An exceptional dining experience from start to finish. We enjoyed the oysters, caviar butter with milk bun, lobster tempura, hamachi crudo, shrimp scampi, and a fresh salad--each dish was thoughtfully prepared and beautifully executed. What truly set the evening apart, however, was the service. Attentive without being intrusive, polished, and genuinely warm--it elevated every moment. Thank you for a memorable experience. We look forward to returning. read more

This place is a vibe! I'm still dreaming about the next time I can visit. The food was absolutely delicious and the atmosphere was so cute. It's upscale but not stuffy, definitely giving coastal, date-night energy with a really pretty interior and a lively crowd. Perfect if you're trying to feel a little dressed up without it being over the top. The food was delicious especially the bread! I loved the lychee martini. 10/10 read more

See all

This restaurant is truly something special. It's one of those places you just don't forget. The space is gorgeous, with warm nudes and earthy tones that make everything feel cozy, inviting, and effortlessly elegant. The vibe is relaxed but still classy... like elevated without the attitude. And the service? Disney‑World level. I barely had to blink before someone was offering a refill or asking if I wanted another drink. That kind of attentiveness is rare, and honestly, it was refreshing in the best way. I've been here twice now, once for Christmas and again simply because the first visit lived rent‑free in my mind. For Christmas Dinner, they had an eight‑course prix fixe menu, and by the end, we were stuffed. The highlights? Osetra Caviar Tart I'm not a caviar girlie, but this dish had me reconsidering my whole identity. The crème fraîche, smoked salmon, and those little tarts were the perfect sweet‑salty balance. I could've eaten that all night. The Crab‑Stuffed Lobster is packed with jumbo lump crab and drenched in a garlicky beurre blanc. Absolutely stunning. And last but not least, a Crispy Striped Seabass. Wow, just WOW. The crisp on the skin, the sauce, the flavor... 100/10. No notes. Visit #2 was my "I'm trying everything I can." We started with a variety of raw oysters--some of the best I've had. Then the Grilled Oysters (pescatarian life means Rockefeller is a no‑go). The Caesar Salad was perfection; anchovies included, as they should be. The Lobster Tempura was fried with precision--light, crisp, and seasoned just enough to let the aioli shine. By this point, I was full, but trust me, once you visit, you'll understand why I kept going. I ordered the Redfish with broccolini, and it was divine. Flaky, generous portion, and that garlic wine sauce? They just know how to pair flavors in a way that makes sense. The Drinks are in a league of their own. My favorite was the Lychee Martini, and I ordered a French 75 "My Way" (talk nice and I might share the details). Every drink was perfectly crafted. Did I spend a small fortune? Yes. Was it worth it? Hell YES. I already have a list of things I'm excited to try next time. read more

We always sit at our favorite spots at the bar-great consistent friendly service, wonderful atmosphere and nice crowd. From the oyster shots, to the champagne and wine pairings, milk buns, caviar selection and more. Carmel transports you. Oh, they have great oysters too-especially the rockerfeller! read more

See all

Girls night out! We really enjoyed this place! Our waiter was amazing. I asked for a lemon drop that was not a menu item. However he did make it happen. Oysters Rockefeller for the table delicious. I had HAMACHI CRUDO $18. Definitely not worth the price. 3 little pieces of fish. The flavor was good but I was truly disappointed. I also had the MUSSELS they had applewood smoked bacon, shallots, grilled bread. Very delightful. Unfortunately, we were so busy enjoying ourselves that I did not take any pictures of the food. They do offer free parking and valet service. read more

See all

So I came on an impromptu "girl let's get out the house" brunch and the food was phenomenal. Sat outside for the most part then when it got too hot (typical Atlanta) we were sat inside and accommodated nicely. But the real star of brunch was Max. He was our server and had the best personality and was the most helpful with suggestions and things of the sort. Definitely come here and sit with Max if possible! read more

Carmel - Sauvignon Blanc - Seafood Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Wonderful service, food was tasty, I would definitely come back! The caviar fries are very yummy. read more

See all

Beautiful place & location- reasonable prices on wine. Everything else very overpriced. The menu prices are very misleading and sneaky- I ended up paying double than what I expected simply for extra butter that I didn't even realize I ordered- and simply the way the prices are written it's confusing and there's hidden fees. Service was good- food is decent but not amazing- did enjoy the caviar fries- could skip the caviar butter though for the bread. Raw fish ok read more

