Coyle's reboot! Beautiful atmosphere - clean, open, and fun. A great place with plenty of room to sit and enjoy your cones. Homemade ice-cream with more flavors than I could count. I went with my favorite, coffee. Super fresh, creamy, and filled with flavor. The kids had milkshakes, chocolate ice-cream, Oreo ice-cream, and a ton of candy! I finally have a new favorite ice-cream shop! read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Atmosphere - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Small old school cream shop feel. Never too busy. Staff I've encountered has been young and not too into service. But they have a great range of amazing flavors and don't skimp on the toppings. Ask them to layer them in a sundae so every bite is a winner! read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Sundaes - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

If they had fresh whipped cream, I'd have given them 5 stars. Flavors were awesome and soft serve excellent. It's cute and old fashioned inside to make a perfect date night scene. Girl behind the counter was very friendly and we had a great experience. read more

Customers service was great, real nice and super clean. I would just recommend a bigger garage can or more than 1 as it does fill up quick!

Tons of ice cream options. The space is small but has booths available -- our party of four fit comfortably. The ice cream was delicious and the service was good! read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

Went in to get information about getting ice cream catering for my bridal shower, they took our information and said a manager will call us back. It's been 2 weeks and no answer and they keep pushing us off saying they are opening a new store and they are to busy. Very disappointing since we heard great things about their ice cream but not very reliable since we can't even get an answer if they have availability. Can't wait forever. Couldn't recommend doing catering. read more

Very sweet worker who was patient while we took some time to decide amongst the MANY flavors. Cherry vanilla, black raspberry, banana Oreo, and strawberry crunch were all so delicious! Surprisingly very warm inside which made sitting in to eat in the winter perfect! read more

Ice cream is good. Tables are always sticky and not cleaned, even when there aren't customers in there. For me, the worst is the poor customer service and lack of allergen awareness. read more

Ice cream was yummy! And I would say I recommend it except the place needs more help so a possible 4 is now a 3 star review. The line was long even for a Friday night. The poor girl behind the counter was all by herself in the store to serve the entire line. The tables were a mess because prior customers didn't clean after themselves. The owner should hire a second person to help with the line and keep the tables clean. We went in because my husband wanted soft serve. Unfortunately there was a sign that the machine was closed for the winter...it's been Spring for a few weeks. A few kids' ice cream options were also out of stock. We ordered ice cream scoops which were a little soft, as if the freezer wasn't cold enough or the door was opened too long. This all seems like complaints but we enjoyed our ice cream and I would go back except I don't want to clean the table again... read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Double scoop: strawberry cheesecake and mint chocolate chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

I loved the aesthetic of the place! Super cute. The ice cream flavors were delicious! I ordered the Irish cream over Mississippi mud in a waffle cone. The texture was so good too! It was almost stretchy it was so smooth. Prices were pretty average. They do have a bathroom available and tasting is allowed. I'll definitely be back again. read more

The Islip location has been a long time favorite of mine because the ice cream is delicious. I even go there on the coldest of winter days because I love it that much. The only downside is the staff rotates a lot and so does the quality of what you get. Lately it's gotten worse. The staff they have now doesn't really care & doesn't care to hide it. They aren't very friendly & are stingy with toppings which is kind of a big deal when making sundaes, especially at this price point. Better training or more QA on the part of the owners is needed here. I would be sad to move on but I'm getting tired of being disappointed. read more

We were 5 adults Came in at 847 pm Girls take the order We pay We tip like always Sit Just about done 9:02 We are being asked to leave they are closing. Perhaps they shouldn't have taken the order Or Maybe waited 2 minutes and let everyone finish up. But hey now we know the owners hired ungrateful clock watchers read more

3.5 but will round up for nice service. I had a medium, two scoops, cannoli and chocolate peanut butter fudge. The CPBF was way better than the cannoli, which quite a bit of ice crystals in it. But the chocolate was very rich and creamy so that made up for it. My guess is this is overall a good spot, maybe just be sure to sample the flavors you want before picking. read more

Happy Saturday We had yummy fun today Hope you did too Say hi to Pat, aka Patricia, when you stop by @coylesicecream in #islip. She remembers my order every time! She should get #employeeoftheyear Also, the ice cream is the best; the 50s theme is nostalgic, and the service is always GREAT! #SpaSuite4 #weallneedatreat #coyles #icecreamlover #itswhyiworkout #dateday #myhhh #beautifulday read more

