This restaurant has become a neighborhood gem. I enjoy coming here to meet friends for pizza (well done so the crust is crispy) and wings and a game on the many TV's Food is pretty good, I tried a few items besides the pizza and wings and enjoyed them. They have different seasonal specials besides the regular menu. Staff are always perky and friendly. This is their third location, this building was a former neighborhood fire house. They maintained the fire engine doors which open during warm months and the decor is fire fighter themed. read more

See all

Stopped by Sunday afternoon around 1:00. The place was almost empty (first indicator). We simply ordered a large sausage pizza. That's it. Pizza came out relatively quickly however it was not "burn the roof off your mouth" hot nor was it large. Sausage tasted good but the crust was flavorless. I would rate 5/10. Service was SLOW however the waiter mentioned that a cook was injured so they were short staffed. Will give it one more try to see if this was a one off, but based on other reviews they need to up their game to survive. read more

See all

Great food, we ordered a plethora of food: chicken bacon ranch pizza, mozzarella, buffalo wings, salad and clam casino. Zero complaints. The staff was helpful, the food was good and there were plenty of seating options from bar, to booths to tables. The outside is an authentic firehouse and the inside has fire gear. I will definitely be back. read more

Fire Engine Pizza Co. - Bar Area - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

Excellent service... great food no wait and food was on point ..... great menu and great service food was great and drinks were great!

I went for a charity event for our local library. The decor is so fun as it is located in an old firehouse. This was the highlight. The service was friendly, but unfortunately slow. My friends and I ordered a few appetizers and a pizza. The fried mozzarella was small considering the high price but was good. The pizza oddly didn't lacked sauce, so we found ourselves dousing it in the sauce provided with the garlic bread.... which tasted like bread covered in melted cheese (no garlic whatsoever...hmmm.) The best thing we ordered was the eggplant rollatini. Sadly despite the acclaim I can't say I will return. read more

See all

First time trying Fire Engine Pizza Co. They have plenty of seating and a big bar in the center. We tried 5 different pizzas and they were all good! Nice place to stop for lunch and dinner. read more

Fire Engine Pizza Co. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

Food was mediocre at best. Pizza was fine but nothing to write home about It. The fact It is in an old firehouse is cool but service was not great either. Really slow and charged for 3 drinks we did not have. read more

After a vigorous hike, my crew and I were ready to refuel at Fire Engine Pizza Co. 2, a new hotspot that's been the talk of the town. Walking through the back door, we were greeted by a long desk that looked like it could be the dispatch center for pizza emergencies--perhaps to-go orders are a serious business here! The decor paid homage to the original fire department that once occupied the space, with vibrant red and yellow hues that made me feel right at home--a true firefighter's paradise! We were among the first to arrive for lunch, and with the bar completely empty and just a handful of other tables occupied, we were seated quicker than a firetruck responding to a 911 call. Our waitress was on the ball, taking our drink orders faster than I can slide down a fire pole. We opted for two lemonades and a local Tribus beer for me--nothing like a cold brew to quench the thirst after a hike! As I scanned the room, the fire department memorabilia and numerous TVs for game-watching caught my eye. The bar dominated the dining area, which surprised me; I half expected more tables for dining. Still, it was a great setup for enjoying a couple of brews alongside some chicken wings or a pizza. We placed our orders: a Caesar salad for my girl and a personal-sized pizza with bacon and onions for her granddaughter. For the main event, we went big with a large pizza topped with eggplant, bacon, and onions. The food arrived in a timely manner, and soon the place was buzzing with patrons eager to experience the new blaze in town. Now, let's talk about the pizza. The dough was fresh and delightful--definitely the star of the show! The Caesar salad, however, could have used a chill plate and a lighter hand with the dressing; it was more average than incendiary. I must commend the waitstaff for their cardio workout, sprinting up and down the stairs to the kitchen--talk about getting your steps in! They're shaping up like true firefighters, ready to tackle any emergency. In the end, we decided to skip dessert--our bellies were already full from the hearty meal. The prices were reasonable, making Fire Engine Pizza Co. 2 a solid choice for anyone in the area. With three new restaurants on our radar--Bonfire, Melbourne Café, and Fire Engine Pizza Co. 2--we're ready to keep our culinary adventure ablaze! So, if you're looking for a firehouse of flavor, this place just might extinguish your hunger flames--no hoses required! read more

See all

We were a party if four that sat at the bar last night. We did order a small pizza which was okay. I would definitely go back again and look more at the menu. The bartender Ilario was absolutely fantastic and he will be the reason I go back time and again. The bottle has a really cool setup. And I got to tell you The restrooms are top rated. read more

