Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Cafe Olivia

    4.4 (55 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Cafe Olivia Photos

    CAFE OLIVIA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Loud
    Casual
    Good for kids
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Cafe Olivia

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Bacon, egg and cheddar on ciabatta bread

    Did you know Olivia has breakfast sandwiches? If you have seen any of my reviews for them you already know I love their sandwiches. Breakfast is no exception. The food quality is always outstanding and the couple that runs Olivia are very pleasant. About the sandwich: Bacon, egg and cheddar on ciabatta bread. They are delicious and very filling. My favorite spot in Indy!

    Milano
    Greg B.

    Milano sandwich is amazing. This was fast and the people were amazingly nice. 100% going back

    Overhead sign
    Jeffrey W.

    A City Market must try! I recently dropped by for a meal. My first choice, a shrimp po' boy, was sold out. The lady behind the counter was quick to recommend the chicken sandwich. Her enthusiasm is certainly admirable. After re-reviewing the menu, I ultimately took her advice. Topped with a unique flavored coleslaw between French style bread, it was nothing short of delicious! A staple eatery in the good ol' City Market that's well worth trying!

    Tank G.

    This is one of many diamond in the roughs tucked away in the City Market. The restaurant's menu is a little rough with papers everywhere. But don't let that distract you from the good food and service there. I ordered the patty melt, and it was very tasty. The line can get a bit long during the lunch rush, but it is worth the wait (10-15 minutes to get food). I love their potato salad too. I saw there was a well stocked salad bar there, but if you could not tell by now, I am not a salad kind of guy. If I was, I were I would definitely give that bar a shot.

    Red Beans and Rice
    David K.

    I grabbed a bowl of Red Beans and Rice from here and it was tasty, warm and filling. They have based their recipe on one of Emeril Lagasses. They don't try to conceal that fact. It's right there on the menu. The gravy was anchored in the holy trinity of onions, celery and green peppers. It was smooth and rich with Cajun spices: I know I tasted a bit of thyme and I got the heat of cayenne powder. There were at least two types of meat in there. Perhaps a type of sausage and some ham. The pieces of meat where finely sliced into tiny little triangles almost the same size as the red beans. It was all ladled over a huge bed of white rice. This is so satisfyingly delicious. I have been trying to make an effort to support little Mom & Pop places during this time and I'll be back soon.

    the order line has a lot of choices!
    Ken N.

    I think I took more time making up my mind than this restaurant took to make my lunch! When you walk up to the booth, there are banners with food (mostly sandwiches) listings along the entire length of the booth. There is also a substantial salad bar along the north side of the booth which can be tempting too! I finally settled on the Cubano sandwich (Pork, Ham, cheese, mustard, & pickle) with a side of cole slaw. I grabbed a napkin from the counter and went to the south end of the booth to A) get out of the way of the new orders, and B) find the pick up counter. Before long, they called the last two numbers on my ticket I received after paying. A plastic fork was included in the styrofoam container. Note that they have a self serve soda dispenser that you can do while waiting too. I took my order upstairs and grabbed a spot in the balcony of City Market. The sandwich was about 6" overall and sliced on a slight bias, wrapped in deli paper to keep the handling clean. I thought the bread and sandwich ingredients were quite good, but not the best I've had. They used sliced ham and pieces of pork not uniformly carved to make the meat of the sandwich. The bread was fresh and had a nice bite texture without being toasted. One thing I particularly liked was a surprise in the slaw that it had some heat to it. I'm used to slaw being either tangy from a vinegar/sugar base or being creamy. This was on the less creamy side and the bit of heat was a pleasant change from the usually cool taste I get from slaw. I definitely recommend it if you like trying something different. Overall, efficient service and good food without taking up your whole lunch hour to get your food. Review #1966

    Brittany S.

    $5.50 for as much salad as you can pack into the Styrofoam box! Being the lettuce/salad snob that I am, I did a quick run through of the bar before pulling the trigger: chickpeas, kidney beans, spinach, peas, hard boiled eggs, beets, potato salad, pasta salad, cauliflower, broccoli, etc. You're set. Tucked away in the northeast corner of City Market, what Cafe Olivia lacks in style, it makes up for in speed, efficiency and price. The line was impressive during the lunch hour yet still moved along fairly fast. In the future I will have to try some of their hot menu dishes like red beans, rice and sausage, soups of the day, and sandwiches. I highly recommend Cafe Olivia if you're in a rush, not looking for frills and need something light and healthy to eat while on the go.