See all

If you read my reviews, I am a chocolate person. I've been to Coyle's in Bayshore a few times. Their chocolate ice cream and fudge is super fresh and tasty. Since we were near the Islip area last night, we had to try their other location. Wow. It was not good at all. I can't explain the taste, but it tasted like practically nothing. It seemed like it was sitting in the tub for a long time. The fudge wasn't as good as their Bayshore location either. We got some candy to-go and it was so hard. What happened last night? read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Very very good ice cream, and the shop is adorable. It wasn't busy when we went, but we also eat ice cream all year long, not just when it's hot outside. This shop has been a fixture along Main Street for a long time... we just never think to go there (and don't exactly live in the area)... but so glad we decided to stop by. We enjoyed our ice cream treats a lot! read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Saturday Treat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

A good classic ice cream shop with standard pricing. They have a small seating area if you'd like to dine in with your ice cream. They have a good variety of scooped flavors and don't mind letting you taste some. There's the classics and creative seasonal ones as well. read more

Yum!!! I looooove homemade ice cream and was so excited to see all these cool flavors. I got the vanilla PB fudge and my friend ordered the muddy buddy. Both soooo good! read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Vanilla pb fudge - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

Th shop looks super cute from the outside. From the inside though, it was a little dirty. My daughter didn't want to stay and eat her ice cream because every single table had sticky ice cream on it. They weren't busy either. I got a vanilla egg cream which was good. My daughter got sherbet in a waffle bowl. The portion was huge. She must have liked it because she ate it all. The staff was very friendly. read more

Good ice cream with a friendly staff. My son loves the pineapple sorbet here. The soft ice cream doesn't seem to be pumped up with air like some other places. read more

Heard about this place and finally gave it a try since it seemed so popular among the locals at work. I'm not quite sure what the hype was about. This seems like a pretty normal ice cream place that has a lot of flavors. I had a mix of the banana oreo and the coffee. Both tasted okay, but way too sweet for me. The banana flavor seemed very artificial and the coffee tasted okay, but just so so sweet. I wasn't a fan of the texture of the ice cream either. Both flavors I got seemed sort of icy and was not the smooth creamy ice cream I was hoping for. For the amount of ice cream you get, it's actually quite expensive. For another dollar, you could be getting Oddfellows or Van Leeuwen in Manhattan. read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Banana oreo (with coffee underneath) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

Amazing. Best Ice cream I have had in a very long time. Super creamy and fresh. The peanutbutter sundae and the the heavenly ash sundae are soo gooood. I cant wait to try more flavors and sundaes from here. Also I have only ordered from Uber eats and it always comes still solid not melty like most other places I have ordered from using delivery service. read more

Best ice cream on Long Island NY perfect I will recommended 100% Every summer we go there are once a week . Love it's

Loved this little ice cream shop. I think what made our experience so great was the counter guy ! I think his name might have been Danny. He was soooo sweet. Was patient with taking all our orders despite us being super indecisive! He even started casual conversation and recommended some flavors. My godson did not want his ice cream so Fanny was kind enough to wrap it for us and put it in a freezer so that it wouldn't melt while we were still eating our ice creams. He made this visit such a delight On to the main event.. the ice cream. It was delicious. I ended up getting pistachios and Nutella ! It had actually little crushed up pistachios and the Nutella had big fat chunks in Nutella in it. What a dream what a treat. All in a huge waffle cone with fresh chocolate and rainbow sprinkles. We would definitely come back for more read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Hallway - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

Average, overpriced ice cream. Flavors are overly sweet and oddly many of them taste the same. The interior and decoration is cute, just like a retro ice cream shop. Other than this, Carvel tastes better to me. read more

Once you're done with any main course, what better way to end it than with ice cream? That's what my little trio (including myself) decided yesterday afternoon, and being in the Bay Shore area, our choice was Coyle's. With two locations, there's more love to spread in ice cream form. We swung in to the Main Street stop and were greeted with a tiny 50's style ice cream parlor (their business card is accurate in promotion). There's oodles (yes oodles) of hard ice cream choices, with plenty of classics as well as original concoctions. Monster Mash was my decision which was chocolate in base and then mixed with peanut butter, pieces of ice cream cone, caramel, and other things that I honestly don't remember because the employee had me at those lovely words of peanut butter. I went with a small size which was more than enough as it packed a great punch of chocolate and peanut butter taste. The cone pieces were interesting in theory, though a little chewy upon consumption. Overall, Coyle's delivered some quality homemade ice cream, and I'm sure to return, though next time I'd like to check out the other location. read more

