Nice surprise. I'd say 3.5 stars for pizza and round up to 4 stars for great staff, clean dining room and overall very nice experience. Staff actually smiles and greets customers in such a genuine way. We love that a variety of slices are available. Will definitely return. read more

See all

Hello, We're Back Pizza We are Dissatisfied Customers Cause We had Ordered a Sausage & Peppers Grinder and it came Out Horribly WrongWhen I called and Talked to the Lady Working there; She said She would Replace it For Free Next time I came In. That Never happened the Other Day. I walked in and Told the Lady with Glasses- Do not goto Her- I asked her Kindly, and Told Her What Exactly happened and NOTHING WAS BEING DONE with Her Attitude; EXCEPT WRITE A QUICK NOTE TO THE OWNERS And they NEVER Called Us back with a RESOLUTION OF SOME SORT!!!! I was SHOCKED BY THIS CAUSE THE OWNERS ALWAYS TOOK CARE OF MY FAMILY WHILE DINING THERE AND TAKEOUT??? We are Very Dissatisfied Customers Cause A Resolution was Never Made!!! UNBELIEVABLE, WE'RE BACK!!! read more

Went in at 8.30 pm to pickup my order.. the place was packed with people picking up orders.As i went to get my order some dumb bo left a vacuum near the door and the cord almost made me fall...Who leave a vacuum near the front door with the cord out on the floor.Tonight the pizza was just so/so ! read more

Neighborhood pizza spot. My family swears by it. Clutch designer pizza spot for home dining. Service is fast. Ambiance is like a normal pizza spot. read more

I put in a large order for our crew to test the quality of their product, ordering several pizzas ( Margherita, plain, gramma, Sicilian, Lasagna, We're Back Special, Bakery Style Sicilian ) salads, wraps as well as garlic knots. Everything was on point, as well as Mike the owner delivered the pizza himself. Mike is really a nice guy who've I've seen on Tik Tok make all kinds of videos claiming to be the Sicilian Capital of CT. He talks up his food but he also backs it up with his love for making his food. We could tell the passion he has for his business as well as making sure his customers are happy with everything. Mike texted me the following day to follow up and make sure we were satisfied with the food and service. I am definitely going to be a repeat customer as he does backup everything he claims about his food. We had 10+ employees in which several brought food home to share with their families. We have ordered pizzeria food from other well known CT pizzerias and most of the time my people pass on sharing it with their families. Mike left a great impression with us and in turn the least I could do was go out of my way to give his business the props that they deserve. Thanks again to We're Back and Mike for a very positive experience. read more

Finally found a place that sells by the slice in West Haven. Its nice, clean and cozy. Many different selection of pizza you can imagine. Taste amazing, my favorite one, Beef Stroganoff pizza. I will come back to try the other slices. read more

We're Back Pizza - The lower right corner is my favorite one, Beef Stroganoff pizza. The top right is bourbon sauce bacon chicken pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Orange, Connecticut

Just casually walked in for lunch and was surprised that we're back pizza offered pizza by the slice. It was my First time having pizza by the slice in Orange! I had the gramma slice, it was absolutely delicious. It's a family owned restaurant with a beautiful story. You definitely get that feel when you walk in. There is a good amount of seating, fountain and bottled drinks, and service is amazing. Would definitely stop by again for a slice. Also, parking is a breeze read more

We're Back Pizza - Pizza by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Orange, Connecticut

See all

We stopped for 2 Sicilian slices and they were flavorful. Very friendly staff as well as a great selection of slices ready to go.

