First time on the island today & first time Carmody's...great food and great service! The Veal Parm sandwich was awesome! read more

We were in the area and needed to kill time before an appointment and found this spot. So glad we did and its not in a place you'd pass by for any reason, very much off course hidden gem. The place is huge and it's very nice inside with a bar, middle enclosed patio and another large dining/party room. The menu has all kinds of items we had to the zucchini and it was delicious, one of the best I have ever had. It was light breaded and not soggy, it came with marinara and we asked for ranch and horseradish sauce. I chose the fish sandwich on Mancini roll with side of garlic mash and my husband had the French dip, both large portions and tasty. Also leave room for the butter cake ( i cant eat it but my husband loved it). He said he would drive the 30 minutes to eat here again. read more

We love this place, but had a bad meal there this weekend. We usually order sandwiches but my wife wanted Prime Rib so we decided to try it at Carmody's Grille. The service was great, but the meat was tough and tasteless. The potatoes and vegetables were fine. At a price of $29.99 does not include salad or bread. We will continue to eat at Carmody's Grille, we just won't order the prime rib. read more

Enjoyed the zucchini. Service was good. Just a bar. Nothing special about the bar not even the zucchini.

We had a party of three and went on a Wednesday evening. The place has plenty of seating, and has a nice looking patio area. Biggest complaint is about the service. It took 20 minutes to get our drinks - two beers and one mixed drink (simply Tito's). My husband ended up ordering a second beer and it took about 15 minutes for that one. We got the fried pickle chips as an appetizer. Could have been crispier but weren't the worst. He got the salmon as his entree, I got the crab cakes. The rice that came on the side was very dry. The crab and salmon were good, and so were the sweet carrots. We also ordered their special brown butter cake as the waitress said it was very good. It was delicious and helped save this review. The inside was soft and the outside had a sweet and sugary crust. It was topped with vanilla ice cream and caramel. Very rich and delicious! This place might be great if you're just going to sit at the bar, although it's hard to tell. read more

See all

Pros: I like the location, atmosphere (like an at-home type feel meets sports bar), roomier than it looks from the outside, parking is convenient and good for conversation for our group of 5 (at least they liked their food). Cons: I wasn't a big fan of the wait staff as they weren't very welcoming or friendly (waitress particularly didn't seem to be people-person, seemed flat). I got the crab cakes, rice and green beans $24.99 - it would be a fair price if it weren't so tasteless (none of it had any flavor) and VERY dry rice & crab cakes (did not taste like crab cakes). read more

Carmody's Grille - Seating style - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

First time at Carmody's. We had a large group of 10. Service was very good. It got busy but our server was great. The food was very good. We all had a great time. Would definitely recommend dining here and we will be back. read more

I stopped in here for lunch after doing a site visit nearby. Carmody's has been around for awhile and a colleague recommended it to me. The sandwiches are standard bar fare (in a good way). I'm always up for a good club sammich and the Turkey Bacon Swiss was just right. I see that much has been written about the service here, but I thought it was okay. If you're in the area, this place seems to be a good solid, no surprises choice. read more

Service was horrible & the food was disgusting! Don't waste your time & money . Over prized & rude

The best bartender ever ! Shawna .. is amazing !! What a wonderful night ! She's amazing! read more

See all

Mom's Smothered Chicken. Not dry had a nice mixture of mushrooms, bacon, and cheese. The 3 potatoes were undercooked and very bland. The asparagus was also nicely cooked but also bland. Solid burger. Minimal seasoning. It is just a burger. Overall the food was kind of bleh. Solid drinks and nice service from the female bartender that doubled as our hostess. Our waitress was training a new employee clearly not happy about. Service wasn't the greatest. The place was very clean and open. Smelled nice from the fresh basil plants that were perched jn the open area/ out door seating area. Four outa ten probably won't go again. read more

See all

Carmody's is a great place for a quick beer and a bite. We have always been welcomed by a friendly staff, and we frequent there at least once a month. The Rueben is awesome, the French dip is awesome, I even love the simple hot sausage sandwich. The deserts are great, and maybe one day I will get daring and try the turtle soup. Only reason this is not a five is that they no longer have Kilkenny Irish Red on tap. Lol. read more

Really tired menu. One can eat only so many French dips. This place really needs a new chef with some creativity and skill.

