Be careful if you enter this place, since you will 100% walk out with pricey cookies, lol. Didn't want to look in, but how can you not when in the area walking around the park. Popped in just to see since store didn't seem to have too much stuff inside. Very friendly workers, offering samples of the cookies to try while you check out the cute displays and wonder at the pricey cookies... Since I like to stick to whatever/original made a place famous, tried the original sample... If you have crossed this step, you know it's too late. So buttery, rich, dense, delicious cookie, perfect in the original formula of sweet/buttery/salt/texture. I still resisted, but wife broke down immediately and we walked out with 2 packs, lol. Think of Brown Butter Cookie as the cookie version of See's Candy's, or a drug dealer, lol. Free sample, since they are all confident you will find it to be awesome and be hooked! So pricey, but even a little goes a long way with these rich dense cookies. Dare to take a peek inside if in the area... Or just trust you won't be disappointed and just order it online to see. Think I saw a deal that made it cheaper online shortly after visiting in March, so look for sales/deals online. It almost made me order some, but was able to resist the urge, lol. read more

See all

Pros: The cookies at Brown Butter Cookie are very good (rich, dense, and delicious). However, they are definitely pricey for their bite-sized portion. Cons: The customer service was average. Note: Parking can be hard to find during busy hours because of the nearby park. Overall, it's a great gourmet treat if you don't mind the premium price and the parking hunt! read more

See all

Assistance+ Balance+ Cleanliness+ Deliciousness+ Environment+ Greeted kindly, treated respectfully. Prices are a bit high but the day olds and sales absolutely make up for it. Amazing quality and decent quantity. Clean and tidy. Every flavor is delicious! Environment is warm and inviting, like family baking cookies for you. read more

Excellent shortbread cookies and chocolate chip cookies! Clean and open store with free samples and friendly service. I will definitely be coming back here and next time I will get more because we ate everything up way too quickly. read more

The Brown Butter Cookie store is a cute storefront with a pistachio green and brown awning in Downtown Paso Robles. They have a prime corner location that practically begs you to visit simply for the nostalgia of it. Immediately upon entry, I was greeted by an employee who walked up to me offering free samples. The cookies are good! They are rich, dense, and everything you want in a shortbread cookie but you can tell the butter is not your typical butter. If you're not familiar with brown butter, it's something you have to try. It's rich, bold, and nutty. Which made the cookies rich and full transparency, it helped me to eat less cookies. I can easily down a dozen cookies on my own, but in this case, I savored them because they were on the dense side. The original Brown Butter Sea Salt cookies are the original flavor and most popular, but they also have lemon zest, which was a nice summer flavor. Not too heavy on the lemon and it had the base of the brown butter sea salt. I also had Chocolate Chip Brown Butter cookies. The chocolate is Ghirardelli chocolate. Other flavors that I didn't get the chance to try are Snickerdoodle, and Toffee Chocolate. They sell the cookies individually, in bags of 2, 6, a dozen, and gift boxes are also available. Prices are a bit steep at a little over a dollar per cookie, but totally worth it if you don't have the chance to eat them often. They have a website and you can shop online. Overall, this is a great cookie shop to stop in and treat yourself to non-ordinary cookies. The customer service was good and I'd stop in the next time I'm in Paso Robles. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

Delicious and unique cookies in the heart of downtown Paso! I don't think Brown Butter Cookie could possibly have a better location, right across from the park and at a crosswalk, it's almost impossible to miss them. I first came in back in 2019 and really enjoyed sampling all the different flavor cookies they had. They had quite the variety and each one was tasty. Since Covid hit they stopped doing samples for a while, but on my most recent visit they were doing them once again! This time it was only one of their flavors instead of a bunch, but it was still good to be reminded on how good these cookies are! It seems like they don't have as many flavors as they used to, but they have some new ones that I don't remember seeing in the past, including a partnership with Ghirardelli to use their chocolate chips in some. I noticed they also have some more traditional classic cookies in addition to their specialty brown butter cookies. read more

See all

Decadent! Really special cookies! Whenever friends come to visit, THIS is where they want to go. The brown butter flavor really is unique. Yes, they are a bit pricey. But they use high quality ingredients, are very consistent in their quality & production, and also very generous with their free samples. Excellent hostess or birthday gift! Even friends who aren't cookie fanatics love Brown Butter Cookie Co. Very welcoming staff. Cute clothes & other gifts too. I highly recommend both the Paso Robles & Cayucos locations! read more

