My brother and I came here for dinner on a Saturday, we made a reservation for 5:30pm (during Winter Restaurant Week). We were celebrating his college acceptances. In the reservation note online I asked for a corner table so that we were not in the dining room and they delivered! It was a 3 course dinner for $35 They took our coats and treated us professionally (even though we looked young-highschooler and grad student). For the appetizer, we got the snake river farms wagyu beef carpaccio and the crab and shrimp poppers. They were alright. For Entree, we got a 8 oz filet mignon which came with mashed potatoes (it was delicious but the temperature was a bit off...we ordered a medium and it seemed medium rare) and the 10 oz prime rib which was alright. For Dessert, we got the cheesecake and the bourbon bread putting. The cheesecake was so savory and sweet. The bread pudding was also pretty good--even though I am not a big bread pudding fan). The service was fantastic! The red headed hostess was very sensible and was AMAZING. Our waiter was pretty good too. The water was always filled and even the chef came to ask us how our food was. read more

See all

Dirty. Food was awful. Have 3 cheeses and one was sold out. The stems I ordered was like a brick. Do not go.

Honestly American prime should be called American subprime. I've been here on a few occasions and you come in hoping for a bull market but you end up with a bear. I was underwhelmed when they first opened. I tried their restaurant week a few years back. Even though they have the smallest meat aging space (our front to show the customers). There's like one piece of meat in it. I recently did not see many "aged" items on the menu either. So I was forced back due to an event. The service was strange, at best. First, they had a heavy handed pour and were pushing drinks. They used this weird old iPad thing where the cover didn't match the version of the iPad they were using. Then, it lead you to think you needed to order on the iPad but nope, you tell the wait staff. So why even use this kludghy iPad?!?!? Then my friend asked if what she ordered was dairy free (to confirm). The response she got was "sure... whatever." My prime rib looked like it had been dancing or sloshed around the plate the entire night before it got to me and it was lukewarm at best. Then there was the food... "chef mike" (the microwave) seemed like he was on duty. Of the people who ordered the prime rib. It all came out well done except one. One was still frozen in the center. I ordered medium rare and it was a weird dark gray color. Not from cooking. But from steaming under the warming tray it was so evident they couldn't handle the 40 people in the room. The prime rib was exceedingly salty. Then there was the "au jus". I said no to the au jus and the staff just poured it over my dish... but it was a food thing... it washed away some of the salt. Again, American prime for the cost is not worth the investment of your time or money. Go elsewhere. read more

See all

I had the cheese steak appetizers which were very salty. I had the Blue Cheese Wedge salad. My food was mediocre at best. The salad was pretty uncreative, light on the bacon and blue cheese. My gluten-free friend had a difficult time even choosing much on the menu. We found that all the marked gluten-free dishes were fried in the same fryer as the gluten items, she would have been in bad shape if she had followed the menu. Luckily, our waiter was extremely vigilant and kept checking with the kitchen to see what she could have. The only stand out was the chocolate flourless cake, which was superb! As for ambiance, when we arrived one other couple was there, and when they left we were the only ones in the whole restaurant. It was very strange indeed. I won't be back and certainly can't recommend the restaurant to anyone. read more

Nothing special. Was pretty dead on a Friday afternoon and the ambiance just felt... depressing. Cocktails were way too sweet and steaks were decent, but nothing to rave about. If you must go to a steakhouse, just go to Capital Grille and call it a day. read more

Loved this place! My friends and I came here for dinner a few days ago, on a Tuesday evening. There are parking spaces in the back parking lot; also, they do offer free valet parking (tip: remember to have some cash to tip them--I didn't, so I parked in the back). There weren't many people eating inside, but we had reservations so we were seated right away. As you enter, the bar area is on your right--it has a sports bar feel to it, with some seating outdoor as well. To your left is the more sit-down restaurant feel--seemed more classy. Our server, Doris, was amazing--super friendly and attentive to our needs. She told us that the restaurant is fairly new--opened about two and a half months ago. The food was amazing. For appetizers, we got the Maryland lump crab and shrimp poppers--pretty yummy! I ordered the 12 oz. house-smoked prime rib--delicious--it was cooked perfectly. I tried my friend's jumbo lump crab cakes, and they were pretty good--loaded with crab meat and barely breaded. I loved the side dishes--we ordered the kimchi fried rice (tip: add bacon, it's amazing as an addition), braised Brussel spouts, and the mashed potatoes (it comes with roasted bone marrow butter!!). For drinks, I ordered a mojitos, which was made perfectly. We ordered some rounds of shots--they came with a good amount of alcohol, well worth the price (about $10-12ish per drink). Had such a great dinner here, I will definitely be back! read more

