Tried The Dirty Cheesecake in Smithtown and I'm still thinking about it. I ordered the Cinnabomb cheesecake and the cinnamon bun latte--both were insane in the best way. The cheesecake was super rich, creamy, and packed with cinnamon flavor without being overly sweet. You can tell it's homemade and made with care. The cinnamon bun latte paired perfectly--smooth, and tasted exactly like a fresh cinnamon roll in drink form. It wasn't overly sugary either, which I loved. The whole vibe of the spot is fun and dessert-focused, perfect for when you want to treat yourself or bring friends for something different. Staff was friendly and the presentation alone makes it worth the visit. If you're a cheesecake lover or just want a unique dessert experience, this place is 100% worth the stop. I'll definitely be back to try more flavors. read more

See all

Noticed this place on my way to doctor visit and decided to give it a try and take something sweet home to the family. Everything was delicious but be warned it's very sweet. Best to share with others to avoid high sugar consumption or spread it out over few days. Tried a bit of the English toffee cheesecake, banana pudding and apple crumb. The decor inside is absolutely stunning and inviting. Service was quick and to the point. read more

See all

I ordered the Dubai Chocolate Cheesecake on a stick, selecting a plain cheesecake as my base. It was fascinating watching how the server put the dessert together (watch the videos below): She took a piece of plain cheesecake, dipped it in dark chocolate, put some pistachio cream filling on top and then for the finale, she drizzled some chocolate on top. It was the best Dubai Chocolate dessert that I have ever had because it was moderately sweet. The ones that I have had at other bakeries and restaurants are sickeningly sweet. The only negative at The Dirty Cheesecake is that the dessert cost $15, which is significantly higher than what I have paid elsewhere even though this one was the only one on a stick. The decor of the bakery-cafe was a craft bakery experience that exposed the ingredients and utensils they used to make their tasty desserts. The servers were professional and enjoyed creating my Dubai Chocolate Cheesecake on a stick. I highly recommend The Dirty Cheesecake. read more

See all

Such cool cute vibes inside!!! The decor is bright and fun! I can't say we had the friendliest service but the product was AWESOME! I got the rainbow bookie cheesecake. They allowed me to omit what I wanted. I ate it quite awhile later in the day after being in the fridge and it was still delicious! I would definitely go back! read more

See all

Such a cute place! 4/5 Pecan Pie Cheesecake- "New York cheesecake dipped in Ghirardelli milk chocolate rolled in pecan drizzled with Caramel and salted caramel and sprinkled" really sweet but really good 3/5 tiramisu cheesecake on a stick $12- unfortunately comes dunked in caramel on the bottom, wasn't expecting that, all I could taste was caramel, tiramisu flavor wasn't there at all cuz of too much caramel, wuda gotten something else if I knew it was gonna have caramel, cheesecake itself is decent but very dense & heavy All the chocolate is milk chocolate, wish they had dark chocolate, originally wanted the triple chocolate but its all milk chocolate including the ganache read more

See all

I think they are purchasing the cheesecake elsewhere and adding gimmicks. frozen in center and way too sweet. cute looking place, and nice for one time visit, but expensive and gimmicky. read more

This is really 3.5* since it's not a 3 and not yet a 4. Note: There is no sign though there is a 3% credit card surcharge. Late Wednesday night, we wanted dessert and saw that this place opened until midnight. That worked for us since it was a last minute discussion. First thing first, the staff is very friendly and accommodating. I didn't want tea nor coffee, she made a hot chocolate and charged as a coffee. It was perfect. Second, the store looked brand new, wide open space, brightly lite and clean. Seating on the left, display cases of the items and ordering on the right. Third, so many desserts for you to decide from - stuffed cookies, cookies, pies, french macarons, chocolate covered strawberries, dessert in a cup, and cheesecakes to name a few. Everything looks delicious though it turned out to be way too sweet for me. If you love cheesecake, this is the place for you whether it's in a cup, slice, or dipped. Fourth, pricing is similar to NYC prices. Yes, I understand rent cost is high, ingredient cost are going up, and wages are going up. It's just a sticker shock during check out since no process were listed. Take a look for yourself and you decide for yourself. read more

See all

Love that they have new flavors of the month. The whole location was clean, there's parking in the back, and everyone's friendly. Tried a few of their Dirty cheesecakes on a stick, a milk shake, and some of their cookies, and everything was delicious! read more

