I ordered a bacon egg and cheese and thought it was delicious with a great cheese pull (the most important part). The service was very fast on a busy Sunday morning. The one thing I will say is it is absolutely freezing in the store so make sure you dress warm in the winter. I will be back to try more of the menu. read more

See all

I always pass by this Stuff A Bagel and finally gave it a try. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a plain bagel. The bagel was fresh and the sandwich itself was delicious. Eggs and bacon were cooked well and there was a generous amount of cheese. The service was fast and friendly. They have a big parking lot shared with other businesses but plenty of spots. Great spot to grab breakfast. read more

Stuff-A-Bagel - Bagels Near Me - East Islip, New York

Excellent bagels, super friendly staff and clean store. New owners who took over years ago really got their system running well. We are EI natives and only venture here for weekend bagels over the past 2 years. Love the addition of fresh pressed juices and even vegan cream cheese for friends and family with dietary restrictions. Figured I'd leave a review to help keep our local GOOD businesses up and running! read more

Stuff-A-Bagel - Everything bagel, sausage, egg & cheese - Bagels Near Me - East Islip, New York

HOLIDAY GO-TO FOR BAGELS on LONG ISLAND! Hanging out in Long Island, NY for Thanksgiving brings a definite change of scenery and atmosphere compared the hustle & bustle of The NYC. The drawback is that food isn't always readily available, like bagels. Day after Thanksgiving ALL the decent bagel shops in the area were closed except this Mom & Pop shop in East Islip. However, When we walked in around 9am, all they had were empty bins... DOH! Open but empty?!?! Luckily, one of the owners, Ms. Jenny is So DANG sweet! LOL! She sweet talked us into waiting, "only 10 minute" for the fresh batch that was cooking as we speak. WHOA?!? Fresh? As in FRESH FRESH?!? I can smell It already! BAGELS: 1 dozen is FOURTEEN here! And THEY WERE truly fresh outta the oven... Mmmmm :) EVERYTHING BAGEL (big hit with my local Fams), BLUEBERRY, CINNAMON RAISIN, PLAIN, and EGG. No Rainbow or French Toast unfortunately, today. LARGE bagels compared to what we have In California! AND... This FRESH thang is awesome! Soft, Flavorful and aromatic make this a delightful carb filled treat! We bought a bunch of cream cheese flavors too... blueberry, strawberry, chocolate chip, plain, and chives. Definitely a great compliment for the bagels! VERY EASY RECOMMENDATION! NomNom level is HIGH! Great customer service and yummy eats are a combination worth return visits all the time. They are open during the holidays, but come early or prepare for a short wait that's worth it! Enjoy :) read more

See all

My chicken. Cutlet was raw and pink and I asked for bacon she didn't give me any I got a chicken cheese hero for 14.50 get out of hereeeee

The cleanest deli I've seen in a long time! The sandwiches were delicious and everyone was super helpful in the store.

I hadn't been to this store in a few months but it's open early so I gave it a chance. Placed an order by phone at 5:30am to pickup on the way to the beach. The staff person was polite and well spoken on the phone. I arrived to a very clean store, smelled delicious and definitely a nicer layout than last visit. The order was prepared properly, packed as requested "individually wrapped for the cooler", and the food was great. We had bagels for breakfast and deli sandwiches for lunch. Will be back again read more

They are good but when the one guy cooks never gets my eggs the way I ask for .I specifically ask for it a certain way yet never gets it right. read more

I'm being generous with a 3 star review .. It's been many years since I was here at this bagel store but I remember them having fairly delicious bagels . Maybe they have new owners ? Sadly these bagels were on the cusp of adequate ! I picked up a few cinnamon raisin bagels ,several onion and sesame. Although the onion bagels did have plenty of onions on them they were pretty much bland and tasteless . We didn't try the sesame but I'm expecting the same quality. Lets call the cinnamon raisin bagel ... an Un- raisin Cinnamon ! I had one Raisin in my bagel ! Toasted with butter it was fine but also on the bland side . On a positive note they were not dry they were light and had good texture . The staff was very friendly and professional , wearing masks and following social distancing and the store was spotless . Since I purchased 6 bagels I got one free . I may consider trying them again , it could have just been an off day ? read more

See all

Used to go here years ago and recently started going again, place is very clean and the food is incredibly fresh , bagels are great and prices reasonable. Service is top notch, very professional read more

Paid over $8 cash for a mini bagel with just tuna. Next time, I learned I should drive up the block to Blue Line for maybe half the price and even better food. read more

