I got the ice cream that was mixed with everything. I would try this spot again. Nothing crazy special inside

Social is definitely not an accurate name for this store. The person behind the counter was not social at all. She seemed annoyed to help customers. Half of the ice cream containers were empty leaving little selection. The ice cream I had was good. This was the first and last time I would ever shop here. read more

A solid ice cream spot, lots of flavors. The ice cream had just the right consistency, creamy and not too icy. Pretty standard in terms of service and atmosphere. I will say the ice cream did seem a bit pricey relative to the size of the scoops and the quality. This was a bit more of a grab and go spot, since there wasn't really seating available, which seemed a bit weird for an ice cream shop. There was a bit of room outside, but that wouldn't do much good for half the year! read more

See all

Up charged for sprinkles after first charge attempt failed. Ice cream is gritty, soupy consistency that if you don't eat it in .03 seconds it'll be all over you and the floor. Comparable to a knock off carvel and that's being generous. Less than impressive flavor selections and items in fridge are always half melted. Extremely overpriced, hard pass on this place. read more

5 years ago I wrote a review for this place when it was Granny's and gave it 5 stars, raving about amazing it was. I moved away and just came back and went to stop in and get my favorite only 8 yogurt. I am honestly shocked at what a bad experience this was. I got a medium only8 chocolate frozen yogurt. I included the picture of what my ice cream looked like, it was soup, and didn't peak over the top of the cup. I even said to the girl who made my ice cream is this what it's supposed to look like and she said yes. I honestly asked again and she said yeah, this is the machine and what it is. The best part was when she told me it was $9.75 for this cup of soup with no toppings that didn't even swirl like normal ice cream. I actually said outloud omg are you sure that's the right price and she said yes and asked me if I was paying with a card. Really disappointing experience and I guess I'll have to find somewhere else to get my favorite yogurt. read more

Ice Cream Social - This is how my yogurt was served to me, I'm still in front of the store and haven't left yet. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Commack, New York

My favorite ice cream place for my grandson and I yet today the ice cream was so soft it fell into the cup and the scoop was like 3/4 scoop. Even my grandson said it's the least ice cream he ever got. We'll go to carvel so he doesn't fell jipped. He is 5. He shouldn't have noticed yet it was bad enough that he did read more

Vegan desserts, especially ice cream, have come a LONG way over the past decade or so. That said, I'll always have a place in my heart for the Carvel cakes of my childhood, with those unspeakably delicious chocolate crunch snaking its way through the middle. It's seemingly impossible to find, but... Ice Cream Social does that for us! They also somehow replicate the flavor of Carvel vanilla which is hard to describe unless you've tasted it. My brother and sister in law surprised the fam with a vanilla chip cake yesterday for Father's Day and it's nothing short of extraordinary. My father, who loves Carvel and is most certainly NOT vegan, loved this cake. I am vegan for decades and wanted to marry this cake. It's so rich and decadent and the chocolate crispies are perfection. Even the whipped cream icing and sprinkles made me feel like I was a kid again (including that feeling that I wanted to beg for a second slice!) Thank you, Ice Cream Social, for your superb selection of vegan flavors (they have pistachio, cherry vanilla, vanilla peanut butter, vanilla raspberry chip... pinch me, I'm dreaming because there's not a single flavor that I wouldn't try). read more

James is a fine server at Icecream Social in Commack NY. He knows all the flavors and says that the ice cream is made there fresh. There is the soft serve as well. Lots of types and toppings. Though no blackberry unless I missed it. My flavor choice was coconut. They do not give paper receipts but give a choice of text or email option.( see pix) read more

See all

Cute ice cream parlor in Commack. It's in a strip mall with plenty of parking. The ice cream flavors were yummy and they had a lot of cool flavors. The ice cream was in general on the softer side though and it was pretty much on its way to melting by the time we stepped outside and hurriedly finished our ice cream in the parking lot. I did like the coffee cake - tasted just like coffee cake! Also I love cookies and cream and was very intrigued to see the base be chocolate ice cream (as opposed to vanilla) - this is the first time I've ever seen that for cookies and cream ice cream. I still liked it but would have preferred the vanilla. I also got the vanilla chip. My spouse said the chocolate chips tasted minty but honestly I couldn't really taste the mint much. I liked this flavor too. Everything was just a tiny bit too soft and melting a bit too fast but overall pretty tasty ice cream. read more

The last time I went to an Ice Cream store that provides their own custom flavors was in Carey, North Carolina. This store is located in a small strip mall with ample parking. From what I read; Ice Cream Social has several flavors of ice cream along with vegan flavors. They do have traditional flavors such as vanilla, chocolate, and cookie dough, but they are constantly designing new flavors. I tried many flavors before choosing the pumpkin pie flavor ice cream. But I did also like the apple cider donut and Coco Almond Joy. Next time I will explore other interesting creations. The staff was kind enough to afford me the opportunity to taste many creative flavors. It was not easy to settle on just one flavor. I recall a family member explaining to me what it takes to create these interesting flavors, and he stated it is all in the Cream mix. If you want to enjoy high quality ice cream with many creative flavors, one must indulge in Ice Cream Social. read more