Perfection ! Guys this is whats called a Pizzeria , the real deal- real mccoy. Bufalo chicken, meatlovers, peperoni, mushroom, sausage and plain slice, come on guys pizza by the slice is the only to go. You can find good Apizza anywhere in conn, you also find good ny style pizza all over but real sicilian pizza ( square pies) very few places. Why buy a pie when you can sample every one order 3 of your favorites or request any topping. But the star is the sicilian pizza. When you a crave a different type of pizza or change try it But warning it may end up being your favorite style of pizza. read more

We're Back Pizza - By the slice !!!! - Pizza Near Me - Orange, Connecticut

This is arguably the best pizza in Connecticut. Not only do they have a nice selection, but they also serve slices! The Alla Vodka Hot Honey pie is literally to die for. I met the owners and they have such an amazing story behind this place and experiences, and they even gave me free grandma slice to try! Every time I am in the area, I have to stop here because it's just that good! read more

Called and ordered a Meatball Parm. $12 per their online menu. Arrived to pick up and was told the total was $15. Didn't make sense considering tax at 7.35% After questioning how much it cost, I was advised the prices went up and was shown a printed menu - on which the price was $13. Which still didn't explain the cost to me of over $15. I was then informed that the price was $14 and advised that the owner maintains the right to change prices without notice. So I asked, 'you're not going to honor the price an either of your menus'? To which the response was no. You can make your own mind up if you whether or not you wish to patronize a business that acts this way - I most certainly will not. read more

This is one of my favorite pizza places. I highly recommend the special which has everything you would want on any pizza. Meatball sausage onion peppers pepperoni. Delicious. I drive from Branford to the West Haven:Orange line their cheese pizza is also delicious. Love the casual atmosphere. You order at the counter and it's brought to your table. If you order soda it's unlimited you fill up yourself and the drinks are Foxon Park. Definitely returning here read more

See all

Consistently enjoy a slice of two here. Our favorite is the Bakery slice. While a thick crust, it is very light. A little close to Detroit style with sauce over cheese. Different than their Sicilian which has an abundance of cheese. read more

I stopped in on Sunday just for a couple of slices. I love when pizza establishments offer pizza by the slice. The lady at the counter was very polite, she explained what each pizza option was, and what the toppings included. I went for two cheese slices. This is a very casual spot with seating. A decent size for a larger group. Very accessible. And, ample parking. I only tried the pizza, but they have a very extensive menu. And because the pizza was good, I may try some other items from the menu in the future. If you're in the mood for pizza, but you don't want to buy an entire pie or you want to sample a variety of slices, I highly recommend. read more

See all

$17.75 for this tiny 9" gluten-free pizza (with no extra toppings). What a ripoff! I expected it to be at least as big as the box. I won't be going back - Ernie's in New Haven is much better read more

We're Back Pizza - Tiny little gluten-free pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Orange, Connecticut

The best gluten free pizza around. Very good cross contamination control, celiac friendly!

This happens to be the best pizza around, delicious pizza , salads, subs, and an awesome array of slices galore. Had the steak and cheese sub today, WOW! Give them a try you will not ever be disappointed, and I'm definitely returning. read more

Placed an order here tonight while visiting. Repeated my order 3 times for a calzone with no ricotta. 3 times. Get back to my hotel and surprise- ricotta inside which seemed like they put extra. The young man even repeated my order back to me. It was the end of the night and was already back in my hotel. The calzone went straight to the trash. I called and spoke to the same person- could care less. What a waste of money! It was apparent that they were more interested in closing- it was 7:40pm and they close at 9:00... read more

They sell slices!!! Which is convenient for a quick stop. The inside is spacious and clean with plenty of tables if you wanted to eat there. The pizza is good. I like the thick bacon. read more

Super great gluten free pizza. Also had a salad with chicken. Chicken was really delicious and a generous portion. Will be going back for more. read more

Went here for the first time. Mostly take out but they have a good amount of tables as well. You have to order at the window and they bring it to your table. Casual atmosphere. Full menu of Italian food and some regular American stuff too. The pizza was very good, thin crust. Looks like they sell slices too. Friendly staff and prices are good. Good amount of parking. Worth checking out. read more

I try really hard to write positive reviews but I was shocked by my food tonight. I had penne ala vodka and the sauce was not a vodka sauce, it tasted like macaroni and cheese. The sauce was so thick and tasted just like melted cheese. Either they need a new chef or my order was wrong. The garlic bread was burnt and dry, needed way more butter/oil and garlic. Overall disappointed given the priceZ. read more

