Ordered the Supreme. The order was going to take about 45 minutes from the time we called but it was a busy Sunday night during the NFL playoffs. The pizza was ready, hot, and delicious. Have been back already and plan to make it our regular pizza place this winter. read more

Not fresh ingredients. Service is nice and pleasant, very attentive. Ambiance is cheap- best for take away.. read more

Delicious pizza! We got the meat lovers and it was packed with meat. A little pricey but well worth it!!! Will definitely get it again on our next visit read more

Genuinely, my family and are are OBSESSED with Tonys Pizza. Everything we have tried is absolutely delicious (and we have tried majority of menu). You will be very pleasantly surprised with just how great each and everything there is to eat. Anytime we are in the area we order take out. I have NEVER left a Yelp review before... but that just shows how much we love everything on their menu. We own a condo in Coquina Condos down the road. We have Tony's on our list of recommended restaurants in the area to order food from. There have been so many times a renter of ours has reached out with a message about just how much they enjoyed the food there. You cannot go wrong ordering from here! read more

As a native New Yorker I know if it's good the moment I open the pizza box or unwrap my hot sandwich. I have not found many places in Florida that really do it for me with the exception of Tony's. This is a top level place I almost don't want too many people knowing about it lol. Everything, from the sauce, the flavor, the quality of the dough and breads is spot on. Simply Delicious!! read more

Tony's Pizza - Chicken Parm - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

We stay across the street at Beachers Lodge and always get pizza from Tony's on our first night. The white pizza is our favorite!

Vacationing in Crescent Beach and we had a taste for pizza so we gave Tony's a try. Tony's did not disappoint! The pizzas were delicious and so were the garlic knots. I love supporting small family businesses who take pride in their customer service and product. Tony's is great and I highly recommend them! read more

Okay why 5 stars for a pizza joint? Well; pizza. When you find a really good pizza place it is worth praising. And when you find a place as quirky and "hidden in plain site" you give more praise. We have been ordering from Tony's for years. Tony is jn a non-descript little strip mall just south of 206 and across the street from public beach access. The strip mall has a dog groomer (new), restaurant (kinda new) jce cream store, tattoo parlor and maybe something else. The whole strip is easy to overlook. And there is Tony's, which is also very easy to overlook. I mentioned that we order from Tony's; we don't eat at Tony's. You could , but it is small, and usually quite warm (not unusual for a pizza joint). They do deliver, but I like to pick up. It is a family business andbit is nice to see familiar faces when you pop in. Also, you get a brief education on humanites and an opportuto to expand cultural awareness. Alright; the food. The pizza is as good as you will find in Florida (i lived in NY for 5 years). The crust is just the right thickness and texture. The sauce is balanced and bright; not the usual dull musty red sauce you often find outside of pizza Mecca ;). The pies are very large so ask for advice on how many you need. The Greek Salad is very good and a side of meatballs with garlic bread is always a favorite. When in Crescent Beach i highly rec Tony's; you will not be sorry. But make sure that, at least once, you go and pick up. read more

Delicious Pizza! We got the Meat Lovers, Hawaiian and the Cheese Bread and it was all so so good! We have tried several other pizza places in St Augustine and Tony's is by far the BEST! read more

Too much grated parmesan cheese and mozzarella on unfinished cooked ravioli. I won't go back again

The pizza was great, true New York style pizza. Perfectly baked and topped. There is a nice choice of toppings here, ranging from your regular pizza topping to little ethnic true New York toppings. But beware, the toppings can get expensive. It cost us 32$ for a large pizza with 4 toppings. My only complaint was I wish they were open later. We stayed across the street at the condos and wanted a pizza around 10pm and they were already closed. read more

Called in to get a couple of pizzas and an order of garlic knots. It was ready in 20 minutes, for it home and it was GREAT! Hawaiian and a meat lovers are the way to go! We LOVE pizza and will order from Tony's again if we are back in St Augustine! read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

