Fresh delicious pastries, breads and cakes. We wanted one of everything. Definitely increases your waistline if you're not careful. They have soup during the winter. Street parking or park in the back, driveway is to the right of the building. You could drive right by and not see the storefront but please stop by and support this Family owned and operated business. read more

See all

The st Joseph's pastry was excellent lite airy and filled with cannoli cream. Great texture. I have never had a bad experience with Mario's. They even have a Sicilian pastry my father use to make. Casateda. Excellent. The service is friendly and helpful. read more

Omg. The smell when you walk in is fabulous and everything is so fresh. I got an extra large cookie for st Patrick's day for my mechanic and his team as I was getting my car serviced. I also got the lobster tail. It was off the hook. I ate it for four days and it still tasted fresh. This is now my go to bakery for sure read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Oversized cookie for st Patrick's day - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

I do not bake ever, but I know exactly where to go for the best! Ricotta cookies are the best I've ever had. I went in for something to bring to a brunch. What picked out looked delicious. The owner asked if I minded waited for fresh ones to come out. That was very thoughtful and appreciated. She even put the powdered sugar on the side so it wouldn't melt. The nicest staff and owner ever. read more

So I went to Marios christmas morning to get pastries.....You would never think it was an italian bakery when you walk inside....90% of what they have out in the display cases are american cakes . pies , and cookies....The only pastry out on display was a few lobster tails.....They only had 2 people working the counter and one was slower than the other....I was shocked to hear that they had NO Sfogliatelle available to buy....How does an italian bakery NOT have them on christmas morning......GEEZZZZ I drove 45 minutes each way to go there but I doubt I would do it again.....P.S. The cannolis had no fruit or cherrys on them .................. read more

The most scrumptious Sfingi I've had since I was a child growing up in Brooklyn! We live in Manhattan now and have literally thrown away Sfingi from many bakeries in the City, Bronx and Brooklyn! Marios truly has kept the old world tradition alive. The cannoli cream is not too sweet with a wonderful texture. Candied Orange bits and no ridiculous choc chips! Authentic!! The cream puff shell is moist and light! The box of 6 weighed a ton. lol. No words can describe how you feel when you bite into one of Mario's Sfingi! They're simply to die for. I look forward to making a trip out to Babylon to try their Sfogliatelle. Thank you from an Italian who desperately needs authentic Italian pastry. Marios is by far... THE BEST! read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Marios Sfingi - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Best bakery around, consistently excellent baked goods! Always has a nice treat for a get together or sweet treat!

Absolutely best Cannoli I have ever had! Very cute inside. Good rainbow cookie and good cookies.

For the 3 things I had here, this place is easily the best Italian bakery on LI and possibly all the ones in queens and the boroughs. They held up to best bakeries in Italy. I had the lobster tails with cannoli cream, the pignoli cookies, and the almond cookies. Those lobster tails are a solid 5 stars across the board. Hands down the best cannoli cream on Long Island and queens. It brought me back to Sicily. Really so fresh, perfect amount of sweetness and fresh ricotta texture was perfect. The pastry itself was perfect as well, buttery, flakey layers, perfectly baked. I'm so impressed. And the pignoli cookies were the best I've had! Again, perfect amount of sweet, perfect texture and just fantastic flavor. The ricotta tart was also lovely. Not What a find!! I'm looking forward to coming back and trying more things. read more

My partner and I got a selection of pastries and cookies from this bakery while out the other day. Some of what we purchased was the sprinkle jelly sandwich cookies, an almond horn, a lobster tail, and a few other things. They were all honestly so delicious, all we can think about is going back. Everything was SO fresh, SO high quality. The lady at the counter was very nice, she was training someone and helping her to help us. When you first walk in, it smells like an authentic Italian bakery where the people truly care about their products and it really shows. We'll absolutely be back. read more

Love to stop in to this pretty little bakery. We love everything we've ever tried. Especially the apple turnovers and chocolate cigar. Lovely staff. read more

Best napoleon on the planet. Pies are fantastic and the crust is delicious! Definitely make your way there.