Always have to pick up some cookies before heading back home. Always fresh and ready. Just your classic favorite and few others. Pop into for a little sample which always the best of whatever that maybe. The chocolate chip cookies are to die for. A favorites always. read more

See all

A central coast go to. Setup in the very underrated downtown Paso Robles is Brown Buttee Cookie. If you've been to Cayucos then you are well aware of how good their cookies are. The original short bread is always top notch. The service at this location is great. The employees are always friendly. Stop by for something sweet. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Front - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

While visiting Paso Robles this summer my sis and I walked around the quaint town and came across this store. Anything "cookie" oriented always catches my attention. Owner Traci introduced herself and told us all about the cookies. They make them on site and are available for delivery and/or shipping. The cookies melt in your mouth! I bought a stack for $20. It included 1 big chocolate chip cookie, 1 oatmeal, 1 lemon, 1 snicker doodle, 2 small round brown butter cookies and 1 small round chocolate butter cookie. Phoenix checked me out at the register and was super friendly. The inside of the store is very clean, organized with an open concept. A hot spot for tourists and a "must"' try if visiting the area. *Plenty of free parking in the area read more

See all

I can't describe these cookies other than YUMMMMMM the consistency is what makes them so different. I feels like a brown sugar cookie that has weight to it but crumbles at the same time. eeeeek so so so good they're dangerous hehehe. i think and crave these often heheh :) read more

You won't find a better Brown Butter Cookie anywhere. Really, I mean it. I've never seen these cookies anywhere but here in Paso Robles Ca. The flavor is unique and the taste is incredible. Can't wait to stop in again. Staff and Service are great. read more

I had never visited this location before, as we usually find Cayucos more convenient. However, this place is far more inviting. It's spacious and pleasant to walk through. The customer service was excellent. If you haven't tried their cookies, you're missing out--they are heavenly. I always bring a tower of cookies back for the family. My personal favorite is the salted brown butter shortbread. If you can't visit the store, they offer shipping to your home, so be sure to check out their website. The cookies are absolutely delicious. 6/24/24 read more

See all

Brown Butter Cookie made a big mistake when they changed their format from a round cookie to a cut bar. Not nearly the same texture or mouthfeel. Talk about a failure to scale. read more

This place has lots of great reviews, so maybe I'm missing what the hype is about. We stopped in and tried a sample, got a gift for my mom, and 2 big chocolate chip cookies for the ride home. Small packet of short bread cookies and 2 chocolate chip cookies came to over $20. Just seemed like a tourist trap. Chocolate chip cookies were ok, a little tough and the chocolate chips were bitter, just a normal cookie. Everything was pre packed so it also made me wonder about the freshness. It's not a fresh bakery with cookies in cases it's a store with cookies all wrapped up in plastic. read more

Staff onsite very friendly. Was provided samples of the cookies which tasted very delicious , I had to buy to bring home as souvenirs tof my trip to Paso Robles. They are quite ef the central California region.nsive but worth the price tagas my friends enjoyed the cookes and they aren't really cookie loves. Qute a few variety of cookies. Should definitely stop by and become a cookie lover. Store extremely clean and well organized. Definitely a gem onf read more

These cookies are fresh literally as you're walking in. They are baking them, packaging them up and getting them back onto the shelves... This was our last stop before heading home .. we had several requests and we wanted to give them out as gifts. They are packaged so beautifully for the holidays each with its own bag with tissue. These cookies are no joke so be prepared to be addicted. They are so buttery and so yummy. They come in original chocolate and I believe maple. We bought the original and the chocolate and they are outstanding. They are located on the Square and Paso right on the corner. You cannot miss them. The staff are incredibly helpful and giving out samples to everyone ... These brown butter bakers were working overtime read more

