Thought the food was good and we enjoyed our meal. The margaritas were very sweet... too sweet really. The place was not busy at all, only a few tables, yet we seemed to have a hard time getting their attention a few times for another round of drinks, etc. The place needs a bit more of a decorator's touch. We sat at what should have been the best table yet two of us stared into a half way upstairs office space as the door kept being left open. Weird setup. The location is also odd, nothing seemingly right nearby. I feel bad for them as not sure they are getting any foot traffic. Probably won't go back but we wish them well. read more

WOWOW... when passing by Bartolo's it seems like a small neighborhood restaurant. But when you explore the menu, the dishes here are of high caliber and excellent flavor! They describe themself as Contemporary Mexican Cuisine. and the chefs know what they're doing. The staff is super hospitable and are so friendly, checking in on us and asking for our feedback for certain new menu items. The menu is on the pricier side, but it's most definitely matches the value! The portions are also large. Bartolo is one of the owners and crafted the cocktail menu, and makes the drinks himself. Great for HH. The mecco calamari was a great appetizer; highly recommend. The highlight of the meal.... the desserts. I was blown away by the two desserts we ordered: the tres leches mezcal (SO YUM) and the the nieve frita. The nieve frita comes with a side of cut fruits of the day BUT not just any ordinary cut fruits - the presentation has them resemble a Mexican food. In our case, it was "pico de gallo" berries. Using apples, strawberries, and mint, it looked exactly like pico de gallo on the plate, while still being a great complement to the ice cream cased in a fried shell! read more

See all

The ULTIMATE hidden gem of Hell's Kitchen! Bartolo gave us a warm welcome into his restaurant. The service was stellar; Bartolo's wait staff is highly attentive. The ambience is beautiful and memorable perfect for a date night or even a private event. For dinner we ordered: Atún Tostaditas Camarones y Uchepo Carne en Tamarindo The amuse bouche of the evening were their fried sweet corn bread (I'm still dreaming about this bread!) with a black bean purée. Chefs Jorge Pareja and Juan Escobedo created a lovely collection of dishes. I look forward to my next visit. Muchas gracias, Bartolo!!! read more

See all

What an amazing find! My friend and I literally Googled places nearby and were so lucky to discover Bortola's Restaurant. From the moment we walked in, we loved the beautiful, warm, and cozy ambiance -- such a pleasant and inviting atmosphere that makes you want to stay longer. Our waiter Jose was attentive, friendly, and made us feel truly welcome. The food was soooo good -- fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Huge shoutout to Gigi at the bar -- the drinks were absolutely amazing! He treated us incredibly well, even surprised us with some shots on the house, and before we left he made us super, super margaritas that were unforgettable. You can really feel that this is an amazing family business. The boss personally came over to our table to make sure everything was okay, which made the experience even more special. My friend is already planning to celebrate her birthday here, and we will definitely be back. Highly recommend Bortola's to anyone looking for great food, outstanding drinks, and genuine hospitality! read more

See all

We had dinner tonight at Bartolo's, a new contemporary Mexican restaurant on 11th Avenue and 51st Street, and it absolutely impressed. This is elevated cuisine with the depth and creativity you'd expect in Mexico City...bold sauces, refined combinations, and remarkable attention to flavor. We kicked things off with two margaritas...one classic, one spicy cucumber...both enhanced by an unusual salt rim that made them stand out from the standard. A complimentary cornbread with bean dip, pico de gallo, and crema arrived next... rich, savory, and far beyond the typical tortilla chips starter. Our filet mignon sopes were melt-in-your-mouth tender, paired with a silky poblano-avocado mousse. The ancho-crusted tuna came perfectly seared, with a tender yuca cake that added texture and balance. The shrimp with sweet corn tamale was another hit...layered, slightly sweet, and full of personality. To finish, we enjoyed a superb tequila, with the owners Artemio and Bartolo sharing the story of its unique distillation process. Dessert was a lush Tres Leches Mezcal, a perfect finale to a beautifully executed meal. Service from Uriel was spot on and very attentive. Between the welcoming owners, great service, inventive flavors, and proximity to the theater district and many hotels, Bartolo's is a neighborhood gem that feels destined to become a destination. We can't wait to return and explore more of the menu...and check out more of those tequila stories. read more

This is a new spot in Hell's Kitchen. Food was delicious and flavorful, the presentation was beautiful, and we experienced the most amazing hospitality. Our group ordered the guacamole, branzino, camarones y uchepo, quesadilla de pollo, and the mixiote de borrego (lamb shank). The tamarind margarita was wonderful. The ingredients were fresh and high quality. We had a chance to meet the owners and the chef and they were so welcoming. This spot won't be a secret for long. read more