Ice Cream Social - a display of chocolate covered nuts - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

I have to knock off a star for their silly portion shenanigans. It's August and I'm driving my Jeep Wrangler with the roof off. The sun is beating down on me and I remembered there was an Ice Cream spot I passed in Commack. I get off the Northern State and head to Ice Cream Social. You can't miss this place, there is a big Ice Cream cone sign by the door! Walking in, there are a few great choices. My choice is Rocky Road in a cone. I'm asked, One Scoop or Two? I need to cool off but I don't want to ruin dinner so its one scoop for me. The Rocky Road? Insane.. Lots of chunky funky things going on, Marshmallows, Chocolate Chunks and Creamy Chocolate Ice Cream. Did I just describe heaven? I was so impressed, I put a pin in it and went home and told Mrs S. We're driving to Nassau county this weekend. I told my wife lets be social and have some ice cream. She's down so I set the Nav to Ice Cream Social. We walk in and the line is out the door? I told her, lets not wait. We'll come back when we head back home. Sure enough, the line is low and we're ready to order. Yippy! My wife ordered "Coconut Almond Joy" and let me tell you, it was pure joy to enjoy this flavor. Creamy ice cream with tons of coconut and almonds. Usually, they have the chunks on top. This flavor had chunks in every single bite. Here's where the shenanigans start. We're asked "cup or cone"? Then, small or medium? My wife said, a small cup please. We see a small cup but then, two massive scoops are put into the cup. I'm like, dang! I changed it up, small please with a chocolate peanut butter base with chocolate cookies and cream?? *What should have been asked, would you like one scoop or two? Ice Cream Social has a mini, a one scoop cup. That would have been our preferred choice. I'll continue. My wife & are in bliss, I asked if I could use my debit card. Not a problem sir! I get home and check my bank app. Those two small ice cream cups were $14 dollars? What. The. F! Wait, did I ask for gold flakes on those cups? Listen Ice Cream Social. That was some damn expensive ice cream, too rich for my blood. I'll stick to my own my own social circles near Miller Place where the same ice cream being served at McNulty's. Peace out! read more

Ice Cream Social - Amazing flavors - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

This place's coffee mud slide flavor is one of the best ice cream flavors I've ever had in my life I'm pretty sure

If I could give this place zero stars, I would. Unfortunately, that isn't an option, so I'm forced to give it one. I took my daughter here, and a staff member gave her a cup of toppings. At first, I thought it was Butterfinger pieces, but when I looked more closely, I realized there were ants in the cup, which resulted in her feeling very uneasy. read more

I love this place. We aren't from the area but the two times we were in this area we made it a point to come here! Just so good.

My absolute favorite ice cream shop. I wish i lived closer, but maybe it's good that I don't because I would be here every day. Quality, homemade ice cream with flavors that I haven't seen elsewhere. And even the flavors everyone has, Ice Cream Social makes it top notch. Their rainbow cookie ice cream isn't just vanilla ice cream with cookies mixed in, it's an actual rainbow cookie flavored ice cream, with cookies added. They are that good, with prices that can't be beat. Super friendly, super quick, my only wish is they had seats. read more

Always delicious, wide variety of flavors. Staff behind the counter very accommodating Will be back soon read more

A cute place for ice cream in Commack. The staff is Friendly. There are many of choices ice cream . Worth a Try.

When in on a Sunday with my cousin and his girlfriend and these two ladies were very unprofessional she really wasn't happy when i had asked a couple of questions about the ice cream and her responses were very quick and the look she gave was that she didn't wanna help so then i had asked for vanilla cookies n cream she gave me chocolate cookies n cream and laughed at us when we walked out AFTER paying for something we didn't ask for read more

Now this was some delicious ice cream! Since trying to eat healthier, we still allow ourselves ice-cream on the weekend and today we took a little drive just to try Granny's... and we're glad we did. I had toasted coconut. I think it's one of the best cups of ice cream I've had. Very flavorful, filled with actual toasted coconut. Hubby had Coconut Almond Joy and raved about how good it was. While I will say from looks alone it was just a small ice cream shop, the flavors delivered, and there was a lot to choose from. They even had a whole section of vegan non-dairy flavors which was nice to see. Plus, they had some frozen ice cream sandwiches and bonnets to take to keep at home. Overall a really cool ice cream shop! We'll definitely be coming back to try more flavors! read more

Ice Cream Social - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Commack, New York

I really want to give this place 5 stars because the ice cream is amazing but the service sucks. The girl with the dirty blond hair seemed more interested in her phone than helping customers. It got pretty busy and the poor dark haired girl was doing all the work. Seriously, stay home if you're not into working. Phones should be banned while you're at work. read more

