Only problem I have with Anthony's is lack of consistency. Normally they bake in the ingredients with the cheese on top (like pictured) but sometimes you get the classic toppings on top. Same thing with just cheese pizza some times it's great but others time it's like did they even put sauce on this thing before they baked it. If they could figure out the consistency issue between cooks it would be better. Other than the sauce with the cheese pizza issue they are a decent pie. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pepperoni and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Damn white boy wrote in his own hefty tip on top of the outrageous $30+ 1L pizza that I had to wait and pick up The pizza was good, but damn read more

ordered XL Supreme for near $50 after tax and tip. Pizza was not cooked, and 2 mm dough was not substantial enough to support the toppings. we tried to eat with plastic wear provide, but pizza was over half un-cooked dough. we only had 45 minutes for dinner and unfortunately were unable to eat at restaurant due to poor production and quality standard. Better luck next time! read more

Esperanza always provides great service and the food is amazing! I come in at least once a week and it always has good music but it's not very crowded! Definitely recommend! read more

Delicious pizza I love it! There's something about a big greasy slice of pizza that never fails to be awesome. Good ranch too read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Dined in last week. The girl Esperanza , is always working so hard, her pizza is absolutely amazing- she provides excellent customer service . Can't wait to go back! read more

We ordered two slices to go. They were giant and my boys said they were delicious. Prices were reasonable, I felt it was a good value. The man behind the counter was very nice. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - A slice of cheese - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Best pizza in denver. It's been hard finding great pizza so we have been doing without. Blue pan is good but far away and not traditional. Anthony's is so good. We get take out and hope the deliciousness continues . read more

Honestly not impressed at all and the customer service was atrocious. We had never been in before so we didn't know what to expect. There are two sides of the restaurant you can sit at so we didn't know if we order or sit first. A big guy with long curly hair just sat there behind the counter not saying anything. When we asked what to do he said "whatever you want. Order with me or use the screen." So we self ordered. The food itself didn't take too long to come out. The crispy chicken ordered on the Alfredo came out grilled and was a bit chewy, but the noodles and sauce were decent. The sausage hero was good as was the chicken Parmesan. However, when asking for a box, the same man sat behind the counter on his phone. I asked for two take home containers and he handed me two pizza boxes. We didn't order pizza. I said I'm sorry but we have pasta. He externally sighed before handing me the to go containers. The containers had ants crawling on them. Even asking where to put the dirty dishes, he didn't say a word just looked at the bin where they go that was only labeled "place trays here". Overall food is average, but extremely poor customer service. *Also note the side to sit on the left is so humid and very warm.* read more

This is a yummy pizza place. I usually get it delivered. I was getting it a couple times a month. The one time I went in to pick It up, I had a terrible experience. The girl helping was awful. Had no idea what she was doing. She couldn't care less. Got my order completely wrong. I waited so long I just had to deal with it. I haven't had it since then. read more

Ordered a pizza online, wrong one was delivered. They offered to correct it but we had to come pick it up. I arrive to pick up, and they never made it. Sucky pizza, sucky service. Go just about anywhere else. read more

Would've much rather went to Snarf's across the street for a meatball sub. So expensive at Anthony's for how small it is. 1/2 a foot is considered a "sub" sandwich. The meatballs were fine but Snarf's wouldn't have left me hungry after eating...and condiments wouldn't cost extra. read more

Good GF options! Adding toppings can be kind of pricy but the pizza always turns out good! Their orders tend to be ready before they predict which is not a bad thing in my opinion. Reliably good pies read more

Soft, doughy and gross. Too bad. Been eating Anthony's for years and it is typically at least decent. This was not. Ugh... read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Terribly undercooked. Not NY pizza. Soft, doughy and gross. Bummer. - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Staff was unkempt and grumpy, and told me if I had arrived 3 minutes later than I did, they were going to eat my pizza for me, then made me move out of the way to mop under my feet. Which is honestly ideal for me I guess. Spectacular pie, like above and beyond good and cooked to extra crispy as I asked for over the phone. Immediately slammed 2 slices in the car before I even started my engine. Caesar salad was on point too, but had a ton of shredded mozzarella instead of Parmesan which is whatever, I had parm at home and just ate the other cheese. Pretty much nailed it, definitely a pizza place read more

Every time I've ever had Anthony's from this location I've got severe food poisoning. It's not good and definitely a health hazard. Do not order from here or you will regret it for the next week read more

This place needs to just give up. Truly horrible pizza EVERY TIME that you get the privilege of waiting an hour for, no matter how busy they are. Save your money and your tastebuds and go literally anywhere else. read more

Best New York style pizza in Denver! We love the meatball topping. It's a Friday night favorite!

