The Conch House Restaurant was great. We arrived expecting a long wait, they said 25-35 minutes, and took us less than ten to get seated. Our waitress was wonderful, her name escapes me, but she was great. I had the Minorcan Smash burger, which was great! Mark had the nights special of a grilled fish (mahi?) It was wonderful! It was a bit chilly, the wind was blowing. The palatable (sp?) style tables were adorable! read more

See all

We're locals and this was our first time here, we took my parents as they came for a visit for my birthday. Ambience is really cool. Perfect for a casual night out. Bar was hopping, live music. It's giving outdoor tiki which we loved. Food was decent, on par with every other seafood restaurant in Florida. Our waitress was great. On to the negatives - the hostess stand and or management is disorganized. Came up at 8:20 and asked for a table of 4. We inquired about an over water tiki hut and were told they stop seating those at 8pm because it gets dark. That's fine. Was told a 45 min wait, we agreed to join the list through yelp. We asked for first available, indoor or outdoor. On the plus side, the wait ended up being closer to 30 mins. However, there were tons of free tables the entire time we waited. Tiki huts were empty. The whole inside only had 2 tables sat. We asked to see a menu while we waited and got an audible sigh and eye roll. When our table was called, the hostess called 4 other groups at the same exact time, leading to a lot of confusion. As we are sitting and eating (it's now 9:30) a couple walks in. They're led to a table on the patio and asks to go into a tiki hut instead, which they are promptly sat in after they clean it off. So we asked our waitress, what's the deal! She said oh just ask the hostess and they can put you on the list for those huts. So not sure what happened. Overall- ambience 8/10 Food 7/10 Service (waitress) 10/10 Management (hostess) 4/10 Not sure if we'll go back because of the disorganization, unnecessary wait times, and rude hostesses. read more

Came out to see a band play and it was a time! In all the years I've been in the area I had never really been to see a band here! The drinks were great. And some were quite a heavy pour... if you're into that kind of thing. And the lines in the bar area out back went pretty quick and the service was lovely. However the food was a different story. We were told a certain amount of time and it ended up being about double that. I heard the same story from others as well. We had to order basically "to go" inside and wait and take it outside to our table. Fine process. But LONG. The food was pretty good tho. Can't rush tasty food. It would just be nice to have a more accurate time. If you say 15 mins I'll just wait there. But when it's nearing 40 mins and now I've missed some of the band - that's a bummer. I would have just gone back out and came back to check in. Idk. There has to be a better process there somewhere. It won't keep me away tho! read more

The Conch House Restaurant - Caribbean Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Came and were seated immediately! They have great indoor and outdoor seating, we sat outside in a cabana which was really nice. The calamari and shrimp bake were our starters and were very hot and fresh! I had the island hopper salad with blackened salmon and it was SOOO good, the perfect summer salad. My friends also enjoyed their meals. I'd definitely recommend if you're ever in the St. Augustine area read more

See all

Amazing food. Amazing service. Amazing drinks. Sitting in the tiki hut is the only way to go for the best vibe! read more

See all

What a great place!! Unique and beautiful outdoor seating. My husband had their chicken sandwich and I had their pasta (added shrimp ) Sooooo tasty and great service too!! Being in the water... you may want to bring a light jacket or sweater if you're outside in the early evening. Cute and classy gift shop reeled me in too The claim to fame is definitely their KEY LIME ‍ pie x1000 Thee very best key lime pie I have ever had in my 56yrs of life read more

See all

This is the spot if you want to dine by the water. Amazing views, great service, cute decor, and good food. My dad and I came for an early dinner on the patio and later discovered there's a separate bar area right out on the dock. They don't serve food out there, just drinks, but it's such a cool space. It felt like a little nautical speakeasy. I ordered a Caesar salad with blackened chicken and honestly wasn't too impressed. My dad got the conch club and the flavors were great. The chicken on his sandwich was actually more tender than the chicken on my salad. We also ordered a side of hush puppies, which I usually don't go for since I'm not from the South, but they were surprisingly really good. We went on a slower weeknight, but I was impressed by how massive the parking lot is. It definitely seems like they can handle a big crowd. Overall, a really nice spot for the views and atmosphere. read more