Carmel - Seafood Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Still 5 stars. My coworkers chose Carmel for my birthday dinner, and it was a great choice--especially since some of them had never been before. We started with the milk bun, mussels, Bibb salad, and a mix of roasted and Rockefeller oysters (note: the bacon can't be removed). For entrées, we ordered two red fish and two whole lobsters, paired with truffle mashed potatoes, roasted potatoes, and broccolini as sides. Everything was well prepared and enjoyable. Dessert was a complimentary mango sorbet, which was a nice birthday touch. We also had several drinks: a lychee martini (clearly noted on the menu with added raspberry liqueur), a bourbon-based cocktail, a lychee mocktail, Hugo spritz, and French press coffee. Most of the drinks were solid and well executed. The ambiance is warm and inviting, and the staff overall is very kind. Our server was just okay, not bad, just not a standout but everyone has off nights. Despite that, I would absolutely recommend dining here. Great atmosphere, good food, and a solid spot for celebrations. read more

See all

Everything was delicious and beautiful. The service was good the ambience was better and must do in Atlanta. read more

See all

Carmel has all the bones for something great, and I want to start this off by saying I will be back to give a second chance! I also want to add that we did come on their Oyster Bar opening night so that could have added to some of the hiccups. Carmel is gorgeous aesthetic wise with warm, brown tones all over that give a fusion of Tulum + Paris Cafe vibes which is perfect for the Atlanta backdrop. Let's do a general review of everything and then I'll get more specific on some highlights/areas of improvement: Service 9/10: our server was the best part! He was honest when we asked for input and every recommendation he gave was absolutely delicious bites/sips for the night. Only docked a point because it was slightly slow but not to any of his fault. I think it was just a higher pressure night & kitchen + bar were a little backed up. Food 7/10: some wins, but a few small issues with some of the items Drinks 9/10: amazing drinks despite the wait! Tried a few and each shined in its own way. Not too strong but I appreciated the flavor profiles and overall presentation. As far as access, Carmel is in the Buckhead shops so easy for rideshare service drop off and there is a parking deck + valet options near, so plenty of options! No to more details on what we enjoyed for the night: * Half Dozen Raw (chefs choice) 10/10: these were smaller but tasted fresh, and were mild in brine flavor so very palatable for anyone even if they don't care for oysters * Seafood Tower 7/10: So this was slightly underwhelming in portion size and general flavor. Shrimp and oysters were great, but the lobster & scallop crudo just weren't great. Specifically the crudo was super salty which I did infirm the manager. Maybe some citrus would have brightened it but it's hard to come back from "too salty" than not salty enough. * Octopus 9/10: delicious! Best bite of the night for sure. Beyond flavorful with a nice Smokey flavor. * Carmel's Burger 8/10: the burger was fantastic! Great portion and amazing temp on the meat. The caviar fries were okay, and extremely salty as well so although I would have given the burger a ten, that's what brought it down a bit for me. Blackened Okra 10/10: I love okra! What can I say. Amazing charred flavor and hands down an underrated side! Drinks: Prosecco: 10/10 - classic, not much to say Lychee Martini 8/10: not the very best I've ever had in the city, but tasted good, just very light on the spirit. Mar Azul 10/10: favorite cocktail of the night! Love the creaminess from those vanilla notes All in all, I would definitely stop by Carmel for some of their sides and small plates & maybe a cocktail but maybe not my full meal just because it can be slightly hit or miss. read more

See all

I celebrated Galentine's Day with a group of ladies at Carmel. The ambiance is very nice and gives coastal vibes. I had a Lychee Martini it was really good. The host ordered cavier fries for the table as an appetizer. The fries were really good. I had the roasted chicken, it was very flavorful. The chimichuri really helped elevate the flavor. I shared an order of the collard greens and mashed potatoes with one of my friends. The sides were good as well. read more

See all

Grilled oysters, caviar fries & drinks were 10/10. Great service, beautiful ambiance, and definitely worth a visit. Buckhead gem! read more

See all

Carmel was a great experience for me! Our server was great, service was quick, and the food was absolutely delicious. The interior is also decorated beautifully, with dimmed lighting but not too dark you can't see. We had the seafood tower, branzino, and a passionfruit based dessert. They also have unlimited raw oysters, with a great oyster selection. For drinks I had their lychee martini which had a fruity addition, which was very yummy. There is a paid parking deck nearby, as well as valet for parking. I definitely would come back again! read more

See all

Stopped in on a whim. Glad we did! Just in time for Happy Hour (4-6 daily). Sat at the bar with Mark. Drinks were on point! Vibe was perfect. Chris was managing and most attentive. The restaurant was clean, that's important to us. The food was great! Everyone was friendly. We really enjoyed the place and will be back. They validate parking so take your parking ticket with you. read more