    Store front
    Austin M.

    The City Market is a long-standing lunch institution in Indianapolis, so I wanted to give it a shot. Plus, I'm a supporter of small business. Cafe Olivia is tucked back in the northeast corner of the market. As with all of the market offerings, the kitchen is open and visible and just a few employees are working at any one time. The lunch rush in the market is hectic, but I was greeted professionally and decided to order the bbq pulled pork with potato salad. The sandwich far outweighed my expectations. The barbecue sauce was excellent and the potato salad was authentic. The market provides sufficient seating on its second level. There is plenty of parking on surrounding streets. The pricing is very conducive to the lunch budget of any patron, especially a college student. Absolutely recommend and will be returning.

    Fresco!

    See all

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    This place makes the BEST panini I've had in downtown Indy. Always fast, well priced, and delicious!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    18 years ago

    My favorite place for lunch, period. The sandwiches are AWESOME and they use good ingredients.

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Donovan M.
    74
    137
    19

    15 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Always the freshest veggies on the salad bar and great sandwiches made to order. Their pastrami and swiss with hot mustard is the bomb!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Great sandwiches..turkey with herb mayo is great!!!!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Teddy D.
    1
    302
    128

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    i do not appreciate being hung up on when im in the middle of talking. that is one of the rudest things you can possibly do to someone..

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Cafe Olivia

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Sandwiches 2,745 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Tupelo Honey Southern Kitchen & Bar

    Tupelo Honey Southern Kitchen & Bar

    4.1(485 reviews)
    0.6 miMile Square
    $$
    Full bar
    Takes reservations

    Stopped in Indy for a couple days and heard Tupelo is amazing so of course I had to check it out…read more As soon as I stepped in, the nature-inspired vibes from the hanging flowers and plants everywhere mixed with the stylish decor really impressed me. I was seated quickly at the bar and the bartenders at that time were great and punctual and making sure I got a menu and everything else I needed. I definitely appreciated that they weren't constantly approaching me, but they read my cues with knowing when I was ready to order or needed something. I was really pleased with the service that I received. The menu had a mixture of American comfort food as well as classic Southern dishes. I took several glances at the food other were ordering and they all looked so appealing and appetizing. I decided to order something that I haven't tried anywhere else, so I ordered the Southern Shakshuka, which is their own unique spin-off to the original. The meal comprised of a base of creamy cheesy grits topped with a somewhat rich layer of roasted tomatoes and vegetables and poached eggs. OMG it was amazing and so flavorful! If you are ever in the area definitely stop by this place!!

    Excellent No notes…read more 10/10 Our server was Keagan. She was cordial and exuded kindness from beginning to end. The establishment was lovely and well suited for the area. It was causal with almost a fine dining flair. The decor was nice and the color pallet was calming. The ambiance could not have been any better. The food was delicious. I had the chicken and waffles. The flavor was amazing and the crispness of the chicken was perfect. My family got the half bird with fries. The fries were crisp and soft at the same time. Id return with no hesitation.

    Photos
    Tupelo Honey Southern Kitchen & Bar
    Tupelo Honey Southern Kitchen & Bar
    Tupelo Honey Southern Kitchen & Bar - Indoor Seating

    See all

    Indoor Seating

    Milktooth - Loaded grits

    Milktooth

    4.1(1.7k reviews)
    0.9 miFletcher Place
    $$

    One of my longtime go-to brunch spots in Indy has been Milktooth, and I'm happy to report the…read morerecent transition to "Arleen's" hasn't changed the things I've always loved about the place. Same great staff, same cool space, same open kitchen where a party of one like me can grab a counter seat and watch the chefs do their thing. I've honestly always enjoyed that part of the experience. Today I had the avocado toast with feta and an egg on top, and it totally hit the spot. Earlier this week I tried one of the newer menu items -- fried chicken with mashed potatoes and gravy, plus a sample of jalapeño cornbread and Asian slaw. Incredible comfort food. And as someone who normally isn't much of a slaw person, I was surprised by how much I loved it. They also tried to tempt me with the roast beef special, which honestly looked great, but at 10:30 in the morning I just couldn't fully commit to roast beef yet. Maybe next time. The new name is a nice tribute to the owner's mother, Arleen, but thankfully it still feels like the Milktooth so many of us have come to enjoy over the years. Definitely worth checking out if you haven't been in awhile.