Bartolo's - Camarones - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

I was in the mood for Mexican food & was hesitant on trying this place because I've tried a lot of Mexican places around the Hell's Kitchen area & they were all mid or bad. Let me tell you this place didn't disappoint at all! I'm not going to lie, this is probably hands down one of the top 3 best customer service experiences I've ever had in my entire life. Everyone there was so nice they made me feel like family at home. Place is not huge but is very cute & even though is not big is really spacious. Bartolo himself was there & let me say he's a very nice humble caballero. We tried for starters the Empanadas de puerco & Gorditas de platano. Presentation wise beautiful! The empanadas I really enjoyed they were crispy fresh & hot the meat was seasoned the pico de gallo was nice & tasty maybe one of the best pico de gallo I had in my life. The gorditas aren't your traditional meat Gorditas this one had goat cheese it was good I'm not going to knock it. It was different. Never had goat cheese but I'm not mad at it. I will definitely get it again my gf loved it! They were also nice to give us a complimentary Sweet corn bread with refried beans and let me tell you that's when I knew they know what they doing back there. I have never had something like this is a different type of experience the corn bread was nice crispy but not to crispy & fluffy on the inside with that nice slightly salty refried beans you get that perfect sweet & salty combo! I will most definitely get that again! Now for drinks my gf had a watermelon margarita & I had a passion fruit mojito. The margarita was sweet but not to sweet refreshing but not to strong was really good I will definitely recommend. Now the entree we had the Branzino Al pastor that was recommended by our waiter I don't remember our waiter's name but he was the best!! Shout out to you! The filet was fresh, light you get that nice clean fish taste but not to fishy with that to die for coconut pineapple rice OH MY GOD! Let me just say that rice is AMAZING. I've never had rice like that but it was so goood everything blended just perfect. I must say this place is not your typical Mexican restaurant. They really stand out when it comes to Mexican food because there menu is different, The way they cook is different, There customer service is different! They just different all around. My personal opinion every Mexican place around Hell's Kitchen should look at each other & buckle up there's a new sheriff in town. Is a new place yes but I will definitely recommend to anyone. If your around the area & want a real Mexican experience nice drinks & good food. This is a must, They show other restaurants why there's LEVELS TO THIS. For dessert we had the pumpkin bread pudding with house made cinnamon ice cream. That was really good I'm not a sweet tooth guy but let me tell you the pudding was nice soft perfect texture the ice cream creamy & packed a big punch with that cinnamon flavor. They were also nice to give us a complementary house made watermelon sorbet & that was just refreshing so goood I was tempted to asked them to sell me a pint of it to take home lol. When we were about to leave Bartolo himself gave us 2 shots on the house & let me tell you that shot was so strong. That I if I was stranded in Alaska butt naked in a -30 degrees weather. I'll survive because that shot would keep me warm. Place was amazing & I will definitely be back. Empanadas 4/5 Gorditas 4/5 Corn bread w Refried beans 10000/5 Branzino Al Pastor 4.5/5 Pumpkin pudding 5/5 Watermelon Sorbet 5/5 Customer service 100000000000000/5 read more

See all

This was an incredible meal!! Get the cornbread, it's excellent! I had a top shelf skinny margarita (ok, maybe 2), well balanced, salt not too heavy, wonderful! Then the Branzino al Pastor. Wonderful pineapple rice, sweet potatoes, poblano sauce! And the fish was perfect! A little charred, not overdone. This place is a little out of the way, but the experience was amazing! read more

See all

Of course, forgot to take pictures of the food! But my husband and I have been here twice, once for drinks and once for food. Both times have been wonderful! They have great margaritas. We had food last night and enjoyed everything. We got the epananditas, filet mignon sopes, and the pollo y mole. Everything was really good! We especially enjoyed the mole chicken, their mole sauce was delicious. The service can't be beat! Both times we have been here, we have been treated so well. It's overall a lovely place that I recommend! read more

Food and drinks were great! Bartolo and Artemo were both lovely and we had a great time and great service! read more

Bartolo's - Strawberry mojito - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

