Last minute, much over due, date night. We have been wanting to check out The Prewitt since it opened, and it did not disappoint. The signature drinks were well thought out, with homemade mixers, and complex flavors. Our entrees were perfectly portioned, able to finish them and be comfortable with room for dessert if you wanted. After dinner as we were leaving, we decided to turn back around and head to the lounge for after dinner drinks. We will 100% be back to The Prewitt, and love having such a great restaurant in Plainfield. read more

See all

We ended up here after a flop of an experience at another restaurant. We had a fabulous time! The rooftop seating is so nice. Our server, Joe, was awesome. He recommended several different drinks and menu items and was an attentive server. We had great drinks and enjoyed our food. The short rib egg roll was really good. We will be back and recommend The Prewitt. read more

Stopped by for lunch with a party of 3 on a slowish Thursday. They were still the "soft opening" phase, I believe grand opening was the following night. The service was attentive and laid back which I prefer. We had the wagyu corn dogs and short rib egg rolls as starters and both did not disappoint. We each had a different sandwich and all 3 were very good and hardy portions. My fellow patron decided on dessert for the entire table even at my disdain. I'm glad he did because the biscuits with homemade apple butter were exceptional! Hats off to The Prewitt for a much needed break from the chain monopoly on US 40. read more

Came to the Prewitt to listen to the live music! Loved sitting in the lounge area..the lounge menu had a good variety for us to order from! Drinks were great and love the history of the place. Will definitely be back!! read more

The Prewitt - Steakhouses Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

WOW! We have visited here quite frequently. However, the steak that we had on 6/5/2024 was on point! I got the special they had that night, the surf and turf. The fillet was pure perfection. The live music on the rooftop was fabulous! And as always, Joe, our server is the definition of perfection when it comes to service. What an absolutely amazing experience! read more

Really enjoyed our first trip to the Prewitt. My husband and I went to celebrate our anniversary. We were offered free champagne, a very nice touch. We both got the special which was delicious. Our server was perfectly attentive. There is always a movie playing adding to a fun ambiance. We can't wait to come back and check out the roof top! We won't be waiting for a special occasion read more

Craft cocktails, seasonal menu and a great wine list. Great place for date night with my wife. We have not tried the rooftop dining yet.... But will soon. Bartender service was too notch. Looking forward to coming back in. read more

Went for the 1st time this evening. Sat in the bar and ate dinner and had fabulous smoked cocktails. The atmosphere was great (no TVs) so all the guests talked to each other. The bartender was great, the food excellent and we will be back! read more

The Prewitt - Charcuterie - appetizer 10+ - Steakhouses Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

I was not crazy about the food itself, but I love the appetizers I did not care for the lower restaurant part of the building, but that was just my taste.. read more

Steak and fries were great, service was quality! Ambiance was quiet and classy. Come check it out!

Went for dinner and show. We watched the Sax Guy and he was outstanding. We ordered the New York Strip, the King Salmon, the Chicken medallions and for dessert we ordered to share the Sticky Foot and the expresso cheesecake. Everything was delicious, service was a bit slow but with only one waiter it was understandable. And we were not in a hurry. Nevertheless Johan was cordial and friendly. We enjoyed the music, the food and the company. read more

Having grown up in Plainfield, I feel like Plainfield is the place that independent restaurants go to die. There just aren't many options if you want to go somewhere that isn't a chain. So I was really excited for The Prewitt. Not only because it's not a chain, but because it is an ambitious project that takes a historical space and redeems it for community use. My wife and I went to The Prewitt on our first date since having our daughter. I called and made a reservation day of (they weren't doing walk ins at the time I think). The renovations are amazing. There are a lot of spaces for sitting and sipping while you wait to be seated. Whether in the lobby, their bar, or in front of the stage, order an app and a drink and settle in. They were playing the Santa Clause on screen which was a fun activity while waiting for food. The bread basket is a thin crisp popcorn cracker with some butter. A little too much butter served for the amount of cracker. Not filling at all but a fun taster. I got the butterscotch rootbeer old fashion. Really fun simple syrup. I would have it again. The actual dinner menu is honestly disappointing. There just isn't a lot on there that is not a risk to order. I wish they had some more options that did not take something familiar and add something exotic on top of it. Of course I want most of the menu to be exciting and new. But there needs to be a level of familiar that mitigates the risk of ordering a couple new dishes. I would recommend ordering from the bar for some of the more familiar food, trying one main dish with a loved one, and enjoying a fun drink and dessert. Looking forward to trying the better looking Brunch menu. read more

