I've missed cafe Olivia so much! I used to go all the time when they were located in the city market. I recently found out they relocated to the Regions tower. Even better than I remembered! Great quality, service, and space! I had the ham and Swiss. Friend had chicken buffalo sandwich. read more

Cafe Olivia - Ham and Swiss sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This tiny shop has delicious deli sandwiches. There are only a few seats inside with a hard working team of 2. The bread is soft and warm and delicious. They are using the freshest ingredients such as spring mix and farm tomatoes. They also use Boar's Head deli meat. Great variety of sandwiches. Enjoyed it so much we went twice! Must stop lunch spot in Indy. read more

Cafe Olivia - Ham & Swiss - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Cute little place, and one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. I've been thinking about it since I went two weeks ago! Service is a little slow because it's just two employees, but they are so sweet and the food is easily worth the wait. Can't wait to go back read more

Cafe Olivia - Milano - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I went here for the first time today on my lunch break. It's so cold outside I didn't want to walk anywhere. I ordered the Cubano and it is a top tier sandwich. Great ingredients, great flavor, bread toasted to perfection. I'll definitely be coming back! Highly recommend. Plus, I ordered my sandwich and had it in my hands within 5 minutes! read more

Did you know Olivia has breakfast sandwiches? If you have seen any of my reviews for them you already know I love their sandwiches. Breakfast is no exception. The food quality is always outstanding and the couple that runs Olivia are very pleasant. About the sandwich: Bacon, egg and cheddar on ciabatta bread. They are delicious and very filling. My favorite spot in Indy! read more

Cafe Olivia - Bacon, egg and cheddar on ciabatta bread - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Milano sandwich is amazing. This was fast and the people were amazingly nice. 100% going back read more

Cafe Olivia - Milano - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

A City Market must try! I recently dropped by for a meal. My first choice, a shrimp po' boy, was sold out. The lady behind the counter was quick to recommend the chicken sandwich. Her enthusiasm is certainly admirable. After re-reviewing the menu, I ultimately took her advice. Topped with a unique flavored coleslaw between French style bread, it was nothing short of delicious! A staple eatery in the good ol' City Market that's well worth trying! read more

See all

Great sandwiches and great service at a reasonable price. I look forward to eating there at least once a week.

Cafe Olivia is a transplant to the Regions Tower from the City Market and the folks that run it really know how to handle lunch. The cajun slaw turkey sandwich is really nice and has a decent spicy kick. Cafe Olivia is a good stop for a quick sandwich. read more

Cafe Olivia has some of my (and my coworkers') favorite sandwiches in the City Market! Since COVID, they also started doing breakfast sandwiches that they serve all day that are a great value, easy to eat, and absolutely delicious! My all-time fave is the li'talian which I think has changed names recently but is basically an italian sub sandwich. It is SO GOOD, I crave it all the time. The bread is wrapped in wax paper so it doesn't drip and get all messy. The bread is great, the ingredients are great, the seasonings are great. And the employees are so nice and speedy. What more could you want for a quick lunch bite downtown at the Indy CM!? read more

Excellent service,amazing Chai Latte with two shots. Big lunch and decent breakfast menu. Would recommend! The muffins looked delicious.

This is one of many diamond in the roughs tucked away in the City Market. The restaurant's menu is a little rough with papers everywhere. But don't let that distract you from the good food and service there. I ordered the patty melt, and it was very tasty. The line can get a bit long during the lunch rush, but it is worth the wait (10-15 minutes to get food). I love their potato salad too. I saw there was a well stocked salad bar there, but if you could not tell by now, I am not a salad kind of guy. If I was, I were I would definitely give that bar a shot. read more

Cafe Olivia - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I grabbed a bowl of Red Beans and Rice from here and it was tasty, warm and filling. They have based their recipe on one of Emeril Lagasses. They don't try to conceal that fact. It's right there on the menu. The gravy was anchored in the holy trinity of onions, celery and green peppers. It was smooth and rich with Cajun spices: I know I tasted a bit of thyme and I got the heat of cayenne powder. There were at least two types of meat in there. Perhaps a type of sausage and some ham. The pieces of meat where finely sliced into tiny little triangles almost the same size as the red beans. It was all ladled over a huge bed of white rice. This is so satisfyingly delicious. I have been trying to make an effort to support little Mom & Pop places during this time and I'll be back soon. read more

Cafe Olivia - Red Beans and Rice - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Fantastic sandwiches, excellent sides, and amazing service. I highly recommend the Verona.

