Mario&#x27;s Pasticceria

19

291

673

1 year ago

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Omg. The smell when you walk in is fabulous and everything is so fresh.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I got an extra large cookie for st Patrick's day for my mechanic and his team as I was getting my car serviced. I also got the lobster tail. It was off the hook. I ate it for four days and it still tasted fresh. This is now my go to bakery for sure read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Oversized cookie for st Patrick's day - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ken S.

0

97

2

5 months ago

The st Joseph's pastry was excellent lite airy and filled with cannoli cream. Great texture. I have never had a bad experience with Mario's. They even have a Sicilian pastry my father use to make. Casateda. Excellent. The service is friendly and helpful. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elizabeth F.

4

30

48

2 years ago

I do not bake ever, but I know exactly where to go for the best! Ricotta cookies are the best I've ever had. I went in for something to bring to a brunch. What picked out looked delicious. The owner asked if I minded waited for fresh ones to come out. That was very thoughtful and appreciated. She even put the powdered sugar on the side so it wouldn't melt. The nicest staff and owner ever. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Lisa M.

Elite 16

87

153

585

2 years ago

The most scrumptious Sfingi I've had since I was a child growing up in Brooklyn! We live in Manhattan now and have literally thrown away Sfingi from many bakeries in the City, Bronx and Brooklyn! Marios truly has kept the old world tradition alive. The cannoli cream is not too sweet with a wonderful texture. Candied Orange bits and no ridiculous choc chips! Authentic!! The cream puff shell is moist and light! The box of 6 weighed a ton. lol. No words can describe how you feel when you bite into one of Mario's Sfingi! They're simply to die for. I look forward to making a trip out to Babylon to try their Sfogliatelle. Thank you from an Italian who desperately needs authentic Italian pastry. Marios is by far... THE BEST! read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Marios Sfingi - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 2

Crista R.

255

155

24

3 years ago

For the 3 things I had here, this place is easily the best Italian bakery on LI and possibly all the ones in queens and the boroughs. They held up to best bakeries in Italy. I had the lobster tails with cannoli cream, the pignoli cookies, and the almond cookies. Those lobster tails are a solid 5 stars across the board. Hands down the best cannoli cream on Long Island and queens. It brought me back to Sicily. Really so fresh, perfect amount of sweetness and fresh ricotta texture was perfect. The pastry itself was perfect as well, buttery, flakey layers, perfectly baked. I'm so impressed. And the pignoli cookies were the best I've had! Again, perfect amount of sweet, perfect texture and just fantastic flavor. The ricotta tart was also lovely. Not What a find!! I'm looking forward to coming back and trying more things. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Phil C.

18

85

0

8 months ago

So I went to Marios christmas morning to get pastries.....You would never think it was an italian bakery when you walk inside....90% of what they have out in the display cases are american cakes . pies , and cookies....The only pastry out on display was a few lobster tails.....They only had 2 people working the counter and one was slower than the other....I was shocked to hear that they had NO Sfogliatelle available to buy....How does an italian bakery NOT have them on christmas morning......GEEZZZZ I drove 45 minutes each way to go there but I doubt I would do it again.....P.S. The cannolis had no fruit or cherrys on them .................. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Craig I.

0

6

0

8 months ago

Best bakery around, consistently excellent baked goods! Always has a nice treat for a get together or sweet treat!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

T-burger T.

0

21

0

9 months ago

Absolutely best Cannoli I have ever had! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Very cute inside.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Good rainbow cookie and good cookies.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Victorian A.

2

11

0

1 year ago

My partner and I got a selection of pastries and cookies from this bakery while out the other day. Some of what we purchased was the sprinkle jelly sandwich cookies, an almond horn, a lobster tail, and a few other things. They were all honestly so delicious, all we can think about is going back. Everything was SO fresh, SO high quality. The lady at the counter was very nice, she was training someone and helping her to help us. [[HIGHLIGHT]]When you first walk in, it smells like an authentic Italian bakery where the people truly care about their products and it really shows.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We'll absolutely be back. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Laurie F.

0

56

1

2 years ago

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Love to stop in to this pretty little bakery.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We love everything we've ever tried. Especially the apple turnovers and chocolate cigar. Lovely staff. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Pamela D.

0

2

1

1 year ago

Best napoleon on the planet. Pies are fantastic and the crust is delicious! Definitely make your way there.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ally S.

325

125

33

2 years ago

The real deal! Seriously some of the best classic, home made Italian pastries, cookies & more! Arthur avenue on Long Island - must go! So friendly too! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Deborah E.

1

28

4

2 years ago

Formerly the old Peter Paul I believe on little east neck rd - Italian biscotti pastry way over priced ! The other store had fair prices this was also way pre pandemic - maybe it's the location ? Most things in Babylon are over priced - I'd would rather drive to Alpine Bakery personally read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 2

Christine M.