The place is a little dumpy and divey, however the pizza and service are phenomenal! We were originally planning to dine in, but since the joint was hotter than the worst Florida afternoon, we opted to take our order next door. Our order included a medium supreme, medium cheese and garlic knots (12 to an order). The $43 price tag shocked me at first, but due to the timeliness and freshness we were all left impressed. I tend to prefer pizza pies with more sauce than cheese. Tony's pie is covered in cheese and fresh toppings. It was crazy delicious! Even the crust had a perfect texture. Knots were also on point. As I previously stated, the front of house server hooked us up with great customer service. I'd recommend this place to anyone craving a no frills pizza joint. It's not fine dining by any means, but it'll get the job done! read more

Ordered pizza from here for the first time and it was simply unbelievable!!!! Best pizza I've ever had ever!!! Highly recommend!!

Solid, east coast style pizza that is worth the wait if you are in Crescent beach and hungry for some Za.

Got to Crescent Beach late on Sunday evening and wanted something quick. You can't go wrong with Pizza. Phoned ahead on the ride in. The young lady answering the phone was polite and helpful. Ordered a medium pepperoni, it easily fed two people and a miniature poodle (just some crust). Very tasty and under $20. I'd recommend it. The restaurant is small but "local." read more

Mediocre at best! I was hungry for pizza and lazy so I walked across the street to get dinner. I won't do that again.

Super good pizza very friendly service!!! If I am back in the area I will most definitely be going back!!

A small place located in a strip mall of 4-5 other small shops. Tony's has adopted a carry-out only approach, like many places post-Pandemic. We called our order in and was quoted an hour wait. As it was check-in day for us and many other beach goers, the wait was expected and accurate. We ordered the cheese bread and a medium sausage pizza. I arrived a few minutes before our quoted time. The order was hot and service was prompt. Nice folks working. The cheese bread had an ample amount of cheese and a good chewy crust. A really unique cut pattern, which created small cube size bits just right for dipping in marinara. The sausage pizza had a lot of cheese and what was described as beef sausage on it. We are accustomed to pork sausage, but really no difference here. A good sauce and crust with a chew. Tony's had a slew of boxes stacked on tables that used to be the dining room. I'd say they are doing good, with all that cardboard soon to hold some pies. We enjoyed our order, even with vacationer car lag. read more

First time here and I know I'll be back. I ordered a pepperoni pizza for pick up and when I got there was excited to see they have seating to have a sit down Italian meal! Pizza was great - NY style thin. The service was phenomenons which really made a difference for me. read more

Ordered the Supreme. The order was going to take about 45 minutes from the time we called but it was a busy Sunday night during the NFL playoffs. The pizza was ready, hot, and delicious. Have been back already and plan to make it our regular pizza place this winter! read more

I've been coming here for years and I absolutely love it. Easily the best pizza I've had. It's now my moms favorite place. The Ryder sandwich is a must have. If your staying in any of the condos south of 206 then you need to try this place before your vacation is over. The staff is very friendly and the food taste fresh so do yourself a favor and get some. read more

The pizza is good but a medium pizza that is gonna take a an hour and fifteen minutes for $35 is ridiculous, i will order from somewhere else, this place is a rip off!! read more

Wonderful customer service and delicious pizza! We had cheese bread as well and meat lovers. It was perfect to bring back to our beach rental. They even carried the steaming got boxes to the car for us. read more

This place had a great pizza. Hot, cheesy and just enough oil! It was just like eating a slice of pizza in NYC! thin crust and crispy. so great. I am lactose intolerant so it was worth the aftermath!! hahahah read more

If you order the pizza over the phone they wait till you get there to cook it takes 3 hours to get your pizza read more

Tony's Pizza - a deer in the grass - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Ordered pepperoni with mushrooms. Pizza well decorated with them and healthy amount of cheese and sauce. Priced good. Tony pleasant personality. I'd visit it again. read more

Pizza is extremely delicious. Definitely some good NY style pizza. Highly recommended! The only place to has Green Olives as a topping. TONY is very friendly. I have been to all restaurants and the pizza here beats them by far. You should check them out if you are nearby and I recommend getting garlic knots and the house Greek salad. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

I like this place, the pizza and the owners. I'd order one right now if I wasn't 3000 miles away. Order and pickup and enjoy. This is a nice place. read more