See all

I've dined here several times and each time is a great experience! Rather sitting at the bar or dining at a table, the service is always great. They have a great selection of oysters and tasty drinks. Whenever I'm in the area, I'll always make a stop here! read more

Carmel - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

My experience at Carmel was great from start to finish. The service was excellent, love the restaurant's vibe and style. Feels like people dont talk about Carmel enough when it comes to that area but its top tier. The Rockerfeller oysters were so good! I also had the lasagna and loved it! Oh the bread too and great drinks. Will be back! read more

Carmel - Rockerfeller oysters - Seafood Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

I enjoyed an amazing brunch on a Saturday afternoon. This place is beautiful inside and out. So warm and cozy. Our waitress Morgan was really sweet and attentive. I started with the blackberry refresher non alcoholic drink it was really tasty. I ordered the lobster roll and French toast. The roll was kinda small but absolutely delicious. It had just enough meat and the fries were nice and salty. The French toast was amazing. It was a nice thick challah topped with a cream cheese sauce. The combination tasted like cinnamon roll. It was so delicious! We were one of the few at brunch so if you'd like to try something new I highly recommend this place. read more

See all

I visited Carmel Woodfire Seafood and Oyster Bar in Atlanta with a group of friends--there were six of us--and we had a great experience from start to finish. Our server (I think her name was Michelle or Melissa) was fantastic. She had a great sense of humor, gave thoughtful suggestions, and made everything sound so good, from the cocktails to the dinner options to the oyster selections. The food definitely lived up to the way she described it. Everything was fresh and flavorful, and the milk buns are an absolute must-try--soft, buttery, and just perfect. The atmosphere made it a great spot for a night out. It's not a cheap meal, but it's an oyster bar, so that's to be expected. I'd absolutely come back without hesitation. read more

See all

I'm not sure who's idea it was to have the heat on when it was 85 degrees in Atlanta today but it was an uncomfortable heat. Some tables had fans on them, we asked for some and never got it. Ambiance reminds me of Tulum in a way, very clean lines and neutal colors. The food was petite, I show a picture of my food below which consisted of 3 mussels, 2 prawns, a slither of fish, 4 cherry tomatoes, a piece of fennel, and 1 slice of onion. I believe the best thing I had was the actual side of potatoes. I didnt show their version of Mac and cheese, as the waiter called it, because we sent it back. The lychee martini isn't standard, I would give it a 5 out of 10. Throughout the night the service continued to go down, started out great but ultimately the waiter wasn't attentive, waited 20mins for him to bring the cake and another to return uncut cake, less than 5 for a birthday party. I cant say I would go back but hoping your experience is better. read more

Carmel - Seafood Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

We had such an amazing dinner Sunday evening. The restaurant was not too busy (which we loved) and we were sat right away. In fact, the host offered us a nearby booth which was available for our comfort. The inside ambiance is beautiful and chic, perfect for date nights. Our server was very helpful and friendly as we navigated the menu. We ordered espresso martinis to start which were very good. We started with the octopus as a starter, which to our surprise was fried instead of grilled, still very good, served with their crispy potatoes. Their oysters were very carefully handled and clean. Our favorite dish was the roasted chicken with the side of carrots though the whole lobster was very good. The flavors on this chicken dish were truly divine, the roasted generous portions of chicken with the cilantro-garlic mojo on top was the most memorable. We loved the richness and sweetness of the carrots that kept that crunch from the roasting. This is the best main dish with side dish pairing we could have opted for. We left the restaurants feeling satisfied and wanting to return. Definitely a must try! read more

See all

Loved every bite. From the spicy shrimp appetizer and the burrata/artichoke appetizer to the caviar fries (amazing) as starters- we continued to be impressed as the entrées arrived. Two lobsters, the chicken and the scallops. All divine. read more

Delicious! Grilled Shrimp to start followed by the Redfish, grilled carrots and crispy potatoes. Really enjoyed this food, and very nice service. Had a cozy corner banquet spot. Enjoyed Carmel - would be very happy to go back! read more

See all

Service was great! Ambiance was great! Dime lighting Oysters and Caviar fries were great! read more

Located in Buckhead Village and there is a parking garage there but you could also valet for a fee. When I walked in, I was greeted by a hostess that walked me to my table. Love the menu style and David was our server for the day. He provided some honest recommendations that met our needs. To start, I love oysters so that was ordered first before anything. I would rate the oysters 7/10 only because of the breadcrumbs on the Rockefeller style was a bit much but overall, tastes good and decent size. To drink I ordered the lychee martini which was a 10/10 for taste and presentation. I also ordered the lobster roll as an entree. For the size, it wasn't worth the amount, but the taste was good and also the shoestring fries that came with it was amazing. The vibe is nice and neutral and they also have outdoor seating if you choose. I will definitely be back but would love to try their dinner menu and other seafood options on the menu. read more