See all

Wonderful views, delicious food and drinks, and friendly quick service. What more could you want on vacation! Easily a great place for some drinks and live music or a nice outdoor meal for a date or family gathering. read more

See all

Great place for a nice dinner. We came here around 6 pm on Saturday. They don't take reservations. We were seated immediately. It was a cold rainy day so we sat inside. They have a nice menu with different options. I had market fish tacos. They were pretty good. Fish was fresh and cooked well. Service was friendly and attentive. They also have some unique drinks. Ambiance is laid back. We also ordered smoothie for our child and that wasn't good at all. Was pure sugar, and seems like was made from some premade stuff and not from fresh fruit. Other than that we were happy with everything else. read more

See all

This cool restaurant is accessible by boat and car. There are neat "high rise" dining areas on the outside deck and spacious indoor dining though the indoors can be a bit noisy depending on the parties dining there. Staff is friendly and very efficient. We started with a cup of their World Famous Minorcan Conch Chowder that is spicy, tangy, and delicious! Our Banana Pepper Calamari was a crispy delight. My Fried Shrimp Platter was so good, I ate it all. Normally have to take some home from getting too full. Not today, this was too darned good and I totally stuffed myself. My husband's Caribbean Chicken Sandwich was just as good. This is a great place to take a date, friends and family, or even a group of party goers. Enjoy the lively ambience and excellent food! read more

See all

Food and service great, great atmosphere with beautiful views and live music. Only negative is they don't take reservations so we never go for dinner, always lunch when it's least busy. read more

Food was 5 stars!! Our server, Amber was the best! We are a group of 8 from all over the U. S. Came here on a girls trip. I highly recommend this place! read more

The Conch House Restaurant - Caribbean Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

We come to Saint Augustine every year for a week and stay at the beach and several years ago. We went to the house and just were very disappointed. Haven't been back until this week. The appetizers which we had was wings were pretty good but the shrimp tacos were extremely overcooked, and one of our fried shrimp plates was very undercooked. It was doughy and not set. I do not think we will be going back after too bad experiences and over $100 meal. read more

This review concerns the music booking at the dockside bar. Conch House is one of our favorite places, often there are full bands on Fridays, which should be the case always, versus a single musician. It is such a beautiful and fun environment for Friday happy hours and that deserves a full proper band/entertainment. However, it seems there is often booking of solo acts on Fridays which is very disappointing and questionable. Solo booking is likely a profit play that will cause long-term patrons like us to go elsewhere. It is simple--Don't kill your golden goose, book only full bands on Friday. read more

The food is amazing and the view is beautiful! We enjoyed the food so much that we came back a second night! read more

The Conch House Restaurant - New Orleans Salmon - Caribbean Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Responded promptly, fair quote for the job, and coming next week to do the work and see the property. I am so grateful for the quick response. read more

I guess I never finished my first review! Second time was just as good. Ordered the same thing LOL The only thing is no hard alcohol til 1. So I drank wine. Next time it's a rum drink for me. We have been wanting to try The Conch house and there is usually always a wait. We happened to be in town on a weekday and thought we would give it a try. It was a great idea! No wait, fast friendly service. I ended up with a shrimp salad wrap with cucumber and onion salad. We started off with cracked conch. Everything was great - fresh and very satisfying. I can't remember our server's name but she was great. We will definitely be back but next time we want to sit in a tiki hut table. They looked fun! read more

The Conch House Restaurant - Shrimp Salad Wrap and cucumber onion salad - Caribbean Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

No matter how busy they are the wait is usually not that long unless you're waiting for a palapa table, and you can always go down to the end of the pier and get a drink and sometimes there's a Caribbean reggae band playing down there. Get a tropical drink and check out the crow's nest. Fabulous views of the marina, and if you have a boat, even better, tie up for lunch. The menu is pretty standard I would say nothing special, but I sort of feel that way about most of the restaurants in town. The clam chowder however was DELICIOUS, and I could've just stopped there and been as happy as a ... We've been here many times and the service is always next level. These servers have a really tough job running up and down those stairs with giant trays and they're always super friendly and attentive. They must do extra service training with their people and it shows. It's really a perfect place to go on a sunny day. read more

The Conch House Restaurant - Parents in the tiki table with the marina behind them - Caribbean Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

