What an amazing place! We loved every drink and all the food. Bartender Alyssa was exceptional, great conversation made us feel welcomed and great attention to detail and to every customer without missing a beat. Give her a raise! read more

Convenient spot on George St. for seafood items! We took a day trip to Saint Augustine and decided to try this place out for lunch. It had ample outdoor and indoor seating and staff were very helpful in their recommendations when ordering. We ended up getting the shrimp nachos, the fresh catch of the day, and the anchor burger. Food came out pretty fast and very tasty! The standout though was the shrimp nachos, served with cilantro crema and lobster cheese sauce on top that really put great flavor in the dish! Food was quite pricey but I guess that's expected on any popular tourist strip. Would go again to get their shrimp nachos for sure! read more

See all

On our first night here, St. Augustine Seafood Company offered up a great seafood in a nice atmosphere with friendly service. We sat on the outside patio, which has a laid back and relaxed vibe. We ordered Oysters, Blackened Fish Platter and the Fish Tacos. I absolutely loved my Fish tacos. They were seasoned really well and I truly enjoyed my meal. read more

See all

Really great seafood in the heart of historic downtown! So many fresh options. Definitely worth a stop, and any potential wait.

We were listening to a band play at the colonial oak music park and went to have cocktails at this old little bar. It says seafood but it was just a rustic cottage with a barn door. Met some people inside while waiting for the bartender to make our cocktails. Strong drinks and chill atmosphere. read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Another great meal, 4.5. Good service, sat outside this time and grabbed a poinsettia from next door. Blackened fish sandwich- with slaw, always a fave. Grilled shrimp Caesar- basic but great flavor and shrimp. Kids cuz quesadilla that came with a large cup of fruit and fries. Avocado bowl with coconut rice and blackened shrimp- potential to be super good with the fresh avocado, cucumbers, slaw, and shrimp, but the coconut rice is served chilled which was a surprise I wasn't fond of. More mushy, but I ate all the good things off. Great dipping sauces too- green goddess and cilantro crema. Will be back again. read more

Came here on Friday evening. They had seating available inside and outside. Very nice place. You order up front and then seat down and wait for your food. So service is not like at the fully seat down restaurant. Ambiance is pretty laid back and pleasant. They offer good quality seafood dishes and healthy options as well. I had grilled fish and instead of fries had rice. I also had some salad. All food was very tasty, the wait time wasn't too long. We definitely enjoyed our meal. read more

See all

We have stopped here many times and it's always a nice place to walk in and grab a fresh bite. It's great for adults and kids plus they have a lot of indoor seating. You order at the counter and then go sit down and they will bring it to you. Tried the shrimp nachos this time and they were amazing. They also have a bar side that serves refreshing drinks and is a nice place to cool up when it's hot. Both sides have windows facing the street which is great for people watching. It's right in the heart of downtown so there's no close parking so heads up on that read more

See all

Cozy, lil spot that offers well-seasoned, fresh seafood! The employees greet you the moment you walk in, & the prices are true to the area! Hint: The Conch Fritters & Shrimp Nachos are to die for! read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Not far from the oldest wooden schoolhouse is this spot on St. George St. You can only access it on foot and there is no parking nearby. This place is definitely not worth a trip there on its own. However, if you're in the historic area already, then you're good to go. Be aware this place is totally open - door, large windows, etc., so if you're looking for somewhere cool to escape the heat, this really isn't it. Plus, because of the open door/windows the place is teeming with flies. Not super fun to battle while you eat. You order at the counter, give you a number, and they bring your order to you (like Culver's if you've ever been there). There's nothing for vegan or plant-based friends without lots of substitutions, so don't bother - too many other food spots around. Okay... so the food. Good. Tasty. My daughter was excited about the shrimp nachos - served on top of blue corn tortilla chip. She found the jalapeños overpowering, but she doesn't love spicy food and easily picked most off. She enjoyed it and was said it was filling. The conch fritters were VERY hot out of the fryer - be wary of that. They were good with large pieces of discernible conch. The green goddess salad was good too, but had waaay too much cheese dumped on one side. Still, it was nice to have an option with baby kale and other lettuces. The thicker carrot match sticks were a bit long with no knife to cut them, so be prepared to go through a bunch of napkins as you maneuver them into your face! read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Conch fritters - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Very filling! Seating indoor and outdoor. The guy behind the counter was very helpful! Just what you would expect for fried shrimp, fries and coleslaw. The catch of the day changes, to day was flounder. I heard a local recommend this place to someone, I wasn't disappointed. However it is pricey! read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Fried Shrimp basket - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