See all

I went in here for a few drinks with my friends over the weekend. Parking was easy in the garage nearby. They validated parking for 2 hours. All the cocktails were amazing. The flavors were very balanced and not overly sweet, just how I preferred it. The bartender was nice and friendly. This place is chic casual and I would definitely revisit for dinner next time. read more

Enjoyed dinner at Carmel. The food is good. Nothing was mind-blowing, but it was good. I really liked the dining room. Whoever designed this space did it so well. It feels warm and cozy...felt very California coastal. It is so difficult to design a dining room to be airy and warm and cozy at the same time. Love this dining space. Nice to walk around to the shops before dinner. Beautiful stores to view and as my mom says..."to eye-shop." The seafood tower here is to be respected. Asked if we could swap out the lobster for more of the other "good" stuff. They kindly switched out the lobster (don't really care for lobster because it tastes like nothing in my opinion...if I need butter or sauce to eat it...is it really good on its own?!) for more raw oysters. Ok...so oysters are my jam...and I am impressed. I don't like my oysters from any place I may have "spring break"-ed at. They did have some AL oyster I think on the menu...which I would not partake....but the tower had only PEI. And also they had NB oysters as well. The oysters we were lucky to have last night were very good. I give half-half for the shucking....no shells or grit but some of to oysters were not shucked all the way...still very attached and had to fight to get meat off the shell. The crackers....so very similar Alabama crackers....saltines with oil or butter with seasoning....amazing. Carmel serves these amazing crackers. I did not eat with the oysters...we ate like chips....so good. Service is good. Seriously. Ebony was on point. Very professional. Overall, I like it. Good place for a good meal. And I think it would be nice for date nights. read more

See all

First time at Carmel! Had brunch at the bar with A, as our bartender. Service was so great but the drinks were 10/10! Started with the Saturn drink as my first and thrid drink because it was so good! The fresh greated nutmeg was a wonderful touch. The grilled oysters and burger with the caviar fries were outstanding! Coby, the mgr, was wonderful and welcoming. Definitely check this spot out! read more

This restaurant is quite underrated. I went for lunch today, and enjoyed the chicken entree. It was delicious - the mushroom and squash were perfectly cooked and the chicken was perfectly seasoned. And the sauce was the best! The ambiance was also fantastic. I sat outside and enjoyed the unseasonably cool temperature. Service in this case was average. Not super attentive or friendly but at least got the job done. read more

Carmel - Seafood Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

We quite enjoyed our dinner here. We had flounder, grilled carrots, Pink Moon oysters, and roasted potatoes. We loved the food. Service was a little awkward. The sauces were amazing, especially the sauce with the potatoes and the sauce with the carrots. Of course, it's also in the middle of people watching central. We will be back. read more

8.5/10 Overall: a beautiful location with an intimate ambiance. The service was great and the food was super delicious. We ordered a dozen raw oysters for our appetizer, some which were a little small in my opinion, but it paired perfectly with the vinegar and spicy sauce that they gave us. Their menu changes seasonally! For our mains, we ordered the NY Strip, Halibut, Whole Lobster, and Diver Scallops. Halibut $41: 4/5 the fish was perfectly cooked and came with a creamy sauce with heirloom tomatoes and fennel. The fish was a little on the dry side though so I really had to coat it in the sauce to cancel out the dryness. I really enjoyed the flavor and thickness of the sauce. Diver Scallops $42: 4/5 this was the dish our waiter recommended to us! The texture of the scallops were perfect but they were on the salty side. Three scallops were paired with sweet corn, leeks, and smoked bacon which were seasoned perfectly and paired well with the scallops. NY Strip $62: 4.5/5 the meat was super tender and had a sweet flavor which went nice with the sauce. The steak was very juicy and cooked at a perfect medium. It was overall delicious! Whole lobster $48: 4.2/5 lobster was cooked well and was easy to eat. I wish it was more tender and i wish the lobster was a bit bigger. The lobster came with a grilled lemon which gave the lobster the perfect flavor balance and brioche crumbs which gave it a crunch. read more