0

2

0

2 years ago

I called Mario's Pasticceria for the first time to see if I could order my husband's Birthday cake the day before the celebration. I had gone to my usual local Bakery and basically there were alot of "no we can't do thats"....that ultimately, even though the young lady was very sweet, it really wasn't working for me. I've always passed by Mario's Pasticceria, saw the signs out front and wondered about this Bakery. Anthony had me at hello. When I asked if he was Mario he shared that he had named the Bakery after his Grandfather. It was such a great experience ordering my husband's carrot birthday cake. Anthony asked questions to put me into the right cake for the celebration I am having with the family. I'm excited to pick up my hubby's Birthday Cake tomorrow! I just have a KNOWING it's going to be absolutely delicious! If that much care went in to the phone call.....I'm sure that much HEART goes into all of the baked goods. ***** Five Star Experience I have a very strong feeling I will be a regular customer Christine West Babylon NY read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Mary B.

42

828

1213

5 years ago

We were driving down the road and saw a sign for gelatos! Quick stop! Wished there were more flavors to choose, but the chocolate scoop of gelato and my stracciatella gelato were delicious! What a place to buy pastry! Check it out or maybe you want a cake made with a personal theme.... They do it here! read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Gelato sign caught my attention! - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - Store front - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Kelly W.

0

7

4

2 years ago

Don't mind the presentation. That's my mess! When I say the BEST tiramisu I've ever had, I mean it. My wonderful neighbor went in to get me a lobster tail but they sold out. She got this instead. Wow isn't good enough to describe how delicious this is. Holy freaking moly Wow is better. Go now. You won't be disappointed. read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Tiramisu - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael M.

1

30

1

2 years ago

Never had a St Joseph's pastry in my life. Saw a review on social media and drove 30 minutes to try it. Didn't disappoint at all. Was phenomenal. The cannolis were great too. Will def be back! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christine A.

111

390

425

6 years ago

If you live near this amazing store, lucky you! I bought some pastries to bring home to Manhattan. Fresh and delicious. The cookies are great. The people behind the counter are nice. My eyes were taking in all the amazing looking cakes, pies, cookies and pastries. read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Pastries - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Dawn D.

37

95

123

3 years ago

Fresh made pastry and cake! While I went into get my St Joseph's Day pastry I picked up a coffee and fresh breakfast pastry Chose the blueberry scone although the jelly donut and apple turnover are enticing . read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Cannoli cake When you call make sure it's Babylon not Cedarhurst. - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - Cookies and pastry just because it's Wednesday - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - Fresh cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - Key lime pie ! Box of rainbow cookies just because it's Tuesday - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - Cookies to celebrate Fourth of July - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - Custom ordered birthday cake. Nut free ! - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - Rainbow cookies for my afternoon latte - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - Fresh Italian bread to go with my dinner. Fresh from the source - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - Saint Joseph's Day pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kathryn P.

2

17

3 years ago

Cozy and delightful place with excellent pastries, cookies, cakes and breads! They do things right and it really shows! The Tomato and onion focaccia I picked up today was amazing! Lovely owners and staff too read more

Mario's Pasticceria - the outside of a restaurant - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - a table and chairs in front of a brick wall - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - a variety of patriotic treats - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - a brick wall and shelves - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Mario's Pasticceria - a variety of pastries - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

C D.

0

28

1

2 years ago

[[HIGHLIGHT]]The minute you walk in you know you're in a bakery. The smell is fantastic![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Anthony is great! [[HIGHLIGHT]]This place is a piece of Italy.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The food and service is great! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mona M.

0

14

0

2 years ago

Excellent bakery. The best brownie and cannoli I've had in a long time. Reminds you of the way baked goods "used to be." You can tell they are using high quality ingredients and everything is baked with love. The fruit squares and cookies are also delicious. We were pleasantly surprised by how good the espressos and lattes were as well. The cherry on top is that it's a family run business with great customer service. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Andrew S.

0

25

5

2 years ago

Great place try it, bunch of nice people and the pastries are great! This place is at least a monthly stop for me

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rob C.

7

112

0

3 years ago

Tried Mario's for the first time on St. Joseph's Day. Went there specifically for the Sfingi. Truly some of the best I've had. It's very easy to see when a place has the passion for what they do, because they take the time to do it right. The shell of the Sfingi was light, eggy and fresh as can be. The cannoli cream was velvety smooth and not overly sweet. Consistency was spot on. The cherry was there, the citron was there, the powdered sugar was there.... and it all adds up to perfection! Round trip for me was 1 hr. But I will definitely return for Easter for my grain pie!!!! Highly recommend this great establishment for quality that you will undoubtedly receive!!! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tom G R.

0

22

0

2 years ago

Everytime I stop in for cake, pie, cookies or pastries I am NEVER disappointed. Outstanding family owned business.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Martha L.

12

310

666

8 years ago

Delicious Italian pastries, cookies, cakes and tortes. Nice bread and a pretty shop. This is just what the neighborhood needed. We love this place. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Pa M.

0

46

3

4 years ago

I too have been going to th is bakery for many years. DELISH!! I've never been dissatisfied. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Camille L.

0

1

0

7 years ago

Mario's Pasticceria always has the freshest, best tasting cakes, cookies and pastries. I ordered a chocolate Napoleon cake for Easter, a cake that they do not make on a regular basis. My request was happily received. The cake was amazing. Their lobster tail pastries filled with French cream or cannoli cream are to die for. If they do not have something that you are looking for, they will make it for you. Aside from the excellent quality of their baked goods, Gabriela and her son Anthony are always very welcoming. It's like going in to visit an old friend. Mario's is my go to bakery for everything and I have told my whole family about their excellence. One last thing, if something is not 100% fresh, they will not sell it to you. To me, that speaks volumes. They are not there "just to make a sale". They genuinely care about their customers read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gene Y.