From the moment you step into this vibrant and welcoming space, you know you're in for something special. This isn't just a Mexican restaurant--it's a celebration of flavour, tradition, and warmth that makes every visit unforgettable. The menu is a masterpiece. Every dish is crafted with care and authenticity. The guacamole is made fresh to order, and the chips are crisp, warm, and lightly salted--simple, but done exactly right. The cocktails deserve a review of their own. Their margaritas are next-level--whether you go classic, smoky with mezcal, or try one of their seasonal twists, they're balanced, bold, and dangerously good. The staff are knowledgeable, passionate, and genuinely want you to have a great experience. Ask them for recommendations--you won't regret it. Whether you're on a date, out with friends, or just craving incredible Mexican food, this spot nails it. A must-visit in NYC--and one you'll come back to again and again. read more

See all

Great service, amazing food and an awesome experience overall! I'll definitely be back! read more

See all

The place is amazing with its quality food and service. Our waiter was great and had good recommendations of food choices. read more

Omg!! Every taste of the dishes that had (the a sweet corn bread, las empanaditas de puerco y quesadilla de pollo) was like a new explosion in my mouth! I know tomorrow I will want to eat some more, but my stomach cannot savor any leftovers because everything was sooo good I couldnt stop eating! You definitely have to come here with an open mind. This is not traditional Mexican-American cuisine. IT IS 100% BETTER! You feel like you are in someone's home! Every bite is like a new burst of flavor! So glad I came here with my partner! I ill definitely come again and with friends! The staff and the owner are also so welcoming from the time you walk in the door to the time you leave! I feel like I have found a new favorite restaurant! read more

Went here on a whim. One of the owners explained the Central Mexican influence on the cuisine...so naturally we had to try. Wow! We shared the Mexico Calamari appetizer. Easily the most unique and delicious calamari I've ever had. The entrees were delicious, the service was superb. Highly recommend. read more

Went for Apps and Drinks! It was all great. And very friendly environment! Try it! It's a breath of fresh air on 11 th Ave!

Welcome to the neighborhood guys! We stopped by the other day to check it out, had some mojitos and guacamole, and we will definitely be back. Very clear that Bartolo's is going the extra mile. Everything was delicious, and the staff is super friendly. read more

Was on a work trip and my hotel was in the area, so I stopped here for dinner, and am I glad I did. The surrounding area itself doesn't look great (its right next to a gas station), but don't let that fool you. The interior is nice and cozy and the staff is very attentive. The food itself was nothing short of spectacular. Very flavorful and balanced. Drinks were great as well. I recommend the tamarind margarita rimmed with their black salt. If I am back in this area in the future, I will definitely be coming back to try the other items on the menu. read more

A fresh new spot for Mexican food. The service was very attentive and the manager stopped by to check on us. I had the artichoke quesadilla and my partner had the shrimp. Both were delicious. The shrimp came with an amazing smoky sauce. read more

The owner clearly cares a lot about this place and puts in the work! The vibe is great and the drinks are delicious. Will be back!

My partner and I came in for drinks and couldn't help but stay for the food. The filet mignon sopes are delicious! We'll definitely be returning soon. The entire staff were friendly and made this a wonderful experience overall read more

My partner and I heard lots of great things about this place-and I must say I agree. Having only been open for a week, these folks are killing it. We had the calamari as an app and then had chicken and steak dishes for our entrees. The service and vibe was really nice and welcoming. I've never had authentic Mexican food like this. We will definitely be back! Oh! Also would highly recommend the watermelon margarita and sangria. read more

Wow! I had heard of Bartolo's on W42St and Next Door and had been wanting to try it for several weeks. We went this evening for drinks and appetizers and it was SOOO good. The service was exemplary from start to finish. Granted, we were early birds and had the place to ourselves but still, the staff and owners were incredibly welcoming. This is 11th Ave folks, and they know what they need to do to keep diners coming and they did it well.. The complementary refried beans with housemade cornbread was a nice nosh to have while we looked at the menu. Simply but so yummy. My husband had the Filet Mignon Mini Sopes and he said the meat was perfection. I had the Calamari in broth with sourdough toast and it was so satisfying. The broth was a little tomato-y with a kick - super delicious. Then we shared the Artichoke Quesadilla as a third appetizer, which was interesting, topped with guacamole and pico. The flavor of the artichokes really shone in the filling. Tres Leches cake for dessert topped it off but unlike any other Tres Leches cake we ever had - this one was laced with mezcal and served with marinated cherries on the side with a drizzle of caramel sauce. Super yummy and the perfect ending to a light early dinner. We drank wine so can't comment on the cocktails. All in all, a lovely early meal with superb service all around. If Carlos is your server, be prepared to be well-cared for! We'll be back! read more