See all

Amazing brownie sundae ! Brownies are always super soft. Ice cream is creamy and good. Toppings are fresh and quick service even with a long line. Tons of outdoor seating as well when it's nice out! Right on the strip and easy to get to after dinner ! read more

Place is great! I always have a great experience when I go. Christian is the man to see when you go. He makes the best chocolate chip shakes I've ever had! read more

There are so many flavors that I can never decide what to get, but I also somehow end up with the usual maple pecan. All the flavors are good as at this point, i've sampled almost all of them, so you'll be happy with whatever you choose. The staff isn't the friendliest and they are pretty expensive for the size of the scoop you get. However, it's my go to place after I have Koi Kokorro which is right next door. It's a nice once in a while splurge for when I'm in the area. read more

This business does a huge disservice to the 2 young employees working on a busy Saturday night. One girl was handling Grubhub pickup orders and one girl was managing a long line of people waiting to order. The ice cream is delicious. The service when it was finally your turn was great. But how can there only be 2 people working there on a Saturday night Memorial Day weekend. So many teens want to work. Add some help. read more

They are the best ice cream. Ordered a cake for my mom's 100th birthday and the owner paid for it! Who does that? Thoughtful people. Great ice cream read more

Perfect location. The last time I went I had the brownie sundae. Decently priced and everyone is always nice. Has indoor and out door seating and normally not a huge line to order. read more

Sat in the shop with my mom and enjoyed the most delicious homemade icecream after a hot day by the marina. Perfect retreat in a sweet old fashioned ice cream parlor. They had many many options and i chose Monster Mash ice cream which was chocolatey peanutbuttery and dreamy... yum! read more

I like the vintage feel of this little ice cream parlor, but it was hard to find parking nearby and the inside is quite small. There are only 4 or 5 tables for seating and no table service or wait staff. They advertise handmade ice cream and I was disappointed there are NO low fat ice cream options!! The next surprise was the price. Two regular double scoop cones (1 was a waffle cone) cost just under $ 15.00 !! Very surprised. read more

Tried the holy cannoli and the strawberry cheesecake. Strawberry cheesecake is definitely my favorite flavor of all time but I wasn't so amazed by it here but the holy cannoli was good. I thought it'll taste more like a cannoli but it was pretty much vanilla ice cream with chocolate chips and some cannoli shells. I wish it had more shells and had more flavor of the cannoli filling but it was good. The price was worth it, it was a fair amount of ice cream. read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Holy cannoli - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

This is your no frills neighborhood ice cream spot. They have a wide variety of flavors that aren't overly sweetened and priced (like cold stone). The staff makes sure everyone is taken care of quickly. read more

Mississippi Mud (chocolate/coffee, brownie, fudge) hands down the best ice cream flavor you'll ever have. Forget Baskin Robbins, Cold Stone, Carvel, Friendlys, Haagen Daaz, Ben and Jerry's and whatever you thought you knew about ice cream, MISSISSIPPI MUD is where its at! This joint is located right next to Bubba's Burrito Bar so grab a couple fish taco's and embrace the food coma at Coyles. My buddy got some peanut butter fudge sundae and he wanted to come back the same night! They have the safe ice cream flavors and then they got ones that'll make you forget about your go to ice cream shop. If you plan on using your card remember that its a $10 minimum, and if you're in Bay Shore then stop in that shop as it has more flavors. read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Giggity - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

I'm not even over exaggerating- this place is INCREDIBLE. I live like two hours away and would love to make the trip to go back. A friend of mine & I went randomly on our way to fire island. We went back a second time it was so good. The ice cream was amazing, the staff was super friendly. The prices are SO reasonable - like I was shocked. I've been to plenty of ice cream places especially around nyc that are so costly for the downgraded version of what Coyle's offers. I wish I lived closer!!!! read more

Nice local place ice cream is ok here wasn't wowed by it. Have nice waffle cone are great read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Having ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Islip, New York

I want to love Coyles because it is right in my neighborhood but it's way overpriced. With that said, the Oreo is superb, one of the best I've ever had. So I'm giving them three stars. I would have given four or five if not for the small scoops relative to the price. It's too bad because I would come to Coyles more often. When it first opened, I was super excited because I had been to the Bay Shore location. Oh well, I guess they have to make money too. read more