The Dirty Cheesecake - Dirty Monkey Milkshake - Desserts Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I came here for cheesecake, not to be taken advantage of.... Let's talk about the moment I realized I'd made a terrible mistake: they charged me TWO DOLLARS for sprinkles. Yes, sprinkles. Those tiny, decorative sugar pebbles normally reserved for children's birthday parties and free toppings at literally any normal establishment. For $2, I expected a waterfall of sprinkles. A cascade. A tsunami. They gave me a sad, timid scattering that wouldn't satisfy a toddler. I've seen more sprinkles fall out of a broken ice cream machine. And the cheesecake? Decent -- but not enough to get me back in the doors to get crushed by one of their other "specials". The whole experience felt like being mugged politely. read more

The Dirty Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Friendly service, very nice inside, desserts are outstanding. Pricey but we knew that coming in. Would come back for a special occasion.

I enjoyed the blueberry crumb cheesecake. I had a taste of the rainbow one. It was very very rich not for me. They have a ton of choices besides cheesecake. A solid spot read more

Very disappointed. The cookies were stale and tasted like it had been sitting out for days. I was expecting something fresh from a bakery, but it was dry and lacked flavor. Unfortunately, I won't be returning!! read more

An amazing variety of desserts! From milkshakes, cookies, macaroons, cupcakes, cheesecake, and more. I enjoyed the cheesecake on a stick. A must-try and definitely unique. The place has a nice atmosphere and staff is friendly. They're open late daily which is perfect for a late night sweet treat! read more

The Dirty Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I love the dirty cheesecake! Everything is always so delicious. The cheesecake is so creamy. I recently got the dirty leprechaun, milkshake and it was amazing read more

The Dirty Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

If you have a sweet tooth, this place is for you! They are known for their trending chocolate dipped cheesecake (hence the name, dirty cheesecake) that is then given delicious toppings of your choice! Pick your own, or choose one listed. By the way, you can do the same with brownies! They have other items like cake in a jar, cookies, cupcakes, milkshakes, cake, etc. If you are a coffee lover like me, they have nitro brew, lattes, and coffee as well! Staff is super friendly and helpful. Btw, the owner is a young girl that had a dream brought to life with the support of family! So inspiring!!!! This is a large location with plenty of seating, and a few Instagram walls to show off the delicious treats! It is bright and welcoming inside, and so clean. Parking is in abundance, so that's another perk! Customers for life! read more

See all

Wonderful experience! The gentleman who helped us was amazing! He made the best deserts, and was the nicest guy. Everything was beyond delicious. They even have hot chocolate that self stirs in a big dispenser. It was to die for as well! The line didn't take too long and they had so many options. We took the cheese cake to go, and by the time we got it home it was perfect to eat! It was clean and cute on the inside and has a nice vibe. Surprisingly there were a lot of older people patronizing this establishment. Take a trip and give them a try, they have so many options you will be beside youeself! read more

See all

The word dirty is so interesting, especially in the food world. Normally, you talk about dirt and it ain't a good thing, but throw that word in front of something edible and you get a whole new meaning. I'd say The Dirty Cheesecake definitely grabs a hold of this multifaceted D-word and uses it more for good than evil. You see, there are some great aspects to The Dirty Cheesecake, which my wife and I visited last night. For one, the hours are fantastic, especially if you're looking for some dessert on the later side as TDC is open until midnight...every night. I feel like those hours might not stick long term (who's buying cheesecake at 10:45 on a Tuesday night?), but it's perfect to know that's what they are as of now. Interior is also pretty nice with a handful of tables and enough space to feel like you can browse, order, pay, and eat without bumping into others. Most importantly though is the cheesecake itself. Now there are a bunch of non-cheesecake options (cakes, cookies, macarons, etc.), though it's tough to want to sway in that direction, unless you happen to have an allergy or *gasp* you don't like cheesecake and for some reason find yourself here. Really, the "dirty" comes into play through the cheesecake slice that are dipped in chocolate and then topped with a wide variety of toppings. My wife and I ended up with similar slices (mine was Reese's and hers was peanut butter and Nutella), but wow were there impressive in presentation and thankfully, the taste was also pretty delectable as well. I'll also tack on the staff member who took our order in being friendly and asked if I wanted to sign up for reward points. Cool. Now with all the positives, I do have a few small notices that can make things a bit more dirty (in a negative sense). Pricing didn't seem to be posted anywhere which I felt was a little odd, and the actual cost of our two slices was about $24 with a credit card up-charge (which also wasn't posted). This sounds like a lot for two slices of cheesecake, but I'll give them a pass as it's comparable to a speciality slice at The Cheesecake Factory. It also should probably be a little clearer or mentioned upon purchase that the slices are slightly frozen so to truly enjoy them you need to wait a bit as they start to soften. I noticed this info on the boxes as my wife and I were halfway through our slices as we sat there in the seating area. Once aware of this, we decided to take the rest home to eat as it would be more likened to what it's supposed to be, but a bit more focus on conveying this might be helpful. Lastly (and this is personal preference), TDC definitely has a vibe going as their bright interior, Insta-worthy signage, and semi-loud pop music creates a certain identity. If you're looking for a more chill situation, TDC might not be your thing, but that's what gives this place its Dirty style and flare. For my wife and I, it might not have been the feeling we were looking for last night, but I respect it as being something that could work depending on the person/timing/moment. Overall, The Dirty Cheesecake has a lot to like. I'm impressed with the setup, choices, and the cheesecake itself with their plethora of concoctions that can be created and consumed. There are some questionable things I'm not entirely sure about, though most of them are fixable with just a little more attention to detail. I can definitely see myself returning in the future, though perhaps to-go instead so those cheesecake slices will be ready to eat once home as we're about 15 minutes away from here. So until the next experience, I'll give The Dirty Cheesecake four stars mostly filled with the good kind of dirt, if that makes sense. read more

