This was the best pizza ever!!!! We eat pizza each year at whichever beach we go to. This will always be a favorite anytime we are near St. Augustine. Such friendly staff. Take out or deliver only. But so worth it. read more

Pizza was big and good for the price. Sauce was a little salty but the cheese was delicious. The crust was very good and pizza part is thin which I like. Got some Type of Pizza with spinach and ricotta.. delicious! read more

First time ordering from Tony's pizza. Total 'home run.' I'm a NY Style Pizza fan and the best way to compare of judge how good of NY Style pizza would be to order a simple pepperoni pizza. So I ordered a Supreme with pepperoni, sausage, onion, green peppers and mushrooms. Total 'home run.' Wife and I put a hurting on it last night and had leftovers reheated in the air fryer for lunch. Another home run. Tony's isn't really close to home but worth the drive for sure. Will be a repeat customer. read more

The Sicilian crust was great, thick with crunchy outside and soft/chewy on the inside. Really good sauce too. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Pretty delicious pizza and friendly service. Perfectly baked crust and the spices added to the pizza made it great. My son loved that with every bite he had pepperoni. read more

We ordered pizza with sausage and pepperoni. Absolutely delicious! Added some of the jalapeño poppers as a side. They did not disappoint! Great choice! read more

Great and friendly service! Pizza is so good the line can be out the door sometimes! Garlic bread is yummy! A great taste of New York in this part of Florida. read more

Some on Yelp have said it was not so good. But took a chance since it seemed to be either a 1 star review rating or a 4-5. Pizza was.good, tasty and done quickly. The interior was clean but oddly fashioned. I'd go there again read more

Best pizza, delicious toppings too. We had the meat lovers medium sized pizza. Had the large salad and 10 Buffalo wings. Everything was fresh and cooked to order. Can't go wrong with Tony's!! read more

Wasnt sure after reading mixed reviews. .but after being here at condos across street and being tired, decided to walk across street and grab something fast...got a small white pizza with garlic, spinach, and riccota. A tiny bit pricey with 3 toppings and side of ranch (17.65) but overall delicious. Nice family business. Super friendly and great customer service...and good pizza! read more

We stayed at the Beacher's Lodge across the street and for convenience we decided to walk over and try out Tony's. They have a cool family owned vibe going on inside. The server was very attentive and polite. The food was surprisingly delicious!! The pizza is just like something you would find on Bleecker Street in NY! The crust is crispy on the bottom, perfectly chewy in the middle with the right amount of sauce, cheese and toppings. The calzones are especially tasty as well. I recommend the Ham and Salami calzone. We will definitely return. read more

Incredible pizza. One of the best pizza crusts I have had in my life. The owner is also amazingly nice. We have been in town for only a week and have gone back twice so far. Can't recommend this place any more strongly read more

Super nice folks and amazing food. Quick and fresh from this family owned restaurant. They have the best white pizza around!

Awesome pizza. We have never visited St Augustine before and arrived late tonite and did not know where to eat. Tony's pizza hit the spot. The oregano seasoned it really well. Would recommend to anyone for takeout. Appears to be a family business. Wish this was in my neighborhood at home. read more

My husband and I were driving back to Ormond Beach from Saint Augustine and decided we would like a slice of pizza. My husband loves to stop at local pizza places and we found a gem here in Crescent Beach on A1A. On the day we were there he owner son waited on us. He was very personable and friendly and made a great pizza Would stop again if we are in the area. read more

Greek salad with dressing was extremely salty and I pulled 1 full cup of green olives off of it. Skimped on the darker olives which are higher quality. An extra large (there is no large) pizza with 3 toppings and 2 salads was $50. Too much money for the quality. Pizza was pretty good but again, extremely salty. read more

Warm and friendly gentleman on the phone made ordering efficient and easy. Food was ready and hot at the promised time. Toppings very generous. We ordered a pizza and baked ziti. Tastes perfect. A great place to grab a take-out meal for the beach. read more

Don't waste your time or money! As a local St Augustine business owner and resident, I try to support local. We usually stay away from the Chain places in town. My company does a lot of work on the island as well as crescent beach. We usually eat pizza from Violas down the street when we are in crescent beach. However, today we decided to give Tony's a try. We ordered a large pizza and wings. The wings were the worst I ever tried in my life, no exaggeration! They were $11 for 8 wings that were baked in the oven, undercooked, soggy and have no flavor. The pizza was bland and just not appetizing at all. I really hate to not support fellow, local business owners but I will never return to this place nor would I recommend anyone else! My employees and I are really not that picky so this was a bag experience for all of us to throw away our food. I would recommend going down the road to violas. read more

Wow! Delicious. I was headed into Publix hungry and weary when I looked over and saw Tony's Grand Opening Sign... so I decided I would go in and give them a try, and boy was I glad I did. No disappointment here. I ordered their 2 slices (cheese) and a drink lunch special (30 cents more for a topping) and let me tell you; I was licking my fingers the pizza was so good. It was the perfect combination of cheese, sauce, and spices ummm!!! and the crust... OMG the crust was soo good, it was like finding a treat at the end of the pizza. I was going to eat one slice and give the other slice to my kids... I ended up eating both slices. Can't wait to go back. read more

The first few times we went to Tony's it was decent. It's pretty pricey for what you get but there isn't much to chose from near by so we continued to go for convenience sake. One night recently we decided to call and order a pizza to go on our way back to crescent beach. We were 30 minutes away and Tony said the pizza would be ready in 30 minutes. We stopped to get gas so we were at least 10 mins late and expected to run in and get the pizza. When we got there it was like they forgot to put the pizza in. There was a whole group of his family there and maybe he did forget. He acted like we were inconveniencing him by ordering a pizza. I mean if you want to have a family party that's great but then don't take a to go order. We won't be back. Viola's makes a great pizza and isn't much further or Romano's on the beach is great too. read more