Do not go here. This has been a go to for me and my family for years, even when the new owners came in. I was there one day to order a bagel with cream cheese. The lady was making two bagels one with butter for another customer and one with CC for me. It was taking a really long time, but not too surprised, they are not very organized there. So i peaked around the counter and saw the lady Cut her hand on the knife. She left the knife in the bagel and walked away and went into the back. Still waiting someone came out and asked who wasn't being helped and i told him he needed to throw the bagels out, that i was and another gentlemen were waiting on those bagels. He went over to finish slicing the bagel and i said "excuse me, you need to throw them out and get a clean knife, the woman who was slicing, cut herself. He said "oh so you're being helped" i said it again and he snapped at me.."OK boss lady"...... Who's next." Seriously, no kidding. They should be shut down by the board of health and that jerk should be fired! I will never go there again. Disgusting and Rude? No thanks read more

I go here everyday. Always very pleasant and the sandwiches have been excellent. The staff is always very pleasant and kind.

We used to go here at least three times a month. Since the new ownership even on Saturday and Sunday mornings, vehicles have been cold and hard. read more

My first visit here and at first everything was going well. Long line but we placed our order quickly. 3 BEC and a cream cheese bagel took over 20 minutes. People who came after us were getting huge heros in under 10 minutes. We were confused.. not sure what took so long. My bagel was okay. Not that much everything seasoning. One BEC didn't have cheese. Probably won't be rushing back here for bagels but hoping when I do we have a better experience. read more

TERRIBLE SERVICE. Bagels are amazing but definitely not worth the time it takes. I waited 30 minutes for 3 bagels. Not worth it. Bagels were really good though but again, not worth the extremely long wait. read more

Went here the other day. The staff is super nice and friendly. They have a great selection of bagels. My bagel was perfect. The coffee is good as well. It's also right next door to my favorite pizzeria. I think I found my new favorite bagel store lol read more

About o pull a Karen I grew up coming here my whole life. I live down the block and come here all time. Since this pandemic has happened everyone knows the rules of wearing a mask, especially in the work place. Well on Saturday I came in to order food when a worker was not wearing her mask. She was cleaning out the seeds from the bagels and replacing them WITHOUT HER MASK ON. When I said to the girl please tell her to put her mask on the girl lashed out at me! As if I was wrong to ask her to do so. Arguing with me that she has allergies and she can't breathe when wearing a mask. As a health care professional that is completely unacceptable. As I argued with this incompetent child for the safety of literally EVERYONE, I left I told her make sure you wear your mask and she proceeded to tell me to never come back. Soo needless to say, I'm absolutely disgusted and thought everyone should know how much they care about their towns safety. read more

They stop serving eggs an hour before they close because they cleaned the grill already. Missed out on 5 orders. I will never return there again. read more

My second time here. Still indifferent staff. Thought first time could have been a bad day etc but this second visit reassures me everyday is like that. No good morning may I help you or any thank you,,,have a nice day. Food was lacking also. Ordered 3 egg whites on bread with cheese and pepper. No pepper to be found and actually maybe half an egg white instead of 3 what happened to the days of pleasantry as a paying customer with a friendly gracious staff. Sure isn't here. Ugh. read more

Stuff-A-Bagel - Bagels Near Me - East Islip, New York

When they are on, the make a great bagel!!! But sometimes the bagels are hard and seem stale although I was assured they make them fresh daily. I like this place a lot, just wish there was more consistency w the bagels. read more

Used to go here all the time. Not any more! Ordered sandwich and drink was told $8.50 total. I gave the clerk a $20 and he gives me $11.50 in change. Then he tells me that I gave him a $10. I said it was a $20. Decided not argue. Decided to take my business elsewhere. read more

Food was excellent and staff and manager were very nice ! Go here everyweekend but im very unpleased on how HOT IT IS INSIDE ! espeically if i theres a line im sweating and i feel so bad for the staff ! There need an AC IN THIS PLACE OR YOU WONT GET MY MONEY HERE ANYMORE ! read more

Not the friendliest staff. The girl that helped me the last two times, doesn't even greet you, just looks at you and expects you to know she's waiting for you to order. Not the best bagels, not the worst. We've ordered for my job, dozens of bagels at a time, and they don't give you anything complimentary. Same thing when we've ordered heroes, no complimentary salads. read more

The people are rude and if you complain about a mistake they actually get mad at you Do not go to this place The food is hit or miss And when they miss you cannot even have it fixed without getting verbally attacked Go down the block to Bagel Basket read more