0

7

2

4 years ago

Cookies were good, but the cake we ordered for a birthday was a bit dry. There was also some confusion regarding picking up items that were ordered ahead of time. When I ordered the cake mentioned, the owner told me to just skip the line on the day of pick up and go straight to the register. On the day of pick up, the counter staff told me and another person picking up an order that we'd have to wait in line. I get it was the day before Thanksgiving but you may want to put up some signage to make your policies clearer for customers and staff. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Philip C.

65

30

18

7 years ago

What a great addition to Babylon Village!! Amazing Italian Bakery. We picked up the Strawberry Shortcake, it was fresh, delicious and impressed everyone I had for dinner. Went back to get it again for another event and they didn't have it .....the owner asked what I was looking for..told her we loved the Strawberry Shortcake...she said give me 15 minutes and made us one right then!!! Beyond fresh and delicious the customer service is wonderful!! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Kevin P.

0

1

0

4 years ago

This family owned Pasticceria is outstanding. Everything is 5 stars and they are friendly and caring and helpful. - Kevin read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mary L.

9

12

0

4 years ago

First time customer but I'll be back again and again. Met Gabriella and her son Anthony such nice helpful people. I had a hard time making my selection from all the delicious looking items. I settled on a fresh loaf of bread( delicious ) to make my avocado toast , raspberry and lemon, ricotta cheese ,apple and crumb pastries Absolutely fantastic ! Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Leslie R.

0

5

0

3 years ago

The wedding cake they made for us was terrific. The owner was wonderful to us, and service was excellent. I would recommend this wonderful bakery to all our friends read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Twist N.

964

105

620

7 years ago

Place has amazing goodies. The St. Joseph was absolutely stellar. The rainbow cookie cannoli cake pieces are unique and fun to try. The rasberry cake loaf was scrumptios. Pignoli cookies were very nice of course, hard to mess those up though. The cannoli empanada is now one of my top favorite pastries i've ever had, looking forward to grabbing another at some point. Rainbow cookies were a great size, just enough jam but could have been a little more fresh. The bakery owner did tell us they were from day before so at least I knew what to expect. Overall great experience and will be coming here oppose to Torta Fina more frequently. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Nicole G.

4

72

32

5 years ago

I'll give it 3 stars because the owner was nice, but, I was extremely disappointed coming here. I tried it out because both bakeries in my town were closed on the day i came here. We were told that their mixer was broken so there was hardly any selection. I feel like we were pressured to buy the items that were "just made", but we wanted other things. The cannoli cream was very gritty, and the lemon cookies were flavorless. The fig cookies were good. Not sure if I would return here. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John S.

2

23

2

5 years ago

I went to this Bakery last week just before Thanksgiving, I was looking for a birthday cake for my wife. They didn't have what I was looking for in the display case but the lady at the counter ( I'm assuming was the owner) was so helpful and accommodating, she took the time to help me figure out the perfect cake AND they made it the SAME DAY. Superb Customer Service and the cake was DELICIOUS, I'm so glad I found this bakery and I HIGHLY recommend you go here too. The interior is beautifully decorated and the assortment of cookies, cannolis, cakes & fresh bread is amazing. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Anthony G.

Elite 19

469

1533

7010

8 years ago

Quite good international bakery in Babylon where you'll find Italian pastries along with some German, Austrian and Jewish confections thrown in. Got a doughnut which was really good as were the linzer tarts. Service at the counter was polite and prices are fairly reasonable making this a nice bakery to stop by for a pastry. Recommended. read more

See all

Helpful 37

Thanks 0

Love this 30

Oh no 0

B. R.

4

17

10

5 years ago

Popped in for some cannolis today and they were delicious! Best I've had in a long time! Met the owner and she was super sweet! I can't wait to go back and try all of their delectable delights! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 2

See more reviews

More info about Mario's Pasticceria

199 E Main St
Babylon, NY 11702
Directions
(631) 539-8636
Call Now

Hours

What time does Mario's Pasticceria open?

Mario's Pasticceria opens at 8:00 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Mario's Pasticceria opens at 7:30 AM on Sunday.

What time does Mario's Pasticceria close?

Mario's Pasticceria is closed on Monday.Mario's Pasticceria closes at 7:00 PM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Mario's Pasticceria closes at 5:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon ClosedTue-Sat 8:00 AM - 7:00 PMSun 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Mario's Pasticceria take credit cards?

Yes, Mario's Pasticceria takes credit cards.

Indoor Amenities

Does Mario's Pasticceria allow dogs?

Yes, Mario's Pasticceria allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Mario's Pasticceria have parking?

Yes, Mario's Pasticceria has parking options. Validated Parking

Other Amenities

Is Mario's Pasticceria wheelchair accessible?

No, Mario's Pasticceria is not wheelchair accessible.