We live right down the road and frequently visit FEPCO! I can't say anything bad about this place everything is always 10/10. Service, food, drinks always amazing. We even came on Saint Pattys day and got shirts and hats! read more

Amazing pizza restaurant with a full menu and bar! This is more than your local pizza spot, it's a full service place located in an old firehouse! Parking is limited, find overflow on the street! Pizzas are New Haven Style, full Italian entrees with sandwiches and appetizers. A must visit. This new restaurant has long wait times, as it is new. read more

Went to Fire Engine Pizza Co to order a take out of Eggplant Rollantini and a Chicken Parm Dinner. When I got home I took what looked like 2 cardboard boxes out of the bag to serve for dinner I was shocked by what was in the boxes. The Eggplant was just thrown in a small box and the Chicken Parm was the same way with the chicken on top of the pasta with no foil or wax paper just in the cardboard box. I went to speak with the owner and showed him the pictures. The answer that I got from him was what is wrong with it. It looked like a Doggy Bag with leftovers from a sit down dinner. There was no extras such as bread or a small salad. This is not the first problem with this restaurant. I would just let it go until now. Will never order or eat here again. read more

Fire Engine Pizza Co. - Chicken Parm Dinner. Just the way I got it. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

Came here on a Wednesday night for dinner. I had high hopes for this place since it seemed to be a long awaited opening. I live on the west coast but was born in Milford so visit frequently and have waited for this to open. I'd love to be able to rate the food but we walked out since we waited almost 90 minutes for food that never showed up. We weren't offered bread during our wait, so I asked for bread and was brought some luke cold bread with butter that I needed a jack hammer to get through. The salad came out 30 minutes after ordering and it was nothing spectacular. Outside our entrees never arriving, the restaurant was freezing and the music was too loud so you could barely hold a conversation. Too many issues to just chalk up as a bad night. read more

We have eaten here 3 times. 1. Undercooked pizza 2. Cold calamari - salad was miniature for price. 3. Two taco salads take out no taco chips and had to go back for them $20 each $40 total skimpy serving no chips We're done ! read more

Classic wood fired pizza. Their sauce on the pizza is super flavorful! Perfect amount of char to the bottom of the pie. Would definitely go back! read more

See all

Ordered a cheese pizza to go, maybe it was an off night, but something wasn't right. Wasn't sure if it was the cheese or the sauce, but it tasted spoiled read more

Great food. Friendly wait staff. Love their pizzas and specialty drinks! Always a nice atmosphere.

Coming from a firefighter family I was beyond excited for the opening of this restaurant. Upon my arrival I was nothing less than impressed with the consistency in the theme through the decorations to the creative menu items. This place definitely deserves the 5 stars for atmosphere. However when it came to the food it was nowhere near expectations. We started with the loaded tater tots with only bacon on the side, however when we received the dish everything was disassembled. For the price of this item the portion size was really disappointing. It barely was enough for the group of 3. Not to mention there was also a piece of hair on the plate when it was served to us straight from the kitchen. We had ordered 3 entrees; Wagyu Burger, Spaghetti and Clams, and the Burrata Chicken Sandwich. The wagyu burger lacked flavor and barely had any lettuce or tomato on it. The chicken sandwich was tasty and the sweet potato fries on the side were even more delicious. Most importantly the spaghetti and clams was delicious, it had both amazing flavor and a good sized portion of clams. Overall service was pretty good except the fact that I saw several employees on their phones when I was entering and leaving the establishment. read more

Fire Engine Pizza Co. - This is a photo of the "loaded" tater tots - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

The chicken parm wasn't hot or crispy. The burrata chicken sandwich was a glorified chicken patty, wasn't hot and was on a hamburger bun. The chicken wings were rubbery and no sauce on them. Pizza was undercooked. $66 for all this. Will not be going back. read more

Went here for a late lunch and it did not disappoint! It was beautiful out so they had the garage doors fully opened which is a nice feature to have for good weather days. Service was friendly and efficient. The steak tip appetizer was seasoned and cooked well. The sauce that comes with them was also a nice bonus. They allow you to do half and half options for the pizzas which I really appreciate so you can try multiple pizza options at one time. We got a half margarita, half chicken bacon ranch pizza. As well as a half loaded mashed potato, half spinach and artichoke pizza. Both pizzas came cooked perfectly with just the right amount of char! They did not skimp on toppings either! The stand out was definitely the spinach and artichoke pizza, but honestly they were all delicious! Will definitely be a repeat customer! read more