Very Disappointing!!! It is ridiculous how bad this is compared to Germantown Commissary. Gtown is a 4.5-5 most times. I can't believe how this place could mess up everything down to the beans. How you can make them flavorless is beyond me. The pie was ok. I do have to say that was the bright spot. read more

Had a delicious lunch here! Wish I took photos of all the good food, but honestly delicious. I opted for the pulled pork bbq nachos after seeing all the photos and they were amazing! They had the best thin crispy tortilla chips, and call me weird, but I love the fake nacho cheese sauce over real shredded cheese, makes the best nachos hands down. The pulled pork was Smokey and tender and the bbq sauce added just the right sweetness. Also highly recommend the banana pudding, so good! read more

I really like this place! Such an improvement on the original by virtue of all the space! All of the delicious food and great service with room to spread out. I recently got to go and learned that they are back open at a lower capacity. My favorites here are the wings and the side dishes. My husband loves the BBQ and my friends like the sandwiches and the huge salads. This is a great and affordable add to the area. read more

See all

Had the pleasure of having lunch here with my sister and we had a fantastic meal. We were seated promptly, the server made great recommendations and was very attentive and we were in and out in about 45 mins. I ordered the brisket plate. Brisket is tender and flavorful. Like I had to eat it with my eyes closed cuz it was so good. LOL. Sides of beans, coleslaw and roll were solid as usual. Sister ordered the bbq nachos with the pulled pork and side of jalapeños. So good..... the chips were super thin and crispy, but this is a double edged sword because they get soggy quicker. We enjoyed our quick lunch on a weekday. We will be back. read more

Collierville Commissary - Brisket plate ..... stop lookin so good- - Barbeque Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

See all

Finally got to try out the Collierville Commissary! I was impressed, friendly helpful staff and the food was on point as is at the original Germantown location. Yummy Mac and I just have one question...are those sister schubert rolls? Visited there again and I don't know her name but she had our drink refills on point and was very attentive and nice! So many service staff in Collierville suck so it's nice to know there are good servers out there! read more

Collierville Commissary - Pulled pork plate and brisket sandwich plate. - Barbeque Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

Wonderful food with a family friendly atmosphere. Good for a party any size. Ribs, brisket, and bbq are excellent. Onion rings are must here. The service was good too! read more

Good food. The chicken wings are delicious. The service is great. I enjoy every meal when I visit there. The prices are great.

Food is good, the average bbq joint fare. Problem is I am here with a party of 40 and although they can accommodate the number of us we were only allocated 1 waitress. So it took about 30 min to even get the drinks ordered and brought to the table. The waitress was polite and as attentive as possible. Now, mind you the restaurant had plenty of notice of our large party. I approached the manager about the situation and was told that is the norm. I am from a food service family, and a regular restaurant patron... let me tell you 40:1 is NOT the normal. 20:1 maybe for an experienced server. So all I can say is except for the culture of overwork, food is OK. read more

Collierville Commissary - Chili cheese fries - Barbeque Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

See all

Not as good as the original. I don't know if it was just a bad night, or indicative of the location. The brisket wasn't brisket. It may have been beef, but not the brisket that I am used to. The service was good, but the quality of the food was disappointing. The place was also empty and when I've been to Germantown Commissary, it was always hopping. read more

Was very excited to try Memphis BBQ and got the brisket Sandwich with Mac and cheese and a soda. The brisket was cooked well but the BBQ does not compare to Dallas or STL. read more

So good. We had ribs, brisket, pulled pork, chips, beans, and fries and everything was really good. Service was quick. A little pricey, but I feel like all bbq places are ‍ read more

Excellent service and best BBQ in West TN - period. Owners always present caring for customers.

I grew up eating at the orginal commissary in germantown Tennessee. When I found out that they were going to open a second location, I was very happy. Where I wondered, only to find out it was going to be in collierville tn. When you walk in, you are greeted by a host or hostess. The employees are very prompt and polite. I ordered beef brisket,coleslaw, bbq beans and a dr pepper. It was very good. I recommend if you haven't been to either one of the locations to give it a try. read more

Collierville Commissary - Brisket, coleslaw, BBQ Beans, bread and dr pepper - Barbeque Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

Always get the full order pork nachos and a sweet tea. Great price. Great portion size. If you get it to go they don't skimp out.