See all

Oh my goodness, where do I even start? If you love cheesecake, you HAVE to check this place out! From the moment you walk in, you're hit with the sweet, inviting smells of fresh coffee and bakery treats--it's like a dessert lover's dream come true. The real star here is their cheesecake on a stick. You can choose from a variety of amazing flavors or create your own custom treat. We tried the Fruity Pebbles and the Nutella Peanut Butter, and both were out of this world! The cheesecake itself was rich and velvety, and I love that it's stored cold/frozen before being dipped in chocolate--makes it perfect for that satisfying, cold cheesecake bite without it being mushy or warm. The service was super friendly and quick, and I was especially impressed that they're open until midnight! If you're like me and tend to crave sweets late at night, this is the perfect spot to satisfy that sugar fix. Plus, parking is available in the back, which is always a nice touch. Definitely coming back soon! Highly recommend this place for anyone who loves cheesecake or just wants to try something totally unique and delicious. Go check it out! read more

See all

This place might be a hidden gem. Had this on my list for several years and finally had the chance to go. Parking is in the back and there's a little underpass to get to the entrance, although it doesn't look like it. Inside is decently spacious and the decor is clean and insta-friendly, wouldn't be surprised to see it in nyc. Shared the dulce de leche and the chocolate lava cookie (with ice cream) with a group of 4 and it was the right amount of food. The slices are very dense so I definitely wouldn't be able to finish one by myself. There are so many other flavors and goodies I want to try. The worker was friendly and even offered ice when we asked for water cups. Some outlets and wifi but beware it's hard to get phone service otherwise. read more

The Dirty Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Smithtown, New York

This is a follow up to my April 2025 review at Google. Owner Tarkek Hassanin sent a reply. I rent the apartment directly above their sound system. Where their patrons sit. I had no idea that the music would impact my rental. I toured at 9 am. They start "business" ever day at 9:50 AM, seven/7 days a week until Midnight. No holidays off. None. Just imagine. You rent an apartment for $2,700/1 BR and you hear music...Justin, Taylor, Ed, Coldplay, Beyonce, etc. It becomes 9:50 AM to 4:00 AM because the owner of the Dirty Cheesecake in Smithtown's staff "forgets" to turn off the sound system. AI can easily handle that, right. However, Mr. Hassanin continually turns it back on me..."Contact the Property Management." I did contact Fairfield...Guess what, not "Fair" I will pursue, just know...It's all about money. Shame. read more

Nicely located, super helpful staff, very clean. An enormous variety of cheesecakes. We had a single slice of Lilly's cheesecake which was delicious. Do I think it was worth $13? Not really. I'm glad we went and I might go back and try something different but at the prices they charge I'm not in a big hurry. read more

The Dirty Cheesecake - Lilly's cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Not a fan... my cheesecake was frozen. In the middle of my order staff helped someone else. It was so rude. I had to go eat my frozen cheesecake come back and my order was still not complete. read more

Always friendly. Bring your hunger because it's all good! The dipped cheesecake is so unique and delicious. The cheesecake is also good on its own. They make wonderful coffee drinks with the best coffee, illy. Definitely worth the calories! read more