Formerly the old Peter Paul I believe on little east neck rd - Italian biscotti pastry way over priced ! The other store had fair prices this was also way pre pandemic - maybe it's the location ? Most things in Babylon are over priced - I'd would rather drive to Alpine Bakery personally read more

I called Mario's Pasticceria for the first time to see if I could order my husband's Birthday cake the day before the celebration. I had gone to my usual local Bakery and basically there were alot of "no we can't do thats"....that ultimately, even though the young lady was very sweet, it really wasn't working for me. I've always passed by Mario's Pasticceria, saw the signs out front and wondered about this Bakery. Anthony had me at hello. When I asked if he was Mario he shared that he had named the Bakery after his Grandfather. It was such a great experience ordering my husband's carrot birthday cake. Anthony asked questions to put me into the right cake for the celebration I am having with the family. I'm excited to pick up my hubby's Birthday Cake tomorrow! I just have a KNOWING it's going to be absolutely delicious! If that much care went in to the phone call.....I'm sure that much HEART goes into all of the baked goods. ***** Five Star Experience I have a very strong feeling I will be a regular customer Christine West Babylon NY read more

The real deal! Seriously some of the best classic, home made Italian pastries, cookies & more! Arthur avenue on Long Island - must go! So friendly too! read more

We were driving down the road and saw a sign for gelatos! Quick stop! Wished there were more flavors to choose, but the chocolate scoop of gelato and my stracciatella gelato were delicious! What a place to buy pastry! Check it out or maybe you want a cake made with a personal theme.... They do it here! read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Gelato sign caught my attention! - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Don't mind the presentation. That's my mess! When I say the BEST tiramisu I've ever had, I mean it. My wonderful neighbor went in to get me a lobster tail but they sold out. She got this instead. Wow isn't good enough to describe how delicious this is. Holy freaking moly Wow is better. Go now. You won't be disappointed. read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Tiramisu - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Never had a St Joseph's pastry in my life. Saw a review on social media and drove 30 minutes to try it. Didn't disappoint at all. Was phenomenal. The cannolis were great too. Will def be back! read more

The minute you walk in you know you're in a bakery. The smell is fantastic! Anthony is great! This place is a piece of Italy. The food and service is great! read more

Fresh made pastry and cake! While I went into get my St Joseph's Day pastry I picked up a coffee and fresh breakfast pastry Chose the blueberry scone although the jelly donut and apple turnover are enticing . read more

See all

Cozy and delightful place with excellent pastries, cookies, cakes and breads! They do things right and it really shows! The Tomato and onion focaccia I picked up today was amazing! Lovely owners and staff too read more

See all

If you live near this amazing store, lucky you! I bought some pastries to bring home to Manhattan. Fresh and delicious. The cookies are great. The people behind the counter are nice. My eyes were taking in all the amazing looking cakes, pies, cookies and pastries. read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Pastries - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Excellent bakery. The best brownie and cannoli I've had in a long time. Reminds you of the way baked goods "used to be." You can tell they are using high quality ingredients and everything is baked with love. The fruit squares and cookies are also delicious. We were pleasantly surprised by how good the espressos and lattes were as well. The cherry on top is that it's a family run business with great customer service. read more

Great place try it, bunch of nice people and the pastries are great! This place is at least a monthly stop for me

Tried Mario's for the first time on St. Joseph's Day. Went there specifically for the Sfingi. Truly some of the best I've had. It's very easy to see when a place has the passion for what they do, because they take the time to do it right. The shell of the Sfingi was light, eggy and fresh as can be. The cannoli cream was velvety smooth and not overly sweet. Consistency was spot on. The cherry was there, the citron was there, the powdered sugar was there.... and it all adds up to perfection! Round trip for me was 1 hr. But I will definitely return for Easter for my grain pie!!!! Highly recommend this great establishment for quality that you will undoubtedly receive!!! read more

Everytime I stop in for cake, pie, cookies or pastries I am NEVER disappointed. Outstanding family owned business.