    Food was decent. We had a latke, sourdough waffle, bacon,…read moreeggs. Latke and waffle had good flavor. However, the service was terrible. I waited 30 mins for a drip coffee. 45 mins for the cortado. I personally think our order was probably not put in and forgotten.

    Photos
    Milktooth - Inside

    Inside

    Milktooth - Raclette grilled cheese

    Raclette grilled cheese

    Milktooth - Outside seating

    See all

    Outside seating

    Taxman CityWay

    Taxman CityWay

    3.9(344 reviews)
    0.5 miMile Square
    $$

    We came during happy hour on Sunday and we had a great time. This place has plenty of seating…read moreindoors and outdoors. The servers are also friendly and attentive. The apps were reasonable prices and filled us up. We enjoyed the drink specials as well. Not pictured are the chicken bites with curry ketchup. While the chicken itself wasn't super seasoned, it was crispy and the curry ketchup was delicious. After we ate our table played a board game and the server continued to check in on us. Overall a great experience!

    The beer is good. I really enjoyed the Deduction Belgian-style dubbel - a Gold Medal winning beer…read more I am very sad about the food and service, though. I will cut some slack on the service, however - I arrives after what seems to have been a very atypical rush of Journey fans who inundated the place before heading to Gainbridge Fieldhouse. The staff seemed a bit rundown and slap happy - not really attentive to the bar where I sat. I waited a bit long before I was greeted with a menu, waited awhile with an empty glass, waited with my food pushed away before it was cleared. No one asked if everything was okay even though most of my food was untouched. The food... my salad (house greens) was a great little salad! I say this despite finding a hair on the plate when I was about 2/3 through. My mussels and fries were not great. The fries were mid - they tasted kind of overdone or as if the oil were old. The mussels were actively bad. The portion (an app) was pretty small. There was hardly any broth/wine and they weren't piping hot. Also, they were actually not tasty and the texture was rubbery. They remained in front of me, uncleared, even after I closed my tab. They did not smell good. I don't anticipate being sick but I do anticipate being hungry.

    Photos
    Taxman CityWay
    Taxman CityWay
    Taxman CityWay - Beer flight

    See all

    Beer flight

    Easy Rider Diner

    Easy Rider Diner

    4.4(252 reviews)
    1.4 miFountain Square
    $$

    I enjoyed this event at Easy Rider Diner. I had been wanting to try as I am a fan of diners, dives…read moreand drive-ins lol. I was not a fan of the drinks. I first tried Christopher oaxanao... can't really spell it but was told it sounded like walken? Anyway it was very bitter, took one sip and asked for a different drink, which they agreed to with no issue. The second drink was called no aloha. It was much better but tini wini! Lol I came home and fixed a good old glass of wine! Now to the food. I had honey hot chicken and sweet potatoes (fries) The flavors were perfect. I can't have dairy so I got honey hot dipping sauce . Perfect amount of spices and heat. I would like to come back and try the vegan nachos. The restaurant is designed like a diner. Nice atmosphere. Throwback music. It's right next to a concert venue.we got tickets to several concerts. Don't know if every customer gets that or it was only for the yelp event. event. I am interested in having brunch next time. Overall pretty good and fun night out. Don't think it would make Guy's pick list tho :)

    We went to Easy Rider Dinet for dinner and it was just as good as brunch! Customer service 10 out…read moreof 10. Food 10 out of 10 ambience 10 out of 10. Easy Rider Diner is easily in my top 20 restaurants. The food is always amazing. If you think you have had steak fries before you really need to try theirs because they are out of this world. So many flavors going on, all complementing each other. The jalapeño cornbread was really good as well. It's a huge portion!

    Photos
    Easy Rider Diner - Mac & Queso topped with pork belly.

    Mac & Queso topped with pork belly.