Went here for Father's Day. I got the brisket and rib platter, my wife got the brisket plate. All meats were so dry we could barely eat it and only ate a little. I complained to the waiter and he said to put more sauce on it. Bad answer as far as I am concerned. No visit by the manager on duty. Paid my full bill and will never be back. Very disappointing. I left still hungry. read more

The Manager doesn't care about anyone or anything! Their links are good but, their Chicken was WAY over smoked and super dry! The service takes forever.... Very overpriced!!!! read more

Picked up carry out bbq 8 pack for tailgating . We live very nearby & I was happy when this opened because we love Germantown Commissary! This location is just NOT as good as the Germantown one. The BBQ was chopped as requested- but almost OVER chopped. The beans were way too sweet- no one in our group liked them. The slaw was just ok- also too sweet. Buns were fresh & good. Potato salad I ordered extra was just bland - almost like mashed potatoes. We ate the BBQ but trashed most of the sides that were left. So many better BBQ stores in our area- won't be going here again. Have been there several times since it opened & it is consistently not good. read more

Really good barbecue just not the very best in town. Definitely worth going to though.

I'm so glad the Commissary has opened close to us. What it does not have the original Commissary charm it does have space. We went about 5 pm on Saturday knowing that the recent opening would equal a crowd. A hostess barked, "anyone eating in?" to the entrance crowd. I spoke up and got on the short list. Once my spouse joined me, we were quickly served waters and drinks. I splurged on a baked potato. It was huge. I always get the meat on the side so the spouse can eat it. I will say that even though I asked for a second sour cream there was a lot of dry potato left. That was fine because I was stuffed. The spouse got a boss man salad and was stuffed as well. I can't wait for the hype to die down so we can go on the regular. read more

Great experience on opening day for the Collierville Commissary! We went early (4pm) to avoid the opening rush. Great local bbq and family dining spot. We had great and friendly service! For us the food was just as good as the original location but doesn't share the super cozy (crowded) feeling. I'm sure the G'town location is happy to have a sister location to relieve the demand and pressure. read more

See all

Great new place in Colliervillle! If you are looking for the best BBQ in the Mid South, look no further! Just like the great food and great service at the Germantown Commissary, you will find a great place here! We enjoyed the ribs and BBQ sandwich...don't forget the Banana Pudding! Walker Taylor has done it again!! read more

See all

I think they need a more training on staff- 4 people for dinner- it took 45 minutes to get served dinner - one plate came out then much later the other three. All cold -waitress said , sorry I forgot they were in the window . No offer to fix cold food. Her explanation was -"we have 3 large groups and it's taking a lot to keep them happy"- what about your other patrons! Sure was hoping this place would be better . read more

I don't know how I really feel about this new place. I like the original better. Maybe because this new store feels to upbeat, made for all the yuppies in Collierville. Maybe because I sat at the table with my daughter for five minutes and watched the people that got seated after us have their drink order takin before us. Could have been because our waitress kept on sayin sorry she was workin another large group. Basically sayin we were on the back burner. I'll try it again but I'll go to the original a few more times before I go back here. Seems they still have to work the bugs out or something. read more

Collierville Commissary - 3 meat combo platter(ribs,link,shoulder,slaw, and beans)! - Barbeque Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

I had a very disappointing experience tonight. I ordered through a 3rd party app and when I got there to pick up I was told they couldn't access the app and if I wanted to order food I would have to reorder and pay again. I asked about getting my money back and they said they don't know how to do it and I would have to figure it out myself. They weren't remorseful and didn't apologize. Since I was already there I reordered and while I was waiting, the Manager (Lou) rudely asked me why I would even use a 3rd party app and just not call them. He proceeded to say he doesn't get why people even use it. Had I not already paid I would have left. They really need to work on their customer service skills. I don't we will be going there again. (PS - still haven't gotten my refund nor can I figure out how to ask for it) read more

My family and I visited the place because it's new in the Collerville area the menu has catfish dinner I asked how many fillets per dinner the waitress say 3or4, depends on the size. I said okay I will get the fish fried hard. When I got my plate the fish looks like mix fish parts, like what you would feed to your enemies (well if I was a cook I would be embarrassed ). One of the pieces looked like a fish tail and they were full of grease. I tried to ignore my plated food but I'm 50, therefore I refuse to be served anything. The waitress was very polite its not her fault. I shouldn't go to a BBQ place ordering fish. Never again will I go back. read more

