I took my niece to Mickey's for an afternoon treat while in NY, and it was an absolute delight! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted by a bright, cheerful atmosphere and a display case packed with tempting options. Whether you're an ice cream enthusiast or just have a sweet tooth, Mickey's has something for everyone: traditional ice cream, cakes, hand made pies, premium pints, non-dairy options, and their famous ice cream sandwiches (yummm). There were so many flavors and treats to choose from that it took us a while to decide! I loved seeing the grab-and-go pints, such a great idea for busy families or for bringing dessert home. Before making my final choice, I sampled the cookie dough ice cream (which was rich and packed with doughy pieces), but I went with a scoop of Java Chunk in a cone with chocolate sprinkles. The flavor was spot on! A perfect blend of coffee and chocolate chips. My niece opted for her all-time favorite, cotton candy with rainbow sprinkles. The look on her face was pure joy. We took our treats outside and enjoyed them in the seating area, which was spacious and comfortable, perfect for relaxing on a sunny day and making the most of the beautiful weather. My niece told me it was the best day ever when we were enjoying our ice cream, so safe to say this place does it right. read more

See all

I can go on and on about Mickey's ice cream forever! I have tried many different flavors but my favorite has to be the chocoholic! My friends and I typically get 4 pints (buy 3 get 1 free) and keep them in my freezer and eat straight out of our own tub of ice cream - that is how much we love this place. Marvin likes their milkshakes which I also get occasionally, depending on my mood. If you get chocoholic in the milkshake just beware that the chunks kind of collect at the bottom! I also appreciate that they have non-dairy options which I have try still. read more

This is legitimately my favorite ice cream store in the world. And I've had ice cream in many countries and certainly all around New York. The ice cream is delicious, the toppings are unique and delicious and the workers are fantastic. Can't ask for much more with the only concern being it's too close to my new house and I'm fat enough already. read more

Mickey's is the local ice cream shop that people visit over generations. It is a very nice shop with a number of flavors. We loved the ice cream, service , location and the shop. It was a quick grab and go but was memorable. read more

Delicious local homemade ice cream. You really can't go wrong here - I'm addicted to the buttery pieces in the chocoholic. But a large range of flavors that don't rotate much. Note you can buy 2 quarts get one free, which is a dangerous proposition. Often a wait with screaming children so be prepared. Also sells cookie sandwiches and cakes. read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - Chocoholic small sugar cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

WHoaaaaaaa, you had me at FREE TOPPINGS! We were looking for ice cream near Stoney brook and tried this place! oMG, sooo glad we did. I would say that this might be one of the best ice cream places I've been to, and I have been to a lot on Long Island and elsewhere . Their ice cream is made for them off site. This is a free standing beautiful white building with plenty of parking in their parking lot and a large outdoor area with many picnic tables. In addition to their regular flavors, they have some fantastic dairy free and vegan ice cream choices! The ice cream flavors we bought had lots of large chunks of whatever they said, large pieces of chocolate in the cherry bomb flavor . I wasn't going to get any toppings, since the ice cream had so much in it, but just couldn't turn down the free toppings, so I added almonds, hot fudge and whipped cream. My other companion go sprinkles, nuts, hot fudge and marshmallow . Another person got peanut butter chips! Staff were incredibly friendly and accommodating. Service was excellent. Clearly I can't say enough, so I'll stop now. But, go there and you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

The ice cream is absolutely delicious, the place is clean and beautiful, the service is so friendly read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

Plenty of flavors to choose from. They are always adding new options too. Place is located in the heart of the town and is a welcome addition. Often times they will have events for children on the patio. Staff always friendly. Prices are a bit on the high side. Worth checking out once in a while for the ice cream craving! read more

Great tasting ice cream, huge selection of flavors, and beautiful building and outside seating. Staff were very nice and offered as many samples as we wanted. Very nice experience for sure! read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - Black raspberry chocolate chunk - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

Terrible and rude service with less than mediocre ice cream. Not deserving of the previous high reviews.

This was a real happening! At 8 pm we didn't expect to see a loud children's party with a DJ and lines out the door. The line moved quickly and our ice creams were excellent. I tried the rainbow cookie & cannoli ice cream, both were very delicious. Everyone enjoyed their ice creams. There was an endless assortment of flavors & I'm happy there are junior cones. Everything here is homemade and comes in small batches. A lot of regular flavors and some unusual ones: Barking Pretzel, Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk, Birthday Cake & Ice Cream, Butter Crunch, Butter Pecan, Cannoli Chip, Choco-Holic, Chocolate Peanut Butter Ripple, Peaches & cream, Coconut Caramel Chip, Cookies & Cream, Cookie Monster, Cotton Candy Confetti, Java Chunk, Mint Chunk Chip, Moose Tracks, Peppermint Bark, Pistachio Almondine, Rainbow Cookie, Rocky Road, Rum Raisin, Vanilla Raspberry Swirl, Vanilla Peanut Butter Ripple, White Chocolate Raspberry Ripple... Sugar free options and non dairy flavors were available. read more