I remember growing up and coming here as a kid and getting some of the best bagels I've ever had. Now I come here and it's totally different. They barely put any cream cheese on the bagels, plus the bagels are hard. Not to mention the prices are through the roof. Real shame that East Islip can't even have a good bagel shop anymore. read more

Solid bagel place... I've read other reviews from the past 6 months and I feel like maybe they just had a streak of bad luck because while I agree there were times they seemed to falter for a short time, they have redeemed themselves. I just had the most perfectly cooked egg everything bagel with white fish, lettuce, onion, & tomato, and it was the best I've ever had. Absolutely perfect. I will continue going here because they always end up delivering good service, yummy sandwiches/bagels & a smile on my face. read more

I just moved from Nassau County to Suffolk County and ALL the restaurants have been great!!! But when it comes to Bagels I guess that I am going to have to do some searching...... These bagels were WAY undercooked and just did not meet up to what you expect from a NY bagel..... They had a very slim choice of salad, and cream cheese selections..... I got white fish salad and it was jus awful....... I guess (and I hope not) that when it comes to bagels, the closer to the city you are, the better!!!!! read more

The staff sucks. Not only did I specifically ask if they had the bagel I wanted they had me wait 15 minutes for an egg sandwich and a bagel and then proceeded to tell me they gave away all of the bagels I wanted so I had to pick a different kind. I literally watched 5 people come in after me and leave with the exact bagel I ordered before they decided to let me know mine was now gone. I'd rather go eat an average bagel at a place with a better staff. read more

Completely filthy inside. Zero pride taken in appearance making it hard to expect a quality breakfast sandwich.

Very rude I bought a everything bagel with bacon..... They rang me up for $5 what is the bacon made out of gold then after that I said how much would a bacon egg and cheese be they said 550 I said what ? "Oh I just shut our grill off" ok can I at least get a free small juice nope very rude read more

What kind of bagel shop doesn't offer a small juice or coffee with breakfast sandwiches? (Only weekdays they said) service is mediocre, staff is not friendly. Better off taking the drive up the road to Bagel Boss. read more

Very disappointed! I've been a customer for a very long time. I ordered a dozen of mini bagels stuffed with cold cuts for Mother's Day. On the website it says $27.00 and I've ordered them a few times before and that was the price. My husband picked them up and was charged $48.00. I called them was told the price went up; however it still states $27.00 on the website. I asked to speak with the owner, left my info he never called back. Not OK!!! I've spoken with other customers who now have told me East Islip Stuff a Bagel is terrible now with new owner..finding new bagel store read more

I used to look forward to visiting LI and having one of their bagels. No more. They must have changed hands. They went from the absolute best bagels on LI to the absolute worst. Sparse topping, stale/hard and no flavor. read more

I started going to Stuff a bagel in 2009. Sean was working there and the food was great. Unfortunately the last 10 or more times the fried egg sandwiches have been cooked wrong ,no cheese on the sandwich or completely wrong. We all make mistakes I understand that . But when it's the same mistake and there is no attempt to do better you decide to go to another place. I usually buy four sandwiches and four drinks. 26 to 30 dollars..Today's experience was even worse. I didn't want to use this method but every time I go too stuff a bagel they get my wife's and kids breakfast wrong. read more

Actually a bit upset. They charged me $7.50 for a side of turkey bacon. That's too much in my book. Not coming here anymore unless it's the only place open. read more

This used to be my favorite bagel shop but not so much anymore. The egg everything bagels had very few seeds and things. It should be called the egg nothing bagel. Plus they throw in an extra bagel when you buy six but when I got home they left out the extra bagel. Sad. read more

Breakfast is most of the time great and reasonably priced. Got lunch there today, (roast beef, cheddar, and coleslaw on an egg everything bagel). The roast beef was sliced super thick and it was so raw that it tasted like blood and you couldn't even chew it. Didn't smell or taste fresh either. I took it off sandwich and microwaved it to try and cook it a little more and it really didn't help at all. I ended up throwing all the meat away and just at cheese on the bagel. The macaroni salad that came with it unfortunately also not fresh and was vinegary which grossed me out. I guess breakfast and bagels only. read more

Stuff-A-Bagel - Garbage - Bagels Near Me - East Islip, New York

I got two bagels with cream cheese, and to bagels with egg. Delicious! The line was out the door.

Love this place for Bagel's, wouldn't get anything else here though. Been coming here for years. Same bagels ever since. The line gets out the door on the weekends but they manage it well. read more