Food was absolutely delicious. Wasn't Sure at first, being this side restaurant. But definitely worth every penny and the owner/cashier was super friendly. Suggested the dessert at front register to, think it was called a baklava. Was amazing whatever it was. So much food too. Definitely over ordered. Had tons left over. Big portions for sure. Would love to get to eat here again before going back to TN, but next time If don't get the chance to. Was very good food. I would recommend. read more

Tony's Pizza - Eggplant Parmigiana dinner (also came with spaghetti side, it's the same size bowl filled full) - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Ordered two extra large pizzas today, one cheese, one pepperoni. Eleven people in the house, six vegan. Apparently they're not ACTUALLY VEGAN when it comes to seriously good pizza because both pies were gone in 60 seconds. Okay, maybe 15 min, tops. And when I say gone, I mean GONE, crust and all. I haven't had pizza THAT GOOD in a long time. Wish I lived here or Tony would move to where I live. If you haven't had their pizza yet, do it. You'll be happy you did! read more

First time dining here. No dine in tonight? Only carry out and delivery. The dining room is being used as a storage area for supplies - pizza boxes everywhere. Very understaffed for sure. Young guy at counter seemed overwhelmed taking orders face to face and over phone. Wait time approx. 1 hour. Not impressed with food unfortunately. read more

Apparently this place is very popular the pizza is supposed to be very good I chose a Chicken parmesan sandwich. Has to be the worst Chicken parm sandwich. Big roll lots of cheese and a lot of sauce And very little chicken not only Do I Mean not enough Chicken the pieces were cut in strips probably about three inches long The chicken had no flavor. I've had chicken parmesan sandwiches from here to Amsterdam from New York to California. This was a total rip off. $ 11.00 And $7 for a piece of Baklava. This will sound strange but I will go back and try their pizza. And hopefully I have a better experience. So with all that being said !!! let me say this. Try the Pizza. read more

Very solid pizza, I can't speak for the atmosphere or storefront in general but the pie is great! Ordered at 5pm on a Friday expecting a long wait for delivery. It took right at an hour which is what they estimated. Delivery driver called when he arrived as requested. Pizza was delicious and it was delivered hot. The butter garlic sauce was bland, just seemed like clarified butter. Everything else was awesome! read more

Tony's Pizza - Half Cheese Half Pep/Pineapple (Medium) - Pizza Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Fantastic pizza. Live locally and love getting a BIG pie from here. Secret is out though, they can get busy and run out of dough. But definitely worth stopping in. read more

My name is Lincoln I'm 21 years old. I never thought I would ever leave a review on yelp. My first experience at Tonys was incredible. The customer service was so amazing and the owner went above and beyond to make sure that my experience was amazing. On top of that the food is absolutely incredible. I would love to thank everybody that is part of Tony's Pizza because you all made my experience so amazing. We need more people like you in this world. read more

I am giving two stars based on the fact #1- menus that's were distributed in the hotel had incorrect hours of operation. Off by 2 hours ! #2 - When we looked up the website it said closing was 9 pm. Called numerous times ( both numbers) from 8:35 to 9:00 pm. Rang one time ,then busy signal. Both numbers ! The fact that they are located right across the street from the hotel , and the sign said OPEN is very disturbing. Called at least 20 times. Not a good impression and would not recommend. read more

We arrived at Beacher's Lodge Monday (6/29)and Tony's pizza was recommended by front desk as a great local pizza. Monday we ordered pizza and Stromboli....I'm not a Stromboli fan....but it was very good. So tonight (7/2) we ordered Stromboli again!!! My husband loves the marinara sauce read more

Staying at Bryn Marr RV Resort and didn't feel like going out for dinner. Staff recommended Tony's and we loved it. Ordered chicken Parmesan, large salad with their homemade Italian dressing and a large pizza. Delivery was quick, chicken and pizza still hot. Gave extra dressing. Would order again(maybe tomorrow!) read more

The pizza was absolutely flavorless. Crust overdone, the sausage was trash, the sauce was nonexistant. Avoid this place.