This is a hidden gem in Babylon Village. You've probably driven past it and didn't realize it was…read morethere, just look for The Pizzeria restaurant on Montauk Hwy and it's right next door. This is a family owned business created with love. Everything the son makes is delicious and fresh. Lots of bread, cookies, cakes, pies, tarts and other goodies. Plenty of Italian pastries and American baked goods. They even have soup! While they don't have a large social media presence like other bakeries I find the products here better and fresher. They even accommodate special requests.

Just don't bother... day old, dry cake...tried it on a couple of recommendations...never mind..,read more

Has the BEST strawberry shortcake, I would definitely recommend this place. Everything inside looks…read moreso good

Tried a couple of sweets - a slice of the peach pie and the walnut brownie. Both were okay - not…read moretoo sweet. The brownie was a bit dry and the peach pie was too sour and the crumble was extremely plain. Ordering here was tough. There was no line, nothing was labled or priced in the display case, and a different person would say they can help the next customer but there was no line. Random people would just say they were next and "cut." I probably would not return even though the location by the water was nice.

This is the place to be! Every item is incredible, I love the savory croissants, and the incredible…read morecakes. If you have a special occasion coming up, please run to buttercooky to order a custom cake to complete your event!! They just brightening up my rainy day with a cold brew & a jelly doughnut The staff is kind, efficient and very dedicated to making the best of the best. My favorite bakery!

I was craving something sweet and I noticed they had frozen hot chocolate on the menu. Sounded good…read moreto me. They now have a seating area inside so I decided to give them a try. Went on a Monday was very busy, lots of people inside. The seating area is nice. It's fairly decent amount of seats, huge amounts of treats and baked goods to pick from as well as coffee and other drinks. The ladies at the register were very friendly and nice. Frozen hot chocolate was good wasn't the best I ever had but it was decent. I say give him a try.

Noticed this place on my way to doctor visit and decided to give it a try and take something sweet…read morehome to the family. Everything was delicious but be warned it's very sweet. Best to share with others to avoid high sugar consumption or spread it out over few days. Tried a bit of the English toffee cheesecake, banana pudding and apple crumb. The decor inside is absolutely stunning and inviting. Service was quick and to the point.

I ordered the Dubai Chocolate Cheesecake on a stick, selecting a plain cheesecake as my base. It…read morewas fascinating watching how the server put the dessert together (watch the videos below): She took a piece of plain cheesecake, dipped it in dark chocolate, put some pistachio cream filling on top and then for the finale, she drizzled some chocolate on top. It was the best Dubai Chocolate dessert that I have ever had because it was moderately sweet. The ones that I have had at other bakeries and restaurants are sickeningly sweet. The only negative at The Dirty Cheesecake is that the dessert cost $15, which is significantly higher than what I have paid elsewhere even though this one was the only one on a stick. The decor of the bakery-cafe was a craft bakery experience that exposed the ingredients and utensils they used to make their tasty desserts. The servers were professional and enjoyed creating my Dubai Chocolate Cheesecake on a stick. I highly recommend The Dirty Cheesecake.

If you're paying nearly $20 for a medium iced coffee and an iced matcha latte, you'd expect the…read moredrinks to be good at the very least. Unfortunately, the matcha was a big disappointment. It isn't freshly whisked or made to order, they have it premixed and sitting in a container ready to pour. You can definitely taste the difference. It didn't taste fresh and, strangely enough, kind of tasted like Play-Doh. The place itself is really nice, and the staff was friendly, so there are definitely positives here. But at these prices, the quality of the drinks needs to match. With so many good coffee shops in town, they really need to step up the drink quality if they want to stay competitive.

Visit Date: May 3, 2026…read more All I want to do is go to the cafes listed in my LI cafe passport book for Christmas but my friends keep picking different coffee shops that are not in my book which is slightly annoying to me lol I made a plan to meet my friend Shani and she wanted to check this place out. I got a regular coffee with half and half because I also got the crepe and wanted to not have sugar on top of sugar if I drank a sweet drink and had a sweet dessert. I ended up choosing a crepe, they had no dessert with peanut butter in it which would have been my first choice. The crepe was okay. I ate half of it and my boyfriend ate the other half when I saw him after coffee. I found this place to be just okay, I gave it 4 stars because it was good but it didn't wow me and I think they made it too trendy looking and too hyped up. The service was also very good the man who helped me answered my questions patiently. So I liked this place but wasn't really wowed by it.