I was very excited to try the Prewitt mainly for the nostalgia. I grew up in Plainfield and the movie theater was one of our hang outs. I loved when I walked in it seemed like I stepped right back into the 80's woth the ticket booth and restrooms right where I remembered them. My friend and I had a reservation for 445 on a Thursday and we were seated right away. We were in the upstairs dining area and it was very nice and cozy. Loved seeing the rooftop dining area and would like to go back again and sit in the area overlooking US 40. Loved the mural on the wall that looked like a hallway. It was so cool. Our server came out right away and she was awesome. Very attentive and knowledgeable. I could tell she had served before and asked her where and she said Coachman. I knew I recognized her and now I can't remember her name to give her a shout out (I want to say Sarah). She recommended some cocktails to us. I had the one twenty one old fashioned. It was delicious. My friend had the SBNTS and she enjoyed that as well. She then brought out a "gift" from the chef and it was popcorn crisps with truffle butter. The crisps were unusual and I didn't love them but the butter was tasty. I would rather have some bread. I have to admit the menu isn't what I'm used to so I decided to play it safe and get the burger and fries. My friend did the same. It was good. Was it $22 good no. It was no better than Bru Burger or any other high end burger place but the price was really steep. The burger patty itself I thought was somewhat overshadowed by the big potato roll. Definitely a eat with your fork and knife. The fries were very heavily seasoned They would've been much better without so much of the seasoning. I couldn't even taste the fries for the seasoning. So with one cocktail and a burger and fries with tip was a whopping $48. Most expensive burger I've ever had! With all that said I would like to return again and take the hubby and try the tri tip steak. It would be nice to have some more regular options on the menu like a steak salad and baked potato. The bottom line is I just might not be cut out for fine dining! We did have an overall good experience and the service was outstanding along with the cocktail. Oh and it was a week before Christmas so our server gave us a candy cane for an after dinner mint. That was a nice touch. The building is just awesome! read more

See all

Full disclosure, we went for brunch, haven't sampled the dinner menu. I don't want to sound harsh, but there were 4 of us for brunch and we were all underwhelmed. The place is beautiful, and we will definitely give them another chance. Went close to their grand opening, so I hope the bugs are worked out. I really want this place to succeed. read more

We had our first dining experience here last night. The food was incredible! The service was amazing. Our waitress Maggie was the best. Can't recommend this restaurant enough! read more

See all

Amazing place and food . You will keep going back . The people are very friendly and will make sure you have everything you need. You have to see it to appreciate it . One of the most unique places I have seen . Roof top dinning , a wonderful Lounge. Main floor shows movies , concerts and has live music. We live about 5 miles from it . No need to ever go down town again. Did a mention the amazing food. read more

So good! We loved the movie theater vibe and the gourmet food! We did a wedge salad, a few flat breads and burrata! Our waitress was great! read more

See all

The service was amazing! Food was outstanding. And the vibe was great! Loved the talent they had playing the stage. had the short rib egg roll, short rib dinner and lamb shack all so delicious. I think we found our new Westside spot. read more