From the Business

Specialties

Mario's Pasticceria offers a delicious arrangement of bakery products. Our specialties include biscotti, Italian pastries, cheesecake and more!

History

Established in 2017.

Mario's Pasticceria is formally from Michael and Paul's Bakery in West Babylon. After having been there for over ten years, we found a new location in Babylon Village.

You might also consider

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe

They always have the best goods even for the gluten free peeps out there. And you can't beat a nice…read morecup of coffee too which they'll always make! Everyone inside is super nice and friendly and you always get served quickly. You walk in and get that old school bakery vibe and there's o many choices to stare at while you order.

This is a very cute shop with lots of different dessert options. Inside reminds me of a grandmas…read moresitting area. I ordered a bicenza, (hot chocolate with espresso and a biscotti) which although it was good, was very expensive and there are no prices posted any where. Service was slow and we were ignored for quite a while before being helped. I think I'd go back to pick up sweet treats but unlikely to get another beverage there.

See all

Custom cake

Shuga pie Shop

4.9

(24 reviews)

0.2 mi

If you likes sweets or even just once in awhile ... this is the place to go. I think it's a great…read moreplace for a box of desserts for a party or bbq. Something different than these pastry shop chana etc. First off Terry was unbelievable sweet & friendly. He went out of his way to be helpful & patient with me because I couldn't decide on Flavors or the amount. I guess I am old school or maybe just plain weird but I really like making the HUMAN connection when I am out & about.... I feel like people just aren't very socia anymore ....for a number of reasons . ANYWAY , if you have not been to AhugaPie Shop you ABSOLUTELY MUST GO. So I guess most people would equate a sugar pie to a Whoopie pie. These sugar pies are pretty big and a half of one is more than enough. Terry told me some people buy them and cut them in half and freeze them and take them out as they want them. Which I think is a great idea and is which what I did because I do not live nearby, but I would definitely drive to the end of the Earth for more. It's just one of those places. And I am not a big sweet person put the cake is just always soft and flavorful and delicious. And the filling is the right amount of the flavor and whipped cream and sugar. I think they have like 10 or so flavors available every day and they switch them around. I've probably tried five or six different flavors over the past two years and again all of them were very consistently delicious and amazing. I can't even explain it . It's just perfect. I've had them a few times before when a coworker brought them in. And I finally got a chance to go myself. I was so happy to share the experience with my family.. personally I love the chocolate cake with the peanut butter filling. So if your peanut butter lover, OMG go go go!!! . The product is very consistent. They do have a very specific hours. And as Terry recommended, it's always best to call ahead and either order , check the flavors of the day . & or the shop hours. It kind of blew my diet, but it was well worth it.. please go you will not be disappointed.. the only negative thing I can say about my experience is I wish I had bought a more of a variety of flavors. But that's on me l. Thank you Terry for your kindness - people like you restore my faith in mankind. and you make a dang good SHUGA PIE

It was a short wait to order. We got a variety to sample. Some were better than others but overall…read morewe enjoyed them! I would definitely support if back in the area but I probably wouldn't travel just for them.

Rainbow cookie Whoopie pie

See all

Chocolate & PEANUT BUTTER FILLING

Cream Puff Bakery

The best cream pies, cakes, everything. My family bought stuff there since I was a baby.read more

My father used to take us kids every Sunday morning for rolls and coffee cake. That was in the…read moreearly 60s. He would give us money to buy the Sunday Daily News and comic books. Glad they're still in business. The products were superb and oh the nostalgia.

Jack Jack's Coffee House

Updated Review: February 28, 2026 I came back to Jack Jack's…read moreafter my original review in 2016. I was a little hesitant after my first experience but they were listed in my LI Cafe Passport book I got for Christmas and I want to go to all the spots in that book even if I'm revisiting. My second experience was much better so I'm upping my review to 4 stars. The staff was nicer this time. I opted for a pour over because that's what the book recommended and I got the cherry vanilla latte as well with half and half. I was able to sit in the coffee shop because I had dropped my son off at a birthday party and had a little time before I picked him up. I caught up on watching Friday Night Smackdown before elimination chamber with headphones on of course so I wouldn't disturb other people and I finished a book I was reading. The seating was nice, an optional variety of different kinds of seats and lots of seating. The latte was very smooth, you could definitely taste the coffee more in the pour over but that was good, the coffee went down nicely, not a lot of bitterness. So Jack Jack's redeemed themselves in my eyes almost ten years after my first review and I would be able to recommend going to them. Babylon Bean will still be my favorite coffee shop in Babylon but both of them are nice to visit. Original Review: March 22, 2016 I came here after picking up my jacket from the dry cleaners. I didn't like it very much at all and am happy to say my heart and my business will continue to go to the Babylon Bean! The baristas did not seem happy at all when they helped me. They weren't rude but they weren't sweet or nice either. I chose a brownie to eat and got a cup of regular coffee. The coffee was okay, not horrid but for sure not great. The brownie was disgusting. I couldn't eat the whole thing ended up throwing it on the ground for the birds to eat. This place also has a hipster vibe, sometimes I can dig it but sometimes I can't. So in my personal experience if the babylon bean and this place had a throw down I would always favor the bean!

