo. In that case, Costco not only refunded the cost of both the Oxi-Clean, but also insisted on refunding the cost of the Kirkland polo. I thought that was incredibly awesome in and of itself.
However, Costco stands equally behind its grocery product, and that's the focus of this update. Grocery products are a more finicky lot. There's considerable handling between harvester/producer, distribution channels and warehouse club. Many things can go wrong. I'm normally pretty reticent about returning grocery items, and nearly always take the loss myself, simply due to the hassle and inconvenience of keeping a bad product until I can return it. I certainly don't abuse the return privilege on these items by any stretch of the imagination.
In one case, for some reason, Costco was getting incredibly perishable bags of Mountain King potatoes. Yes, they had been on cold storage, which seems de rigeur for potatoes these days. After several consecutive sacks of Mountain King that didn't even last a week, I'd had enough and returned one. Not only was there no problem, the Costco associate encouraged me to do so whenever I felt inclined, saying "We want you to be satisfied with everything we sell, so if this happens again, please don't hesitate." Fair enough. [Oh, by the way, Mountain King no longer supplies this Costco's russet potatoes, and quality has improved.]
The real test happened earlier this Fall, with a prepackaged meat item. I had sampled the item (Southside Market of Elgin's cry-o-vac beef brisket) at an in-store demo, and thought it to be tasty, convenient, and a good value. I kept the brisket at home well-refrigerated in the coldest part of the refrigerator for a couple of weeks before I opened it, well within the "sell-by" date posted on Southside Market's own packaging.
When I opened the cry-o-vac, the Southside Market brisket absolutely reeked of Chinese-made plastic. I'm not sure if it was the wrapper, the brisket, or an interaction between the two over time. The brisket could have been shrink wrapped at Southside Market while it was still too hot, it could have been exposed to improper handling during distribution, or something could have happened at my local Costco store.
I sliced and heated a portion of the Southside Market brisket anyway. After half a slice, I had to toss the rest of the portion due to the nauseatingly obnoxious smell and complete lack of flavor. Although I had swallowed very little of the Southside Market brisket, as bad as it was, I felt fortunate not to have made undue acquaintance with the porcelain throne overnight.
Given that this Southside Market product cost well over $20, I chose to test the Costco grocery return policy yet again. I was really apprehensive about the return of a refrigerated, open, and possibly unsafe Southside Market meat product. Not surprisingly, Costco cheerfully refunded my money without any hesitation. [Oh, by the way, I no longer see Southside Market brisket offered at this Costco.]
I am more than aware there are people who game the liberal return policies at Costco because they know they can. I'm not one of those. But I am truly appreciative that Costco is understanding and blind to the cause of the return. They truly keep the customer satisfied.
That's five-star in my book. read more