While out in St. Augustine for a night of fun on the Grinch trolly ride for Nights of lights, my husband decided he needed to eat before we boarded our trolly. We only had a short window of time, approximately 45 mins, in order to make that happen. He chose St. Augustine Seafood Company after a short walk up St. George street. He ordered a mahi basket, fries, & a fountain drink. It took like what seemed forever to get the food after Sasco C. input the order and there were NOT many people in the restaurant that night at 7pm. He finally received his portion of the order at about 7:30. The basket of fries was missing but that was my portion. Once we received that we both had to eat extremely quickly as we had about 20 minutes to board the trolly after that. He took a few bites of the Mahi and it wasn't cooked all the way through! He left more than half of his $24 meal on the plate. NO ONE came to check on us nor ask how the meal was. They seemed too concerned to talk amongst themselves about other things more important than performing their job that they were being paid for! Where did the customer service go that belongs in the SERVICE industry? Thankfully, he didn't get sick and we had a great time on the trolly ride! read more

5 stars! Absolutely stellar seafood in the heart of historic St. Augustine! We popped into St. Augustine Seafood Company on St. George Street and were blown away by how fresh everything tasted -- you can tell they source straight from local boats (they even list the fishermen on the board!). I went for the fried shrimp basket -- perfectly golden, crispy, and juicy without being greasy -- paired with their Minorcan clam chowder that had just the right spicy kick. My partner devoured the blackened mahi tacos: flaky fish, bright cilantro slaw, and that creamy cilantro sauce... heaven in a tortilla! Fast-casual vibe but the quality feels full-on fine dining. -- pure vacation magic. Friendly staff, strong cocktails at the bar, and prices that don't break the bank. Hands-down one of the best meals we've had in St. Augustine. We'll be back every trip! read more

I wish I could say 5 stars for the oysters (they were fresh and not too small) but the service and the ambience brings it down to a 3. Given, it was a Night of Lights evening so it was busy, but it was taking a long time to get hot water and they couldn't move us to a different seat due to theit tipping system. Other than the oysters, the rest of the food quality/size was tourist-grade in a bad way. My friend and I got clam chowder, shrimp tacos, and catch of the day. Not terrible, not great is the verdict. read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Raw oysters - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

No lies, I really wanted to love this spot tucked away along the street in St. Augustine. The decor was cute as it felt appropriate to both the seafood and city vibes. The staff were very helpful and seemed genuinely happy to be working. However, the food was only fine - nothing amazingly good. Honestly, I'm not sure I would want to go back since there are so many options nearby. We began with conch fritters that were so overdone they were black and dry with no flavor. Next, we had the avocado rice bowl with fish which was better, but still lacking all around. It was a cute spot that didn't pan out, but maybe we had a bad day. read more

Food was good. Ambiance is interesting/ touristy. Service wasn't great - kitchen messed up the order and the redo took over 40 minutes to re-deliver. The waitress was helpful and friendly but massively over-tabled. read more