See all

Nice family style place with outdoor tables to sit and enjoy family time. Ice cream seems fresh and creamy, by today's standards. Young adult servers are welcoming, patient and kind. Would give a 5 start review, if the gentleman (owner??) would have the same attributes as the employees. read more

I just simply love this local ice cream spot. It's definitely molding itself into the fabric of this great community. I'm updating my review to 5 stars since my last review having been here numerous times of the past couple years, and consistently been great. Never disappoints, service is always very helpful and friendly. The shop always looks clean and well maintained. Flavors are great! Go Mickeys ! read more

See all

Great new spot in the heart of St James. Saturday afternoon, we're running around and doing our weekly errands. I knew there was a new Ice Cream Shop opened on Lake Ave, the flags outside caught my eye as we swung into the parking lot. The first thing I noticed is how large everything is, from the parking lot to the outdoor deck, Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen is ready to have a party! Walking inside, its a nice looking spot with window seating up front. There's a case with grab & go homemade ice cream sandwiches. The flavors look amazing and there are multiple selections. The girl behind the counter was helpful and answsered all our questions. My wife wanted a taste of whatever I ordered so chocolate peanut butter chunk it is! sooooooo good! I also got another peanut butter flavor scoop but with pretzel mixed in? Here's the issue, when you have ice cream sitting with pretzels, the pretzels will get soft and soggy. Mickeys Ice Cream was very fresh and the pretzels tasted fresh so Total fan! Great to see a new shop opened in St James, we'll probably come here because its closer to our home. read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - Ice cream two scoops - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

See all

Two words..... barking pretzel!!!! Omg vanilla ice cream with lots of peanut butter and chocolate covered pretzel bites. MY FAV. I crave it every week!!! And I don't even love ice cream that much. Also, it's the peanut butter cookies and cream. Service is always great. The girls behind the counter are always so nice and the prices are decent!!! Love!! read more

First time at Mickey's, absolutely delicious ice cream! They offer sorbet, hard ice cream, soft serve and Vegan options. The staff is extremely friendly. There is a large area to sit outside. read more

Looking for a nice hometown ice cream shop nestled in the heart of St. James on Main Street, then you've come to the right place. You will not be disappointed! The ice cream choices are endless and delicious. They've got sorbets, oat milk ice cream and so much more. And you've got cone options as well. Wafer, sugar or waffle. Not sure what flavor to choose, then ask for a sample tasting and/or ask for suggestions. Not in the mood for ice cream on a cone then you can try one of their amazing shakes, ice cream sandwiches, pints/quarts to go or cakes. Whatever you fancy by way of ice cream you'll be sure to find it here. The ice-cream servers behind the counter are always super friendly and helpful. On this particular night, I especially liked being greeted by someone who appeared to be the owner as we entered. The warm vibe makes this ice cream shop feel like home and keeps me coming back. As if the ice cream wasn't enough. There are plenty of tables to sit outside and savor your treat(s). Enjoy! read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - Showcase filled with so many delicious options - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

See all

This place is one of my favorite ice cream places in Long Island! I get the Coffee and Mint here. Both these flavors were soo good! The coffee wasn't too strong nor sweet and the mint wasn't too minty. Everything was delicious! I totally recommend coming here for ice cream if you are in the area. The consistency and range of flavors for the ice cream are fantastic! Service and Ambiance: The workers are very nice and there are tables inside and outside for you to sit and enjoy your dessert! read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - Coffee and Mint Chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

Mikey's Ice Cream in St. James delivers the goods. Tons of flavors, creamy perfection, and my pretzel peanut butter scoop was a salty sweet masterpiece. Outdoor seating, parking in the back, and yeah it's a bit pricier, but totally worth every lick. read more

We absolutely love Mickeys, Mickeys is such a staple in our community and they have excellent ice cream. The establishment is always clean and the staff is just phenomenal. They have so many cream flavors to choose from and non dairy flavors as well which is always a plus. I believe toppings are free. You can get it in a cone, cup, or even a Shake. I'm excited to try the ice cream cake next. read more

Friendly staff and a great product. A bit overpriced, but tastes great. Great location with ample parking in rear

Great local ice cream parlor in town. The ice cream is amazing. The service is fast even when there are lines and there is plenty of seating outside in the picnic area. Parking is plenty. Very clean and nice inside. read more

I phoned in yesterday afternoon for guidance on purchasing a gift card on the website (I couldn't locate it). The employee that answered the phone provided the VERY best customer service I've encountered. She was genuine, knowledgeable and professional from the moment she answered. We live in Florida and want to visit this location due to this singular interaction! If I was hiring for my team, this employee would be at the top of my list! read more

Great ice cream and friendly employees- great service I love the ice cream - fresh homemade taste