Welp... I just have to say how much I love little ole Anthony's Pizza. THIS LOCATION SPECIFICALLY. They are fast, friendly and deliver some great food. (You can pick up too). No they do not ONLY offer pizza, though that is what makes them stand out. They have a variety of salads, pastas and apps. Their garlic bread is yummy and they give you a whole little loaf with dipping sauce. Nom. Their pastas are good and their salads are always full of fresh veggies and arent those soggy salads packed three days before sitting on the shelf. I LOVE their wings. If you order them to-go and extra crispy, they come out perfect and they put the sauce on the side so they don't get soggy by the time you get home! Hello! Geniuses! The pizza is what really rocks. It is thin like New York pizza and their sauce is not to sweet and tastes really fresh. I just go for the typical cheese pizza. They come in medium and HUGE so find someone to share with. :) I have been going to this location for years and recently visited after a hiatus. There is something to be said for the quality of food and here the staff. These guys are always friendly and working hard. They really rock at customer service and I hope they know how valuable that is to their customers. Especially when it can be night and day from their other locations. Thanks for amazing service for so many years Anthony's on Evans! read more

Anthony's Pizza is consistently the best pizza in Denver. Pizza is always ready on time for pick up.

Yikes!!! This use to be such a great place. Ordered a simple pie last night with sausage and mushroom. It was hot and looked great when it arrived, but... not lying here: NO FLAVOR. Now I'm not saying it was a little bland... Being totally serious here: I actually had a momentary "Covid Panic". I could neither smell nor taste it at all. Then I popped open my soda and could smell the coke immediately without putting up to my nose, so... not Covid. But seriously this was not simply the least tasteful pizza I'd ever had... it was the least flavorful food I've ever had! What gives? Use to love this place but something's gone horribly wrong! Reheated a slice today with a ton of parmesan I put on it... I could taste the parm only... Will have toss the rest out. Lesson learned. read more

I ordered here for the first time 1/2/23 and it was so delicious! I got a gluten free pizza (amazing!!) and my partner got a small normal, gluten-filled pizza. Along with pizza, we each ordered a salad. Anthony's upgraded my small salad to a large, free of charge! We both loved our food, it was delivered in about an hour, and we will 100% be frequenting this location more often. Thanks Anthony's! read more

We LOVE Anthony's.... great NY style pizza, NYC decorations... It is a little pricey, but compared to some pizza places but... IT'S WORTH IT! read more

Always a solid slice or pie. They have the good Coke machines too where you can select your flavors. read more

Pretty good pizza. I stopped in for a quick bite for dinner with my 2 year old. We both got plain slices and they were fresh and tasty. It wasn't a slice that had be sitting around all day and recently reheated. Oh- and the slices were HUGE. One was plenty. That and a Shock Top beer and I was satisfied. They have two rooms for eating. One side a booth/table dining room, the other a couple pool tables and video games with some tables for eating. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Huge slices! - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Usually pretty good. Last time my order was wrong and veggies were thrown on after it was already cooked so they just fell off. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - two slices of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

This. Place. Is. Delicious!! Went here on my lunch break, and they had my food done so quickly, even though there was a bit of a line. The staff is super friendly, and did I mention the food is delicious?? They also have super cheap beer. I'll definitely be making this place a lunch break favorite. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Lunch break treats! - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Pretty authentic pizza, but not 100% NY. Of course, the slices are bigger, but they are easily foldable which is the key to a good slice. The cheese and sauce are layered thin which is correct, but the only elements missing were the orange grease and the oregano flecks on top of the slice. Yes, they have oregano shakers, but that isn't enough. It was still a very good slice. The chicken parmesan hero at $7.50 was also a pleasant choice - very solid cutlets with good sauce and cheese. Might have needed a few more minutes in the oven, but this was a decent version of the classic dish and my personal favorite. Staff was friendly too, but some workers looked like they just walked off the streets with their shorts. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Slice - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

We love Anthony's pizza. They always have fresh hot and great thin crust pizza. Service is always excellent too. Even good the next day to eat cold for breakfast! Our favorite is pepperoni with mushrooms. read more

Dropped by to grab a few slices of pizza to go. When I get home they had put one slice on a paper plate on top of two slices of cheese pizza. Well the results are obvious, half of the cheese stuck to the bottom of the plate. I called to let them know. The only thing they were willing to offer was new slices of pizza if I want to drive 18 minutes back to their restaurant. They won't even honor it tomorrow when I'll be up that way again. They also wanted pictures to prove it, here ya go. Terrible customer service! read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Ordered pizza and came two hours later. Was expensive and not worth the price I paid especially for the time it took to be delivered.

Omg this is the real deal. As a transplanted east coaster, I can say this is the best NY pizza in Denver!!

Delicious New York Style Pizza- Simply that. If pizza is your favorite food, like mine, then this is a restaurant worth checking out. I am a cheese lover so a hot large slice of cheese is all I need and this is the best spot in the neighborhood (DU/ Platte park) to get just that. Certainly, I have tried other toppings (always on a pizza with at least half just cheese) and those are tasty as well. read more

Anthony's sent us a seriously burned pizza. Spoke to the manager about the quality of the pie and he thought this was ok to send out. For the price of this pizza I expect more than burned pies. He gave us store credit which isn't acceptable either. A full refund would have been the right thing to do. This isn't the first time we've had poor quality from this place. Seriously disappointing. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - This burned pie is what the Anthony's manager thinks is acceptable. - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Great pizza, when you catch it right, but terrible service. Ordered online, went when website said. Waited 20 minutes to get a lukewarm partially baked pizza. No apologies or offer to make right. Always a crap shot at this location. read more

Anthony's pizza is a great pizzeria. Maybe even going as far as saying my favorite. The delectable taste and cool indoor atmosphere all makes it worth while but the service is what bumps this place down from 5 stars. My last couple visits there ended up a disaster. The pizza was cold, the wrong toppings were added, and it was very poorly cut. When I came back a week later I consulted them of their mistake and I expected an apology but received nothing but sass and harsh attitude. At the end of the talk he finally gave in and told us the pizza was free (which is what he should've done in the first place). When Anthony's pizza is made correctly and with care than its hard not to LOVE! Especially with the fresh ingredients, the large slices, and crispy crust Overall I recommend( most of the time). read more

The pizza was really underwhelming and lacked flavor. We asked for a small pizza and added chicken, artichokes, basil, and garlic. I love garlic, but they put way too much of it in the sauce. The chicken was both bland and dry. And the extra toppings mentioned that added like $10 were pretty light. It was pretty expensive and again not very good. We definitely wont be back. read more

I got a single slice. It was old clearly old by visual appearance (the tomato sauce was hard looking, the cheese looked dull.) I came because it had good reviews but maybe that's for the pies not the individual slices. I wouldn't recommend. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

The secret to great pizza is in the crust. The rumor in New York is that their crust (And bagels) are so good because NY City water is so good. Well we have some pretty fantastic city in water in Denver too (It comes from a little thing called GOD and the ROCKY MOUNTAINS New Yorkers, how do you like THEM Apples?) and that contributes to some fantastic crust at Anthony's Pizza and Pasta. I've never had the pasta here. Could it be good? Maybe, but the kitchen here is pretty much a pizza oven and some dudes in t-shirts so I'm going to recommend sticking to the pizza. It's fantastic NY style pizza, which huge slices which demand to be folded and inhaled. The atmosphere is VERY collegiate, half the place is booths, the other half is pool tables and pinball machines. The two sides are separated by the kitchen and walls, so you don't have to be annoyed by the sound of frat guys playing pool. I really prefer to go in and order it by the slice, but their prices on entire pizzas are reasonable. I've never had a bad experience with the service and I think Benjamin needs a big hug. read more

Alright, I'm from New England originally and there are a few things you absolutely can not get in Denver 1) the ocean-obvious but still true 2) A Philly Cheesesteak-yes there are places that pretend to sell them here but, alas, they only pretend 3) A decent sub-again, they are sold here but I have no faith in anyone here that makes a sub 4) New York style pizza-Yep, it's true, all the Italian food and pizza in CO pretty much sucks and, please don't even try to sell me on Maggianos. Ug. that's just a sure sign that you have never lived anywhere with actual Italians. Anythony's: congrats! You win the prize for having authentic pizza that is delicious and in true New York fashion. Also, I had your chicken parm sub and HELLO-it was the real deal!!!! I'm sooooo proud. Crusty, chewy roll with lot's of sauce and cheese. You guys nailed it! read more