Came for brunch this morning. The wait from when we sat to when a serve greeted us way too long. The server never checked on us after we got our food. Drinks took 20 minutes to get. read more

The restaurant, staff, and food are always on point. It's a little expensive but not too. Incredibly convenient when you are staying at the Kimpton-Monaco. I would recommend both! read more

Dined there last evening as a party of six trying to celebrate a birthday. Noise level is off the scale. We were at a round table, which is usually nicer than a long table for conversing with a larger group. In this case, the noise level pretty much restricted conversations to whoever was sitting to your right or left. Even then you had to talk very loud to be heard. So if you're going, and hoping to catch up with friends on what's going on in their lives, consider yourself warned. My food was very tasty. I had their Seafood Chowder every bite of which was delicious. Happily the waitress warned me that it was "deconstructed" rather than a bowl of soup, but they provided a little pitcher of the chowder cream which was just right for pouring on and/or dipping the various ingredients in. The portion size was just right for me, which means a tad small, but plenty. My wife had their Brick Chicken which was also quite tasty, but in contrast to my meal, her portion size was huge. My meal left room for dessert which was their delicious Whitepot, a form of bread pudding. We shared it and it was very good. And finally, the valet parking. It was very busy when we arrived and the sidewalk out front was jammed with cabs forcing us to wait 5 to 10 minutes until we could pull to the curb and turn the car over to the valet. The valet charge is $9. We observed that they parked our car on the street right across from where we got out. When I left I gave the valet our claim check and pointed to my car. He said I should go get it because he doesn't drive a "stick". I paid him and gave him a tip, which I later though was dumb on my part, given the lack of service. Four of us walked across the street, got in and left. I guess he also is challenged when it comes to opening doors. If there is a next time, I'll park elsewhere. Funny, on the way in my friend asked if valet parking is a problem these days seeing as how my car has a stick. I told him it has never been a problem, and that apparently being a valet requires knowing how to drive a standard transmission. So...there's a first for everything. read more

I enjoyed my recent visit to The Commoner. I staff was very nice and the food was yummy. Overall, I had a pleasant experience.

Sat at the bar with my wife for 15 minutes. The bartenders were cleaning glasses and chit chatting and doing everything but serving customers. The bar wasn't that busy as it was only 4:00pm. Finally had to shout over to a bartender to place a drink order. Haven't seen service this bad at a bar in a while. read more

Very nice below ground level restaurant. Long and narrow with 1/2 devoted to bar area with high top tables for two to Eight guests. Wine served is private label for most part so difficult to chose a familiar label. Food selection was great ranging from Tika Marsala to bone in pork chop. Had the salmon with spinach, small portion but adequate. The appetizer steak tartare was exceptional. Pricey. read more

Had dinner reservations for 4 people before a concert. Restaurant was about 90%full. Sat a bit longer before server appeared but very nice once she did come. Ordered bottle of wine( note the bottle prices are 4x retail) and charcuterie to start and placed our dinner order same time. Wine brought quickly to table. Waited over 30 minutes for the charcuterie even after asking about it. Was told they are trying to keep up due to how busy they are....?!? The charcuterie, once delivered, was "interesting " ...it looked like a child just dumped things on a plate...literally and there was barely anything on it. Fortunately it was comped. The dinners were served within a few minute of the appetizer. I had the angry lobster rigatoni. Was good, nice spicy sauce but nothing extra special. Interesting that the waitress mentioned that some people thought my other possible dinner choice was salty but neglected to mention the "heat spice" in the pasta dish. ‍All in all would not return though...too many other options in the city that can handle a busy Saturday night. read more

Stopped in for brunch today sat there for 15 minutes no one even came to offer water or say that they were a little behind they would be with us . Walked across street went to the William Penn service was phenomenal I recommend it highly. Walk the few steps to the William Penn it's worth it read more

I visited The Commoner for the 2nd this past weekend. My 2nd experience was just as good as the first. The decor is beautiful, the atmosphere wonderful, we had excellent service and the food was amazing. We had the cheese board and mussels for appetizers and both were delicious. Our entrees consisted of the pork chop and pumpkin gnocchi, and we ordered a side of brussel sprouts with bacon. The food was amazing! The first time I visited I had seitan that was made in-house and it was unbelievably good. Our server was very warm, friendly and attentive. Our food was served with perfect timing. The cocktails were excellent, as well. This is a must try place! read more

This place was amazing when it first opened up, but after changing executive chefs so many times, it is now just okay. The roof top bar, however, is the best in the city. read more

came for the drake-themed cocktails, stayed for chris the waiter. give that guy a raise.

I've been there several times for their delicious bbq brisket sandwich. It's still advertised on their website but I learned today after sitting down for lunch that it's no longer being offered. Big disappointment! read more

Sat at the bar and had some appetizers - unique flavors and large portions. Extensive list of craft cocktails - enjoyed the few we tried. Service was top notch. read more

This is based on only one visit and one meal, but I'm not inclined to return. I ordered the shepherd's pie. Given the type of restaurant and the prominence of the shepherd's pie on the menu, I'd expect it to be a signature dish. In fact, it was little more than piped mashed potatoes on top of a pool of gravy. As soon as my fork (it actually comes with a soup spoon) touched the potatoes, they wobbled back and forth on the pool of liquid. The gravy had tiny crumbles of ground lamb and only two small "chunks" in the entire bowl. I swear there were no more than about 15 peas and 3 small pieces of carrot. Otherwise, it was all gravy. And for this, I paid $16. The flavor was fine; no better or worse than you'd expect of shepherd's pie. No complaints about service, and the atmosphere is nice. But that's the best you can do with the food, I'll have to pass. read more

I just went to The Commoner for the first for dinner last night and it was a wonderful experience. I had made a reservation and we were promptly seated by a friendly host. Our waiter was very attentive and our food came out incredibly quickly (I caveat this statement with the information that we were there at 5:15pm, just after it opened for dinner). There was a Pens game at Consol that night and our waiter asked if we were going to make sure we were out on time if we were going. The food was really excellent. I especially loved the "to share" asparagus with poached egg plate. I was pleasantly surprised to find the high attention to detail at the restaurant, which manifested itself when I was brought curry powder and chili oil fresnos for my Tikki Masala when I asked for additional spiciness and the way in which my leftovers were boxed, with plastic laid down at the bottom of the paper box to prevent leaking and herbs carefully sprinkled on top. My only disappointment is the lack of vegetarian options on the menu, but they were very accommodating and made a flatbread without the meat for my sister. The prices are on the higher side, but worth it for the quality of food you are getting. I will definitely be going back! read more

Worst hostess service!! It is freezing in here. We asked for extra stools as they seated us at a table with 6 on one side and 4 on the other and they bring us chairs that do not even reach the table. It's so cold we have jackets and ear muffs on --- they don't care!!!! Do not come here!!!!! The hostess is the worst!! The waiter John is awesone!!! read more

Excellent food! Wonderful ambience and amazing service! A great addition to Pittsburgh restaurants.

The food tasted fine. And I hate to sound nitpicky, but that's purpose of a critique. I ordered the Commoner Burger, cooked medium, to go. The burger was well-done, with some bites leaving the occasional "burned" aftertaste. The side salad was combination of edible and wilted lettuce, around a 50-50 split. I don't see the point in ordering food from a reputable restaurant, such as The Commoner, only to receive a meal that was less than desirable. Busy or not, a burger is one of the easiest things to cook and maintaining fresh greens is straightforward. I won't be dining at the Commoner again. read more

We were off to a rocky start when the hostess wouldn't even suggest how our reservation for two could accommodate another person anywhere despite a nearly empty space. Our third even offered that perhaps he could just stand by our table, partly in jest. Finally, I asked if we could just sit at the large communal table and she basically shrugged a yes. Wow, so helpful and friendly. We ordered the deviled eggs, a salad, mushroom soup, succotash and crab mac and cheese. All except for the soup was tasty if a bit pricey. The soup was awful- completely flavorless and I mean completely. During our meal a woman breezed by to inquire about the food but never even gave me a second look when I said,"Actually, this soup is terrible." My cocktail was good but they were out of a few microbrews the guys wanted. The whole vibe came off as "We are just soooo cool." The Biergarten was closed because it was too cold- about 65 degrees. Huh? read more

Amazing place, great cocktails and food. Must try the cauliflower app!! Also the tikka masala was amazing!!

Pork chops are amazing. Skip the potatoes and ask for red cabbage. Also try the octopus. Great service and great cocktails too.

The name says it all - common. The place itself is pretty cool - clean, etc. Went for breakfast. The service and the food were very average - not terrible but certainly nothing to remember. There are better places within walking distance. Overpriced as well read more

I wish I could give more stars than three! But I think it is suitable! I'm not basing this off of one visit but, several. I have gone countless times to the Commoner for cocktails. The drinks never wow me. I have tried a pantheon of whiskey concoctions that have all been boring and uninspired. They were never bad but never great! I went the other day for food though and was very impressed!!! I get steak tartare anytime I see it on a menu. We shared the tartare (I ate the whole thing) along with a meat plate. It wasn't our wisest decision to order a meat buffet but that's what we were feeling at the time! The tartare instantly was ranked second best in my mind, only behind Butcher and the Rye. For our entrees we shared fish and chips and a shrimp salad. The salad was so good and had a smokey dressing but kind of was forgotten because of the perfect cooked fish that came with the other dish! I think I just need to continually eat when I go to the Commoner and stick to the wine! read more

Outstanding service. Eclectic and savory food and drink choices. Another great Hotel Monaco restaurant.

I want down there with my friends on the Friday night. It was outstanding. I had the steak pie. It was delightful. It was a great service and I will definitely go back there. Great food great atmosphere great drinks. read more

I would love to give this place a 10 review but can't. I can however give John, the one bartender, and a couple other staff members a 10 review. Wow. What a great bunch of people. Everyone that works here is awesome. People who actually want to work, want to help people, and want to be kind. This hotel did an awesome job of hiring people. John, our bartender, even though he was busy with a bunch of other patrons (some total assholes) was awesome. He remembered what we were drinking, he was genuine, and just overall awesome and knowledgeable. Everything bartenders used to be. Also, the valet?? Awesome!!! My BF forgot his phone in the car, and I "thought" I left something in it as well...4 hours later. They were so busy parking new comers and retrieving cars for existing patrons, and never once made us feel bad for sending them on another venture to the lot...because of our thoughtlessness. I seriously can't say enough good things about this place. I would stay a night or two more if we could. Definitely will be back. read more

Great atmosphere in the heart of town. Service was great. Nice drink selections. A limited food menu but prepared and presented well. Meat and cheese plates had some unique additions but somewhat underwhelming overall. Fantastic burger and the special that night was perfect. read more

Fun place for happy hour. Very happening. Lots of corporate crowd too. Very good bar food. Loved their Brussel sprouts and Cosmo.

Great atmosphere, good service, but lunch menu seemed limited. Became even more limited when our server informed us they were out of chicken entirely. Brisket sandwich had excellent sauce but slightly stale bread. Maybe dinner options are better? read more

Went to brunch on Saturday around 11:30am and didn't have to wait for a table. Started off with coffee which was amazing. I ordered the broccoli/cheese Quiche with roasted potatoes. It wasn't a huge meal but delicious. My wife had the "Yinz Need Breakfast" and it was enough to feed her and our 15 month old daughter. Overall, service was great and the food was delicious. We will definitely be back. read more

The charred cauliflower is insanely good!! This place is so delicious!! We just loved our experience there and would definitely go back as often as possible! The food is awesome and our cocktails were pretty tasty! The staff is so attentive! The Commoner never disappoints!! read more

Everything was absolutely delicious. Hands-down best pancakes I've ever had! The pancakes didn't come with anything, so i ordered two eggs and bacon for sides. I thought I'd get a few pieces of bacon, but it was more like ten pieces! Drinks perfect. Great service, no wait, great atmosphere! read more

Food and drink. Staff very nice however a little bit slow showing and attending to the customers.

Great food. Been here 3 times. The food is a little pricey. The amount of food on the lunch list is. Wry limited.

The food was delicious and the drinks great, but unfortunately our evening was ruined by the noise level throughout and primarily emanating from the neighbouring table of 9 women who were drinking and doing shots. The pleasure of some should not be at the expense of others, especially at an establishment operated by the KIMPTON Group. We did complain, but rather than asking the offending members to be considerate, they offered to move us, as we were finishing our main course. REALLY? Unfortunately, we have no guarantee that this scenario will not recur and probably will not return. Is this what the definition of good vibe is? read more

Nice selection of seasonal small plates to share and/or to put together into a satisfying meal. Plenty of vegetarian choices, along with a wide range of meat-based options. Especially enjoyed the roasted cauliflower and Brussels sprouts. Didn't try the seitan, but plan to visit again and give that a go. Good selection of wines and beers. Great industrial chic decor with a combination of seating choices between the bar, communal tables, and traditional tables. Attentive but laid-back service. read more

We have been here a few times now and loved each experience. Our last was definitely one of the best! We decided to celebrate our second anniversary here. Everything was great. My husband enjoyed the seafood special and I couldn't get enough of the steak and ale pie. We were told to save room and enjoyed not one but two desserts. My husband loved the fudge while I preferred their signature pudding dessert. The best part was definitely the service. Deanna really made sure everything was perfect and gave excellent recommendations. We will continue to visit here on a regular occasion and will request Deanna every time! But this is now officially a part of our anniversary tradition. Looking forward to eating here again soon! read more

Was in Pittsburgh for the weekend for a friend's wedding & stopped here for breakfast due to 4 stars on yelp & proximity to hotel. It. Was. Terrible. Service was awful - slow, server was not friendly & was unable to be found most of the time, we watched our food sitting under the heat lamps for almost 10 minutes. When it did arrive it was ok but nothing great. They gave me an overload of undercooked bacon as well as two pieces of toast the size of my pinky. My friends were satisfied with their meals but for the high price of an omelette/eggs & toast to us it was not worth it. Overall we were not impressed & would not recommend The Commoner. read more

I never post but I just had a great meal here. The roasted veggie salad was mouthwatering and the short rib was fantastic. The drinks were divine. The wait staff could not have been more attentive. He was the icing on a really good cake. The only thing that marred this night out was the young hostess who was way too snooty for such a young woman. She sighed like it was chore to seat me and was in no way welcoming. Sometimes the arrogance of youth is not what a diner wants when going out with friends. read more

Awesome service and atmosphere. The food was excellent. We had beef jerky as an appetizer, which I thought was odd to have on a menu, but it was excellent! read more