We ordered pizza for lunch every Friday. Me and a couple others. Called today to order 2 pizzas and was told because it was being delivered to a business there is a $50 min. for delivery. That's not right but no worries we will just order elsewhere. There are lots of good pizza places out there . read more

Amazing meatball sub. The sauce tastes house made and soooo good. The meatballs were perfectly cooked and large. The sub itself was very large enough for two servings and the bread was just as good as the rest. I will definitely be back for the meatball sub! Also the restaurant itself had a nice setup, plenty of seating. read more

Best gluten free pizza I have ever had!!!! Perfectly crispy and beyond delicious! I got grilled chicken,roasted red peppers and olives.will be getting this on repeat!!!my boyfriend said he would order this instead of the regular pizza because it was so good. read more

We're Back Pizza - Gluten free pizza with grilled chicken,olives,roasted red peppers. Amazing - Pizza Near Me - Orange, Connecticut

Take out. Food was good but cold by the time we got it . Strongly recommend pick up .

I'm glad you're back! I used to go here all the time until it switched owners. I'm so glad the original owners are back. Don't let the name throw you off, it made me a little hesitant in going there, but I now regret not going back sooner. The Pizza was excellent. You once again have me as a return customer. read more

We ordered for the first time using the Slice app. I ordered a pizza (med. sausage light onion) and my husband ordered a crispy chicken sandwich which we customized by omitting the cheese and pickle and adding bacon. The food arrived promptly and the way we ordered it. The pizza was hot, nice thin crust and a generous amount of tasty sausage. The three stars was for my husband's chicken sandwich. The chicken patty was tough and gristly. He got three successful bites before he was done with the sandwich. I took a bite myself and did not want to chew it. The sandwich came with seasoned fries which was a nice surprise but they need to use a better cut/brand of chicken. read more

Employees very friendly and helpful. No ambiance- simple barebones place. Pizza okay. I found the dough very chewy. Their stuffed breads, calzones, and other items are very good. Prices are higher than average for this area. Equal to what you pay for the Big Three in New Haven. read more

Stopped in heading back from Boston to Philly. Small pizza with pepperoni and Stromboli with ham, pepperoni and salami. Absolutely delicious. We wanted to try New Haven style pizza. Perfect. We drove the leftovers 3 hours home and our son devoured them as well. One of the best pizzas I've ever had. read more

Love the food, clam chowder amazing pizza is so good, people are nice love the knots .

Great pizzas, stuffed breads, apps. Very tasty, good flavor. Good service, prices are reasonable. read more

We're Back Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange, Connecticut

Amazing! Original owner's are back, and pizza is better than ever. We went and got one of each of our favorite menu items just to be sure. Everything was awesome! Lasagne pie, NY BBQ, chicken Alfredo pie, GRANDMA PIE!! And the place looks great. So glad they're back... read more

We're Back Pizza - Chicken Alfredo with bacon! - Pizza Near Me - Orange, Connecticut

See all

I didn't care for it just my preference. The staff were very nice the pizza was mediocre.

Went for my first time last week. Enjoyed the pizza. I got a few different slices as well as a grinder. The bread is nice and crusty.

Only ever had takeout or delivered, but as far as pizza goes it's not bad. Nice crust, cooked well, sauce is a bit bland but any topping fixes that right up. The sausage pie is the best read more

Picked up 2 pizzas from here tonight for dinner! We had the Connie's choice (garlic, spinach, bacon, ricotta) and a sausage and garlic. Both pizzas were delicious and cooked great! read more

Went right at lunch time and they had fresh slices ready to go. Old ownership is back from 2019 and the pizza tastes as good as it used too. Highly recommend supporting a local pizza place that cares about its customers and wants to serve Orange. Looking forward to making this my regular pizza place for my customers read more

worst party pizza I have ever!!! Spent $150 on three sheets of bread!! I will NEVER SPEND MY MONEY THERE

awesome place free fresh load of bread and a snack while I waited plus the Foxon park fountain soda machine is still there.