I too have been going to th is bakery for many years. DELISH!! I've never been dissatisfied. read more

Delicious Italian pastries, cookies, cakes and tortes. Nice bread and a pretty shop. This is just what the neighborhood needed. We love this place. read more

Mario's Pasticceria - Bakeries Near Me - Babylon, New York

Cookies were good, but the cake we ordered for a birthday was a bit dry. There was also some confusion regarding picking up items that were ordered ahead of time. When I ordered the cake mentioned, the owner told me to just skip the line on the day of pick up and go straight to the register. On the day of pick up, the counter staff told me and another person picking up an order that we'd have to wait in line. I get it was the day before Thanksgiving but you may want to put up some signage to make your policies clearer for customers and staff. read more

This family owned Pasticceria is outstanding. Everything is 5 stars and they are friendly and caring and helpful. - Kevin read more

Mario's Pasticceria always has the freshest, best tasting cakes, cookies and pastries. I ordered a chocolate Napoleon cake for Easter, a cake that they do not make on a regular basis. My request was happily received. The cake was amazing. Their lobster tail pastries filled with French cream or cannoli cream are to die for. If they do not have something that you are looking for, they will make it for you. Aside from the excellent quality of their baked goods, Gabriela and her son Anthony are always very welcoming. It's like going in to visit an old friend. Mario's is my go to bakery for everything and I have told my whole family about their excellence. One last thing, if something is not 100% fresh, they will not sell it to you. To me, that speaks volumes. They are not there "just to make a sale". They genuinely care about their customers read more

What a great addition to Babylon Village!! Amazing Italian Bakery. We picked up the Strawberry Shortcake, it was fresh, delicious and impressed everyone I had for dinner. Went back to get it again for another event and they didn't have it .....the owner asked what I was looking for..told her we loved the Strawberry Shortcake...she said give me 15 minutes and made us one right then!!! Beyond fresh and delicious the customer service is wonderful!! read more

The wedding cake they made for us was terrific. The owner was wonderful to us, and service was excellent. I would recommend this wonderful bakery to all our friends read more

First time customer but I'll be back again and again. Met Gabriella and her son Anthony such nice helpful people. I had a hard time making my selection from all the delicious looking items. I settled on a fresh loaf of bread( delicious ) to make my avocado toast , raspberry and lemon, ricotta cheese ,apple and crumb pastries Absolutely fantastic ! Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! read more

Place has amazing goodies. The St. Joseph was absolutely stellar. The rainbow cookie cannoli cake pieces are unique and fun to try. The rasberry cake loaf was scrumptios. Pignoli cookies were very nice of course, hard to mess those up though. The cannoli empanada is now one of my top favorite pastries i've ever had, looking forward to grabbing another at some point. Rainbow cookies were a great size, just enough jam but could have been a little more fresh. The bakery owner did tell us they were from day before so at least I knew what to expect. Overall great experience and will be coming here oppose to Torta Fina more frequently. read more

See all

I'll give it 3 stars because the owner was nice, but, I was extremely disappointed coming here. I tried it out because both bakeries in my town were closed on the day i came here. We were told that their mixer was broken so there was hardly any selection. I feel like we were pressured to buy the items that were "just made", but we wanted other things. The cannoli cream was very gritty, and the lemon cookies were flavorless. The fig cookies were good. Not sure if I would return here. read more

I went to this Bakery last week just before Thanksgiving, I was looking for a birthday cake for my wife. They didn't have what I was looking for in the display case but the lady at the counter ( I'm assuming was the owner) was so helpful and accommodating, she took the time to help me figure out the perfect cake AND they made it the SAME DAY. Superb Customer Service and the cake was DELICIOUS, I'm so glad I found this bakery and I HIGHLY recommend you go here too. The interior is beautifully decorated and the assortment of cookies, cannolis, cakes & fresh bread is amazing. read more

Quite good international bakery in Babylon where you'll find Italian pastries along with some German, Austrian and Jewish confections thrown in. Got a doughnut which was really good as were the linzer tarts. Service at the counter was polite and prices are fairly reasonable making this a nice bakery to stop by for a pastry. Recommended. read more

See all

Popped in for some cannolis today and they were delicious! Best I've had in a long time! Met the owner and she was super sweet! I can't wait to go back and try all of their delectable delights! read more

Great options for gluten-free allergy customers besides regular customers cakes and pastries a delicious