The Dirty Cheesecake - Marble cheesecake and oak milk latte with 2 lavender pumps. - Desserts Near Me - Smithtown, New York

The Dirty Cheesecake in Smithtown has a lot of potential, but my experience landed right around 3 stars. The ambience is actually really nice. The space feels modern, clean, and inviting, and it's the kind of place you want to like the moment you walk in. It has a cool, trendy vibe that definitely sets it apart from your typical dessert spot. The cheesecake itself was just ok. The flavors were fine, the presentation was good, and it wasn't bad by any means, but it also didn't have that standout richness or texture that makes a great cheesecake memorable. It felt like it needed a little more depth or creativity to match the atmosphere they're going for. The real issue was the service, which unfortunately was pretty poor. It wasn't busy at all when I went in, but it still felt slow, disconnected, and a bit unorganized. There wasn't much effort to welcome guests or guide them through the menu, and it gave off the impression that the staff wasn't fully engaged. When a place is quiet, great service can really elevate the experience, but here it just fell flat. I genuinely want this place to succeed. Every time I drive by, it seems slow, and I keep hoping it'll pick up because the concept has promise and the space looks great from the outside. With better service and a stronger focus on improving the flavors and consistency of the cheesecake, The Dirty Cheesecake could easily become a local favorite. For now, it's an average experience in a spot that has the potential to be much more. read more

The product diversity is interesting but not a place for anyone looking to cut calories. And if you have diabetic issues steer clear. Oh and the prices are ridiculously high. I made the mistake of buying there once and would not go back unless I was gifted a visit. read more

It's a really gorgeous spot in a newly built location with an annoying parking lot that you cannot reach from the front street. The initial hype is such that it gets pretty busy but the service moves pretty quickly and the staff are super friendly. Past these things, the big thing is the cheesecake which is subpar and not very good. The slices they serve are relatively small and don't taste all that good for the $13 per slice price tag. (Wow!) There is a gimmick which places the cake on a stick that actually makes it more annoying to handle amd consume. If you're a cheesecake place and the cheesecake isn't that good, that is a problem. Cheesecake Factory is much better quality, even at their exorbitant prices. Once the hype dies down it will be interesting to see if people will continue spending a very pretty penny for low quality food. read more

Love this spot! The perfect spot for a delicious sweet treat! They have so much to offer and everything is so delicious! I also love the vibe in here! Friendly staff and everything is so clean! I got a brownie on a stick paired with a milkshake... Literally mouthwatering! I can't wait to go back and try more of their delicious treats read more

See all

WOW! WOW! I can say it again but come here & see for yourself what I'm saying WOW about. Large space, plenty of seating, Instagram ready, and the desserts! I had an English toffee cheesecake OMG!!!! Decadent, rich, delicious....what more can I say? Lots!!! Plenty of other treats to pick from, Cookies, bars, macarons, cupcakes etc. I think what wows me the most is the young lady, who inspired this whole concept. Lili and her Dad, WOW! Lady Boss! Yes girl! You've got some magic happening here! Cant wait to try more goodies. read more

I received a text message that they were open today, Thanksgiving Day. I took advantage and picked up an apple pie. It's a beautiful store and the service is always top notch. I've gotten their macaroons, cannoli's, cheesecakes, banana pudding, and their brookie bar. Next time I'll be courageous and try their famous cheesecake on a stick. read more

See all

Tried the banana pudding and toffee dipped cheesecake. The cheesecake is soooo filling but it is a fantastic dessert and honestly great to share. Service were very nice and friendly and it was cool to see them dip the cheesecake in front of us. Loved the decor. Very California and trendy read more

The Dirty Cheesecake - English Toffee Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Smithtown, New York

What is NOT to love about this place? From the moment you walk in the door, you're hit with the most delicious smell. It's bright and beautifully set up and I love that you get to see your cheesecake be made right in front of you! Such a hard time picking what to get because everything looked amazing! Shoutout to Tarek, the owner, for being so gracious in talking to my friend and I about his passion and love for the business. Should you come toward Nassau, you've already got a customer right here! ‍ read more