$5.50 for as much salad as you can pack into the Styrofoam box! Being the lettuce/salad snob that I am, I did a quick run through of the bar before pulling the trigger: chickpeas, kidney beans, spinach, peas, hard boiled eggs, beets, potato salad, pasta salad, cauliflower, broccoli, etc. You're set. Tucked away in the northeast corner of City Market, what Cafe Olivia lacks in style, it makes up for in speed, efficiency and price. The line was impressive during the lunch hour yet still moved along fairly fast. In the future I will have to try some of their hot menu dishes like red beans, rice and sausage, soups of the day, and sandwiches. I highly recommend Cafe Olivia if you're in a rush, not looking for frills and need something light and healthy to eat while on the go. read more

See all

I think I took more time making up my mind than this restaurant took to make my lunch! When you walk up to the booth, there are banners with food (mostly sandwiches) listings along the entire length of the booth. There is also a substantial salad bar along the north side of the booth which can be tempting too! I finally settled on the Cubano sandwich (Pork, Ham, cheese, mustard, & pickle) with a side of cole slaw. I grabbed a napkin from the counter and went to the south end of the booth to A) get out of the way of the new orders, and B) find the pick up counter. Before long, they called the last two numbers on my ticket I received after paying. A plastic fork was included in the styrofoam container. Note that they have a self serve soda dispenser that you can do while waiting too. I took my order upstairs and grabbed a spot in the balcony of City Market. The sandwich was about 6" overall and sliced on a slight bias, wrapped in deli paper to keep the handling clean. I thought the bread and sandwich ingredients were quite good, but not the best I've had. They used sliced ham and pieces of pork not uniformly carved to make the meat of the sandwich. The bread was fresh and had a nice bite texture without being toasted. One thing I particularly liked was a surprise in the slaw that it had some heat to it. I'm used to slaw being either tangy from a vinegar/sugar base or being creamy. This was on the less creamy side and the bit of heat was a pleasant change from the usually cool taste I get from slaw. I definitely recommend it if you like trying something different. Overall, efficient service and good food without taking up your whole lunch hour to get your food. Review #1966 read more

See all

I visited Cafe Olivia for the first time and didn't know what to order. The sweet lady suggested the "Shrimp Po'Boy" and that was such a good idea! It was fantastic and I ate it so fast I had no leftovers! Or pictures. It's also housed in the Indy city market which is such a cool building with awesome vendors. read more

This was my first time back to the City Market since a good hot minute, and I am so happy to have found Cafe Olivia. I couldn't decide whether to try the gumbo or the shrimp Po boy. I was excited to see I could get the gumbo as a side, so obviously I got both. They were both so delicious! They don't skimp out on how much shrimp you get. Both the spicy slaw on the sandwich and the gumbo had the perfect amount of heat I needed during this cold winter day. By far my new favorite restaurant in the Market! Next time I can I plan on getting a full order of the gumbo and can't wait to try everything else eventually. (I forgot to take a photo because It just tasted so good ha) read more

The City Market is a long-standing lunch institution in Indianapolis, so I wanted to give it a shot. Plus, I'm a supporter of small business. Cafe Olivia is tucked back in the northeast corner of the market. As with all of the market offerings, the kitchen is open and visible and just a few employees are working at any one time. The lunch rush in the market is hectic, but I was greeted professionally and decided to order the bbq pulled pork with potato salad. The sandwich far outweighed my expectations. The barbecue sauce was excellent and the potato salad was authentic. The market provides sufficient seating on its second level. There is plenty of parking on surrounding streets. The pricing is very conducive to the lunch budget of any patron, especially a college student. Absolutely recommend and will be returning. read more