The Conch House Restaurant has such a beautiful view from the cabana seating! We ordered the fish tacos and banana pepper calamari which were more than enough to share between two people. We loved the hot sauce that was provided and honestly preferred it to the banana pepper sauce. Our server was so kind and knowledgeable about the menu as well and was honest with us about his favorites on the menu. I loved my experience here. read more

See all

We love it here! It's where I like to bring my out of town visitors. It's nice to get away from the craziness of downtown and have the beautiful view of the water. Everything we've ordered has been wonderful! read more

Lovely tiki-inspired restaurant & bar with local seafood and lovely wait staff. If in the St Augustine Beach area, recommend you give it a try! Oh ... and the kids will appreciate the alligators! Live display in support of the local Alligator rescue farm 1.5mi away! Cool place ... sorry no food photos - too busy eating and forgot to take. read more

See all

The best atmosphere and food. The service is always great and if there is a wait it does not matter because it gives you a chance to walk the pier and enjoy the water views. read more

Worst restaurant experience since relocating to Florida. Maybe an off day because of the weather. I was served fish tacos that sat underneath a heat lamp, wilting the lettuce (slaw) and toasting g the corn (salsa). Supposed to be lime cream sauce was actually tartar sauce. Cilantro rice was just rice pilaf. Husbands Cuban was inedible (taste). Ham was just poor quality. Hard no. No we don't complain. We just paid the bill and left. We won't be back. read more

This is a great place to have a drink and/or getting a bite to eat. We had no wait time for a table. We got a table outside with a nice view. Our waitress was a ball of energy. Over the top friendly and all smiles. I had family in from out of town and they wanted some fresh seafood. They were very pleased with everything they order. I really enjoyed the fried chicken. Unfortunately none of us had room for dessert. read more

The Conch House Restaurant - St. Augustine Fried Dátil Chicken - Caribbean Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Food: The Grouper sandwich was amazing. A nice prince of fish perfectly seasoned. The fried shrimp had a large amount of fried shrimp. Everything is amazing when you add Conch house Datil sauce! The keylime pie had a weird jelly/Jello consistency (5/10). So I was not a fan. Service: Super friendly and responsive. Ambiance: Great beach vibe. Awesome "treetop" seating. We sat Inside in the Ac because it happened to be super hot inside. Good for kids. And they handle large parties well. We came on the boat and docked. Super easy. Will absolutely come again read more

My wife and I stopped in here with two of our friends living in Saint Augustine. I wish I would've taken pictures of the actual dishes as they were fabulous! We opened with adult beverages and then had conch. Fritters. My dish was a salad that had jerk flounder on it. Absolutely delicious! Super traffic place to take people! We look forward to coming back during our next visit! read more

See all

Great recommendation from a local! Started with a great rum runner, add the dark rum floater! Fried conch app, then had the conch chowder, entree was the flounder(Salt Run Catch style, amazing!), and finished with the key lime pie. My wife and I split the entree and dessert and we were both very full! Great service by a local waitress that gave great advice. And the vibe was low key and very relaxing! Nice breeze from the water. There also have a nice tiki bar down from the main restaurant that serves just drinks and you can watch the fishing boats come in. Thanks Elysia Carter! read more

See all

Most of the food was good. Our server, Jessie, was really fun and sweet. I'm disappointed ,because one of our party members is vegetarian and tasted seafood in the sauce of her pasta. She didn't eat, but 2 bites the manager refused to remove it from the bill. Sadly, we were on vacation for my birthday and this was a down point read more

The Conch House Restaurant - Lobster Mac& Cheese. - Caribbean Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Our experience was disappointing overall. Our server, Erica, was quite slow throughout the meal and never informed our table that an automatic gratuity had already been added to the bill. Because of that, everyone in our party tipped on top of the included gratuity, resulting in us being charged double tip without realizing it until afterward. When we requested a printed itemized receipt to review the charges, Erica disappeared and we had to ask another server for assistance. The food was good, but the service and lack of transparency surrounding the gratuity overshadowed the meal. To management's credit, they did follow up afterward to address the issue, which we appreciated. However, customers should be clearly informed when gratuity is automatically added so situations like this do not happen. read more