I had the grilled cheese sandwich which was crispy, toasted with a gooey, melty center. The bread…read moretasted toasted and buttery, and the cheese pull was unreal. Definitely deserves a repeat .

See all

Inside

Doughology - Babylon

(112 reviews)

0.3 mi

I've been waiting to get to doughlogy Nice place I would say…read morevery clean The donuts are very good. I'm definitely coming back to this.

Incredible verity, amazing staff, and the doughnuts were top shelf! Can't wait to go back again!!!read more

Rainbow Cookie Donut & Chocolate Peanut Buttercup Donut ~ 3.15.26

Rainbow Cookie Donut ~ 3.15.26

See all

Bill

A & R Bagel World

4.3

(27 reviews)

0.2 mi

Ordered the the chilaquiles with eggs over easy and added chicken (for delivery). I also asked for…read moresome shredded lettuce and tomatoes on top. I was really excited because I read some good reviews but was instantly disappointed when I opened my container. My eggs were missing and no lettuce or tomatoes. The rice was hard and tasted old like it was left over from yesterday. The beans were good. The salsa verde and tortilla part was tasty . However the chicken was dry. It didn't feel like a part of the dish. It was sprinkled on top like a last minute afterthought. There was also a brown rotting avocado on top. When I called the restaurant to complain, they blamed the driver, instead of owning up to and trying to rectify the situation. Last I checked, drivers don't prepare food. I do not recommend ordering takeout from here.

Love the vegan cream cheese and bagels at this location. My favorite is the veggie tofu cream…read morecheese on whole wheat everything. There is seating available and it's located on a cute street to shop and walk around.

Lunch wrap plater sampler for 20 people

French toast bagels

See all

Homemade primavera pasta cold salad

Babylon Bean Coffee House

Great vibe, friendly baristas, and a solid matcha. Can't ask for better than that! I'm also always…read morea fan of a place that sells locally sourced merch, so I grabbed cookies from a local baker. I wish I snapped a picture of the bag, but they were these chewy chocolate cookies that were divine. There were 8 in the bag and propped right on the counter. If you see them - get them! So good!

Bummed about this spot. The reviews looked promising enough but I have to disagree. Maybe it was…read morejust an off Sunday but both our drinks were just outright bad. My latte tasted like it had no espresso & way too much syrup. My boyfriend's coffee was watery, with a burnt flavor. It was over filled and the lid wasn't on right so it spilled everywhere. The staff was nice but they didn't really seem to know what was going on :( the inside is cute but there was no bathroom available when we went. It was out of order and we couldn't use the staff one. Ultimately the coffee / latte reminded me of the Dunkin' Donuts by the train station, not a stand alone coffee house

Iced Matcha with agave, lemon juice, & water

Coffee run

See all

Fall menu

Babylon Village Meat Market

Great prices will definitely be back. to this butcher they…read morewhere super friendly and professional they completely took care of my meat needs.

Went after trying a sample of Green Crack. Hadda grab some for the family. But of course I wanted…read moreto try out some of their meat so I grabbed a few skewers to snack on. Wow! Here it may cost 3x more but it tastes 5X better! The family run store is super friendly and has a great variety. Can't wait to go back.

See all

Jack Jack's Coffee House

Updated Review: February 28, 2026 I came back to Jack Jack's…read moreafter my original review in 2016. I was a little hesitant after my first experience but they were listed in my LI Cafe Passport book I got for Christmas and I want to go to all the spots in that book even if I'm revisiting. My second experience was much better so I'm upping my review to 4 stars. The staff was nicer this time. I opted for a pour over because that's what the book recommended and I got the cherry vanilla latte as well with half and half. I was able to sit in the coffee shop because I had dropped my son off at a birthday party and had a little time before I picked him up. I caught up on watching Friday Night Smackdown before elimination chamber with headphones on of course so I wouldn't disturb other people and I finished a book I was reading. The seating was nice, an optional variety of different kinds of seats and lots of seating. The latte was very smooth, you could definitely taste the coffee more in the pour over but that was good, the coffee went down nicely, not a lot of bitterness. So Jack Jack's redeemed themselves in my eyes almost ten years after my first review and I would be able to recommend going to them. Babylon Bean will still be my favorite coffee shop in Babylon but both of them are nice to visit. Original Review: March 22, 2016 I came here after picking up my jacket from the dry cleaners. I didn't like it very much at all and am happy to say my heart and my business will continue to go to the Babylon Bean! The baristas did not seem happy at all when they helped me. They weren't rude but they weren't sweet or nice either. I chose a brownie to eat and got a cup of regular coffee. The coffee was okay, not horrid but for sure not great. The brownie was disgusting. I couldn't eat the whole thing ended up throwing it on the ground for the birds to eat. This place also has a hipster vibe, sometimes I can dig it but sometimes I can't. So in my personal experience if the babylon bean and this place had a throw down I would always favor the bean!

I had the grilled cheese sandwich which was crispy, toasted with a gooey, melty center. The bread…read moretasted toasted and buttery, and the cheese pull was unreal. Definitely deserves a repeat .

See all

Inside

Talina

4.4

(76 reviews)

0.4 mi

The best Italian restaurant on Long Island. Fresh pasta, authentic taste, amazing ambiance, and…read morefriendly service. Have been here several times and everything I've ordered has been amazing. Highly recommend coming here!