See all

The store front its self is very welcoming and inviting, it just grabs your attention as you drive by. We have been patiently waiting for months for this establishment to open, and it was definitely worth the wait. The establishment was very bright and the decor was just fun. The staff were very friendly and didn't mind that I was taking a ton of photos, they actually encouraged the reviews. I expected to see some many different kinds of cheesecake but we saw much more than that. The first thing that caught my eye was the Macaroons tower with so many assorted flavors to choose from. My daughter got a strawberry flavor one and was very satisfied with it. The next thing that caught my eye was the cake in a jar. I love cake in a jar and now being able to have an establishment that sell it so close to home is always a plus for me. Let's not forget the banana pudding. This banana pudding tastes like mine so in that case it was pretty awesome and I have no complaints. We ordered a NY Style Cheesecake with strawberry and my daughter loved it. The next time we return we will order cheesecake on a stick. Next we sampled some ice-cream flavor and cotton candy was everything. Then we ordered a slice of cake, I was torn between a slice a cake or cupcake. So I just ordered a slice and was not disappointed. It was the perfect amount of icing and very moist and fluffy inside, it just melted in my mouth. I can't wait to try the cupcake and the big cookie and some of the other treats. I also notice they have a coffee selection but I'm not a coffee drinking so I can comment on that. There is a lot of space to dine in and one public restroom. read more

See all

The Dirty Cheesecake was absolutely amazing! So good, I can't wait to go back and try everything else on the menu. Seriously, a must-try! read more

The Dirty Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Smithtown, New York

With Parking in the back behind the building. Beautifully clean and Instagram worthy, this place has baked goods, ice cream, milkshakes and custom designed cheesecake by the slice. $13 gets you a frozen slice of cheesecake, dipped in Ghirardelli chocolate and loaded with several toppings. They say to let your masterpiece thaw out before eating. We shared a Peeps milkshake, which was overly sweet. read more

Love the vibe! Bright, clean and fun. We had a cheesecake dipped in chocolate with Nutella and peanut butter and a brownie dipped in chocolate with fruity pebbles. Vanilla sauce and sprinkles. No pictures because we devoured them! Our favorite was the brownie. (Should let cheesecake defrost before inhaling) They have a great selection of other desserts too - so much to choose from. We will definitely be back. Cost $23 for the two items we purchased. read more

The Dirty Cheesecake - Inside - Desserts Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Sadly, it wasn't what I envisioned....a creamy thick, amazing crust Fluffy cheesecake... that wasn't. the Brookie, hefty in weight, was $16 +for a slice! (gasp, I know)! & the plain cheesecake wasn't thoroughly blended, $11...tiny slice. sadly, the family rated them all at a 2 or 3 out of 10. sigh, read more

Great cheesecakes ! I love that they are open late as well. I love that they have all types of dessert and illy coffee :) read more

New store in the Brand new building.. Plenty of parking in the rear, the building is connected to an apartment complex,, they've only been open a week, but they had the same location in Times Square, so they were very familiar with their business,, Very impressed as soon as I walked in plenty of display to see the items they have signage was perfect. The lighting was very good,, the staff was very friendly and very helpful, and very patient explaining to me the ingredients for each of the cheesecakes and their recommendations for the most popular items were well appreciate it., They do offer a rewards program, so the more you shop, the more points you get, not just cheesecake they have cookies, pies, cupcakes, a coffee bar they even have shakes and ice cream .. Every piece of cheesecake is made to order. They dip it in hot fudge and apply the necessary ingredients... Everything was fresh and delicious, , Nice little touch with the individual cakes that are wrapped comes with a handy fork, Salted caramel, was my favorite, The fruity, pebble and dolce de leche,, The decaf, triple espresso and latte were brewed to perfection Lucas was very helpful The Dirty Cheesecake made by Lilis read more

See all

My wife and I stopped by recently--this was our third visit. The Smithtown location had just opened, and we were excited to give it a try. Let me tell you--this place is a fantastic addition to the neighborhood! Smithtown was missing something of this caliber. We tried the Lily Bar, the Dubai Bar, the Classic Banana Pudding, the Mini Banana Pie, the Mini Key Lime, and the Lily Cheesecake--wow! So good! Everything tasted well-balanced--not too sweet, yet full of rich, enjoyable flavors. We also had a latte, and it did not disappoint! The staff was very friendly and provided excellent service. My wife and I will definitely be coming back again--this time, we're bringing the whole family! Haha! read more

Beautiful storefront with lovely baked goods but we were here for the cheesecake on a stick. Incredible number of options but we got the Oreo and pumpkin- both were very good even though they were still par frozen. The service was great but would be better and faster if they streamlined the topping station where they make the cheesecakes to order- this process take a little time and everyone on the line was getting the famous cheese cake on a stick. Had the specially brewed coffee with it which was outstanding. A must visit! First time but definitely won't be the last time. read more