    Easy Rider Diner - Chef Ricky Martinez

    Chef Ricky Martinez

    Easy Rider Diner - Baked Eggs - A Mexican take on Eggs in Purgatory with chorizo and pico de gallo

    See all

    Baked Eggs - A Mexican take on Eggs in Purgatory with chorizo and pico de gallo

    Yolk - City Way

    Yolk - City Way

    4.1(897 reviews)
    0.6 miMile Square
    $$
    Gluten-free friendly
    Vegan friendly

    We had a great experience at Yolk in Indianapolis. The food was excellent across the board, and we…read moresat at the bar which ended up being a great spot. I usually base a lot of choices on coffee options and was happy to see flavored creamers for drip and LOTS of specialty options for coffee lovers. The woman working on the getting plates ready for the servers and expediting food was fantastic--super attentive and kept everything moving quickly. We watched everyone's plates came out fast and fresh the entire time. We ordered the All Star and upgraded the cinnamon roll French toast for $3, which was absolutely amazing and worth it. We also got a half order of the red velvet French toast--just as good and perfectly done with fresh strawberries. The avocado toast was solid as well. Only small note: the capers were a nice touch, but pickled red onion instead of fresh chopped would've taken it over the top for more balance and brightness. Overall, really good food, great service, and we'll definitely be back.

    I was a disappointed by this restaurant…read more For context, I got an egg white breakfast sandwich and they cooked the avocado into the egg and it was really disgusting. I also got a side of egg whites, but they were cooked in that butter spray and didn't taste fresh. The cheesy grits were OK but not very flavorful. I also got a Matcha, but it was pretty watery about a two out of five stars. I will note that the service was good and the staff was friendly.

    Photos
    Yolk - City Way
    Yolk - City Way
    Yolk - City Way

    See all

    Spoke & Steele - Pinot Noir Poached Pear

    Spoke & Steele

    4.0(463 reviews)
    0.4 miMile Square
    $$

    Spoke & Steele, located in downtown Indianapolis, offers a dining experience that beautifully blend…read moreof modern design with upscale food. It sits at the base of the Le Meridien hotel. The restaurant features an extensive drink menu that will suite anyone's pallet. We chose to start with the bread service which was killer especially the honey butter. All of the apps look d amazing but went for the dry rub duck wings with home made ranch. My only critic was I wish there were more than 3. Finished off with the shrimp and grits. Although, I wasn't in New Orleans the spiciness took me back there. The wait staff was great. Even though we were late for the reservation we were seated promptly and had multiple people taking care of us. Spoke & Steele is a must if you are staying in the hotel but also if you want a cool vibe for drinks and great food I would stop by and take a look.

    There's brunch... and then there's Spoke & Steele brunch!!!…read moreFrom the moment you walk in, the vibe is giving cozy, elevated, and just the right amount of "I deserve to be here." The seating? Intimate. The lighting? Soft. The whole space feels like a quiet luxury moment tucked right into the city. Now let's talk about what REALLY matters, the food. The shrimp & grits??? Listen... this wasn't just a dish, this was an EXPERIENCE. The grits were creamy, smooth, and perfectly rich, but that sauce layered on top?? Whew. Flavor on flavor on flavor. You've got that deep, savory, slightly smoky profile with juicy shrimp, sausage, and those pickled onions cutting through everything with the perfect tang. Every bite felt intentional. Like somebody knew what they were doing in that kitchen. And can we talk about how beautiful it was plated?? Because yes, I absolutely appreciated the aesthetics before I even picked up my fork. Paired it with a simple coffee moment, sitting by the window, and honestly... it felt like a reset. Not rushed, not loud, just good food, good atmosphere, and a chance to actually enjoy it. If you're looking for a brunch spot that feels a little more elevated, a little more intentional, and delivers on both flavor and experience. This is it. 10/10. I'll absolutely be back!!!

    Photos
    Spoke & Steele
    Spoke & Steele - Cajun Duck Wings

    Cajun Duck Wings

    Spoke & Steele - House Bread

    See all

    House Bread

    Bluebeard - Perfect Brussels Sprouts

    Bluebeard

    4.4(1.4k reviews)
    1.0 miFletcher Place
    $$$

    I stopped by this fantastic spot in Fletcher Place for lunch and it was a total win! I loved that…read morethey offer two different experiences a great bar area and a beautiful full-service dining room. I opted for the dining room, and even though it was buzzing with a lunch crowd, it was the perfect level of energy without being noisy. The service was 10/10. My waiter was incredibly warm and took the time to explain the day's dishes in detail. I ordered the Brussels Sprouts and a drink, and both arrived in just a few minutes. The sprouts were perfectly prepared and very satisfying easily some of the best I've had. If you're looking for a high-quality lunch with excellent service and a great vibe, this is the place. I'm giving it a full rating and will definitely be back!