See all

Brown Butter Cookie is located on the corner of 12th Street and Park here in Paso. It's a very spacious store and there was a lot of different cookies. I was intrigued by the name and wanted to check it out. The girls that work inside were very helpful. They did have samples of all their different flavors. Their original is the best of them all and they also recommended the cocoa and of the cinnamon flavors. I went with the espresso flavor since my parents would like the coffee taste to it. They also had a bunch of you have different packaging for the cookies. You can buy an individual cookie or if you got a pack up a couple of them. I went with the sealed packs which can last up to three weeks because they are heat sealed. The parking situation around the downtown the park area has been a little bit tough to find. They also have meters if you're spending more than two hours here. Definitely a fun cookie place to check out if you're ever in the Paso area read more

90 degree temperature outside, casually strolling downtown Paso Robles, walked into Brown Butter Cookie for the first time and were so impressed by the shortbread sample. The woman passing out the samples was offended/upset (either thought I was stupid and/or just giving her a hard time), I asked what percentage of cacao was in the samples. I HAD NO IDEA that the samples were shortbread - it was so hot out and we simply casually walked in and out of all the retail establishments which appeared to be aesthetically pleasant. After touring the store and seeing their attractive packaging, I asked how much some items were to my surprise finding that they were specializing in SHORTBREAD and not chocolate. I shared that and apologized immediately and then was intrigued as to what I should purchase as a closing gift for my soon to close seller's COE. Their shortbread is OUTSTANDING! We tasted the Ghirardelli enhanced chocolate sample (remember - I thought it was either chocolate or fudge until I actually tasted it), and then I purchased their large (own brand) large variety pack. Regan was excellent, as was Devon in the San Luis Obispo store. I called SLO store today to see how long they would remain fresh - she took ownership of the conversation as if this place was her own. read more

This place popped up when I googled places to go in Paso Robles. Seemed like a good cookie place. I, myself sure love cookies so I was excited to try. While my mom and my friend went to get a massage, I came here lol I m not sure why these cookies were $1.50 a piece (bite size cookies). It was made with just sugar, salt and butter. The texture was somewhat dry. Also, too sweet and somewhat too salty. I felt like I was biting into a block of sugar. The almond flavor did make it better compared to the original. Still, I don't think I will get it again. It was a mistake purchasing 2 bags.. I need to control myself lol read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Almond & original - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

Are we in Costco because what's up with the samples everywhere you turn?! Between the sugary sweet scent that wafted into my face upon stepping inside & those samples, my money was as good as spent. This was my first time at a Brown Butter Cookie store; I appreciated the warm welcome & run-down of their products. Their new "Made with Ghirardelli" shortbread cookies were a real treat, especially the White Chip, but ultimately I went home with a bag each of the Original and the Cocoa Brown Butter Sea Salt Cookies. Small in size but the buttery, melty mouthfeel makes one piece seem like enough. It's almost too much of a good thing but I never did like anything too demure. read more

These are the reason to stop for a treat downtown. An original texture and buttery and sweet. I am a local and shop once a week! Thye give samples and do seasonal offerings. This place is quaint easy grab and go packs nicely wrapped for a gift. A must stop downtown Paso Robles. quick friendly check outs. read more

Loved the location and the service. The original brown butter cookies are a sweet deliciousness. Since you open the front door the smell activates your senses. read more

See all

I initially was drawn to Brown Butter Cookie while looking for gift ideas in downtown Paso Robles and spotted the cookie gift boxes through the shop window. The store associates were very friendly and welcoming, and they offered me a sample of their brown butter cookies. The cookies were sweet and rich with a sandy, melt-in-your-mouth texture. Most of the cookies they sell are small, about the diameter of a golf ball, but they are dense and satisfying. Some of the gift packages included larger, flatter cookies as well. While I had hoped that the cookies would have tasted more "fresh-out-of-the-oven," I understand it might not be logistically possible to package up freshly-baked cookies (given the high butter content). As a plus, I could tell that these cookies were made from high-quality ingredients. On the day of my visit, the available flavors were honey, pecan, chocolate, and, the original, brown butter. I ended up purchasing a bag of the pecan cookies as a gift and the original cookies for myself - can't wait to enjoy them with coffee or tea! read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Brown Butter Sea Salt Cookies - 3 Pack - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

Randomly stumbled upon this adorable cookie shop while visiting Paso Robles. I love brown butter anything so I definitely had to stop in due to the namesake. They had samples of the brown butter crumbly shortcake cookies which were good but I am not into shortcake cookies I like regular chewy ones. They didn't have the regular cookies in brown butter but they did have the smaller chewy ones so I bought that, 6 for $10. The bigger regular cookies didn't have brown butter flavor. Overall they felt pricy for cookies but I'll support a small business. Staff was nice! read more