See all

What a miss. Had a 6:30pm reservation, got sat at about 7:15pm. The hostess kept telling everyone the wait would be "a couple of minutes". Had their house old fashioned made with popcorn syrup, it just tasted like the popcorn syrup, couldn't tell if there was any bourbon in it at all. My wife had the "sweet but not too sweet" and it was indeed Far too sweet. I had the short ribs, they were way over cooked to the point that it was essentially bad pot roast and even worse it was just soaked in bbq sauce and that sauce wasn't good either. And to top it all off there was live music. That live music was far too loud. There is apparently an upstairs and downstairs, so theoretically seating away from the music, but it wasn't offered. I would never go back or recommend it to anyone. *update to respond to the business owner: we were not offered the rooftop seating and didn't know it existed and had to wait 45 minutes after our reservations to get the seated anywhere. And again most importantly, the food and drinks were all pretty bad. read more

This is my second visit to the Prewitt. I am very happy that Hendricks County has this restaurant. The food is so good and different. It is nothing like the restaurant chains that dominate most of Hendricks County. It is not the cheapest place, but you will have a great meal in a nice atmosphere. read more

Great food and setting, live music on roof top. Our server Hannah was top notch, excellent knowledge of menu, tremendous recommendations. Swordfish risotto was excellent. Highly recommended will be back.Keep working on the wine list....more value choices. read more

The ambiance was great, however the service was slow and unprofessional. The wrong food was brought to our table and once we received ours, it was a bit cold. The server said they were still figuring things out and no manager visited our table. Horrible sewer smell in the restaurant. This was brought to managements attention the very next morning, and their only explanation was we can't control the sewer smell and offered no solution to our issues. We spent over $300 for 4 people. Very limited menu. read more

I had a girlfriend visiting from out of town and thought this would be a really unique place to take her to brunch. I had been following the renovations of this charming movie theater and having an open reservation for brunch worked out perfectly for us. Lets start with the aesthetics of entrance, very clean, simple and chic, the framed double doorway into the theater/dining area gave a dramatic entrance that made you feel like you were really stepping into an experience. We had a Christmas movie playing with a low volume as to not interrupt a conversation, such a cool way to pay homage to this historical building while dining. The menu was extremely clever using a script influence and the selection for brunch was plentiful. You are not going to receive a large dining plate with a traditional breakfast if that is what you are looking for, however you will be very satisfied in the serving of whatever you choose. I had the Bees and Gees, which was a lavender biscuits with chorizo gravy that had a few grilled onions and some micro sprouts of sorts. It was very delicious once I got over the initial punch of Lavender. The hint that I was expecting was overpowering because it was so unexpected, but it was a very wonderful dish. My friend had the dutch baby egg dish and was also very impressed. The only thing that I was a tad disappointed in, was the service. Although the server was delightful it took nearly 20 minutes to be greeted and her visit to the table while we were dining was like a pass by that didn't give us enough time to ask for another beverage. The bottled water was a nice touch but it was room temperature and not refreshing. Keep in mind that I understand it is still fairly new and she may be learning a new job, she was very lovely. It wasn't a flaw at all or didn't spoil our visit what so ever . Looking forward to a romantic anniversary dinner with my husband next week, I have a feeling we are going to be very pleased! read more

The place looks cool and the live entertainment was good. The food, however, is way overpriced. I got the pasta in mushroom sauce and was served half a bowl of overcooked pasta, maybe five slices of mushrooms, very little sauce, and two tiny pieces of bread that were hard as a rock. For $21, I at least expect a full bowl with sauce and a decent-sized piece of bread. I was hungry again two hours later, which should never happen after pasta. The cocktails were also overpriced and served in the tiniest glasses I've ever seen (like maybe two shots worth of a mixed drink). Won't be returning. Would rather go to one of the many Mexican restaurants in town where you can get good food, decent portions, and an entire pitcher of margaritas all at a decent price. read more

Great service from Kay! The crispy burrata was the best I've ever had. Great appetizer. The burger royale was also very good.

food was very nice and out of the ordinary! short ribs were especially good. Service was adequate but I wouldn't have expected the servers to hand plates to us when we are paying $150 for the meal. the atmosphere was ok but noisy but when the music and musician played it was unbearably loud. don't go here if you expect any conversation read more