The cookies by the pound! That's all i got to say. The best you will ever have I've been here…read moremultiple times and the food and service is always the same.

This place is now called The Ultimate Bakery and located in one of those strip malls. Hubby was…read morecraving some sweets from here the other night so we stopped by and he specifically wanted to come to THIS place. He said he's been coming to this bakery for quite some time and his brother always buys a bunch of things when he visits. There was plenty of free parking on a Saturday night and the store itself was brightly lit. Very spacious inside and very clean. I was surprised at the variety and amount of items for sale! Everything was stocked pretty full, especially the cookies and individual pastries. I believe everything goes by weight when you're purchasing the cookies and pastries but if you have any questions, the staff were super sweet, patient and helpful! Hubby purchased an assortment of items like eclairs, cookies, rainbow cookies, cannolis and some sort of Napoleon looking pastry. Although some were a bit on the sweeter side (I have a sweet tooth too), everything was very delicious! I was very surprised that the butter cookies were really good because those are usually my least favorite anywhere I go. The rainbow cookies were also very good! There were no tables and chairs for customers so if you were planning on sitting down to enjoy something, sorry! I did see a small round table with two stools next to it but the table contained their cake binder so I'm assuming it's used for cake related orders.

Stopped by to pick up a few snacks and I'm sure glad I did. They offered a huge selection and I…read moreended up getting a rainbow cookie cupcake and a slice of red velvet cake. The cupcake was so delicious and I love that they included a layer of jelly in the cupcake itself. The cookie on top was such a nice addition as well. Super moist and super flavorful. The red velvet was also super tasty but the cake was a tad bit dry, but that's fine. The cream cheese frosting was stellar and the slice was decently big and could be split by two easily. Staff was super friendly and the service was quick. Lots of options, and super clean. Would absolutely recommend and will be coming back.

I am surprised to see the negative reviews of Park Bake shop on here honestly. We have been coming…read morehere since we moved to the area 5 years ago and this is honestly one the best we have ever had. The negative reviews are kind of funny because of what people are complaining about. One guy went here to get coffee? No, this is not the place to get coffee, walk in the door and see that, it's not what they do. I don't think they even have an espresso machine here. I do have to admit that Park Bake shop does do breads and bagels but they are not very good. I tried once or twice because they looked good but the taste just isn't there. But what they do well is cookies, cakes, and pastries. Pretty much anything in the cases are excellent. All the cookies are awesome, always fresh, and all reasonably priced. I love Park Bake shop and will continue to come here often!

Omg! The pastries here a sooo soooo good. We got the regular cannoli, pistachio cannoli, rainbow…read morecheesecake, tiramisu, cartocci, coda d'aragosta. They were all delicious. The rainbow cheesecake was creamy and light. Found this place from a Facebook tell someone did a while back and searched it here on Yelp and saved it to my collection. This place is out of my way but happened to be relatively close by in Holtsville. While I would never come out here from Plainview, I'd definitely drop by if I'm in the area

For my husband's birthday an Italian cheesecake will be on the menu but honestly I didn't realize…read morehow hard it was finding Italian cheesecake on Long Island. Apparently, you need to call ahead but not here, La Roma Pastry Shop. They have your Italian cheese cheesecake ($33.00)and it is exquisite. Upon entering you see how adorable and quaint, the little tables and chairs and decor are so romantic. From the moment I walked in the door. There were people in front of me and the whole time I was there there was steady flow people coming in behind me. This place is busy and they keep it going. There's plenty of staff. They're friendly fast efficient and pretty much amazing they do it all. Although I did not try one today, I hear they're famous for their rainbow cheesecake. I look forward to coming back and enjoying some coffee and cake with my husband.