On my first review, I was just coming through for a quick bite. (Text: I was actually going to stop at the Italian place next door, since I'm not a big fan of diners, but I saw about 3 cars there and about 103 cars here, so I went with the popular choice. Glad I did.) Although I only had the souvlaki the first time, I noted friendly and attentive service by all, including the manager. The food came out fairly quickly given that I arrived during the peak lunch hour. The pita was the best pita I have ever eaten. The fries were up there with the best fries I have ever eaten. There was plenty of food for my money overall, and it was memorably delicious. So for this update, I finally went in for a full meal. I can offer the following updates: * I went during the dinner peak this time (I should say: just after a Hudson Valley Renegades game across the river), and service was MUCH slower to attend to us. Now, to be fair, I arrived with one person and we were waiting on a third, so I didn't expect them to rush to take or order until the third person arrived... but at least bring us water? Took like 15 minutes for that. * Shrimp pasta was delicious. But if you're smothering shrimp in sauce, please de-shell? Otherwise serve them on the side so I can do that myself. Annoying to have to sift through the sauce and clean my hands. * They did sub in pasta of my choice. * Carrot soup was OK, nothing special but it was the soup of the day vs. just a plain salad for my veggies. Desserts were on display but I was stuffed. Again, you will get plenty of food here. But try not to come at the same time as /everyone/ else. read more

Alexis Diner - Shrimp santorini, adding cheese - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York

5/20/26 - 4 stars for the classic diner decor. Private dining rooms, great for special occasions or meetings. Service is attentive and get the job done. Some of the entrées look like they came from Restaurant Depot down the block. Not bad, just OK. The crabcakes didn't have much crab flavor. But for the price you can't complain. Their burgers looked good though! Plenty of free parking, and it's easier to get out of the parking lot than some places over there. read more

See all

Enjoyed my breakfast at Alexis Diner. Ordered the Alexis Omelette and thought it was very good! I would have no problem ordering this omelette again, and I had no problem with the variety of items on the menu that some reviewers complained about. The food was good, coffee was good, and the service was good, even when dining with a group of 12. The server did not hesitate providing separate checks, which is rare with a big group. read more

The food was quality and the service was friendly and efficient. Allie, my server was very attentive. Very clean diner concept. One of the best diners I've ever dined at. read more

On our way to a baseball game and a quick stop at Alexis's diner for breakfast was worth it. The broccoli cheese omelette was perfect and the seasoned potatoes alongside it made for a great plate of goodness. And imagine my surprised to see that Italian rainbow cookies actually made into a cake. The owner mentioned someone had previously requested it for their wedding cake and after I tried it, I can't imagine why they wouldn't have. Alexis's diner will be my next stop when I'm headed to West Point area again. Thanks much for the slice. read more

The Alexis Diner is conveniently located right off I-84--can't miss the classic diner shape and glowing lights at night. There was lots of parking available too. We came at a less busy time and were seated promptly. Our server was quite friendly. After much deliberation, I ordered the baked pastichio ($18.95) which consisted of macaroni and ground beef with béchamel sauce. I'd never eaten this dish before, but it was kind of lackluster and needed more pep. But the Greek side salad that came with it was more impressive, with generous amounts of feta, a stuffed grape leaf, and anchovies, though the dressing was on the oilier side. read more

The server was quick and thorough. I had the prime rib sandwich which was delicious and cooked just right for me. It was a large portion to include the potato salad! My husband had the corned beef omelet and gave it a great review. Will definitely come back when we pass through again! read more

Alexis Diner - Prime Rib sandwich with potato salad - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

Great service, great food and a great ambiance. They have everything you need in a diner breakfast, lunch dinner cocktails desserts etc. they make a great Reuben pastrami Panini comes with coleslaw and fries. Substitute the fries for onion rings which were fantastic. read more

See all

I've been to a lot of diners and this one was pretty disappointing. Don't get me wrong, the food was ok. Just average diner food. I got the Rueben which I feel could've been a little better, and a soup, which was very very bland. I love soup, I eat it every where I go, and I even make a variety of soup myself. What got me was where we got seated. They put us near the walkway to the bathroom, and it smelled so bad. Every time someone would walk by from the bathroom this rancid smell of sewer and cleaning chemicals would trail behind them. The bathroom smelled so bad, I went to wash my hand and it almost ruined my appetite. I think if it wasn't for the bathroom experience, I would have given maybe another star. read more

Lovely local spot with a large menu. Had a grilled cheese and a toasted muffin both lovely. Service was fast and everyone greeted us warmly. read more

Alexis Diner - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Stopped by Alexis Diner at 10pm on a Wednesday. Our server Kayla was very kind and accommodating, offered good recommendations and provided overall amazing service. The diner is bright and has a nice homey vibe at this hour. We ordered the broccoli cream soup with cheddar cheese which is nice and mild. Next was the Ultimate Snack Platter, I think the mozzarella sticks were the star of this dish and I've eaten plenty of these elsewhere. Lastly we also had the baked moussaka which came with the most delicious Greek salad. First time trying this dish and it was solid and balanced. read more