You can't miss this cookie store as you're walking around downtown Paso Robles. The inside as large and spacious. The friendly staff will offer samples and describe their different flavors. The original brown butter cookie is a smaller thick cookie that is very dense and very sweet. It crumbles easily yet melts in your mouth. This is a nice place to stop for gifts to bring home to anyone who has a sweet tooth. Their cookies are very sweet. They also have more traditional flatter cookies too. Their cookies are all in cute packaging for gifting. There is street parking, however you may need to circle around a bit to find a spot or park a few blocks away. read more

See all

First impressions are everything! And the service was not it! The cashier was unwelcoming and a little tense. I felt rushed to choose so I just grabbed whatever sounded good, I imagine everything would be good. They are priced a little high but it was worth it because they were very delicious. We got the almond, original and honey. And the honey were my absolute favorite! I would definitely come back just because when it comes to cookies, I don't need service anyway. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

These cookies are consistently awesome. They're unique and delicious. Our go to ones are the almond and original. Though the hubs of the group really likes the honey cookies. If you're in the area, definitely stop in and try their free samples. The service was fine, nothing of note. read more

The cookies at Brown Butter Cookie are very decadent, rich and delicious. I try to stop by every time I'm in Paso Robles. The original brown butter cookie is a favorite but they used to have a lot of other cool flavors like espresso, almond and pecan that I miss. I was bummed to see they no longer have those. There was a new cocoa mint flavor but it didn't sound as appealing as the older flavors. The cookies are very pricey at $12 for a half dozen, the prices seem to have increased recently also. The shop is located right next to the downtown park near a lot of restaurants and boutiques. Store is a nice size with open layout. Staff are friendly and they usually offer samples. read more

Bite sized cookie shop in wine tasting district of Paso Robles. They give out free cookies sometime but not gluten free ones. I got a bag of coconut gluten free and it was the only flavor. They tasted yummy but not as good as the ones I got at another bakery earlier. Still a good idea to grab a bag or two if you are a cookie lover or want something to snack on for wine tasting. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Gluten free - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

I think this cookie place can be summed up with one emoji - the emoji with its eyes half-closed and with drool pouring out of its mouth. These cookies use a combination of butter, sugar, and salt to make a treat that causes a Pavlovian response when you see the cookies- and then euphoria when you bite down and they hit your taste buds and the cookies melt in your mouth. The cookies are small, but pack a mighty, mouthwatering punch. I've tried the cinnamon, espresso, and original cookie. I've also tried a sample of a honey, wafer-like cookie that was super tasty. All flavors tasted delicious, but my favorite is the original. However, I'm sure you'll find something you like in this perfectly balanced, savory treat that are almost guaranteed to cause you to drool just a tiny bit due to their scrumptiousness. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - The entrance - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

LOVE this place! They always have samples and this is probably the best shortbread I've ever had. Always love their seasonal cookies, too. Great service and nice little place by the park. read more

Visited 21 July 2022 Yummy!! The hours of operation conflict with our work schedule so every time my friends and I were downtown and tried to go, they either didn't open yet because it was too early in the morning, or they were closed because it was too late in the evening.  Luckily, we passed by on our way to dinner and was able to catch the store open. It was just before closing so we barely made it again. We were greeted as soon as we walked in and offered samples. Yes, please. I first tried the espresso. Wow! That was amazing. The espresso flavour is really prominent. I also tried the pecan and the original. The texture was crumbly & soft and reminded me of shortbread cookies. Visually, they look like sugar cookies. The lady offering the samples was pleasant, bubbly, and inviting. She seemed genuinely happy to offer us samples. The cashier on the other hand seemed stern and disgruntled. I felt compelled to purchase cookies because of her seemingly piercing, disapproving stares of us sampling multiple flavours. Of course, when it came time to make a decision on which flavour to buy, I was indecisive. So, what do I do? ...I'm glad you asked!! :) I bought 3 small bags, 1 cinnamon, 1 espresso, and 1 pecan. Each bag had 3 cookies and cost $4 each. My friends all got a bag of the 6x cookies, which cost $8. The cookies are a bit pricy but, surprisingly, no added tax. Hopefully I can catch them before I leave so i can grab some cookies to take home. read more