We had very high hopes for this place and I am so disappointed. The menu is very upscale and quite limited - which implied that the service and quality would be top notch. Maybe we hit an off night, but our party of six all had cold or over cooked food. Our waiter never checked on us. We ordered wine and our waiter wasn't able to open the bottle - we wanted a second bottle right away (party of 6) he failed to bring it. Hoping they get staff trained up and work on getting the food up to the standard the price suggests it should be. read more

Love having a place in Plainfield for live music, can check the line up of movies or artist for the night on their website. Menu changes which for us is great, the swordfish on their right now is delicious. read more

We held a community event at The Prewitt in November and were so very pleased with their service, the quality of the food, and the beautiful ambiance of the venue. Thank you so much team Prewitt! read more

I went there last night for the first time, because I heard they have trivia, which was a lot of fun. The atmosphere was great and the service workers were very friendly at first. For a restaurant that was as slow as they were I was surprised by the wait time. I was also feeling an underlining sense of misogyny from the service workers while I was sitting with my male friend. There were a lot of assumptions being made by every worker and they only made eye contact and spoke with him not me (female). The food was also EXTREMELY OVERPRICED. I got 5 medium size shrimp in my shrimp cocktail for $18! The Caesar salad was $12 when it was $5 quality. The food together should've been about $10. I was very disappointed and regretful when paying. I will never eat there again. The pink cocktail was delicious though. I now understand why the restaurant was empty. If I return for trivia, then I will only have drinks. read more

The Prewitt - Steakhouses Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

It's a cute place and I like the idea of it, but I wouldn't Recommend if you are a picky eater such as myself. Charcuterie board was good. Little pricey. read more

First time here. I stopped by with no reservation on a Thursday evening during prime dinner time and they were able to seat me with no problem. I felt like the menu was ample, covered all the bases but wasn't overwhelming. I chose the roasted half chicken which turned out to be a really good choice. My hostess, Heather, was delightful but when I asked her if I could substitute something for the mashed potatoes (diabetic issue) she had to go talk to the chef to get his approval first. I thought that was a little awkward. I was delighted when she came out and said I could have broccolini instead. The chicken was out of this world delicious! The broccolini was a little tough but since it wasn't normally part of the meal I can't complain. The atmosphere is unique and in my opinion kind of cool. Overall I thought $28 was just a little bit steep for a half chicken and no-salad, but certainly not outlandish, especially for the quality of the food. Overall, great food, great service and unique ambiance. I give it two thumbs up and I'll be back sometime read more

See all

Met after work with some co-workers for appetizers and drinks. Enjoyed our time together in this cool setting, if you have not been yet check it out! I recommend the Diablo and the Savannah drinks read more

Horrible absolutely horrible. Have been now multiple times and disappointed each time. The service every time has been very slow but of course apologetic staff. Doesn't help waiting at least 15 for drinks. Should've given up then but we ordered food and the food was not good. Steak couldn't have been cooked any longer, the potatoes were burnt but the carrots were pretty good. The ambiance is about the only thing good going for them. My suggestion is to simplify their menu and stop trying to be something they are not. Only go for a drink read more