See all

Not sure why so many lower reviews? Each time I visit here, the food is fresh and prepared perfectly - and with homemade desserts! Chicken kabobs on greek salad was outstanding read more

Alexis Diner - Chicken kabobs on rice - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Very friendly servers. Service was fast. Prices reasonable. Ordered a bison cheese burger deluxe. 14.95. Was very good. Not many places have bison burgers. They are much leaner and very tasty. Diner is a diner. But this is a step above. Will be back. read more

Alexis Diner - Bison burger - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Nice big updated diner. Windows being cleaned in the morning which is nice to see. Went for a quick Monday morning breakfast. Simple eggs, home fries and sausage. Coffee good. Breakfast was good and good portion. Turkey sausage was 3 patties so a good value. read more

Alexis Diner - Eggs with turkey sausage. Rye toast. - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York

service stinks - food is haphazard and stingy - Manager is crude, loud, insulting and disrespectful. waitresses indifferent and overworked. Cooks rush instead of care - they think they are working at McDonald's. VERY stingy, commerical portions that look like cost-cutting is the prime motive - and it is apparent in every serving. they survive only because of the location - transient traffic hub affords innocents easy mistake - ample parking helps. If you're travelling from Connecticut to Pennsylvania and you're starving - you'll go there. ONCE. and DO NOT let them seat you near the bathroom. It smells like an old gas station latrine in Mississippi - in August. read more

Clean. Fast. Extremely amazing service. Im GF and they had wayyyy more options than I have ever seen at a diner! Desserts look amazing!! We have four to try when we get home. We normally take a diff way home but will be going out of our way to stop and eat here again! Couldn't be more happier with how amazing we were treated. Very welcoming! read more

So much of the restaurant experience is in the story of how you get there. We were in dire straits when we walked into the warm glow of Alexis Diner. They welcomed us in to their breakfast paradise under the green neon lights and showered us in delicious french toast and tremendous hospitality. 5/5 stars. read more

The food is not all that. I ordered a meatloaf dinner plate and it was good. Tasted very conventional.

I have never had a bad meal or experience at Alexis Diner. It's classic and never gets old. I love this place!

This is a popular diner for locals and tourists. We were tourists and grabbed a bite to eat before traveling back home. Although a long line, the wait time was surprisingly manageable. This is a big establishment and have fast service. The service was amazing and accommodated to our needs. There was cool murals displayed on the walls. My Buffalo Chicken Panini was delicious and filling. The Onion rings were tasty. Chicken Cordon Blue Wrap - really good as well. The portion sizes are big enough to take home for leftovers. The only downfall is the those who ate the burger and chicken parmesan wrap had a horrible stomach bug. read more

See all

Decided to go back for dinner after the food was so delicious a week ago...this time not a good experience! The waitress was fairly good. There were 2 orders of chicken & waffles but the meals had to be sent back due to the waffles being cold! The waitress said she would have the kitchen warm up our food but when she returned she said they made us brand new waffles. Something about the waffles were off & I didn't finish that meal. The nachos were delicious. The burger was asked for "well done" & instead we received medium rare. The restaurant was busy as usual but seemed to have plenty of staff working. read more

See all

Food is good I suggest eating in as takeout can be hit or miss. I order an omelette and they asked what toast? Told them and no toast with order. Fries were mushy but luckily I had an air fryer for the other meal. Great place though. read more

The food here is AWFUL. Maybe if they cut the menu down from a thousand offerings in six cuisines, they'd be able to cook something right. I ordered eggs benedict and a side of corned beef hash. The eggs were overcooked, so not at all runny. The hollandaise sauce was sparse and tasteless. The "canadian bacon" (or whatever it was) was so thick and dry (not to mention unevenly cut) that it was hard to eat and dominated the dish. And the corned beef hash was too salty. My wife had the nachos supreme. She said it was tasteless. How do you make tasteless nachos?! What an incredible waste of money! read more

First and last time I will ever go to this diner. There wasn't one courteous employee there. They were impatient, rude and could care less about making our experience a pleasant one. Food is grossly overpriced. Took my daughter to the bathroom to find one stall with no toilet paper in it, another with toilet paper all over the seat, another with a clogged toilet and the handicap stall had feces smeared on the wall. Horrendous experience!!!!! read more

The service was great. The service is always great!! I come here all the time to eat an enjoyable meal. Their breakfast is really great and delicious too. read more

Adele was our server , he was great to say the least. Plenty of parking and very clean . The food was plentiful and the presentation was excellent. I will be returning!!! read more

Alexis Diner - Mediterranean Eggs Benedict - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York

We love this diner, you will feel like family. We love this place!! Lemon Meringue Pie & M&M cookies and ask for the cheesecake milkshake from George. It's so good. read more

Nothing could be finer than eating at the Alexis diner ! Breakfast dinner or lunch we love this place a bunch! Try the bagel with lox cream cheese onions and tomatoes ! Or one of the phenomenal omelets or dishes from their menu! read more

We were out and about in the local area and wanted something to eat. That wasn't gonna be a big production but would be good. We came across Alexis diner via Google and decided to stop by and have lunch. We all had Panini's and let me tell you they were so good. They were fresh big and crispy. We had the roast beef, New York Panini along with the New York pastrami Panini's. The macaroni salad was very good and the fries were hot and fresh. A little New York cheesecake for dessert and we called it a day. Overall, a very good experience. read more