See all

What an amazing find. We went to Paso Robles for a wedding and walked around the downtown area to explore. My friend bought some cookies back to our Airbnb and we were all addicted. In particular, we LOVE the brown butter sea salt cookie with honey, it's thin and comes in 3 pack or 6 pack. After the wedding we went back to the shop before heading back to nor cal. I bought two 6 packs of the honey cookies. The service was so kind, they offered free samples while we were there and were so patient with our large group. The store was clean and well organized. I would highly recommend anyone in the area to swing by and get some delicious cookies!!! read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Brown butter sea salt honey cookies. Already ate two before I remembered to take a pic! - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

Specifically, they specialize in Brown Butter Sea Salt Cookies. Super dense, shortbread cookies and they have a vegan option. Buy three of the bags of six and they'll throw in another bag of six for free. If you like salted caramel or salted chocolate chip cookies, this is the kind of sweet you'd probably like. Good for if you really like that satisfying, sandy texture that comes with the cookie being dense enough that it manages to be so without being hard-crumbly. Just...soft-crumbly, if that makes sense? I was reminded of sandies/Mexican wedding cookies and French Sablé cookies. The Brown Butter Cookie Company actually has three locations with this one being their second location and 1st boutique retail shop. So if you can't make it to Paso Robles, you can also try these cookies in San Luis Obispo and Cayucos. If you can't make it, they also sell their products online for delivery. With COVID restrictions, the Paso Robles location has the register and display at the door of their store. No seating past what you'd find publicly. There was plenty of street parking in the area, including diagonal parking ringing the entire green. Overall, my family has repeatedly remarked about coming back here specifically if we're in the area again. We hadn't actually even tried the sample. Just bought what we thought would be a kind of souvenir snack since we were already walking around Downtown City Park and actually on our way out of town. Then we tried them on the drive home and instantly regretted not buying more, even if they are on the pricey side. read more

See all

I bought 3 batches of cookies for a total of about 3-3.5 lbs. of Brown Butter cookies which included 2 dozen originals, 1 dozen Ghirardelli shortcakes and "1/2 off" 6 chocolate chip cookies. I was stupid enough once I heard the total price to continue with the sale instead of cancelling and walking out. What a dummy. The grand total was $80.00!!! Holy idiot mistake!!! That means Brown Butter cookies are about $23.00-$25.00 per pound!!! Don't get me wrong. I love Brown Butter cookies, but they're not that good. I'll likely never buy them again unless I'd rather have cookies than filet mignon, but it's doubtful. I included a photo of the cookies I bought and a photo of filet mignon from Costco. I won't make that mistake again. Wealthy people, enjoy your Filet Mignon of cookies. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Filet Mignon at Costco for $19.99/lb. - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

We found this delightful cookie shop while walking around downtown Paso Robles in the rain on our recent visit. It's a cute boutique store focused on their variety of cookies. The shop was so cute and well designed that it would fit into Main Street U.S.A. in the happiest place on Earth. We browsed and ended up buying just the brown butter cookie and chocolate brown butter cookie. I wanted the cinnamon cookies but didn't get approval. They have their cute little sugar cookies and bigger ones. You really can't go wrong here. Service was friendly and helpful. We'll definitely return to buy more cookies but we may have to order online before then. read more

Wonderful cookies. We stop every time we go to Paso. They have a great selection but the brown butter, snickerdoodle, lemon, and chocolate Chunk are our favorites. The service is amazing as well. You won't leave disappointed! read more

The original cookies are perfect salty, buttery & sweet -- simply fun to bite into. They are bite-size so it's easy to eat a package. Make sure you grab more than a bag. My favorite are the original, pecan and cinnamon. They add every so often but you won't be disappointed. They will let you sample! The pack the cookies in cute clear bags & ribbon tied. It's ready to give away as cute gifts. The store is clean, bright & service very efficient. Lines go fast. read more

See all

I entered into this establishment because a friend recommended it. They asked if I wanted a sample. Ah, yes please! Then, I fell in love with what I put into my mouth ~ pecan cookie! I bought the tower special for $20, as they said it's all their most popular cookies in it. I can't wait! read more