We were craving seafood and found this fast casual spot! Ordering was a breeze, you order at the counter and sit down while the food is brought out. They had many food options including soups, salads and sandwiches. We ordered a clam chowder and a blacked fish basket to share. The clam chowder was delicious! Very thick and lots of clam and potatoes, my favorite! The blackened fish basket was a great portion and came with a side of fries, two fish pieces, and a side of coleslaw. The coleslaw was different than the slaw that I'm used to (no mayo) but it was still delicious. The fish was cooked well and not dry but well seasoned. Finally, I was obsessed with the fries! Highly recommend stopping by for a fast casual seafood spot! read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Blackened Fresh Catch - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Me and my family ate there July 22. We've eaten there many times and enjoyed. I always bragging about how good the food was but this time I was disappointed. We got the flounder basket, flounder sandwich and Avocado Rice bowl. It came out to be $78.81. The fish was no better than Captain D's. I paid $78.81 for a meal that I could have got at Captain D's for about $20.00! Me and my family will never go there again. There are so many good restaurants around that you can get a good, delicious meal for around the same price of $80.00. I always look forward to going to this restaurant when we go to St. Augustine but no more. Come on, you can cook better fish than a bland fast-food restaurant! Can't you? I'm giving you two stars, but you are really a one-star restaurant at the most. read more

Order the coconut key lime colada! Bartended for 14 years and this is the best drink I've ever had! Peel and eat shrimp and oysters are a must. How do you spell it? Alyssa is fantastic! Omg we will definitely be back. Love love loved it! read more

Actually was pretty good. Saw on the menu oysters on the half shell. Thats what brought us in. Market price and a bit pricy but still good to have. Service was good. Had to ask for additional napkins. I had the mahi mahi grilled tacos. Loaded and nice filet in them. Messy so definitely needed the extra napkins. Cyndi had the blackened shrimp basket and they looked great. Started off with a GREAT bloody mary. Overall good all the way around. Nice place sitting outside. Just the market price was a bit of an ouch for the oysters. read more

See all

This place was good! I got the fresh catch basket and subbed the slaw for black beans. Also got the Coconut Key Lime Colada to drink, which was really really good. Food took a bit to come out but it was worth the wait I'd say. read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Fresh Catch - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

The place is rustic looking tables wood tables covered grape vines in the outside sitting area . I started with the fried shrimp , plater with fries they were ok I don't like the batter that much it was a bit spicy and a bit dry. We also got the fried fish plater the fish was good and the fries also it was just a bit to small for the price , our server was great and we loved the atmosphere if it's relaxing away from all the crowds.. read more

See all

We walked around Colonial quarter looking for a restaurant that offers oysters. Saw oysters on their menu and walked into the courtyard. This restaurant is cute, we sat indoors and it felt very rustic Spanish feel. Raw oysters were fresh and the fried shrimp was also delicious. I ordered the ceasar salad to have something healthy. I can see myself back here drinking with friends in the courtyard. read more

See all

Courtyard seating was a perfect getaway from the hustle and bustle of St George St. We were seated quickly. We ordered some drinks and French fries to snack on. The draft beer selection was good, but neither beers were cold. The sangria was delicious. The fries were served quickly, but the portion was very small for the price. read more

It was a busy Saturday evening at the St Augustine Seafood Company and from service to food, they nailed it. The kitchen was swamped with both sit-down and to-go service being busy. But the food didn't take long to come out and was nice & hot. I had the Shrimp Basket. Got the shrimp fried and they tasted delicious. The Shrimp Tacos were also delicious. The fries were nice & crispy. Even tried the Lighthouse Lemonade which was a Peach flavor. That was good & refreshing. I always enjoy sitting outside especially when the weather is beautiful and you can hear the live bands off in the distance. I would return here many many times. read more

See all

Perfect quick bite in the historic center of St. Augustine. Walked in on a whim for dinner and it was a little busy, but the staff were very attentive and friendly. The drinks were delicious and probably my favorite thing, but I did enjoy the Anchor burger. read more