I really debated on whether or not to write this review, but here we go. We had an 8pm reservation for Friday night during Devour. Our party of six was seated promptly and were provided with phenomenal service by Brock who was our server. The drinks were very good and we all enjoyed every single cocktail as well as the ambiance. It took quite a while to receive our appetizers but they were also good; we got the Brussel sprout dip and the burrata. When it came time to order our entrees we were informed that several dishes were not available, my guess is because they had overlap with their devour menu. 2 of us ordered steaks, 2 ordered the salmon, one ordered the short rib bowl, and one got the vodka sauce pasta. It took quite a long time for the food to come out and our server was struggling to professionally cover for obvious back of house issues. When our food finally arrived, it was all awful. Steaks were under seasoned and quality was lacking. Salmon was also poorly cooked, under seasoned, and pale. Pasta overcooked, and part of the short rib bowl was unavailable and the mushrooms substituted. I got a side of Brussels sprouts which were also poorly cooked and under seasoned. To say we were profoundly disappointed is an understatement. This was more of a meal that one would expect at Applebee's or a similar restaurant. Due to the time we waited none of us wanted to complain and simply wanted to leave. The salmon also made my wife violently ill a short time later. This is not an accusation I level lightly, as I know there can be many causes. However, we have iron clad stomachs and the only thing that could've cause this was the salmon, which noted on the menu is cooked to medium rare level due to it being sushi grade. I can confirm, it most certainly was not sushi grade. We had been looking forward to visiting as we had all heard great things about this place. It's fair to say that none of us will ever make to drive from downtown to frequent this place ever again. TL;DR, go for a cocktail and eat elsewhere. read more

My husband and I selected The Prewitt for our anniversary dinner. the setting was theater-themed, lounge-like, and unique. When the server recognized the occasion, he offered us a complimentary champagne toast. That was unexpected. There was a distinctive buzz that I always associate with a good restaurant. The food was delicious, properly presented, and timely. We're definitely going back! read more

My fiancé and I were looking forward to a movie night and finally getting to go to try this newer restaurant. I've never been as disappointed in an experience as I was in there Christmas movie night. We walked in and the ladies at the front desk were bickering with each other on where to sit people. After we were given a table we sat at our table for 40 minutes before a server came to give us a menu and fill up our water cups. We paid $15 a ticket for a movie we couldn't hear and then they moved a large party in front of us so we couldn't see it either. We waited for our popcorn it was never brought when we asked we were told "oh sorry it's burnt so you probably don't want it anyways." Our food came out finally as the movie was already over. My fiancé paid $16 for a bacon and cheese only hamburger that came out extremely dry and almost burnt. The burgers were extremely small on the bun that it didn't even fill him up. It was crazy to pay $16 for that and it not even come with a side. We paid $61 for over done food and small portion sizes. Then on top of that we paid $30 for a movie we couldn't hear or see, not to mention it was a movie we had already saw before but were excited for a movie and dinner experience. I think a movie and dinner could be a great idea but the effort by staff and the overall experience was awful. We love to support local but it's hard to come back after an experience like this. I reached out to management via email about this experience the next day and still a month later have yet to hear back. I do not recommend wasting your money and especially not on there "movie night." read more

One of the most disappointing restaurant experiences of recent memory. Reservations were for 6:45, we were seated 7:15. The charcuterie preordered for the table was uninspired and very disappointing. Placing and getting our order was painfully slow. The food was pedestrian. Any home town cafe has more flavor and flare than this supposed elevated high end restaurant. The atmosphere is excellent, set in an old theater in Plainfield Indiana. Plenty of nostalgia. But the service and the food were more on the scale of a food truck going out of business. This could be an amazing venue. The head chef seems to lack the sophistication of truly inspired cuisine. There must have been an anomaly on this visit since most reviews are good. Maybe the kitchen staff did not show up. But we weren't the only patrons with a bad experience this night. First impressions are sometimes the only impression. And the fact this enormously bad experience even happened speaks volumes about management. read more

Exactly what the west side needs, and non-Westsiders should venture out for. Atmosphere is great and honors the history of the building. For those wanting a quieter experience, request the upstairs, it's a more quaint environment with its own bar and a few tables. We loved the fusion of classic dishes with a unique flare. The staff were all kind and welcoming. We will definitely frequent this place, kudos to the team! read more

The food and atmosphere are fantastic. I loved every course, and their cocktail are outstanding. The live music was excellent. The Prewitt exceeded my expectations. I usually go to downtown Indianapolis for dinner, and the Prewitt is just as good, if not better, than some of my favorite spots. Everyone is so welcoming. The service was wonderful. We can't wait to return! read more