See all

We came for restaurant week to try out this spot for the first time and had a lovely dinner Al fresco. The truffle Arancini were yummy and we enjoyed our scallops. The staff was also very friendly, which made for a very nice meal. read more

American Prime - Deconstructed Prime Potatoes - American Near Me - McLean, Virginia

See all

Great prime rib; minimal wait; sides were good. Overall good place. Pricey but expected in the McLean area. More formal, dining. Service was good; server checked on us a few times. Drinks were good; had a few of their specialty cocktails. read more

Decided to take our mom and my sister out for Mother's Day. This restaurant is really cute and cheek. We were greeted and seated. The server was nice and provided great service. We ordered appetizers and drinks. The food was delicious and we also ordered entrées. We ended ordering key lime pie and bourbon pound cake and it was delicious. Everything was tasty. I would say they have one of the best mash potatoes I ever had. read more

See all

We picked up their premade Thanksgiving dinner this year. The owner was very friendly and welcoming and the food was delicious- smoked turkey, cranberries, string beans, stuffing and mashed potatoes. We'll definitely be back next year! read more

When on its game, American Prime is a fantastic restaurant. However it's far too inconsistent to be given 5 or even 4 stars. This is a great spot for business lunches or happy hours - I haven't tried (or even thought about it) for a family night or date night because I just associate it with work. Like other Tyson's Corner steakhouses it's in the ground floor of an office building - but this building is awkwardly located at the corner of Spring Hill and Tyco Rd which isn't easy to get to. The interior has a rustic farmhouse feel to it, and the dining room is small (maybe 15-20 tables tops) which creates an intimate environment. Service is usually on point, and prices are comparable to other Prime steakhouses. Where American Prime differentiates itself is via its unusual cuts of meat and its unique sides. Also it's wine list (while just a run of the mill selection) is excellently priced. The down side to the restaurant is that the steaks are hit or miss. Usually cooked appropriately, but often over or under seasoned - and sometimes the flavor is frankly "off" - meaning quite simply that the meat tastes like it was left on the counter over night. Overall I like happy hour and occasional work meals at American Prime, and truly enjoy the food when they're on their game, but unfortunately about a quarter of the time they're off. read more

Amazing food and service! Went for an anniversary dinner with hubby. Ambiance was awesome too!

Good food the charcuterie cheese was so cheese like hardcore I can only take mild cheeses so my tongue was burning. The servers were good but like what do you expect they are probably trained the restaurant was dark and the tables were like weirdly placed no privacy for you! It was good though idk read more

American Prime - Signature House-Smoked Prime Rib - American Near Me - McLean, Virginia

Pretty terrible experience overall. It was a beautiful night, so we sat outside. The inside & bar was pretty much empty. We ordered two Manhattans at the bar waiting for one more party. They were extremely sweet, more like a Shirley temple. Table service was very slow. It took about 15 mins to get the first round of drinks. It was downhill from there. Ordered two Stoli dirty martinis on the rocks. They came out neat and disgusting. Overly dirty to the point they were undrinkable. Had they been ok, we would have overlooked the fact they weren't on the rocks. We sent them back. 10 mins later, they came out again, neat. They were sent back again. Third time is a charm. They were served with olive juice on the side because they can't make a dirty martini. Switched to wine. Can't screw that up. The food was rather good as compared to the service. Steak and Grouper were nicely prepared. The sides were smaller than expected, but good. There were a lot of excuses and apologizing for the slow service. The kicker was the bill. Soli Dirty Martini - They served Stoli Elite instead of Stoli which is twice the price. + $2.00 charge for olives and $3.00 charge for ice for each. My wife asked for dressing for her Caesar salad, $1.50. Ordered Frangelico with our coffee, $3.00 added for neat pour. All in all, over $20.00 in additional charges for ridiculous add ons. When the manager was confronted, he explained everyone does that. My wife and I have traveled a lot for both business & personal purposes over the last few decades. We dined at many of the finest restaurants this country has to offer in about 35 states. I have only seen these up charges In Miami Florida about 20 years ago. That place went out of business 19 years ago. To say the least, locally, Eddy V's, Capital Grille, Fleming's, and Morton's don't practice these dishonest upcharges. We will never dine at American Prime in Tysons again. Ever. Advice, check your bill closely. read more

Today at the American Prime Steakhouse Tysons Corner, Virginia. Jon Mathieson, new Executive Chef here at Prime. Take a few minutes to hear how his experiences and deep culinary passion will help bring an even higher level of taste to you. Signature 16 oz smoked Prime Rib $40.00 and Beef Brazoala cured beef Northern Italian style $11.00 Located in: Tysons Dulles Plaza Address: 1420 Spring Hill Rd, McLean, VA 22102 (703) 891-8900 Menu: americanprimeco.com read more

American Prime - Alex Bajan at Prime American Steakhouse 7/28/2020 - American Near Me - McLean, Virginia

Wife and I went to American Prime in Tysons Corner area for our date night last Friday. First time here and I don't know how we've missed this place for so long. The prime rib was extraordinarily delicious, perfectly tender and juiciest cut I've had. The cowboy corn was savory, the perfect blend of corn, cheese, and spices. I would caveat that some items I found are overly smoked, but that's my own preference. It is tucked away in an office park a mile or so from Tysons I and II, and I saw comments on Yelp or Opentable that it was difficult to find. I had no problem finding it. Parking is along the outer ring of the office buildings. Normally we hit Randys', Nostos, or Flemings as our go to place in Tysons, now have to add this place in our rotation. read more

Pretty low-key steak place for the area. I will say the inside is super small and simple in the main room but I noticed that they do have a separate room for bigger parties. The food itself is pretty good but nothing outstanding. The fillet mignon was cooked really well and it was tasty. However J Gilberts is way better!! Also for the sides serving size that they gave is way smaller than other steak places. The mushrooms were delicious the brussels sprouts were pretty good, and the mashed potatoes were really yummy. If you want a decent steak place come here but not if you're looking to celebrate anything or go out for a special meal! read more

Pandemic paradise! American Prime can make you feel special and with a sense of near normalcy. The patio is awesome! Real patio space with good furniture and a mesmerizing firepit -- not a tent in a parking lot. The staff is so friendly and professional - especially Stela who greets me every time with a welcoming hello! Food is amazing! Try the meat and cheese board. Highly recommend the duck prosciutto and the goat cheese. The Brussel sprouts are crazy delicious done in their little skillet with yummy bacon bits. Going to try the deconstructed potato tonight which is a loaded baked potato cut into chunks and fried. Then all the toppings added. See you read more

American Prime - American Near Me - McLean, Virginia

See all

Underwhelming food -- appetizer was a mess, filet was subpar and didn't stand up to its name. Service (waiter) was very good and much appreciated. read more

Sigh. Hmph. Ugh. Came here for my husband's birthday dinner, specifically for the prime rib. First off, I want to say that the reason that this review is 2 stars and not one star is the service. Lovely. Our waiter (and eventually the manager) were both excellent. The issue was the food. Husband started with the French onion soup, which he deemed as "ok" - onions...cheese...and salt. Lots and lots of salt. I would not have minded some of that on my wedge salad...or any flavor for that matter...where was the dressing? Back in the kitchen apparently. Even the "blue cheese" scattered around the plate- which I suspect was the really cheap kind that tastes like tofu with fake blue "veins" was flavorless. Like like picked up each individual piece of cheese to taste it by itself and...nothing. Next came the prime rib with my husband again deemed - ok. Not great, not bad, just...ok. I got the steak frites ordered medium well (you may commence snickering) which was nicely charred on the outside and completely raw on the inside - like cold raw. I sent it back and the waiter (who really was great) apologized and said the new sous chef was "nervous"...huh? If you're hired to be a sous chef at a high end steak house and you can't cook a medium well steak...I suppose I would be nervous too. I opted to have the steak taken off the check and watched my husband eat his birthday dinner alone (by the time my dinner was ready he would be finished anyway) and opted for my daughter's leftover dim sum at home (which were really good btw - shout out to A&J in Rockville!) and the manager also comped our drinks (excellent drinks at that) which was a very nice gesture... We left without having dessert...on his birthday. Until they get some more competent cooks in the kitchen...proceed with caution... read more