See all

Another rainy day in St. Augustine so we took shelter inside this bar. We sat down and the bar tender came up to us and took our order! Glad to know we can order food at the bar side. We shared the Buffalo shrimp and clam chowder fries. The Buffalo shrimp was probably the spiciest buffalo I've ever had - the slaw was dry. The clam chowder fries were delicious and generous. Drinks to go were an old fashion and gin on the rocks. The place is pretty expensive but server was fabulous and the bar was clean and comfortable. Downside is that the restroom is at the restaurant side and it's only one stall per gender. read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Foods good but No customer service. If you want another drink, you better bring it from your hotel or home. Too many places to eat to get stuck at this one. read more

Located along St. George Street, "civilian street" which most of the restaurants, shops, and on-foot attractions of old town St. Augustine are located, St. Augustine Seafood Company is another option for food in one of the more prominent touristy parts of the city. Along the same road as other well-known restaurants like Tavern de Caballo and Bull & Crown, The St. Augustine Seafood Company (which I will shorthand SASC for the remainder of this review) is one of two prominent (off the top of my head) local seafood restaurants within the historic and tourist part of the old city. Staying with the theme of the old city, the restaurant has the appearance of an outdoor patio of a hacienda with parts of an inner courtyard. Fits very well with Spanish Floridian architecture at the time. Because the restaurant is somewhat outdoors, take into account the season will either make or break your experience depending on your tolerances to certain weather conditions. True SASC will bring out portable fans or heaters depending on the temperature, but it is still good to know your own preference for eating somewhat outdoors. There is, however, a small section of the restaurant that is representative as part of a small courtyard. This part of the restaurant is the "indoors" section and has better ambient temperature control. As for the service and food, they were good as in good on a common level. This means I would expect such friendliness and helpfulness from the waiters in general and the food, though specifically more seafood fare, is good enough. Waiter kept our drinks filled and kept checking on us. Food was delicious and a $$ price tag meaning between $11 to $30. I had the gator, conch, and Minorcan soup. My dad ordered the burger. My stepmom had the mahi-mahi tacos. As mentioned earlier, they were delicious but did not stand out compared to other seafood options I had at other restaurants. Overall, an averagely good experience in which SASC delivered the core but rarely went above and beyond. Ergo, I would definitely give this restaurant a 3 out of 5 though. More stars will be added if they are consistent at minimum but primarily improving. Sidenote: No restrooms at the restaurant. Since SASC is loacated alog St. George Street, there are numerous public restrooms along it. Its cleanliness is dependent on how the public treats them. read more

See all

We had the shrimp basket and the shrimp were huge, definitely recommend. Food and drinks were great. We sat at the bar and we able to order from the menu, service was excellent read more

We stopped in here for lunch after a morning of roaming and shopping. The wait was less than 10 minutes. We also didn't wait much for the food. The service was fast. The food was basic and okay. The one thing I could appreciate was that the manger on the floor was everywhere and doing it all. She helped in every way she possibly could. read more

See all

Only reason why we stopped was for the dogs. They allowed our dogs outside to cool down. The teens at the counter were not helpful at all. All the food was fried. Not happy campers. We had the quesadilla, the fresh catch and grilled mahi tacos. Went next door to the bar and got drinks and brought them over... which was the only upside. Expensive for what you get. read more

This was some of the best tasting shrimp I've ever had. A great place with pleasant atmosphere. The lady who served us was delightful. We ate there twice. read more

Walking thru old historic St Augustine we slid into this restaurant because the menu selections looked yummy and reasonably priced. We weren't disappointed. My wife had the grilled Mahi Mahi but didn't want fries so our server offered a cucumber watermelon salad instead and along with the vinegar coleslaw rounded out a delicious meal for her. The Mahi was fresh and tender with just the right seasoning. I ordered the grilled shrimp, which were plump and juicy and delicious. The fries were crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. The vinegar based coleslaw was crispy and tasty. Service was attentive. We sat inside in nice air conditioned because too muggy outside. We will eat here again. read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Grilled shrimp and grilled mahi mahi - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