This is Saint James' HOMEGROWN ice cream! It's an incredible, family-friendly place that has incredible flavors for everyone, like Cookie Monster for the kids, incredible coffee ice cream for the adults, and even vegan options. Their soft serve sundaes and toppings are great too, the perfect balance of homemade and comfort. This is also a wonderful place for young kids' birthday parties - affordable and interactively fun. The outdoor patio is hopping in the summertime - if you want to park in the lot during this time, come early before an event or park on the street. This place is worth the trip!!! read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - A happy customer :) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

See all

I came here after eating at St. Jame's pizza with my friend, her husband, their two kids and my son. At the time I was vegan and happily they had some dairy free ice cream for me to eat. One day I hope to come back again because I'm back to being a vegetarian and want to try to the regular ice cream. They have an awesome backyard picnic area for you to hang out and eat your ice cream and they also have some indoor seating. The set up is just beautiful so it's a great place to also hang out. My dairy free ice cream was great, my son loved his ice cream too. If you're in the area you've got to pay a visit here! read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - Dairy free chocolate and coffee with peanut butter sauce - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

Great ice cream and milkshakes! Seems family owned and stop by here when ever I'm in the area. My wife loves the black raspberry chunk and I just go for the cookies and cream milk shake. Everyone is very nice and they have a good indoor and outdoor seating area. read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

Dropped in today to pick up a birthday cake. Was greeted by young woman who helped me pick a cake to my liking. How refreshing to get friendly service upon arrival. The place was so nice and clean with benches and beautiful crepe Myrtle's in the back. Great ice cream too. This place is a winner. read more

Great ice cream at a reasonable price. Everything here is made in house. They have pretty good specials too if you want to take some pints to go. Buy 3 get 1 free or buy 2 quarts and get 1 free. The seating area outside is cool with some lights strung up. Another great thing to keep in mind is when you're shopping here you're supporting a Saint James local who owns the establishment. Stop by and enjoy one of the many flavors. read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - a cup of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

Wonderful ice cream option for the St. James scene. Came here after hearing about it from a friend and was pleasantly surprised. Inside is clean and stark white with seating areas. Walk a little bit further and a wide variety of ice cream flavors await you. I ended up choosing the moosetracks: vanilla with fudge and reeses pieces. Overall, good! Good portion size with lots of fudge and reeses pieces. Totally kills that ice cream craving if you're in the area. I hope it sticks around to test around some funky new flavors! read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

Great ice cream. The long lines go fast because they have plenty of help. Prices are pretty steep, especially for a family. Owner a really nice guy. read more

Loveeeeeeee mickeys ice cream .I have travel over 20 minutes to go here . Always the best and love all activities they have for the kids from time to time read more

Truly wonderful. Just heard about this place today and thought I'd give it a try. Well worth the trip. Delicious ice cream and a welcoming crew makes for a delightful experience. read more

See all

Mickey's ice cream is always so fresh and delicious! I had two scoops of rainbow cookie and cannoli ice cream. Both flavors had the perfect amount of rainbow cookie and cannoli shell/chocolate chips throughout the ice cream that you got a little bit in each bite. The flavor of the ice cream bases were distinct, yet subtle and not overly sweet. My husband had a cookies and cream MickStacker which was loaded with cookie pieces and fudge. Portion sizes are generous and the pricing is remarkable considering the ice cream is made fresh with obviously high quality ingredients. A bonus for us is that they are available for delivery through DoorDash, so we can enjoy their sweet treats anytime! Mickey's is definitely a summer staple for our family. read more

Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen - Rainbow cookie & Cannoli ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saint James, New York

5 minutes after dinner and as we were going to drive around seeing decorated for Halloween houses, my mom had to pee. As I looked on yelp and then looked out the window I was like there! What a cute place that sadly I did not go inside but I did enjoy my ice cream from here. My mom also seemed to be happy with the service. read more

O M G!!! I'm a LI native but live in chicago now. I've had Mickey's NYC locations on my radar for a while now, and much to my surprise, they have a new location right by my sister-in-law's family's home! Wow. I'll be a Mickey's fan for life. Rainbow cookie ice cream - ARE YOU KIDDING ME! My Italian American Long Islander heart burst with joy. It was perfect. read more

came for my wife she can only have non dairy ice cream and they use oat milk. I got one also so she can try my flavor. It was very good and a nice option to have. The service was very good they were empty at the moment and theres some indoor and outdoor seating. read more

Amazing little spot! Owner is super nice and allows You to try flavors before you make your final decision. Super clean and friendly staff. Take the kids on a Friday after school or just one day for a sweet dessert and enjoy the outdoor seating area! read more

I love the ice cream I like the service I like that it is in a quiet area I had a lot of party's there read more

so happy with have this in the neighborhood. Mickeys ahs a lot of stuff happening and is an assent to our community. very generous and engaged. the ice cream is delicious. and its busy. i was so happy when i saw them turn the old dilapidated building in to a wonderful ice cream kitchen right across the street from the park. read more