Every thing was awesome and delicious! The cocktail and lemonade were great and all food was delicious. The smoky wings were a little too smoky. The outdoor seating area has quite good view. The price is high but worth the quality of the food. read more

Tucked into a kind of courtyard surrounded by office buildings this is a nice spot separated from the hustle bustle of Tysons with lots of heated outdoor seating. The wait staff was great, very attentive and nice. Unfortunately the food simply isn't very good, which is especially unfortunate given the prices. We started with a crudités plate, which had about 25 slices of not-especially-fresh vegetables, two different kinds of hummus that were delicious, and a large pile of flatbread. Kind of ok. I got the signature prime rib, medium rare, with creamed spinach and a Caesar salad. The prime rib was rare, chewy and unseasoned, slightly smoky on the outside edge but basically inedible unless you like chewing on bland raw meat. The au jus that came with it had no more flavor than water. The creamed spinach was a bowl of molten cheese, cream and fried shallots with spinach flavor, which would have been good as an appetizer with bread, but impossible to have more than 2 bites on its own. The Caesar salad had a few crisp pieces of lettuce buried under a pile of shredded cheese, bland dressing, and no anchovies. Perhaps it is a preference thing but I expect food to have flavor and for vegetables to be fresh and taste like vegetables. Maybe it is a steak house standard to try to see how much fat you can cover your vegetables with but I find it beyond unappealing. There are lots of other steak houses and upscale restaurants nearby that are better options. read more

The food, bone in ribeye and broccolini, was fair. The steak was cooked well but nothing special, average. The broccolini was not good. Didn't eat it except for a sample tasting..... never inquired why, or if it was ok, just cleaned up the table. You're in $75 to $100 per person restaurant and there is no bread service Service was adequate, bit of a language barrier Disappointing at this price point read more

You have to get the signature prime rib!!!! It's so good and melts in your mouth. The dry aged steak was good too but I definitely like the prime rib more. For the dry aged steak I would recommend getting a side sauce. Side sauces cost $3.00. The prime rib didn't need any sauce. It was perfect! I shared the mussels as an appetizer. It was good but I've had better. The entrees do not come with sides. You have to buy the side(s) separately but one side is large enough for two people. The customer service was great! From host to waitress. It was mr first time and I will be returning. read more

See all

Excellent timely service but part of order was never delivered to the table. Appetizers were better than entrees especially the beef entrees which were of not up to quality of competing steak restaurants. read more

I went to American Prime on Valentine's Day with my boyfriend. I liked how they offered Valentine's Day dinner menu--it looked reasonably priced. They were giving out roses at front, so that was really nice of them. I ordered Prime Rib and side of wild mushroom & my boyfriend got a filet mignon. The prime rib was soooo juicy and yummy! It was one of the best. It was so tender and flavorful :) The mushroom exceeded my expectation. The food was amazing. It was tricky to find the place but with GPS, you will find it with no problem. Also, the service was really nice. I think the manager was walking around and checking on the customers and he provided the best service. I would like to go back in my special days. read more

See all

Skip over everything else on the menu and order the house-smoked prime rib with sides of bone marrow mashed potatoes and bacon creamed corn! Overindulgently rich and decadent pairings, yes. Just run a marathon or something to work it off after, and it will be worth it ;p Don't get me wrong, the other things I've had here (risotto balls, brussel sprouts, truffled gnocchi, cowboy ribeye) have all been well prepared, and you'll leave satisfied after a delicious meal. But if anyone at your table gets any of the above (at top) you're only going to sadly smile and sigh at the thought of the dinner you could've had. The prime rib is suuuuuuppppeerrrrr smokey-aromatic and has a very light savory-sweet rub on the edges. Rich, tender, and the most flavorful steak I might have ever had. Comes with a tasty horseradish paste that is not too punchy but adds just enough sass. Also, I've never tried this but have been told you can order a 20 oz. off-menu! The bone marrow mashed potatoes are very rich and buttery, and work excellently to sop up steak juices (because I have no shame). The creamed corn has giant chunks of salty-crispy thick-cut bacon, really great texture and flavors. The restaurant itself is nice enough, but feels a little 'stock photo' and could use more personality. Luckily our service has been spot-on both times with a super chill and hilarious server. Bottom line - for an indulgent special dinner out, will definitely be back! read more