My girlfriend ordered the Grilled Shrimp , and it only came with 8 shrimp and a little handful of fries. For $20 8 shrimp is way too little. I ordered the fresh catch for $24 I got 2 pieces of fish and little handful of fries. The crema slaw doesn't taste good and just looks depressing. I ended up spending over $50 and we weren't even full . I know many other seafoods that are more affordable and still better quality . read more

I am always going to recommend St. Augustine Seafood Company. It's located in the Colonial Oak "complex" and offers a counter-service option, bar seating option and seated dining experience. There are also picnic tables outside under the oaks with a stage for live music, as well as a couple of walk-up bars. Super fun. The menu is not huge, but offers fresh oysters, two kinds of chowder, seafood baskets (grilled, fried, or blackened) and sandwiches. Get the chowder fries. It's the best of both worlds if you want to try and don't feel like committing to a whole soup order. Honestly, the fried shrimp basket and the Fish and chips burrito are two of our favorites. Everything is flavorful with just enough breading. For fried meals, neither one is heavy. Fries are always crisp and yummy, and cilantro slaw is fresh. The watermelon and cuke salad is a great side as well, especially on a hot day. Also, as a condiment queen, I highly recommend the tartar and John-John sauces for dipping! read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Visited on Aug 8th. The place looks like Long John Silvers but the food is far better and premises much cleaner. Wasn't expecting much but the quality and taste of all our food was superb! Wife and I had the shrimp nachos plus the grilled fresh fish basket. Great taste and excellent fries! Cilantro lime slaw had a light dressing, wonderful. Also must add that this is the only place where the cashier automatically set the tip to 0% on the pay screen. I tipped them in cash anyway for their service and friendly demeanor. After a table of people left, employees would immediately begin cleaning. Nice! A very pleasant visit! read more

The shrimp po'boy I ordered from here was a miss for me - a po'boy starts with the right kind of bread and this was not it. They served theirs on some kind of elongated ciabatta roll just too heavy. The shrimps were pretty nice, but I feel this one was not "dressed" properly - the lettuce, tomato and onions just felt off. The fries were well made. They have a few entrances along St. George - one with a bar and the take out counter and some outdoor seating. I ordered at the counter, was given a number and the food was brought to the table - they were not busy at the time of my visit so everything went smooth. I think my experience was a case of ordering poorly and I would give them another shot when I am in town. read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Shrimp Po' Boy - never seen a Po' Boy on an elongated Ciabatta Roll before :/ - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Bad Service and the food was even worse ! 1 hour and 45 minutes we waited for our Fish wrap and Fish sandwich were Cold . I sent it back and the manager came to my table and asked what was wrong with my meal he said he felt it and it was warm to him, I don't know about you but I think a fresh mad fish sandwich should be Hot ! read more

My guys really enjoyed their lunch (Anchor burger & fried shrimp). My avocado rice bowl with tempeh was ok; I wouldn't order it again though. I'm one of those people who hates cilantro because it tastes like soap, so I made sure to order my meal without the cilantro-lime slaw & requested the regular slaw. It came out without any slaw, not a big deal at all, it's slaw. I ended up only eating the top half of the bowl because either the avocado rice or créma on it, had cilantro in it. The top half of the bowl was more than enough to fill me up, so I definitely didn't leave hungry! We also got an order of hush puppies (they were a special) and while they may've been in the fryer a few seconds too long, they were still really good! The cost, however, was astronomical! Our bill was $92! IMO, that's way too high for two standard meals (a burger & shrimp basket both with fries), an avocado rice bowl, hushpuppies, two drinks, and a water. All in all, I recommend this place, but be prepared to open your wallet. read more

St. Augustine Seafood Company - Avocado Rice Bowl with Tempeh, minus the cilantro-lime slaw. - Seafood Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida