Reason for not 5 stars is that their service isn't the best, and the past few times I've been there (including tonight) there's been flies circulating the dining room-including around my food. Other than that their all you can eat deal is great. Unlimited all you can eat anything on the menu for $20-22 or so, a person depending on when you go. Filet mignon roll is definitely the best. But all of their rolls are delicious. The manager at the front desk who takes care of all payments is always super friendly. One of my favorite sushi spots to go to! Make sure you have a big appetite! PS it's BYOB !! read more

Sushi Time 560 - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

Good sushi, great service, reasonable prices, and a friendly atmosphere. Our second time here and we'll be back again! read more

For about $20 or so you can eat as much sashimi, sushi, appetizers, soups, etc. it's decent as well. Bang for the buck it's quite good. HOWEVER, if you come here when it's busy, the service is abysmal. You notice that some servers adapt and try to do as much as they can but one in particular just kind of went her own pace no matter how busy it was. This place is under staffed to say the least. Waitresses are busing tables, bringing out food, taking to go orders, seating people, etc. that's why stuff gets missed. So on a busy time 2 stars. I put in an order and got about half of it. I had to get my own order tickets because there was not a server in sight. I think at some point they just are wanting for the eaters to stop ordering. Understandable. BUT, if you get here before the rush the service is very good. It may be wise for management to hire extra people for the busy hours. Slow hours I'd say 3.5 - 4 stars. read more

Sushi Time 560 - Sashimi and hand rolls. After cycling feast. - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

I love sushi and have tried a ton of different spots but I am not a fan of this place. I wasn't in the mood for fish so I decided to get 3 vegetable rolls which are normally pretty hard to mess up. The regular vegetable roll was ok it was by far the best of the three. The mango roll just wasn't great the mango was really mushy and warm and it just really wasn't great. The last roll I got was the sweet potato roll. I think they should indicate on the menu that this roll is deep fried tempura sweet potato - the very unhealthy kind that I wasn't expecting when the menu just says sweet potato. That roll only came with I think four pieces with huge pieces of deep fried sweet potato, which I ended up just throwing out that entire roll. I won't be going back here and really feel like I wasted my money. I'd also like to note that the menu doesn't indicate that the lunch rolls come with miso soup and a salad, so I ended up ordering a salad for $3.00 not knowing my meal already came with it. They charge $3 for basically 3 pieces of romaine lettuce. read more

Been coming here for a few years and always had a great time they bring the food out right away it's BYOB and the food is pretty fresh and amazing always a great time out with friends. If you bring your own wine they open it for you and bring you wine glasses The last time I was here we came an hour before they closed and they rushed us out clearing away our food when we weren't even done taking our away silverware and the soy sauce. It was rude we had said something as we left. I'd come again but at a more reasonable time read more

Would do a negative star if i could!!! Such rude service. Pushed my friends chair that they were sitting in so they could move past without saying anything. stopped serving us food even though we followed the "unlimited" rules. A kid was working in the back! Covid wise: all the tables are extremely close. Atleast 100 people in the restaurant on a saturday night. Not good for New York. Never coming back read more

How hard is it to find *quality* AYCE Sushi on Long Island? Pretty hard. I made reservations for a group of 6 on a Thursday evening and this place was packed. Everyone was thrilled to find out that this place is BYOB, with a King Kullen on the same block. We ordered more rolls than normal because there was just such an abundance of choices. Each roll sounded more interesting than the last. The roll with banana was my favorite - I can't find the name on the website. The starters were decent but can easily be skipped over to make room for the rolls. The shrimp tempuras were really hot and flaky though, definitely a treat. The rolls come out quick but if you have a food allergy or need something special, be prepared to have a hard time conversing with the staff - they move quick and just want to keep the sushi coming. There are always coupons in the local paper and for $19.99 AYCE on a weeknight, you can't go wrong. read more

Sushi Time 560 - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

All you can eat for $20 per person with Facebook offer..friendly staff, food was delicious and fresh. A lot of great options to choose from including soup, salad, kitchen items, sushi, sashimi, dessert. read more

See all

RECOMMENDED Damn.....is this a controversial place or what? I'd been eyeing this place for one of my group's dinners but was a little spooked by the diversity of Yelp opinion. Therefore, I took the opportunity to dine here with another Meetup group on Friday, June 24th to form my own opinion.It features AYCE Sushi/Sashimi/Rolls and Kitchen Items(including dessert) at $21.95. Insane or what? The restaurant is also BYOB. It is located in a strip mall on Stewart Avenue, immediately north of the LIRR tracks. There is ample parking. If you are pressed for time or simply not a good planner, there is an excellent liquor store a few doors away toward the King Kullen which anchors the strip mall. I bought an fruity and delicious Bogle Petite Syrah there for about thirteen bucks. My fellow diners arrived at this dimly lit space and were seated at a large table for twelve.The restaurant was packed with a youthful crowd on this Friday evening. Service here was pretty perfunctory but, when it's AYCE, I do not care. Just show me the food. You order on paper sheets. The restaurant is cheap. They only permit one order sheet each(kitchen and sushi) per four people. I consulted with four others and we placed our orders, which, for the most part, consisted of the lovely array of sushi and rolls which I photographed. The kitchen was very quick in getting our order out, despite being so busy. Let me make this perfectly clear....stay away from the kitchen items and stick to the sushi, sashimi and rolls. While the restaurant is cheap with the former(three small fried calamari rings?), it is generous with the latter. I LOVED that the sushi and rolls were presented in a good fish to rice ratio. This restaurant, in contrast to other AYCE Sushi places, does not pursue the obvious strategy of trying to fill you up with rice(despite the fact that the protein in fish will make you feel full quicker). My three fellow diners consumed a very large platter of Sushi, Sashimi and Rolls, Eel Avocado and Filet Mignon being some of the latter. The fish was extremely fresh and delicious.The Rolls were particularly terrific. I was pleased that the Sushi platter contained an abundant amount of Wasabi and Ginger to season our fish. Unlike some of the other cavonnes at this event we were too full to order a second platter of food.With tip, our individual share of the check came to $29.00. You cannot beat that! I was too full for dessert.....but......immediately after dinner.......headed to Krisch's in Massapequa for its heavenly Peach Ice Cream......but that will be another review. read more

Sushi Time 560 - Sushi Platter for Four.....Cavonnes - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

Kick ass specialty rolls! order them all! This spot is the only one with Filet Mingon roll - and BOY is it good! DOWNSIDE: Beware of the "disappearing orders"! Those 5 apps you ordered are never coming!! We had to order over and over to get our original order! grr PROTIP: Try the very special CRUNCHY TUNA on weekends only. Very exotic! .... actually its a pringles chip with spicy tuna on it -_- Get it anyway for some laughs!! read more

Only thing that really drew me to this place was their cheap menu options and the fact my friend wanted to do the all you can eat sushi deal. I was hesitant to come because of the negative reviews I had read on yelp in regards to their poor fish quality and lack of freshness but we decided to come for the lunch specials. I ordered two spicy tuna hand rolls because I wasn't in the mood for anything too heavy. Came with miso soup which was cold and gross. Rolls did not taste fresh. My friend ordered the all you can eat which came with absolutely everything! The options were limitless from appetizers to desserts. Sushi was okay nothing too amazing and the apps were absolutely gross. Don't even bother ordering appetizers they are a complete waste of food. The green tea ice cream that we ordered for dessert we found a piece of PLASTIC IN IT. Obviously we were completely appalled.... When I called the waitress over all she could say was "oh. Sorry" as if this particular instance happened all the time at the restaurant. As stated in one of the previous reviews on here, keep in mind that although this place might get you more bang for your buck, this is still RAW SEAFOOD we are talking about. Please don't resort to coming here to save a few dollars and God forbid get plastic in your food!!!!!!!! Absolutely disgusting Needless to say never coming back! read more

Sushi Time 560 - Piece of plastic found in the green tea ice cream, YUM!!!! - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

BYOB, $20 dinner all you can eat, made to order I came expecting crappy Chinese sushi but I was pleasantly shocked that the sushi was good. Nothing truly authentic but the rice was cooked well and the fish tasted fine. If you are an authenticity snob, then you should always stop at the description of "All you can eat". If you're a fun person that likes to eat a lot and bring your own booze, like me, then you'll love this place. It's a good place to go with a group of friends and share a bottle of wine or pack of beer. You can buy some beer right at the King Kullen in the same shopping center. I felt a little rushed as they handed me the check when I wanted a third order. The portions of some of the appetizers are small so don't be afraid to order more than one if you know you like it. The rolls are regular size. read more

Sushi Time 560 - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

- didn't offer tuna sashimi - bland miso soup - the rice seemed off, not sure they used the right amount of seasoned rice vinegar. . or if they used any at all. . . might've even been the wrong kind of rice - the sushi was shabbily assembled. . . all of them fell apart - won't find better price for made to order all you can eat sushi/sashimi/kitchen menu - was pleasantly surprised by the quality of their yellowtail sushi read more

This review shall be titled 'Irony.' I've been to Sushi Time several times and I'm always pleased. Good sushi, everything is fresh, and the price is hard to beat (though most all you can eat sushi places match the price). If you're worried about getting your money's worth order five Filet Mignon rolls and call it a day. I like their sushi. A lot of the rolls taste pretty similar, but that is likely because I am a little picky and tend to stick to crab, tuna, white tail, and salmon rolls. I've never had anything here taste off, or wrong, and though they don't ever tell you which roll is which it gets a little confusing at times. I very much enjoyed the Crazy Monkey roll, which was topped with fried banana and wasabi cream. Very strange, one of the more unique rolls I've had. I also recommend the Angry Bird and the Pink Lady. Stick with the 'specialy' rolls for a more interesting meal. Everyone makes California, Spicy Tuna, shrimp temp, and peanut avocado rolls. The reason I try new sushi places is for the interesting combinations they have made. The service was fine. Took a while to get our waters and first course (edamame and Udon soup), but after that everything came out very quickly. We even got some extra food delivered we didn't order (more on that below). My main problem with Sushi Time and all All-you-can-eat sushi places I've tried is the wasteful ordering process. If I were to ever open my own sushi restaurant I would handle ordering differently. Here they give you the two slips of paper with their rolls and other items on it and you take the pen and make, what? Three marks on it? You then give it in and they take it, make your order, and throw out the paper. Such a huge waste! At my sushi restaurant, I would print the menus once per table on 4x6 paper, put the paper into cheap plastic picture frames, and give everyone a dry erase marker. You can still change the menu as often as you like and only have to print one copy of the menu per table instead of ~10 per customer! Despite what my last name would suggest, I am not the most green conscious person, but this bothers even me a bit. It's not just Sushi Time that does this, either. Anyway, on to the irony: Many of the reviews here claim that their orders were not completely filled, meanwhile we wound up with servers coming and dropping off food we didn't order to our table! It was odd, and once we got their attention, they took the food to the proper table (worrisome, as they didn't know for sure that we didn't touch it [we didn't], but I digress). TL;DR: Good sushi, decent service, wasteful ordering process. Pro-tip: There's a pennysaver coupon for $1-off per person. It's not much, but hey, money back in your pocket. Go buy yourself something nice. read more

All. You. Can. Eat. Sushi! I drove 25 minutes to try this place out with my cousins. They're regulars here. I had to see what the hype was about. It's BYOB. We brought a bottle of wine + the waitress opened the bottle and brought us wine glasses. You fill out a piece of paper and circle all the sushi rolls you want! The special rolls that are normally $10-$15 a roll! well, you can have as much as you want. All for $20 + tax. The quality of the rolls, great! Delicious! The reason I didn't give it 5 stars, well for some reason we had a bunch of fruit flies flying around our table. Eek. But, still...ill come back! Just for the unlimited sushi! read more

Sushi Time 560 - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

For an all you can eat sushi place the food is quite good. They have a great variety of different rolls and sashimi. Price is reasonable, $19.95 from Mon - Thu and $21.95 from Fri - Sun. You can also BYOB which is great as its right next to a liquor shop and you can pick-up a nice bottle of wine. The only thing keeping me from rating this a full 5 star is that the place could use some lighting and the staff needs to learn a little bit of better english to communicate better with the customer. read more

Sushi Time 560 - Great variety of rolls. I live the filet mignon sushi - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

Went this week and was disappointed to see my two favorite rolls no longer offered (the Butterfly and Pink Lady). All of the other rolls seem like the usual tuna, salmon, shrimp offering. My husband likes the filet mignon roll which is still on menu. We asked for crabmeat salad 3 times before we got it, so you I can't say service is wonderful. The tea is really weak. The ice cream is really good quality. Bottom line.... If you are in the mood for ok sushi, and a lot of it, you will find good value here If you like interesting rolls, I would go elsewhere. Probably kashi or Bluefish. read more

Went here saturday night, prime time dinner time. NO WAIT. People are foolish. I've been to sushi "buffets" before and they stunk!! This place crushed it, knocked it out of the ball park. Everything was fresh, was prepared as it was ordered. Specialty rolls (dragon roll) was delicious. BYOB was just a bonus. They even open the bottle of wine for you. If the yelpers don't go here, they make very poor decision. The asian invasion hits Bethpage, NY read more

BYOB AYCE sushi place - quick service, friendly staff, good quality sushi for AYCE, lots of roll options! Come here often, really cheap -- $22.95 AYCE weekend price, $20.95 weekday price read more

Sushi Time 560 - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

Tucked away in the King Kullen shopping Centre next to the train station, there's plenty of parking here. We went on a Saturday for lunch and found the place half empty because of the snow. We ordered off the AYCE menu, which had a good variety of sushi, sashimi, rolls, and other items. Most of the rolls we had were good combinations. We avoided ordering generic stuff and anything that was heavy on sauce or fruits, so that may have helped. The table favorite was the filet mignon roll which comes with thin beef slices torched on top. I liked that they did not skimp on the avocado but didn't overdo the rice. But the sashimi and sushi items were of poor quality and lackluster. The other items were hit or miss. I ordered Tom Yum soup out of curiosity and it was awful. We shared a few orders of beef ribs. The sweet potato tempura was actually yam (which was another order option) and soggy. But the shrimp tempura we had after that was good. Our server was also inexperienced. He dropped soups off in the same corner of the table even when we vocalized who was getting which soup. He took away plates before we finished the food sometimes. It was very confusing. I felt bad for the guy bc he seemed like he didn't know what he was doing, but we weren't asking for difficult things for him to so and it's the restaurant's job to make sure their servers are trained. It's not bad for the price and it's pretty much what you should expect for an AYCE sushi roll place on the island. read more

I've only been here twice. It's bring your own beer, sit down with the all you can eat mark off pages. Some pieces on the hot menu are small, but over all everything tastes pretty good especially the special rolls and the service is good. read more

Sushi Time 560 - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

This place is alright. The sushi and food items here may not be the top of the line best, but it's the novelty of being able to try various things at a set price. Also, it's a great place to meet up with friends to sample various sushi items. Things are ordered per table on slips of paper. So the sushi bar items come nicely presented on a large platter. This could be a reason for some hold up for sushi bar orders. From the sushi bar, you can order sashimi, hand rolls, specialty rolls, regular maki rolls, and nigiri. So, during the weekends there can be a bit of wait for a table. The kitchen orders (salads, soups, hot foods) come on individual plates per item. A surprising favorite here is the ika/ fresh squid sashimi and sushi. Fresh tasting and tender. It was clearly a table favorite. Some of the nigiri pieces have very slim pieces of fish, so definitely order sashimi to even out the fish and rice ratio. Some of the kitchen items, such as the teriyaki squid are chopped into tiny pieces that it was extremely hard to eat it. The tempura shrimp and broccoli are pretty standard. The fried calamari/squid came with a very mango dipping sauce which was different. Skip the hot and sour soup as well. Service was attentive, but we went on a weekday night, so there wasn't much of a crowd. One thing I would complain about is the ventilation here, I felt that my clothes and hair smelled a bit like fried things after dining here. Otherwise, everything is pretty clean. read more

Sushi Time 560 - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

Usually most people don't associate "all you can eat" with "quality" but I have been very pleasantly surprised with this place. I came with four people and everyone really enjoyed it.The quality was actually above average and every kind we had was delicious we ordered 2 times and didn't even leave one ! The only con was that the staff was very hands off. They weren't rude but they weren't very lively or interactive. They just dropped the paper menu on our table passively,refilled water and brought food. Regardless I will definitely come back :) read more

Sushi Time 560 - Amazing! - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

Very nice and patient people. Accommodating. Very much into good customer service. The food is really done well. This is a good sushi place to take people who don't necessarily like sushi. The reason for this is they have a hot menu that serves cooked food. The portions are designed for a taste. So this allows you to try new things read more

The food is on the slightly fresher side for an "all you can eat" sushi spot. There are other options if someone in your party doesn't like fish. You can choose from an array of Japanese hot or cold appetizers, soups, tempuras, and meats. It cost $22 a person for all you can eat, and that's not including a drink. If you and your group want alcohol, its BYOB, and they don't charge extra if you bring a bottle or two. Service is OK, the waiters are usually running around and catering to the massive crowds that are always around. It is kinda loud, because again the customers are usually big groups. PSA: If you over order and don't finish your food, they charge you by the pound. I recommend ordering slowly and minimally because you always have the option toi order more. We usually end our meals off with red bean or green tea ice cream, and a hot green tea to wash it all down. read more

Sushi Time 560 - Good for groups. $20 for all you can eat sushi and asian fusion apps! Also good for anyone who drinks because its BYOB! - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

Wednesday night me and friend, ＄20.95 per person is great in Long Island, the soups are bad taste.. fried Oreo was awesome! Sushi are nice on average taste, ice cream was great, bottom line: will come again oh ! The beef stew was awesome too! read more

See all

I love a good byo, all you can eat sushi place. It's a definite plus plus. Some of the staff was not sure what we were asking, others were happy to assist. Try and eat everything or it's a little rude. But you get great fresh sushi and more for 20! Plus brining booze saves you money $$ Tons of fun! read more

Sushi Time 560 - Japanese Near Me - Bethpage, New York

Wanted to really love this place but the sushi is terrible. Took one bite into shrimp sushi peice and it smelled and tasted like old rotten shrimp. Got food positing right after. read more

Horrible service!!! The server seemed pissed off to begin with and just threw the napkins and plates on the table. The whole time we were there, no one came to check in or asked for anything. They had the audacity to charge me extra because my 3 year old ate from my dessert bowl. I did not even fight it because its not about the money, its about their service. I would never come back here. Even for the all you can eat price, i can get a much better dinner option at other places. read more

Great for the price; 50% off all rolls for lunch. Good quality, although I stick with cooked and vegetable rolls here. Pass on the full price menu items and stick to the half priced rolls. read more

This is not a very nice place! Putting the food aside the service is very bad! They are very rude and disrespectful! I would never go back! We went and had a horrible experience! They kept huffing and puffing every time we asked for something! We where almost afraid to ask for something! Absolutely a horrible time! Don't bother going, they don't deserve our service! There are plenty of great sushi restaurants around just not this place! I can't say enough of how rude and horrible they where to us! read more

Is it the best sushi ever? No, not by a long shot. Do they have a huge selection of all-you-can-eat food, that's all very good? Absolutely. If you are hungry, and you like a large assortment of Chinese and Japanese food, and you're not looking for a high-end restaurant, this is your place. It's not fancy, and the wait staff is just okay (although certainly not bad), but you will enjoy stuffing your face here nonetheless. read more

Great food but the ordering process on line is awful. They use some trick to not give the 20% discount. I called them and the only explanation I got was call 3rd party vendor??!! In other words, tough shit! read more

Came here for dinner as it was near my friend's house. Turns out they have an all-you-can eat Sushi that seems very reasonable (22.95) and a lot of choice including plenty of cooked food. The food was worth what you paid but some was bland. As it got busy (after 7:30pm) it was difficult to get serviced. We had to ask for one sushi 5 times before it came 15 minutes later. I would not go out of my way to return. read more

They've improved since the laser time we were here about 6 months ago. Orders were accurate. Sushi fresh. Not limited on quantities ordered read more

It's not terrible, but I wouldn't say it's ever my first choice for sushi and Japanese fare. I don't live in the area but I do find myself in Bethpage about once a week because my fiancé's roots are here. When I get a craving for sushi, Sushi Time 560 is convenient especially because it's located right in town in a small shopping center with an amply sized parking lot. We come here with our friends for their AYCE deal because it satisfies everyone's tastes and I think they're BYOB as well. I've found the food to be sub- to on par. I've come here for AYCE dinner and I've also ordered to go. Service is lacking on weekend nights when it's completely packed and you get your food frequently rather than all at one time. One time I think we ordered multiple types of BBQ sticks and they all arrived at the table at different times, some even arriving after the main sushi plate. My fiancé tried ordering a noodle soup like 4 different times in one meal before they actually brought something but it didn't come until the end, so he wasn't even hungry anymore. The soup was too salty anyway. The sashimi is really not my favorite by far. I would go so far as to say I don't want to eat the sashimi here unless Sushi Time 560 is the only place open, and even then I'd probably go with the maki rolls despite the fact I'm limiting starches in my diet. I've gotten the Sashimi combo which is 18? pieces of sashimi. The tuna is pretty pale and doesn't have much flavor, the white tuna is standard, the red snapper is okay, and the seared tuna I could've definitely done without. The fried oreos are pretty good but it's hard to mess that up. Also, the downside to the fried oreos is they're only available until a certain time of day. Whatever, Carvel is like two doors down so you can head over there if you're in the mood for something sweet to end the meal. Would I come back? Yeah, if I was with a group and they all wanted to but likely 99% of the time I won't be saying to myself, "oh man I haven't had Sushi Time 560 in a while, gotta go there for dinner!" read more

Love this place:) my go-to for years! Some great options for vegetarian and vegans! Always delicious, good people. Thank you

worst sushi ever. never fresh. gave this place 3 tries and it was terrible all 3 times

Shocked at the $19.95 AYCE price tag a friend and I had to try out Sushi Time. Arrived at 6pm on a Thursday and the place was pretty empty. It has a traditional Japanese feel to it and is a decent size. They have AC units on the walls but they were not turned on. It was 85 out. Sooo....when do you turn these on? Anywho, we sit down and get tossed 2 menus with tons of sushi and kitchen items on them. We go a bit nuts with the ordering. Skewers of all kinds, tempura, udon soup, salad, gyoza, shumai, rock shrimp, crab salad and a boat load of rolls / sashimi. The kitchen items come out and look like they are made for kids. Bite sized everything. Salad that is 4 wet pieces of lettuce. Rock shrimp was quoted as "looking like the dehydrated cup-o-noodle shrimp" (although the sauce was good) and crab salad that lacked crab. While this would normally suck, we simply ordered more the second time around. No bigs. The sushi came out and was OK. Rolls and sashimi ranged from a 2.5-3 out of 5 on the sushi scale. What really weirded me out was that they had a roll on the regular menu for $13 that had Spicy tuna, crunch with tuna & red tobiko on top. Soooo your saying for $19 I can order as much tuna sashimi and spicy tuna as I want, but for $13 I can get one roll? Surely I'm eating lesser tuna right? I dunno. Conspiracy theory right there. In the end, I left stuffed and spent $26 including tip. Not too bad. Would I come here again? Nah. Does AYCE go against what I think sushi is all about? Yep. Should you come here and order 50 orders of something just to see if they'll bring it out? Indeed. read more

I came here for lunch today at 12pm with my whole family because they were raving about how good the food was and to my surprise, they were closed. After doing some research, I noticed that they changed the hours to 1230. We decided to wait until 1245 and the restaurant still was not open. There was no sign informing us that they will be closed today. This is very unprofessional and I was highly disappointed. read more