See all

Not great. Even during Covid I would expect better service. Also didn't care much for the dry aged steak. When I sent it back, the chef came out to explain that I was wrong. All pretty odd. On the positive side, they have great fire pits outside. Super place for a drink when it is chilly. read more

Amazing food, outstanding service (thank you Bibek)! From start to finish, possibly the best prime rib and NY strip I've ever had. Can not recommend this place enough if you are looking for a place for a mouthwatering steak, look no further than American Prime! read more

I tried this place during the Valentine's Day. They had a prefix menu. The steak was mediocre at best and very dry even though I had ordered a medium. It was just OK and not something that is considered fancy. Maybe it was just that night. read more

Affordable cocktails and outdoor seating. The bartenders are so super nice! I was waited on by Matt and AJ, and not only did they perfect my drinks, but I got to try mew cocktails they created too. I'll be back without a doubt. This is probably gonna be a new favorite spot. BEST EXPERIENCE! read more

We came here for Restaurant Week and tried the Signature Smoked Prime Rib. I have to say, I haven't had such a good steak for a while! Especially, I just went to Fogo De Chao the night before for Restaurant Week as well and the meats were not nearly as tasty as Prime Rib. The smoked flavor really makes an otherwise boring steak interesting and I ordered medium which I would expect to be a bit dry but it actually turned out to be very tender and juicy! I got bread pudding for dessert and it was delicious and comforting, without being too sweet. I took off one star because our waiter messed up our bill by charging me the wrong amount when we gave simple instructions. read more

American Prime - Smoked Signature House Smoked Prime Rib - American Near Me - McLean, Virginia

See all

Found this place on OpenTable. It's a little bit off the beaten path on the bottom floor of an office building, however do not let that dissuade you. Hassle free parking and I would love to visit this place on a nice warm sunny day and experienced the patio at night time. Important thing is the food. I'm a little picky when it comes to my steaks and this place did not disappoint. I usually stay away from prime rib due to the amount of fat, however since it was their signature steak I decided to give it a try. it did not disappoint, in fact I was extremely impressed. They smoke their meat and the flavor was incredible. Very little fat except on the outsides which is normal near the crust. The cut I got was so perfect that I didn't need any of the dipping sauces or salt. I'm 160 pounds and the 20 ounce was a challenge for me, especially since most of it was delicious tender meat. The deconstructed baked potato was unlike any other baked potato I've had before. It was not greasy even though it's baked and fried. I got the traditional Cobb wedge and it was the perfect size. Prices are very reasonable compared to other high-end steakhouses and I'll go here over Morton's any day of the week and twice on Sunday. Staff was incredibly friendly which definitely added to the overall experience. Our waiter was excellent and wasn't just feeding us lines. He knew the menu and cared about our visit. If I'm being critical, the only thing I could've done without was the 90s grunge music. A background track of some thing light and instrumental would definitely add to the ambience. Definitely recommend to give them a try. We will be back, next time with friends. read more

American Prime - 20 ounce signature smoked prime rib in front. Deconstructed baked potato on the right. Steak Frittas in the back. - American Near Me - McLean, Virginia

See all

Service and food was amazing! Doris was our server for the night and she was attentive and provided great suggestions from the menu. My husband and I went for a late dinner and found the atmosphere to be exactly what we had wanted (intimate and quiet). We shared a charcuterie board with 3 items to start. Then a cesar salad for him and a potato and leeks soup for me. For dinner we decided to share the 16oz prime rib with brussels sprouts and crab Mac and cheese. Doris surprised us with dessert, which was a Guinness infused cheesecake with Oreo crust. Our bill with 2 drinks each came to $155-ish. read more