Beautiful and cozy restaurant, it's very small so definitely make a reservation! Nice bar area and…read morea few high tops by the front window. Small menu but very nice and interesting recipes. I really appreciate the attention to detail in regards to ingredients and flavor pairings. The pasta is very good and is homemade, made in house. The service was impeccable. Great wine list and drink menu. The salad was huge and more than enough for two people, though it was slightly overdressed.

Zucchini- served cold which was interesting but still very good

Coffee bar vibes

See all

Strozzappreti Gratinati

Sweet Sensations

Like fancy lee and really babylon village as a whole I hadn't been to sweet sensations in YEARS! My…read morefriends and I went in to an empty store which was great so we could really look around and figure out what we wanted, when I saw the dubai sundae on the specials menu I immediately went for it and it did not disappoint! the pistachio sauce was smooth and nutty the katafi pieces light and crispy and the chocolate shell pieces were the cherry on top! the chocolate ice cream was well balanced in and of itself not too much/ overpowering like some chocolate ice creams can be , you can also get whipped cream and a cherry on top but I didn't feel that this needed that and wanted to try it as is for what it is, very enjoyable!

Lots of good options in this ice cream shop . A lot of hard ice cream including vegan options and…read moregluten free cones ! Also soft serve, vanilla, chocolate and swirl. However they have 50 flavored syrups that they can add to the soft serve to give you different flavors . Got the cherry hard bonnet. Gotta say it was not that hard and def didn't taste like cherry. Didn't take bad, just didn't have a flavor. Asked for a little water and they said it would cost 50 cents! Thought that was not great. 3 benches outside and parking lot in front of the store. Staff were friendly.

Colorful soft ice cream image

Dubai chocolate sundae

See all

Many flavors of soft ice cream served

Ninja Ramen & Poke Bowl

Definitely one of my favorite places for takeout in Babylon - their spicy tuna poke bowl is always…read moretasty and fresh. Plus friendly service and easy pick up.

The poke bowl had big cube pieces of tuna which was appreciated. They don't advertise any make your…read moreown bowls. The have standard poke, rice and Ramen bowls with limited toppings included. They have some fried appetizers and buns. The mixed greens was not mixed, it was just standard iceberg lettuce, disappointed that it wasn't spring mix lettuce. Price was $16 which is standard. There are a few small tables inside that you can eat at.

Inside

See all

Babylon Cheese Cellar

This place is just so awesome! Anytime I need a good cheese it's my goto. The staff and owner are…read morefabulous - this last time I took my daughter (who recently discover cheese) to find out which one she liked most. They let us sample a range of awesome blue's, and then we grabbed her a wedge of her own "nibbling cheese" that I'm not allowed to touch. Make sure to try their sandwiches, mac and cheese, or charcuterie boards (or supplies for them). They are all fantastic!

Cute little shop! The staff is always very kind and knows what they're talking about but not…read moreoverbearing which I appreciate! Tons of different cheese to try and other things here and there. They're also always more than happy to let you sample the cheese. The parking could be better, but it's not usually super crowded. I'm definitely going to try some of their food next time I go!

Cheeses

See all

Babylon Village Meat Market

Great prices will definitely be back. to this butcher they…read morewhere super friendly and professional they completely took care of my meat needs.

Went after trying a sample of Green Crack. Hadda grab some for the family. But of course I wanted…read moreto try out some of their meat so I grabbed a few skewers to snack on. Wow! Here it may cost 3x more but it tastes 5X better! The family run store is super friendly and has a great variety. Can't wait to go back.

See all

BesTea by Hitch

4.6

(39 reviews)

0.2 mi

Such a cute shop, everything is pink which is right up my alley. They have gummy candy as well, not…read moresure if it's considered Swedish candy as I was only there for an iced latte. Went with the banana bread iced latte which was good, I think I was more excited about the heart shaped cup and heart shaped straw that it comes with.

This is one of the cutest tea spots on Long Island! The décor and ambiance are absolutely adorable,…read morecreating a fun, vacation-like atmosphere that's perfect for both adults and kids.They offer a great variety of drinks, including boba tea, candy-inspired beverages, and plenty of other delicious options. Everything we tried was really good! As an added bonus, there's a charming boutique right next door where you can browse jewelry and other cute accessories. It's the perfect place to enjoy a refreshing drink and do a little shopping. Definitely worth a visit!

Sitting area

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Rosario S. C.

15

871

2215

2 years ago

Mario's Pasticceria, a quaint and beautiful bakery in Babylon Village, offers an array of delectable pastries, cookies, and cakes. The mini cakes are particularly amazing. When I visited, I craved a black and white cookie, but they had run out. The staff kindly made a fresh one for me on the spot. Although parking can be challenging in the village, there is parking available in the back. The friendly and welcoming staff make Mario's Pasticceria a must-try bakery. read more

Marie Z.

0

2

0

9 years ago

Definitely as good as it gets. I would give Mario's Pasticceria six stars if it were possible. I am so happy Gabriella (of Michael and Paul Bakery) has relocated to Babylon Village. We really missed all the goodies here in West Babylon. I will once again be getting all my bakery goods from Gabriella and Mario. BTW, it's right next door to Gemelli's. What could be bad! read more

Ginny S.