Another stop for lunch on our road trip. I have eaten here a few times before and it's our go to diner in the area. The menu is vast, the service is great and the desserts looking so spectacular from the glass cases. I ordered the cream of mushroom soup and the roast chicken dinner. My dining mate ordered the tuna melt and fries. The food is plentiful, plated nicely and came out hot. My soup was good but I had better mushroom soup elsewhere. I enjoyed my roast chicken it was flavorful and tender, veggies steamed nicely. The tuna melt was also very tasty. The atmosphere was comfortable and prices reasonable. Glad we stopped here read more

See all

One of the best diners around; always a hot delicious meal! Service was good, they were packed and the waitress was hustling, at times it was hard to get their attention but nothing too bad. Not many diners can actually make a medium rare triple decker cooked to perfection with a side of onion rings ($). The cheese fries and gravy were not what we expected; but they were good, but we're used to the gravy bring on top of the fries. The desserts are phenomenal and we find are best to take home to enjoy after such a filling meal! read more

Alexis Diner - Mozzarella Cheese Fries and Gravy - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

Run away quickly! Terrible management and incompetence servers. My husband & son came for breakfast and paid $23 for a western omelet and added Bacon/sausage no peppers. When questioned management said yes server made mistake and should have informed them but felt it justified. Not worth the $$. read more

Alexis Diner - Omelette prices - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

We had a tasty lunch here while on a road trip. This is a classic roadside diner with huge portions, an assortment of Greek dishes and just generally a HUGE menu of just about anything you could imagine eating. Service was speedy. Food was tasty. It's right off of 84. read more

See all

I love Diners...but with that said, I can only muster 3 stars for Alexis. Typical NY/NJ diner. Big menu, so my saying "you don't have a problem until you have a choice" stands true. Food was good. Large portions. Service was okay. No pictures of dinner as it was nothing to capture.... except for dessert. Definitely save room for dessert. read more

See all

The service was great. The food was also good; I had pancakes and a margarita. The margarita was good and the pancakes were also good. My sister ordered French fries and her French fries were good. The other things which my family ordered were also good. My niece ordered lox and it was good; they gave her alot. The place reminds has a nostalgic feel to it. They were very friendly; it was my sister's birthday and they surprised us with a slice of cake. No one told them to do that; they did that on their; which was very thoughtful and kind. I would definitely come back. read more

See all

The alexis diner always has room for us and a nice staff. They have some good food. My favorite is the buffalo chicken wrap. They also have the best honey mustard around. I also enjoy their waffles. They're a little crunchy but always yummy! read more

Alexis Diner - Belgium waffle with chocolate chips and strawberries - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York

We got seated in the main dining room and it was a very nice spacious atmosphere . The Italian artwork & decor gave more of a nice restaurant feel . The special plates they serve the food on also granted such a lovely presentation . You will not leave hungry and the food was absolutely delicious !!! Of course we had to take home desserts, which you must not pass up !! Our very tall son ordered two appetizers, a burger platter and had a slice of chocolate mousse cake with a big glass of milk . We ended up taking home a portion each of appetizer , it was all held together by our sweet lovely waitress who has been there over 25 years ! The gentlemen who were head of house were so kind , so really it's a nice huge restaurant with a special family run touch .. we loved it all :) read more

Alexis Diner - I dug into the Napoleon , sturdy boxed to bring home the rest - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York

This is my favorite diner to go to in Newburgh New York. They have great service they get you really fast. Have you seated bring your drink order and it's a breeze to check out my favorite dish. Here is the Reuben sandwich. It comes with a side of Russian dressing or 1000 islands whichever you prefer. read more

OMG the steak fries - perfection. 25 of us descended on the diner after a funeral at Cedar Hill. Ordering was easy, staff was on point, food delicious. Good value for the price too. read more

I'm not typically someone who writes a same day review, but I didn't want to forget about the details of my visit @ Alexis Diner. Firstly, we waited forever. Like... about 30 minutes for two burgers and a Turkey sandwich, and I was REALLLLY worried that the food was going to come out and the fries were going to be cold (IMO, that's probably the worst thing that could ever happen to me in a restaurant; cold fries) but the wait was the only downside of our experience. Food came out and WOW these plates were HUGE and the fries OH MY GOSHHH. Smaller steak fries, which I'm not normally a fan of, but they were hot and hit the spot just right. The Turkey and Swiss melt was as big as my face, and my parents burgers were cooked to perfection and just as huge. Pickles bordered on cucumbers and the cole slaw was a little watery, but overall the main food was absolutely banging. Like I said, I'm not one to write a same day review, but we got out to the parking lot to leave and I just felt myself being like "dang, that was a good meal." Staff was busy, but extremely pleasant. Took a bit to get back to us some waters, but I could tell they were busy, so that's okay in my book. Food was hot, that's all you can ask for when everywhere is as short staffed as they are these days. read more

Alexis Diner - Diners Near Me - Newburgh, New York