We got there at 2 pm on a Monday, no line, or wait-list. We were told that no one was in front of us, she was just waiting for a hostess to come back to seat us. She took my name and number and I received confirmation of being #2 in line for a table. We waited 20 minutes, 4 groups came and were seated. I checked my wait-list status and received a message that I was no longer on the list. I think they messed up and didn't want to just tell me. I went inside to inquire on how much longer and why I couldn't access my wait-list status (even though I was told there was no one in front of us).... & we were immediately seated, at a table directly in the sun. I should have requested a different spot. The waitress was very sweet and attentive. The smoked fish dip was not good. The shrimp tacos were pretty good. But the entire experience would make me not go back. The food was not worth the cost. read more

Our dinners, we did Fish & Chips because it was one of their specials today. The fish was beer battered Flounder, very flaky and excellent taste. Instead of normal fries they do wedges and they were the best I have ever, yes ever, had. Served with a nice cold slaw. Try the key lime pie .... great. Our server did a good job on checking on our needs. I would however offer this piece of advise to the manager, get over yourself! I thought it was extremely rude to walk around the dining areas, make direct eye contact with your customers and not offer some sort of acknowledgment. How about asking how our dinner was, etc. read more

Service and food were great. Would definitely recommend. We have eaten here 2 years in a row while passing through.

The food was delicious! The service was amazing and I loved how the tables are spread out. They have live music after 3:00 at the marina. I loved the view of the water while eating! read more

The Conch House Restaurant - Shrimp & Grits - Caribbean Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Great food, Great Service, Great history, and Outstanding vibe! The food was delicious but the views were what the experience was all about read more

See all

The worst experience ever on Mother's Day!! The management staff was the rudest I have ever experienced in any restaurant I have ever been to in the USA!! I will not waste my time with the details but I will tell you for their high prices and below mediocre food they are in no position to treat diners the way they treated my family!!! read more

Blackened mahi was not spicy as claimed and did not taste well. The collard greens actually tasted better than the entree. The signature rum drink, goombay smash, tasted like bitter orange juice. Overall, the preparation of the meal and drink was done in haste and lacking in flavor and expired seasoning. Not to mention, our server brought out just one dish and provided two plates to share. We placed an order for two. read more

Sitting outside in tiki huts, provides a great view of the marina, but they do also have indoor seating. I had the Cuban sandwich and my wife had the fried shrimp and hush puppies, they were really good. The service fast and friendly. They don't have a large selection of draft beers, but they are good and cold. read more

See all

I really liked this on the water seafood spot! The conch fritters were tasty and the tacos were packed with flavor. The coconut rice was my fav part. My only gripe is that when I called to ask about the tiki bungalow tables, I was told that they were first come first serve. But the very next day when we arrive, we were told they were closed?? Plenty of other restaurants were serving outside, so I was bummed I didn't get the chance to have that experience. Service was great. I had a lot of questions on the menu and she answered them like a pro. This was a top choice place in St Augustine! read more

This restaurant was recommended by family, so we came to check it out. The tiki hut was lovely in the light breeze, and the service was very friendly. However, the calamari was so highly spiced, I couldn't eat it. I'm a huge fan of calamari and order it everywhere it's offered. It's not standard for it to be spicy. I understand that a lot of people prefer for everything they eat to be spicy, and if the Conch House wants to serve it that way, it's ok, but there should be a warning on the menu. Just call it spicy calamari. My husband had the "cracked conch." Cracked means it's tenderized with a hammer--this conch was hard and chewy because it wasn't cracked. Again, if you want to serve conch without tenderizing it, you can do that. But don't call it cracked conch, because it isn't. read more

We ended up here after a failed trip to a seafood place across the street because they were closed for vacation, and it was great luck because we had the best meal! The ambience and service were both amazing and our meal was even better. We tried the appetizers conch fritters, gator bites and conch chowder- all were fantastic. For entrees we shared shrimp tacos and buttered rum scallops. If you go here you must try the buttered rum scallops. It was a perfect dish of savory and sweet with perfectly prepared cheesy grits and scallops. I'll forever dream about the flavors of this dish and am inclined to try to replicate it at home. The kids loved the pina colada smoothie. I wish we had saved room to try the key lime pie, but it was impossible after how stuffed we were. I'd definitely come here again next time we are in the area. read more