See all

I was traveling for work and found this place on Yelp. It was a little off the beaten path but worth it. There's traditional seating, bar seating and a section of patio seating outside of the bar and an eclectic happy hour crowd. The service was really great. They were attentive and professional. I had the smoked duck gnocchi. The duck had a great smoke and was cooked perfectly. The gnocchi was fresh and perfect consistency. I had the flourless chocolate cake for desert. It was fudgy and rich with a raspberry sauce on the side. worth every bite. It had a comfortable, low key vibe/crowd but had the quality service an food of a steakhouse. I really enjoyed it and will visit again. read more

Good old fashioned deliciousness with class. The location threw me off but this place was highly recommended so why not? We get there and they immediately we were seated The staff, especially Oz , was highly trained and ready to provide us a high quality service. The appetizers and sides were absolutely amazing. Our friends had the French onion soup, my wife the salad. When you order your entree it doesn't really come with sides so make sure to order those separately. We chose the mashed potatoes with bone marrow butter as our side - it was as good as it sounds. My friend and I ordered the New York strip and it was fantastic, we had to send it back to be re-grilled because it was a little too raw for us in the middle but they were very apologetic and brought it back perfected. My wife had the filet mignon and it was perfect and my friends wife had the salmon and it was on point. The desserts are pretty small but are packed with deliciousness. Overall fantastic dinner - we will be back read more

See all

Disclaimer: American Prime has the BEST prime rib ever! My husband and I stumbled across this restaurant during restaurant week and decided to give it a show since it was new and in Tysons Corner which isn't too far from where we live. We used GPS to get there and still almost missed the restaurant because it's tucked back in an office park area. There was valet parking, which we used because we didn't know any better, but realized that they were just going to park our car in the spaces right outside there and should have just parked ourselves. We tipped the valet guy after dinner, but told him that we would just walk to our car instead of him going 20 feet to get it. The décor in the restaurant is very nice and you see some of the meats being cured when you walk in, very modern and kind of hip. We got seated right away and there weren't that many others in the dining room on a Sunday evening, which was surprising, especially since it was restaurant week. We ordered a chacutterie board to start with and did 3 meats and 2 cheeses. It also came with fruit, bread, and some other stuff....very nice and plenty of food for my husband and I to share. For our entrees, he got the prime rib (which is their specialty) and I went with the filet. My filet was good and cooked fine but the prime rib stole the show. They smoke it and season it to perfection. My husband and I both said that it was the BEST prime rib we've ever had! Our server was good and we had a great experience and knew we'd put it on our list of favorite restaurants to visit. We went back a month or so later on a Sunday evening around 6pm and we were the only people in the dining room. Not only were we the only people there when we arrived, but still the only folks there when we left. For us, that means we got undivided attention and had the place to ourselves, but it worried us that it was so dead on a Sunday evening. But the food was still amazing. We both got the prime rib and a side of their mushrooms and they were both out of this world. I really hope that this place does good business during the week because it appears that they are pretty quiet on the weekends and we don't want to see this great establishment closed. read more

See all

The short ribs and the gazpacho were great. The prime rib, however, was fatty and tough to cut. One star off for the prime rib, otherwise a great experience. read more

I went with a group of friends during restaurant week. The place was nice, specious & had a warm welcoming atmosphere. The service was great. I had crab cake for appetizer. It was amazing. Prime rib was good. It perfectly cooked the way I ordered. High quality meat. I also got additional 3 giant shrimp. I didn't like them much. Ended with Guinness cheesecake. It was ok. I also got to try pudding which was very good. It was a very good deal $35 for 3 course meal. read more

See all

We ordered the Thanksgiving turkey meal for 4 people-- the entire meal was excellent and could definitely feed a larger family. The smoked turkey was delicious, tender and full of flavor. The traditional sides of stuffing, brussel sprouts, creamed corn and creamed spinach were devoured by our crew. Admittedly, I tucked away small portions of each for leftovers the next day because they were soooo good. And yes, the fam thanked me the following day! The service was fantastic. Everyone we spoke with was very nice and called to confirm our order. We will definitely be ordering from here again. Thank you American Prime team. ...unfortunately I thought of taking a pic too late, but our full bellies were certainly happy! read more