Very good pizza. I would only carry out from here as store was hot. We had a supreme and a half plain, half pep. Yum! Service was fast. We stayed across the street at Beacher's Lodge and I would say that it's a must have for one of our nights' stay. (We've been to Beacher's twice, and have had Tony's both times) read more

Surprisingly great pizza!!! They are not eating in at this time so pick up or delivery is a must! We met the owner in Isreal two years ago while he was visiting his brother. Invited us to eat at his restaurant when he found out we were visiting St Augustine! Wow was it worth it! The pizza is great- the best around and to prove it- the best pizza award for 2021 is proudly displayed on his counter! Thanks for the invite- we will always come back when we are in town-"your friend!!!" read more

Amazing Sicilian pizza here. It's deep dish and square. Any toppings you want. The service was awesome. I will return next time I am in Crescent Beach. read more

Got the veggie pizza here Saturday and it was excellent. A lot of pizza spots in and around this area but this spot is on point. Crust was just right and a lot of veggies. Actually having left overs now. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Ordered delivery last night, a medium margarita pizza and a salad. Delivery took over and hour and a half and the margarita pizza ended up being a regular pizza with sliced tomatoes. I don't consider that margarita pizza but apparently they do. Pizza was decent and the salad was ok, the salad dressing was awesome though. Probably wouldn't order again read more

This pizza was great! The fam is staying at Crescent Beach for the week and we were looking for somewhere to order pizza. We decided to try Tony's. We ordered a super supreme, a white, and a pepperoni. My husband and I picked it up. This spot is a little hole-in-the-wall type place, but the family that owns/operates it was SO NICE! Very sweet people. Our order was ready on time. If you're used to paying $10/pizza, this pizza will seem pretty expensive. It's about $16. Yes, it's a lot, but it was so good! I had a slice of the white (my favorite usually) and one of the super supreme. Both were excellent! Not what I expected from a tiny hole-in-the-wall place. The herb blend used on both pizzas was so delicious. The white pizza had a lot of ricotta on it, and it tastes FRESH! Not store-bought. I was happy to eat this pizza. I would've given them 5 stars if their crust was amazing. The crust was good, but an awesome crust would make this pizza pretty impeccable. Try it out! read more

Great food my husband said it was the best sub he ever had bar none. Pizza and spaghetti and chicken Parmesan for excellent went back twice while we were on vacation. read more

Excellent pizza! We always order one when staying in Crescent Beach. This time we tried the vegetarian supreme and I think it might be my favorite. read more

We just stopped in for a quick bite and the pizza was delicious! My mom and I got classic pepperoni. The pizza was thin and a little crispy, it was perfect! The service was also fast and friendly. :) read more

Good pizza.....skip the jalapeño poppers....get the garlic knots ....salad was really small portion

A must have on every beach vacation. Absolutely delicious. The staff is very attentive. And food is made fresh.

Sorry not sure about the other post, found the place to be rather dirty and run down with real competition not sure this place would make it just my honest opinion clean it up fellas. read more

Stopped in for an early lunch right at opening (time change had us hungry) and they were ready to go with a smile! The owner was EXTREMELY kind and the pizza was delicious. We had the small pepperoni mushroom pizza and it was so flavorful. Fresh mushrooms, fresh cheese, not greasy, piping hot and even the crust was amazing! They told us they have been open in the same place in Crescent Beach for 35 years. Don't let the humble shopping plaza fool you, it's delicious! Also, PIZZA BY THE SLICE until 5pm! Perfect for after the beach!! read more

Got a to go order last night. The pizza is the real deal & Greek Salad was just as good. If you are into Authentic New York style pizza, this is the place for you. read more

We went to Tony's for lunch during work one day. It was ok. I had the chicken parm sub. The portions were big I thought. Food tasted ok. It was nice n hot. The atmosphere was so so. read more

Best Pizza in all of St.Aug!! Tony's catered my nephew's 2nd birthday party and everyone loved all of the different pizza choices. Pepperoni and the supreme are my two favorites. Keep in mind they have small, medium, and Extra Large. Best to carry out here. I promise you, it will be some of the best pizza you've ever tasted! read more

This place knows how to make pies!! I love pizza and am being completely honest when I say it might have been one of the best of my life! So good we ended up ordering 3 days in a row! Save yourself the disappointment and just go with Tony's pizza!!! read more

The real deal! I knew we came to the right place when I saw a table of construction workers there for lunch! Red vinyl booths and a huge menu. Really good pizza!! Got 2 different pies, the supreme and the white, with a few alterations. Fabulous! We intended to come back for stromboli and calzone, but didn't get the chance. Nothing fancy, mom and pop pizzeria like in the old days. Highly recommend. read more

Have taken out from Tony's for years. I have always thought the pizza is some of the best I have had. Took out again tonight and was not disappointed. Crust is nice and crispy with plenty of toppings and sauce just spicey enough. Garden salad was crispy and tasty. Dressings are very good. The owner is just the friendliest guy on the beach! Store help is also friendly. The ambience of the restaurant is somewhat ethnic, but ok. Have not had other dishes. I will not hesitate to order from there any time. read more

Really good spot that I got a Togo order from. People are super friendly and the price is reasonable. Ordered the Sicilian with pepperonis and a Greek salad and was very pleased. The salad was spot on with fresh lettuce, combo of olives and feta. The pizza crust and cheese top notch and I recommend if you are in the area! read more