Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Which Wich

    3.8 (127 reviews)
    Closed 10:30 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Which Wich Takeout or Delivery

    Which Wich Photos

    Business Info

    WHICH WICH ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Good for kids
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Which Wich

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Matthew S.

    Probably one of my favorite sub places (this and Potbelly). The staff is super friendly, the flavor is great, and the options are amazing. Milkshakes are pretty good too. Not the cheapest, so I can't come here as often as I'd like. If the prices were a buck or two lower, I'd probably come here 3-4 days a week for lunch.

    Choices
    Amy M.

    The hubs and I were in the Williamsburg area when we decided to stop in for lunch. We both are fans of sandwiches so it was only fitting to stop and check it out. It was bustling with customers which is always a great sign. The eatery had a nice number of chairs and tables to accommodate the masses. It is clean which is a plus. There was even seating right by the windows perfect for people watching lol. The menu is displayed on the side by the register. It took a few minutes to peruse the options before opting for the cali club. To make it a meal you can add a side of crinkle fries with a drink. There's also a choice of dessert that is locally made which I recommend to satisfy a sweet tooth. Since it was pretty busy some orders were getting mixed up. We had to wait a few minutes since our fries were forgotten. The fries are better than shake shack! Yep crispy and made in house. The Cali club comes with avocado, Turkey, cheddar, red onions, lettuce, and bacon on a wheat roll. It was standard and wrapped nicely. It satisfied our hunger. The birthday cake was good as well. There is a rewards program so download their app to collect points to redeem free food. We will be back and I believe it's franchised so this is not their only location:)

    Free WiFi!
    Patrise S.

    Yum, yum, yummy!!! 5 out of 6 of us love dining here. We love the quality ingredients and we're happily surprised to see that they now serve fries, crisp, fresh and deeelicious! I dived into the chocolate cake shake and left everyone wishing they had cake too. Cake and ice cream in every sip is delightful. I'm certain that birthday cake and carrot cake shakes are amazing. This post isn't written by one full from their great delicacies, in fact it's he next morning and I'm still reminiscing....

    Not impressed, especially for the price.
    Dale S.

    Had a busy moving/cleaning day in Williamsburg, so I grabbed some Which Wich for everyone to try. I got a few BLT's, Cheeseburger and Reuben sandwiches and a garden party for myself. I made sure to get some fries as well to try the sauce I have heard so much about. The food was ok, but I wasn't really impressed (especially at this price tag) nor was anyone else. We all tried a small sample of each sandwich as well to make sure we weren't missing anything. Some in the group really did like the fry sauce, but the fries themselves were soggy and bland and I was not a fan of the sauce. The bread was very basic, like day olds you might get from a corner market, and the ingredients were lacking as well. Don't be fooled by the amazing pictures, I had to open up the BLT to check that there was even avocado in it. For what I paid, I could have taken everyone out to get something heartier so I was disappointed overall but it fit the immediate need. With so many sandwich shops out there and nothing that stood out about this place, I will probably not patronize a Which Wich again.

    Za Which sandwich
    Kellee G.

    The sandwiches we got were amazing. I got the Za which and my daughter got the grinder. The fries were ok...a little soggy after a while. I do not give it more than 3 stars because we got 2 sandwiches and 2 fries and paid over $40...that's a bit much for sandwiches.

    Neva W.

    Let me start off by saying I'm a huge fan of deli sandwiches. I love Which Wich! I wish there were more around. The ordering from the menu is a bit different t here. You grab a paper fill out what you want, grab another if you want fries, then take the papers to the register. Not a bad idea, that way you never mess up a sandwich. Everything is fresh and fast! I also like the dining set up. If your not an extrovert the dining set up may be uncomfortable but there are private seats on the side. I'm friendly so I of course sat and talk to strangers. The sandwich was amazing and the fries were perfect. I don't know about you but i love lemonade, so they pretty much gave me the world. I would definitely drive 20 minutes again just to have the same meal. See you again soon!

    Meat Balr
    Burt M.