0

1

0

9 years ago

So glad I found this bakery! Missed your old Michael & Paul Bakery in West Babylon. Good luck in your beautiful new shop. Authentic Italian baked goods made by 3 generations of family. Delicious read more

Zak S.

255

14

1

9 years ago

Gabriella and Anthony treat us like family. Unlike other local eateries, I find true value in the authenticity of the baked goods. Fairly priced and always fresh. Thank you! read more

Mario's Pasticceria - bakeries - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Mario's Pasticceria also viewed

Villa Bella Bakery

(78 reviews)

This used to be a great Italian family owned bakery. My kids grew up on the cookie every…read moreholiday.... then it all stopped. The prosciutto bread is salami bread, but still $7 for a small loaf. Ok but dont says its prosciutto! In the just year or so new owners took over and it really sucks more than just the bread. Everything is smaller, less flavor .. but higher prices? Come on you replace real butter with lard, dont try to object it's obvious in your mouth! Do yourself a favor and accept villa bella is dead and the replacement isn't italian and knows no quality!

This is nothing like the quality of product the old owners gave to customers - was unaware it was…read morebought about a year ago - stale cartucci such a tiny amount of cannoli filling in stale pastry - 5 bucks each - not worth 50 cents to be honest - cookies the large one 5 dollars everything grossly overpriced and underwhelming ! A woman came in for a small tray of cookies 1 lb she told her 36 dollars - come on !! The bread was small - better going to uncle Giuseppe's for at least bread - sad that this place was bought out ! We miss them ! Plus the new owners very cold and not embracing of customers !

Patsy's Italian Bakery

4.3

(116 reviews)

Stopped in for Italian ices this weekend, but it's impossible to not be distracted by the…read moreoverwhelming amount of delicious goodies they have on display! Live local and highly recommend

First time going since moving to the neighborhood and I will definitely be back. It reminds of how…read morebakeries were when I was a kid. The smell as I walked in was the best. The staff was sweet & helpful. Oh and the display cases were immaculate and nicely arranged. Can't forget about all the cakes (tiramisu almost came home with me today but I'll be back for it). Can't wait to go back.

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe

(105 reviews)

They always have the best goods even for the gluten free peeps out there. And you can't beat a nice…read morecup of coffee too which they'll always make! Everyone inside is super nice and friendly and you always get served quickly. You walk in and get that old school bakery vibe and there's o many choices to stare at while you order.

This is a very cute shop with lots of different dessert options. Inside reminds me of a grandmas…read moresitting area. I ordered a bicenza, (hot chocolate with espresso and a biscotti) which although it was good, was very expensive and there are no prices posted any where. Service was slow and we were ignored for quite a while before being helped. I think I'd go back to pick up sweet treats but unlikely to get another beverage there.

A & G Bakery

(89 reviews)

This place is now called The Ultimate Bakery and located in one of those strip malls. Hubby was…read morecraving some sweets from here the other night so we stopped by and he specifically wanted to come to THIS place. He said he's been coming to this bakery for quite some time and his brother always buys a bunch of things when he visits. There was plenty of free parking on a Saturday night and the store itself was brightly lit. Very spacious inside and very clean. I was surprised at the variety and amount of items for sale! Everything was stocked pretty full, especially the cookies and individual pastries. I believe everything goes by weight when you're purchasing the cookies and pastries but if you have any questions, the staff were super sweet, patient and helpful! Hubby purchased an assortment of items like eclairs, cookies, rainbow cookies, cannolis and some sort of Napoleon looking pastry. Although some were a bit on the sweeter side (I have a sweet tooth too), everything was very delicious! I was very surprised that the butter cookies were really good because those are usually my least favorite anywhere I go. The rainbow cookies were also very good! There were no tables and chairs for customers so if you were planning on sitting down to enjoy something, sorry! I did see a small round table with two stools next to it but the table contained their cake binder so I'm assuming it's used for cake related orders.

This is a great bakery in Deer Park area. Lots of cake and pastry options and freshly baked. The…read morecustomer service is great and she was very patient and gave excellent recommendations. I already told neighbors to try it and even the famous tre leches is sold there.

Hummel-Hummel Bakery

4.1

(94 reviews)

The Ultimate Crowd-Pleasing Dessert! I was recently invited…read moreto an event out East and needed a great dessert to bring--and this spot in East Northport delivered! If you haven't heard of them yet, you definitely need to check them out. They're famous for their incredible "Pizza Crumb Cake." It's a delicious, giant crumb cake served right in a real pizza box, shaped just like a pie! They offer a ton of unique flavors, making it as fun to look at as it is to eat. Beyond the crumb cake, their traditional bakery items--from fresh-baked breads to delicate pastries--are top-tier. Bonus: You can even ship their crumb cakes anywhere, which makes for an awesome gift. A fantastic talking piece, delicious treats, and worth every mile of the drive. Check out my photos below!