This family restaurant is a few minutes away from the Roxian Theater so we decided to check it out before a show. We arrived around 5:30 and were seated right away. Shortly after that, there was a wait and a long line. The service was excellent on a very busy night. They have a decent beer selection on tap and the food came out pretty fast. We ordered the fish tacos and the reuben. The tacos were sort of skimpy on filling to be honest and the fish was not well seasoned. They forgot the cabbage filling entirely and we had to ask for it after they brought them. The reuben was pretty good but really needed more corned beef for the $14 price tag. This place really packs them in on Saturday nights. We sat in the bar area and could see all of the families coming in with big parties. They run a tight ship and get the orders in quickly and efficiently. We enjoyed our visit but would probably order something different. read more

Carmody's Grille - Fish tacos - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Always a nice weeknight or weekend venue to eat with friends, family and perhaps a few drinks? ‍ the bartenders are always great and remember frequent visitors:) I just love the Pretzel and the Italian Beef, and not to mention the awesome burgers and Turtle Soup. Sports always on... Quizzes and Games on TVs and good music...Casual warm, neighborhood vibes every time. read more

Nice neighborhood restaurant with friendly and efficient staff. Best Turtle Soup in W PA.

A real neighborhood gem! A friend suggested we try the French dip sandwich saying it was the best one anywhere. It was outstanding as were the French fries and the onion rings. Onion rings might also be the best ever. We found the service to be excellent! We will definitely go again to try some other house favorites! read more

We loved Carmody's! This place is super cute! We sat outside because it was a beautiful day but it had a sheltered patio incase it did happen to rain! The waitress was amazing! Super kind & had great recommendations! Everyone around us had the fried zucchini so we had to order & it did not disappoint! The breading was so thin & flaky! We also ordered the special of angel hair with crab meat, unfortunately this was super bland, but still good quality food! The wings were pretty good & decently priced! We will definitely be returning soon to try more food! read more

See all

Turtle Soup is worth the trip to Neville Island. Excellent, friendly service too boot.

We have been going to Carmody's not too frequently for years. We like to sit at the bar and have a beer with our food. For the most part our servers have been "old school" pro's. They recognize you and make sure you are well taken care of. This visit was a big disappointment. The two appetizers (onion rings and pickle chips) were good. I asked the server what the vegetable was and was told it was a mix of broccoli, cauliflower... I ordered the crab cakes accompanied by vegetables and wild rice. I got crab cakes with white rice and green beans with garlic. Or was it garlic with a few green beans? I pointed out the discrepancy from what I read on the menu and what I got and was told (by a server that was new to me) that it should have been changed on the menu but wasn't. I asked for a side plate to remove the garlic with green beans off of my main plate. I did so without an offer from my server to provide a substitute. I didn't "push" my disappointment, but it was pretty evident I was not pleased. I supplemented my dinner with some fries from my partners plate. We left this visit underwhelmed and $88.00 poorer. I will be hard pressed to return anytime soon. read more

Service and food were both great! Plenty of space both at the bar and the back patio for all parties. We were in town for the US Open staying nearby and this spot turned out to be one that we enjoyed during our stay. Would recommend to anyone looking for a nice meal, some good drinks and a place to watch some ballgames. read more

Decent food always. Normally pretty good service. The drinks are pretty good, too, but the location and parking situation are annoying. I'm not sure it's worth the hassle. We go there if friends want to meet there, but don't choose it ourselves. read more

Carmody's Grille - Bar& outside patio area - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Service was extremely slow. Ordered side salad & the burger medium rare. Salad was very small, burger was cooked medium well. Younger female bartender working very hard. A bald male bar tender doing not much of anything. Was never asked how my meal was. Very disappointed. The bar area was not that busy. read more

Dined in with a group of approximately 20 and had a horrible experience. They sat us in the private room (not the bar area) we were the only ones in there which was nice. The bar was not very busy . We had two servers who treated our group like separate parties instead of one big group. I have never experienced service like this where the servers don't work together to tend to the entire group! Our food came out in 3 stages.... therefore, part of our party had their food and ate before the rest of us even ordered! The last group received their food way after everyone else everybody in our party was ready to leave. None of the appetizers came out as appetizers rather they came out with the meals. It seemed that the more experienced server did a great job and brought things out promptly but the other server who seemed to have more of the bulk of the group had a hard time keeping up. We had to ask for everything, no one came back to see if the food was OK. Speaking of food the burger was a little disappointing didn't have a ton of flavor and for the price the side of fries was extremely small! I would just say the food was OK in general.... A little on the pricier side for small portions. The appetizers, however, were amazing but like I said, it would've been nice to have them as a true appetizer. The breading on the fried pickles and zucchini was nice and light and crispy! And the ranch was a good quality homemade ranch. read more