See all

Nice staff, good food! Loved the pasta and potato salad. Also enjoyed the Reuben and suggest getting the chicken salad "spicy"

Their menu is large and has something for just about everyone. I decided on the Fresco grilled sandwich and it was really good. I forget what it was called, but the sauce they gave on the side was what made the sandwich a winner, so don't skip! They have very short wait times and would be great if you are in a rush or just want something quick. read more

Cafe Olivia - Fresco! - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I'm usually not a very big deli sandwich person but this place is so good! The grilled cheese panini and the cajun turkey are both delicious

EVERY SANDWICH WE'VE TRIED IS DIVINE!!!!!!!!!!! we especially like the Mediterranean!!! (my fav), b/f loves the Reuben, i know the (usually Wed Special) is the Brazilian Black Bean with Roast Pork (YumO) & we love the soups, & they have a salad bar (i think the only salad bar in the City Market) & a small Boar's Head Meat / & Cheese selection on the side Great Staff, a family owned local business (the ones we need to support) Cafe Olivia was created in high spirit and with the aim of bringing a small piece of Province, France to the Indianapolis City Market. All dishes, soups, and roasted meats are made fresh on the premises. Taste delicacies such as Roast Beef and Gruyere Cheese and Prosciutto, Provolone and Spinach Sandwiches. From fresh fruit to omelets, breakfast is served daily http://www.cafeolivia.com/ read more

I had the Panino "Fresco" and it was the best lunch I've had in the US. You could tell that they were using real italian-style mozzerella and the whole thing was just very tasty. They included a cup of aioli which just made the panino even better - great place! read more

Cafe Olivia - Here's the shop, it's in the far right corner if you enter from Market Street - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Cafe Olivia is tucked in the back corner of the City Market. They have lots of sandwich options made with fresh, creative ingredients. When I was there, the staff was friendly and patient while I figures out what to try. I had the spicy Cajun turkey with mozarella, LTO and aioli on ciabatta bread. The sandwich was excellent and the ingredients were very fresh. The food is fairly priced and very filling. I'll definitely be back. read more

This is my last week working at the City-County Building so I went to Cafe Olivia for one last City Market lunch. Today, I went whole hog and ordered the half-pound Angus burger (two stacked quarter pound patties, perfectly prepared) topped with Cheddar Cheese, lettuce, tomato, ketchup, and sauteed onions. What a sandwich! Not the kind of thing I would eat more than once a year, but it hit the spot and was well worth the caloric splurge! I'm moving on from downtown Indianapolis as a work location, but I'll never forget the variety and quality that Cafe Olivia always offered. read more

Had their Monday special Italian sausage and pasta as a to go. I would rate the food ordinary from all aspect. The Italian sausage itself was not particularly flavorful or spicy. The garlic was not sautéed well and id say the white wine used wasn't good enough. So the dish was not terribly to taste nor was it particularly tasty. read more

During my recent visit to Indy for my Super Lady Friend's Science Conference I visited the City Market everyday. I was incredibly happy that we chose to visit Cafe Olivia during one of these visits. As soon as I read Catfish Po'Boy on the menu my decision was made. I was so overly consumed with my sandwich that I honestly have no idea what Alison ordered and ate. I know it was a sandwich and that she liked it though. The catfish on my Po'Boy was a bit greasy, I think they might have left it in the fryer a bit too long. But I also don't eat a lot of fried foods so its possible that I am overly sensative to that. Aside from that small error the sandwich was fantastic, I paired it with a Moustache Ride Red from Flat 12 Brewery served at the Tomlinson Tap Room. The two were a good pair. I can understand why some of the other reviewers say its the only reason they go to the market or the only place they visit. I am a bit more adventuresome, but given the chance I would certainly come back. read more