This is the go-to bakery for crumb cakes if you want to impress guests at a holiday party. The…read morecrumb cakes are baked in the shape of a pizza pie. On 12/20/25, server Gianna recommended the Chocolate Raspberry Crumb Cake because it is the most popular one other than the original. So I ordered a slice. The topping was to die for! It was buttery, sweet, and crunchy. The cake itself was moist and sweet. I will be ordering a whole pizza crumb cake for my next holiday party. It will certainly be a hit! Gianna told me that there is a $5 minimum for debit/credit card payments. The bakery is in a small commercial space--holding no more than 10 customers at a time, but there is plenty of free parking in a huge lot in a relatively-large retail strip.

Cieslaks Modern Bakery

4.7

(54 reviews)

Cieslak's bakery in Lindenhurst is a hidden gem. Everything is DELICIOUS, fresh and made in-house…read more Family owned and operated. The prices are extremely reasonable. The box with the apple turnovers and 6 other goodies was under $20. The other box with the mini cheesecake and mini chocolate cream pie and 6 other goodies was under $26. Please support this business. You can call to check availability and have her hold items for pickup later in case it's almost sold out.

I was in the area and wanted a sweet treat so I decided to stop into this cute little bakery. The…read moreyoung ladies behind the counter were super nice and helpful. I opted to get the pastry they call a chocolate cigar and it did not disappoint. I warmed it up when I got home and had it with some coffee. If you love to support local small businesses, please give them a try. They have a plethora of options to choose from.

Polish Crumbs Bakery

3.7

(28 reviews)

•$

The food may look good but they have an infestation of flies there and that a hazard that can…read moreeasily send some one to ER or even kill a person , something so simply to fix but it seems they don't care , I hope they get inspected soon and post their inspection report so people can see it, I order 3 pastries wich immediately went to the garbage place has no air conditioning and pastries with cream inside like the one I ordered was at 70 degree already ruined custard was decomposed I just waisted 12 dolars and never going back again I feel sorry for people that can't see when something can get them sick Blue berries pie was melted that's how hot this place is I can't recommend this place I am a certified pastry chef and this place needs to reorganized and place customer as their priority

I have been to Crumbs Bakery 2 times. It's hit or miss with some of their baked goods. I loved the…read morebread but the staff ignores you if you ask questions. I thought it was a language barrier but it is not. I went a second time and I bought savory food and it was like pulling teeth to get a question answered. I began to feel like they were racist which I could not understand because I was there to buy their food. I never felt like this in any store .. Why don't you guys just put a sign that you only like your own..

D & D Bake Shoppe

3.2

(38 reviews)

I used to go there especially christmas. This year is total disappointment!!!! The Apple turnover…read morewas Not flakey pastry like it should be. It was like a cookie dough. The Italian clamshell were awful - hardly any filling and hard. The lemon cookies were absolutely terrible - they had a foul taste. The butter had no butter flavor. The biscotti with the cherries were not red but a purple color ???? I will not be going there ever again.

Very authentic and high class designed Tres Leches! I come from a Puerto Rican and Dominican…read morebackground and was looking for something for a celebration with my family. This did just the trick. And as someone just stopping by Long Island for the first time, this place left an AMAZING first impression. Support your local businesses !!!

Shuga pie Shop

4.9

(24 reviews)

If you likes sweets or even just once in awhile ... this is the place to go. I think it's a great…read moreplace for a box of desserts for a party or bbq. Something different than these pastry shop chana etc. First off Terry was unbelievable sweet & friendly. He went out of his way to be helpful & patient with me because I couldn't decide on Flavors or the amount. I guess I am old school or maybe just plain weird but I really like making the HUMAN connection when I am out & about.... I feel like people just aren't very socia anymore ....for a number of reasons . ANYWAY , if you have not been to AhugaPie Shop you ABSOLUTELY MUST GO. So I guess most people would equate a sugar pie to a Whoopie pie. These sugar pies are pretty big and a half of one is more than enough. Terry told me some people buy them and cut them in half and freeze them and take them out as they want them. Which I think is a great idea and is which what I did because I do not live nearby, but I would definitely drive to the end of the Earth for more. It's just one of those places. And I am not a big sweet person put the cake is just always soft and flavorful and delicious. And the filling is the right amount of the flavor and whipped cream and sugar. I think they have like 10 or so flavors available every day and they switch them around. I've probably tried five or six different flavors over the past two years and again all of them were very consistently delicious and amazing. I can't even explain it . It's just perfect. I've had them a few times before when a coworker brought them in. And I finally got a chance to go myself. I was so happy to share the experience with my family.. personally I love the chocolate cake with the peanut butter filling. So if your peanut butter lover, OMG go go go!!! . The product is very consistent. They do have a very specific hours. And as Terry recommended, it's always best to call ahead and either order , check the flavors of the day . & or the shop hours. It kind of blew my diet, but it was well worth it.. please go you will not be disappointed.. the only negative thing I can say about my experience is I wish I had bought a more of a variety of flavors. But that's on me l. Thank you Terry for your kindness - people like you restore my faith in mankind. and you make a dang good SHUGA PIE

It was a short wait to order. We got a variety to sample. Some were better than others but overall…read morewe enjoyed them! I would definitely support if back in the area but I probably wouldn't travel just for them.

Vin’s Bake House

4.3

(19 reviews)