    Went here on vacation and loved it! Reminded us of earl of sandwich! Bread is really good, all of us (kids and parents) were happy. Will come back when we are in town

    Great service and food. Easy to order your Fav. Nice,clean location. Ultimate BLT was very tasty

    Ultimate BLT with avocado

    See all

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Bijal P.

    Bijal P.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Rich K.
    64
    18
    5

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Sue H.
    1
    50
    0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - Which Wich

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Sandwiches 349 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Second Street American Bistro - Flatbread  pizza

    Second Street American Bistro

    4.4(1.7k reviews)
    3.4 mi
    $$

    My wife and I split a full rack of ribs at Second St Bistro. The ribs were fantastic and fell right…read moreoff the bone, very tender! I would recommend getting the mustard drizzle on the side, just to be sure it is to your taste. We also had the Crab/Corn Chowder soup. You must try it! Super delicious and flavorful. The onion rings were also very good/hand breaded. Service was excellent and the manager stopped at our table to check on us. The atmosphere is comfortable and ambiance is nice/quiet and clean. Strongly recommended for a good meal in a very nice setting.

    We were looking for somewhere to eat in Williamsburg and came across this spot. At first glance, it…read morelooks like an upscale restaurant, but it's actually casual dining and kid-friendly. We were seated right away, and our service was awesome from start to finish. FOOD REVIEW Thai Poppin' Shrimp 5/5 - I really appreciated Robin for making sure we had a great experience with this dish. Berry Burrata 3/5 - Not my favorite, but still decent. Asian Chicken Wraps 3/5 - This was okay, just a little too saucy for me. Fried Green Tomatoes 5/5 - One of our favorites. The pimiento cheese paired perfectly with it. Carolina Burger 4/5 - Huge portion, and my son really enjoyed it. 2nd St Burger 4/5 - Another big portion and overall really good. Kids Pizza & Tenderloins 3/5 - Decent for the kids, though the pizza bread was a bit dense. DRINKS Margarita 4/5 Prickly Pear 4/5 Robin really made our experience even better. She checked on us frequently and made sure everything came out right. The portions here are on the larger side, so I'd recommend ordering family-style if you're dining with a group. Overall, the food was great, and the service made the experience even better.

    Photos
    Second Street American Bistro - Bar area

    Bar area

    Second Street American Bistro
    Second Street American Bistro

    See all

    Masala Craft

    Masala Craft

    4.6(155 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $$

    This spot is amazing!…read more We shared 2 orders of garlic naan and one order of butter chicken with rice! A perfect date night spot and meal. The food was absolutely incredible, and full of spice and flavor. The restaurant is pretty, clean, and a great vibe. The service was quick, the staff were very attentive! A lovely evening at a lovely restaurant! Definitely recommend for both tourists and locals!

    My first thought was that one comes to Williamsburg expecting like a vegetable pastie or…read moregingerbread or something, not Indian food. To be fair though, India and Williamsburg were both British colonies. Having said that, this particular Indian restaurant has a Goan-influenced menu, which is actually the historically Portuguese part of India. There is a lot worth trying. It was a pleasant setting with indoor and outdoor tables; given the rain and wind I sat inside even though the outdoor tables were covered. Spoiled for choice, I got a fairly straightforward lentil soup to start before ordering a more adventurous dish of tofu and mushrooms in an onion-heavy curry. They offered the option to order okra as a side dish, which I don't usually see but jumped at the chance to do. An aloo paratha on the side was quite filling and good for mopping up the curry. Salt was a bit excessive, particularly with the bread I think. The actual amount of tofu in my curry could have been more, but the flavors were abundant. My chai arrived unsweetened and with options to sweeten it myself, which I deferred on. A lot of people got takeout, but for a place to eat in and get a high quality and regionally distinctive meal, this place fit the bill.

    Photos
    Masala Craft - The interior is beautiful.

    The interior is beautiful.

    Masala Craft
    Masala Craft - E.H Taylor

    See all

    E.H Taylor

    Which Wich - sandwiches - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...