Delicious food! We loved the fried zucchini, Turkey bacon cheese sandwich and chicken and waffles. The syrup was more like a creamy icing. We were never here before, and got a recommendation! Waitress was so kind, and very clean restaurant. It's very big inside, very deceiving from outside. Our bill was only $45. You must try NOW!! We will definitely be back! Thank you! read more

Carmody's Grille - Turkey Bacon Swiss Sandwich - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Excellent food and service. Had a quiet, delicious lunch w a friend. Was a busy day but we were taken care of promptly. Will definitely return ! read more

Work group came here for dinner. It wasn't crowded but the food was great! The service was excellent! Zucchini with horseradish sauce was delicious and I had the black bean burger. We were very impressed with the servicing sizes. Not too much and not too little. I will definitely come back when traveling to Western PA again. read more

This a local dinner go- to for us! Servers are friendly and food is always very good and prepared fresh. Highly recommend the french dip on Mancini's bread, also love their power slaw (i think that's what it's called). Lots of indoor and outdoor seating read more

We visited here over the holidays and had a great experience. Our server, Ron (I believe his full first name is Sharon) was delightful. He gave helpful recommendations from the menu and also took great care of my daughter who was feeling poorly and just needed some cucumbers to feel better. I had the hot sausage sandwich, which was undercooked more than I would like, but Ron handled it like a pro and brought it back in a short time and it was perfect. I wish I could remember what everyone else ate! There were five of us, and we all got something different, and everyone left feeling satisfied and happy. I would not hesitate to go back again. read more

Have eaten here Twice each time the Food and Service were Good. Had their Hamburger Platter, which was Good. The Pattie was actually Seasoned and just not a Beef Pattie on a Bun which some restaurants do. Service was also goood. Would Definitely go back there again read more

Great food as always. Sydney's last day is this Friday. Great bartender will be missed. Comfortable atmosphere. read more

Carmody's Grille - Salmon dinner with rice and veggies of the day. Sad day because Sydney's last day is this Friday. - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Service at the bar is the worst. Both bar tenders walked by multiple times, asked for another drink, no reply , no response . This has happened on more than one occasion. Guess you have to sit at the tables to get service.. read more

Great chicken salad. Best place to eat on the island. Service is good. Atmosphere looks to be in good health. read more

Service was great and burger was really good. Plenty of room at the bar. Thanks Sidney!

When we want a good meal that is consistent, we always goto Carmody's! Their staff is beyond amazing and even with different staff we have an amazing experience. We love the change of space whether it be a date night, night out with our family, friends or coworkers the atmosphere delivers for all crowds. read more

The French Dip sandwich was awesome! The fish was also good. Jeff was a great waiter. All of the staff acknowledged us as we left. So glad we tried Carmody's. We will go back! read more

Visited for lunch for the first time. Love the indoor patio. The BEST fried pickles I have had in a loooong time, no cucumber taste, not greasy. The seafood bisque is GREAT! I hope they keep it on the menu! I didn't love my grilled chicken salad, chicken definitely needed more seasoning. My fiancé got the chicken & waffles, he said they were delicious. My father got the crab cakes, was not impressed that the "vegetable" was corn but liked the crab cakes for sure. The brown butter cake was heavenly. 90% of the food was absolutely delicious, server could've been faster but she was also working the bar so I understand. Will definitely be back often! read more

I've never left a negative Yelp review until now. Terrible service. MULTIPLE tables that came after my party got their meals before my appetizer came. Very inefficient. No excuses for this. The crab Alfredo was overcooked ramen noodles. The special touch was the styrofoam cups with straws at my elbow. Not sure if this was garbage or someone's order? Surely this is a health code violation. Zucchini strips were great but I'll make my own next time. AVOID this place. read more

Carmody's Grille - Gross - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Had lunch here after flying in on business. Service was great and the food was even better. Great atmosphere and large space.

Great food, great service!! We had the French dip sandwich and it was outstanding. Real beef, reasonably priced. A+