    Heading back home from Sturgis SD taking the I80 route, stopped in Indianapolis IN for a quick…read moredinner. Quick web search, Bluebeard popped up as one choice. Reviewed the menu seemed to be eclectic enough, off we go. The place had a decent size outdoor dinning area. Few of the tables were occupied. Table for one...indoor, outdoor was the question? Indoor. Although the weather was beautiful, indoors was my choice. Al fresco dining is not my first choice. I don't like to do battle over my meal with insects and other wild life. I deducted 1 star for red wine served at room temperature. How is it that, red wines are chilled (55F) on the west coast but served at 'room temperature' (72F, 82F...) on the east coast. Had two dishes, they were OK, service was ok Would I go back? Yes, if the red wine was chilled.

    Photos
    Bluebeard - Draft Taps

    Draft Taps

    Bluebeard - Winter Panzanella salad

    Winter Panzanella salad

    Bluebeard - Brussels SproutsBrussels

    See all

    Brussels SproutsBrussels

    Love Handle - Waffle and pork belly

    Love Handle

    4.3(409 reviews)
    1.0 miChatham Arch
    $$

    Met up with two friends for brunch at Love Handle and it absolutely delivered. Great location at…read morethe end of Mass Ave near Bottleworks--and pro tip: parking directly in front on the same side of the street is free. The space is big and fun, with a large dining room, an old-school video arcade game, interesting art, and a big screen playing movies, which adds to the laid-back, quirky vibe. It's counter service with clear menu boards on the wall, making ordering easy. I had the cheesy jalapeño grits with bacon and an egg and... my goodness. So incredibly delicious. One friend ordered the same grits but swapped in fried catfish instead of bacon--also a fantastic choice. Our third went with a classic plate with eggs and bacon, and let me tell you, the bacon is thick and plentiful. We ordered a side of fries for the table and there were more than enough to share. Self-serve coffee with all the fixings is a nice touch, and the service was friendly and welcoming. Fun atmosphere, great food, solid portions--definitely will be back.

    Stopped in here for brunch this past Sunday with my husband because we had been wanting to try it…read moreout for a while and had mixed feelings. We were greeted right away and looked over the menu a bit before ordering. My husband ordered the country breakfast with chicken (definitely the way to go) and I ordered the cheesy jalapeño grits with bacon. We each got a cup for water and I ordered a coffee, excited because I saw ahead of going that it was self-serve (like at Cafe Patachou where I can get as many coffees as I like without having to wait for our server to come check on us first). However, the self serve coffee excitement was short-lived after seeing that they only offered half and half as creamer (I'm lactose intolerant) and the two coffee carafes were not labeled for what was inside (decaf? medium roast? you'll never know!) and then one was completely empty and never refilled during our visit. The water station also was not ever refilled during our visit, so we were not able to get refills after filling up our cups the first time. It took a couple of tries to find a table we could sit at because you seat yourself, but several had not been cleaned after other guests left and had food and drinks spilled on them. There were definitely enough staff members there to be able to clean them in between customers, so we weren't sure why they were left that way. We ended up sitting in the middle of the room towards the front, across from the clown art wall, which made for interesting conversation as we looked through everything. When the food came out I was impressed with the portions, but I had no flavor whatsoever to my cheesy jalepeno grits. The egg and bacon were good, but not enough to make it a good dish and I would not order it again. And I love savory breakfast and grits in general, so it was a real bummer. My husband's dish was worth the visit though. It was a huge portion size and we honestly would just split it if we came back and ordered it. It was so savory, seasoned perfectly, and juicy. One of the best breakfast dishes I have tried recently! I really debated between 3-4 stars for this, but my dish was a flop, the lack of cleanliness for the seating area, the lackluster self-serve coffee station, and not refilling the beverages ultimately scored a 3 star review for me. I would come back and try something else though, or split the country chicken breakfast because it was really good. Hopefully next time the beverages won't be empty!

    Photos
    Love Handle - Coffee Station

    Coffee Station

    Love Handle - Waffle and Pork Belly

    Waffle and Pork Belly

    Love Handle

    See all

    Cafe Olivia - sandwiches - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...