I work downtown and am trying out new places (to me) at the city market. This has become my go to for lunch! They have a wide variety of options from salad bar, pulled pork and sandwiches. I have only tried the sandwiches and they have been delicious! They use boats head meats. The bacon is always cooked perfectly as well. The lady that takes the orders is very friendly and efficient. She always smiles and makes you feel welcome. The food is made pretty fast so the wait is not long at all. Get there early because they can sell out of certain items. I love cafe Olivia's! read more

Cafe Olivia is located in City Market, downtown Indy. I was looking for a good sandwich and stumbled upon this little gem. They have awesome Cubano sandwiches, one of the best I've had. Their sides are also great - I recommend the red beans and rice. When I was pregnant, I craved Cafe Olivia and found myself walking 5 blocks from work. Plus, the employees are super nice and for the amount of food you get for the price this is a great lunch option for downtowners! read more

Cafe Olivia is the first place I've tried in City Market. I ordered the Le Poulet Panino. There was no line so I ordered immediately. The woman who took my order was very friendly and informed me they were out of their normal bread for this dish but could substitute the sandwich on a french baguette, works for me! It was delicious. Plenty of chicken that was seasoned nicely with a generous helping of provolone cheese and a tasty tomato pasta. Simple yet delicious. The Aioli that came with the sandwich was excellent as well. The sandwich was quite large for $8. Pretty good price for the size I'd say. I will definitely be back! read more

The poulet panini-chicken, provolone, and sundried tomato on bread brushed with herbed butter and served with herby aioli is amazing. I'd probably eat just about anything if it came with said aioli! Everything is made to order and they use high quality ingredients. A tasty and indulgent lunch choice. read more

Very good sandwiches and by far the best food option in the City Market. My favorite is the mozzarella, tomato & zucchini sandwich. You order at the counter and then grab your food on the other end. read more

Hidden in the northeast side of The City Market, Café Olivia is a must try. Solid sandwiches, fairly priced and quick service. The Godfather sandwich is a must try. So much talian meat and veggies you can hear the bread ( and amazing bread it is) crying for help. Check this place out! read more

Best food in the city market. I've been eating here since they were in the back by enzos and never been let down. Never ever. I can't recommend anything because everything is great. Can't say enough good things about this place. Best salad bar in the market too. Ran by people who care. read more

The food is always good here and I would probably eat here a lot more often if they didnt protect their napkin supply like it's gold in Fort Knox. Sorry, but 2 napkins is not enough for a big sloppy sandwich and chips. read more

I'm not a big sandwich fan, but I love this place. I've tried the Prosciutto and Provolone, the Mediterranean, and the Mozarella, Tomato and Zucchini, and they were all wonderful. The Supreme and the Cuban are also very popular. The ingredients are all very fresh and tasty. The bread alone is delicious. The toppings are a great compliment on each sandwich and not overdone. It's so nice to find something tasty and different for lunch at a reasonable price. read more

The food at Cafe Olivia is really good, the service is not. This is a business that cares more about pinching a penny than serving the customer. The owner runs the register while another man (presumably owner as well) barks orders at his workers and refuses to do anything extra even on request. Once the owner's daughter was working the register and I requested extra sauce, she told the man running the pass, however he refused to add the extra sauce, I told her I was happy to pay for it. Another instance, I asked the owner for extra sauce on the side, she was happy to charge me for the extra sauce, but then insisted that it could not be put on the side, the extra sauce would only have to go on the sandwhich. If you don't ask for anything extra or different, you are in good shape and your experience will be fine.... but don't bother them by asking for a side of sauce, it just can't be done! read more

My favorite place to eat at City Market. Good food, reasonable prices, and healthy options.

At least once a week I have to order one of the grilled tomato mozzarella sandwiches. My absolute favorite. Never disappointed in the food.