See all

Compliments to the chef! My friends and I ate at Carmel for my 28th birthday dinner and I'm so glad I found this place. The service, drinks, and food were divine -- next level. We had the grilled oysters, lobster, chicken, scallops and even tried broccolini, okra, and roasted potatoes for sides. Every dish was well seasoned and near perfect! I can't wait to eat here again and again. read more

Carmel - grilled oysters - Seafood Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

This place has a beautiful aesthetic and honestly the brunch was genuinely really good! I had heard mixed things but I was pleasantly surprised. A must have is the milk buns. I could eat those forever. The lobster scramble was super tasty and rich with flavor. Their drinks were refreshing and overall paired very well. The service is great. Came here with a big party and it all went smoothly. One thing is that parking validation only works if you're there for two hours or less. read more

See all

Highly recommend! Excellent service and food was excellent! The oysters are probably some of the best in the area !

I had a great experience at Carmel. We dined on a weekday, so the ambiance in the restaurant was quiet which was perfect. Our server was great and very attentive. I would go back just for the drinks! Everything we tried was delicious. I'd recommend Carmel for a date night or dinner with friends! read more

See all

Celebrated our "original wedding" anniversary (canceled 2020 wedding date) here. First, the space is beautiful. Like so, so beautiful. Staff was very friendly and not pretentious. The food was all phenomenal. I had a mocktail which was an on the spot creation with passion fruit, was also phenomenal. I've been trying to recreate it at home ever since. We had a later reservation on a weekday, so once the dinning room cleared out a bit they let us move to a more "aesthetic table" to take some photo's and videos for socials and the waiters actually helped stage it and take photos and videos. They all seemed to understand that free content in a trendy restaurant is free marketing. I only took away a star because we were celebrating an anniversary which I noted when I made the reservation, and our waiter actually said she was going to bring us champagne on the house, which didn't happen. (which is fine because I wasn't drinking at the time we were there) but when she realized she forgot after saying it out loud, she told us she would be coming our desserts instead (both) so we ordered two rather than splitting. They were both comically small...but delicious. but when the check came they were also both on there...just pointing that out. It would have been less of a thing if they were tiny and expensive. It was fine, more comical than anything. Didn't ruin our time We will absolutely be back and I recommend it for sure. It's the kind of place I would recommend as a first date spot, or to take someone who's from out of town and you want to impress. The bar is beautiful and I want to go back just for drinks. read more

See all

I have been here for just drinks and for dinner and both times they were not playing with their amazing mixologists and chefs. This place is a high end seafood restaurant with mixed cuisines to highlight the best flavors of whichever type of fish they are serving. Our waitress was the absolute sweetest that really felt not only genuine but almost like we knew each other for a long time. We came in not really knowing what to get but I loved exploring this menu and trying multiple drinks that are influenced by the variety in their menu. Everything we got was delicious! Especially the sauces everything is served in. Very dish has a different flavor but they all fold together to make a delightful meal. The octopus specifically was absolutely amazing and I would highly suggest it. The tuna tartar is on the spicier side, which does kinda sneak up on you. This place is fairly new and I hope it picks up business and stays a while. The inside is a bit dark, giving a very intimate vibe for anyone on a date. I wouldn't suggest bringing a large group because this place is an open concept and sound does travel. This place is a nice treat, and really has set an environment that is unique especially in buckhead. read more

See all

This restaurant is located in the buckhead village. I just wanted something really quick to eat. I was able to sit outside because now they have some outdoor seating. It's very small but it's enough for a couple of people. I ordered the avocado and lobster. Its like guacamole with lobster in it. It was really good. The chips seemed like they were homemade. I was almost able to finish the whole thing so is was just the right amount. I just wanted something quick, not a big deal, so I was served quickly and I was done quickly, which I appreciated. I recommend this restaurant to any and everyone visiting the buckhead village. read more

Carmel - Entrance - Seafood Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Was excited to dine here, but the food fell a little flat. The tuna tartar was served minced with 2 squirts of avocado puree on a bed of a soupy vinegar/citrus... broth? Dressing? Sauce? The Bouillabasse (mixed seafood dish) was minimal - 2 prawns, 3 mussels, and a 3x3 portion size of fish. All for $36. The branzino was good, a little undercooked in my opinion, but had flavor. But not worth the $62 price tag. The drinks were good, the ambiance chill, service great, but I'm hesitant to come back. read more

We came in for some drinks and I ended up getting the shrimp scampi which came out with the shrimp with the heads on it. That wasn't a problem but the shrimp was mushy. Won't be getting that again but they have a great sparkling water called Eira which was very good. I got an amaretto sour but it wasn't Disaronno and it was okay. The service was very good and the ambiance was nice. read more