Food was not hot. In fact, it seem like it may have been microwaved. Lots of gnats flying around. I had to cover my drink with a paper towel. The tea taste like it was from yesterday. I paid my bill and tipped but didn't eat the food. I have eaten here many times and never wasn't this bad on a scale of one to 10. It's normally a five however, the other location is always excellent. Definitely not coming back read more

Meat had good flavor but side were terrible. Mac and cheese was the worst I've had, potato salad had way to much mustard and the biscuits I have no words for. read more

Collierville Commissary - Three meat plate with potato salad and mac and cheese. - Barbeque Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

I went for an early dinner on a Saturday night. I was seated right away and had a wonderful server who provided some recommendations and great service. I ended up getting the brisket sandwich with onion rings and a deviled egg. I enjoyed the meal and thought it was a great value. My waiter also was really nice and refilled my drink and provided a lid so I could take it to go. read more

Pretty much have liked everything I've had. Only complaint is the BBQ nachos have cheese sauce instead of shredded cheese, but that's just a personal preference. Overall friendly staff and food always served in a timely manor. read more

I'll always be the first to say that it seems when "landmark restaurants" branch out, they fail. The expansion locations pale in comparison to the original. HOWEVER, we visited this location and found that to NOT be the case. They hit the mark I've come to expect from the original location. To boot, the interior of this location was awesome. They did a great job in making it have an original look to stand up to the quality of the cuisine being prepared here. The staff was also extremely friendly and courteous. I will be back again and again! read more

Great food, and excellent service. Restaurant is big enough to hold a lot of people, too. Dry smoked chicken wings are especially great. Chocolate pie, too. Not sure why this is rated lower than the other location- doesn't deserve it! read more

Great experience , Walker takes pride in his establishments and the food, service , and atmosphere proves it . Only drawback I had from original location was parking at times was a drag - not here . Love it and always recommend this location and the original when I can . May I suggest the ribs , the pork , brisket, or maybe the chicken ? YUM ! You can t lose here ! Take them all ! read more

This is one of our FAVORITE BBQ places in Memphis...and that's saying a lot since Memphis is the home of BBQ! We love their Ribs, pulled pork sandwiches, BBQ chicken! As soon as you walk in the heavenly scent and adorable authentic charm sweep you off your feet! Save room for the lemon meringue pie...it's the really deal, like your Memaw made! In fact I regularly drop by and pick up a pie to take to potlucks and they look and taste like something I baked at home...if I could cook! read more

At last, a bigger cousin of the famous Germantown Commissary. Great BBQ, Beef, Pork, Sausage or Chicken. The beans are solid and probably the best potato salad I have found at a BBQ joint. Easily Top 2 in Memphis for Cue, which is saying a lot. Leave room for desert, the banana pudding is incredible and the ice box pie is one of the best things I ever ate. Can't go wrong here and so much more room then the other location. read more

Picked up an order to go. They swore all our food was in the bag, but we got home only to find we were missing an item. They replaced the missing item, but I was still disappointed I had to drive 20 min there and back to pick it up. read more

GET. THE. NACHOS. And the pig chips. And the caramel cake. You'll never regret it. The new place is awesome. They did a great job making plenty of room for everyone, while keeping the spirit and taste of the original in old Germantown. This is my place. read more

Collierville Commissary - Bbq nachos - Barbeque Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

See all

Food was "good". But with so many BBQ choices around Memphis - you gotta do ribs better. Good flavor, but the fat cap was not rendered enough to my liking. Stay local - but definitely hit the more well-known favorites. read more

Decided to give Commissary's drive-thru a try since it was raining buckets. First observation is that the turn along the curb entering the drive thru lane is a little tricky. Don't curb your tires like I did . Placed an order of BBQ pork sandwich and potato salad, chicken nachos, and 2 desserts. The sandwich was delicious, generously portioned but not chopped as requested. Potato salad was tasty but portion was a bit small. Chicken nachos get an A+. Great smoky flavor and order was quite large. Desserts were mixed reviews. Coconut pie was great as always but caramel cake was a bit dry. Overall a decent experience but still prefer eating in restaurant. Happy to have the new location! read more

Dined Sunday after church, very busy as you might expect. Our server was great, food was very good, place was clean. Being so busy we thought food would be a little slow but it wasn't everything was hot. Just a good place to eat. We will be back. read more

As good as the original IMO.went for lunch and loved the fact that it's bigger than the original and the food tasted as good as it does in germantown. read more

Collierville Commissary - Brisket Meal - Barbeque Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee