Best pizza in NYC! Every bite is absolutely delicious, and the customer service is amazing. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, making every visit a great experience. I'll definitely keep coming back. Highly recommend! read more

Sunny John Pizzeria - Hot honey pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Sunny John Pizza is the absolute best. The grandma's pizza is the best I've ever tasted anywhere. His pizza is thin crusted and absolutely delicious. I give it five stars. read more

Sunny Johns is the best. Great pizza, fantastic zeppoles and I love their grilled chicken over salad. Delivery guys prompt and friendly. You gotta give them a try !! read more

Local hole in the wall pizza place. Grandma pie is great. It's good to eat it right there as it's super thin. If you get it for take out, it's ice cold by the time your home. read more

I have been to Sunny John's many times but decided to order via Grubhub+ today. I was so happy that the order actually came early! The order was stuffed shells, veal parmagiana with spaghetti (extra sauce & extra cheese), ziti with alfredo sauce & garlic knots. My hubby loved the veal. It was saucy and hot. I had the stuffed shells. To say my stuffed shells were a disappointment is an understatement. Talk about overcooked, slightly burnt & DRY! I had this before many times & it's always been perfect. This wasn't even during peak business hours. This order was placed around 2:30 PM. The garlic knots were burnt in several places. Someone wasn't manning the oven or something. I could even understand if it was during school & they were busy serving kids slices & forgot. I don't think I will order anymore. In person has always been great. Also, my daughter's ziti with Alfredo doesn't look like it has much Alfredo sauce. She hasn't eaten it yet. We'll see what she thinks I Will probably have to eat something else later being I only ate 2 dry shells & peeled the burnt bottom & top off of 2 garlic knots & ate them. This order was pricey! I expected more from Sunny John's. Very disappointed. Will think twice about ordering again. read more

See all

The pizza, wings, calzone and Cesar salad are amazing! We've never had a bad meal from here. read more

My favorite neighborhood pizzeria. Anytime the house wants pizza we drive over and get one regular and one extra cheese. The other night my husband wanted pizza and wings and we were shocked that there's actually delivery now so we tried it out. Everything arrived hot, fresh, and in one piece. read more

Ordered delivery with Slice. Expensive but good. Delivery on time and Courier very friendly plus a little funny. Ordered: *Grandma Square 4 slices with pepperoni *Lasagna with extra sauce Grandma Slice hit the spot and lasagna was very good. Wish the lasagna portion was bigger. Will definitely order again but pockets will have to be right. read more

Sunny John Pizzeria - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Been coming here for years they treat the customers very nicely and I love the bbq slice

Brand new store, reopened around New Year's across the street from the old location. Looks really nice inside, and the owner and staff are so friendly and really good people. My business partner can't have cheese and they made him his own 4 square grandma pizza w/o cheese and some really great sauce. The slices and choices are plentiful and the prices are great as is the food. read more

Sunny John Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The pizza is great, they make the pie to my liking, well done but not burnt, delivery is fast, and now they are open on Sundays. They have a lot in back if you can't find parking in front. The only problem is there is no way in through the back and so you have to walk around to the front read more

they are alway serving hot pizza slices when I tell them not to hot all the cheese n sauce dripping from the slice making a mess it's maybe because I'm a proud black person eating here not recommended read more

Sunny John Pizzeria - two slices of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We normally order here on Friday nights. Everything is delish, from the chicken wings, to the salads, the hero's & entrees. The only issue I have had which I learned from is when you order chicken cutlet parm they cut up the chicken, if you don't want it cut up you just need to ask not to cut it. read more

Just got a shrimp parmagian hero and a pepperoni roll. Both were hot, fresh, and delicious. I ordered online and it was ready right on time or a little early. And they were friendly, too. A+ read more

Just didn't cut it for me. Guess I'm used to amazing Italian food not just good or less than good. We ordered dinner and I love eggplant parmigiana and what I got was a crap load of ziti (mushy) and 2 slices of eggplant. I'm not kidding 2 slices usually most "restaurants" load the plate with eggplant not here. I read the reviews and and don't quite get it. It doesn't stop there because the potato and egg hero is potato and French fries, WTF !!!!! I want chunks of potatoes not fries. I could go on but I'm done. I think I'll go have a bowl of cereal for dinner. That never disappoints. read more

i really don't know why it's taken me so long to review sunny john's - they're the type of pie you want to eat when you're stuck at home during a pandemic for the holidays (true story), in a snow storm (walked over in a 15 minute trip that usually takes 5 minutes, but well worth it), and when relatives are visiting from out of town (they were here for two weeks, and we ended up ordering twice because they loved the pizza so much). my family is a pizza family and has been in the area for almost 20 years now. we were always pretty loyal to the original pizza on ralph avenue - i grew up on their everything pizza. however, as quality and service there declined, i heard some great things about sunny john and we ended up trying out the grandma pie. and that, as they say, is the end of that story. we never looked back. the garlic knots are smaller than i remember (though i was a kid, maybe garlic knots were always this size?), but fluffy and crisp in the right places and so garlicky and just a home run. good for the price and perfect with a slice. the buffalo chicken is good, as is the old fashion square pizza (man, that dough...), but the grandma is really my favorite. the right thinness to balance out the layer of cheese and sauce. you can eat slice after slice. so good. the staff here are also just so, so nice. i've never had any issues. a great place to go for pizza in any mood. read more

I always order for delivery here! I'm not sure what some of these bad reviews are about. Food is always on time and delicious. The delivery man has to be one of my favorite delivery men just because he treats you like a friend would. I believe most of the time he's the one who picks up the phone as well. He makes funny conversation with you and even has complimented my onesie I have came to the door with. (Haha). I had to give that man credit because he does a great job! If you are the type of person that loves a good grandma slice or a crispy slice period, this place is for you. They also make a delicious spaghetti and meatball platter. Their meatballs are really well seasoned and never disappoint. This is a clean and solid place. It is definitely one of those underrated pizza shops. I have never had a problem receiving the wrong order or them leaving anything out. The only thing is, if you want something with seafood like for example Penne alla Vodka with shrimp, I'd say pass. It's delicious but costly for seafood, as they charge for each shrimp. Otherwise inexpensive, reliable, and delicious. read more

Sunny John Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

So I ordered a bunch of stuff from them, and most of it was ok. But I ordered 2 soups, minestrone and chicken noodle....they had the NERVE to try and pass off a can of CAMPBELLS vegetarian vegetable soup as minestrone! And charged me $5 for it! Same thing with the chicken noodle soup, it was canned. I'm BEYOND PISSED!! And when I called and asked to speak to a manager or the boss, they told me "oh he's not here, I'm just the delivery guy"....yea how convenient! They wouldn't even let me speak to the cook! Never buying from them again, I don't like places that do shit like this....10 f**king dollars for 2 CANS OF SOUP that cost a $1 in the store! FOH! They just lost a good customer, and I'll be SURE TO SPREAD THE WORD!!! read more

Sunny John Pizzeria - CAMPBELLS CANNED VEGETARIAN VEGETABLE SOUP, being PASSED OFF as minestrone!!! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I have been eating this pizza since I was 5 years old, and as far as I'm concerned this epitomizes great pizza for me. The sauce is perfectly flavored, not sweet like at so many other places and with a nice tomato punch. The cheese is great, and maybe it's not fresh mozzarella, but nostalgia will always make me love it more than anything fancy. The crust is where they really get it right though: thin, and if you eat it soon after it's pulled from the oven, crispy and savory to contrast perfectly with the gooey cheese and sauce melding on top. Toppings aren't a strength here, but that's all right because a plain slice is so delicious all on its own. I'm also a fan of their calzones; they're nothing particularly unique but how can you dislike a burst if mozzarella and ricotta cheese oozing out of a perfectly browned pocket of crust? Their garlic knots are my favorites of any I've ever tried, and people tend to agree with me; we go anywhere else, and we always measure by the Sunny and John standard (the best we've been able to say is "pretty good, but not as good as S&J"). I haven't had any of their square slices in a while, and I know I should, but usually I get distracted by everything I've already described, and sometimes also their spinach rolls. Dipped in a to-order cup of marinara sauce, and sometimes a spinach roll is just what I need to give me the hit of green that I'm craving. read more

FAST delivery and called me to confirm correct drop off - excellent service and food we will order again:)

Pizza is good. Quick servies. Just very exspensive Pizza is all way good. You get what you pay for. It's the only reason I go out of my way to go though brooklyn when coming home from nj Wish they where closer to Suffolk county great pizza just a little expensive Will keep going there. read more

I have been coming to this pizza place for the past 3 years and the quality of ingredients, service and cleanliness is second to none. Management always goes above and beyond to make sure that i was completely satisfied! I love the Grandma Pizza! Out of a scale of 10 i give it a 9.9 ! We moved to Florida and come back here to my favorite place everytime we visit Brooklyn! ITS A MUST TRY! read more

We have been comming here for years. Best grandma pie in the area! They have fast delivery great zeppoles and fast service. They have served my sons birthday parties for 7 years with pizza and everyone always raves about there pizza. I will still be comming here for years to come read more

Just got another special Sicilian from Sunny John's Pizza....unfreakingbelievable!!! These guys make the tastiest everything pie I ever had. Just the right amount of toppings, not greasy, and sooooo tasty, u gotta try them! read more

See all

Polite staff! Great sized portion. Picked up my order of eggplant parmigiana and it was piping hot! I asked for extra sauce. No problem. Great neighborhood place with good prices. read more

It is really clean. $5 can go a long way in here. 2 slices & a Arizona or a snapple. 5 pepperoni pinwheels. Or any combination of the above. (That's what I usually get) I haven't tried anything else on the menu as of yet. I usually get my food to go because it's hard to have a full meal while you're trying to get your hair done. They have free parking behind the restaurant. read more

Pizza is good. Quick servies. Just very exspensive Pizza is all way good. You get what you pay for. read more

Good pizza. Good chicken rolls. I order often from here. Not stellar, but good and better than good enuf. Delivery is quick under 15 minutes but the delivery food tastes old so now we pick up our orders. read more

Good pizza and delightful interior. Nothing extraordinary but great for a mid-day stop and snack.

The pizza here is great and is always fresh. If there's any slice that you want them to make special, they'll make it fresh and fire it up for ya. One of my favorites is the grilled chicken caesar salad slice. They don't show it up at the front so you have to ask for it. This along with the buffalo slice makes for a great filling lunch, just what I need to get fired up and right back to work. I've been getting to know the owners and they're a great bunch of guys. In fact I've been coming in so often now, I caught them taking bets on what slices I was going to order that day. Fun crew, who will take care of you with some good pizza. read more

Love the grandma pizza it was very tasty the wings are also good by far the best grandma pizza I had

By far the best pizza in Brooklyn! My uncle took me here the other day for a slice of pizza and I just went again. The slice was amazing! The crust was crispy. I am from Florida and I have been coming to New York every year for about 20 years. Most delicious! read more

Sunny John Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I go here because they have parking and its only $2.00 a slice. The chicken rolls look like a long bread stick, I don't think I will try that. And it is not that clean. They could use a good scrubbing. read more

Listen I been to every pizzeria in mill basin and half of brooklyn let me be brutally honest when telling you that this is one great place for your family. The place is very clean and is family like every time I walk through the door and to top it off everything on the menu is delicious and other pizzerias in the neighborhood cannot compete the place is great the father and soon who own it for years treat me like family read more

Pizza is always hot and fresh and the Zeppoles make you wanna WALK home and slap your Mother!! LOL Staff is friendly and welcoming. Definitely worth the trip! read more

Best neighborhood pizza!!! The sauce is amazing here. It's not over priced at all, like the other pizzerias around the neighborhood. Very clean place and very kind workers read more

Sonny John's is the best pizza in the neighborhood. They also have really good rice balls & chicken rolls. I highly recommend if you are looking for a good quick slice. read more

My family and I have been ordering from here for years. This place is clean, the owner and staff are always friendly and pleasant. The pizza is great, grandma slice is the best! Hands down best place in the neighborhood! read more

Grandma pizza excellent always seem to have a tummy ache after over eating them.They deliver quickly and the kids love the thinness of the slices.. Above average for the area but location not so great .. read more

Sunny John's make the best Margarita pizza in Brooklyn. The crust is thin and crisp, but not too thin. The fresh tomato is exceollent, the quality of the flour and the fresh mozzarella are superb and exploding with flavor. I usually have them add chopped garlic and anchovies to make the ultimate slice. I have been all over Brooklyn and Manhattan. This is better to me than Grimaldis. read more