Found out about Granny's via Facebook back in June/July! Was able to make it here today. The girls working behind the counter were super sweet! Very polite and nice. It appeared that they actually liked their job and they wanted to be there. When it was my turn to order I had asked if they still had the rainbow cookie sundae, as it was last month's sundae of the month. I did see that they had rainbow cookie ice cream...so I figured it wouldn't hurt to ask. The girl helping me was such a sweetheart. She checked to see if they still had the toppings to make the sundae for me. They had the rainbow cookie bites but not the raspberry syrup. She offered me chocolate syrup instead, but I decided on no syrup. The flavor of the ice cream was out-of-this-world delicious! Tasted just like a rainbow cookie. Flavors 100000% on point! There are so many different flavors of ice cream offered here. Both soft and hard serve ice cream. All homemade. Can't wait to try more flavors. Prices very reasonable! Social distancing also in full force. Lines on the floor where to stand, gloves and masks worn by all employees. read more

Ice Cream Social - Birds eye view of rainbow cookie sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

I saw a write up in Newsday that this place was owned by a chef who was on Hells Kitchen so of course I had to check it out. Pulled up at 9 pm on a weeknight and there was a line outside, surely a good sign. All flavors are touted as being homemade and I have to say they did NOT disappoint. This ice cream is nothing like what you'd get in the supermarket. It's luxuriously creamy and imbued with flavor. So good that I in fact shamelessly had two different items and I ain't even made about it. Pistachio is my favorite flavor of all time so naturally I had to try it. Unlike some other places, Granny's has the ratio of nuts to ice cream perfectly proportioned. I went in for seconds with pumpkin pie ice cream topped with caramel and whipped cream in a waffle bowl. Basically Thanksgiving dessert in ice cream form. My only complaint is that they need more powerful spoons. My chintzy utensil was not able to effectively scoop the ice cream out of the bowl and into my mouth efficiently and I was concerned a number of times it would break. read more

See all

This place has changed a lot since I was last here and I gave it 2 visits before I updated. So good! Great, prompt service and so much better than when it was Granny's. My favorite flavor is the chocolate peanut butter. The portions are huge, even the ''mini' size! Bring cash as there is an up charge for using your card. We will be back! read more

Visit Date: March 12, 2021 I took my son to Smithaven mall and than found Granny's and we went there for ice cream after because we have adventures that involve doing something fun and getting ice cream after. He deserved ice cream because I've been hardcore obsessed with Tupac lately and took him to the mall for a Tupac hoodie. I got nutella flavored and pumpkin flavored ice cream with peanut butter sauce and hot fudge. It was a pretty good combo and pretty nice ice cream. My son got chocolate covered pretzels too and I got the maple bacon cup it was pretty good too! Granny's is a nice ice cream shop worth visiting. read more

This is a fantastic spot to get ice cream. I have become a big fan in a short amount of time. I dream about my next flavor options every time I'm finished with my current cone. read more

See all

Creamy dreamy deliciousness! I tried almond joy and rainbow cookie. The almond joy tastes just like the candy bar! And who doesn't love rainbow cookies! So so good. I've been wanting to go but during this crisis I took advantage of their curbside pick up. Olivia was the friendly young lady who answered the phone and the process was quick and easy. Check out their website with 55 flavors, call to place your order, tell them what you want, call when you get there and you have yummy yummy ice cream brought to your car. I can't wait to go back when things return to normal as they have other goodies as well. Hey in times like these ice cream makes things better. I love you Granny's! read more

Ice Cream Social - Almond joy and rainbow cookie, YUM - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Commack, New York

The ice cream here is some of the best! So delicious, creamy, fresh and most of all, they have fun and unique flavors. The staff is always super friendly and they are very efficient when there's a high volume of customers in the store :) read more

Ice Cream Social - two cups of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

I took my daughter here to Granny's because I was very curious about the ice cream, homemade so of course we were full of expectations. The place was clean, marks on the floor to keep people 6 feet apart and staff were all wearing masks and were very nice which is all very much appreciated. There were so many flavors to pick from and we decided not to stick with our vegan diet for now. LOL. My daughter got peach and blueberry, I got toasted coconut and I think it was called chocolate crazy. The ice cream was so unbelievably rich that after a few bites we both couldn't really eat anymore, I finished 1/2 of mine and my daughter ate less than that. We got smalls but they were very big! I liked the coconut flavor but was not a fan of the chocolate. I'm a chocolate freak but this was just not doing it for me. The ice cream was rich and very sweet but lacking depth. My daughter had a similar impression. I'm still giving Granny's 4 stars because I'm not 100% sure that our lack of loving the ice cream was not due to the both of us being used to non dairy. We will have to go back and try the vegan offerings next time to be positive. Cheers! read more

My husband got me a strawberry shortcake for my birthday. It was our first time ordering from here the cake was amazing!!! It was so delicious, I recommend this place. read more

See all

I've been going to this spot for ice cream for years when it was originally called grannies and I have continued to get my ice cream here since it changed ownership. The service is good and sometimes terrific. The options available is amazing. All of the different types whether you're getting regular ice cream or soft serve or only eight or vegan plus their cakes and flying saucers, etc., is pretty terrific. My complaint is that every single time I buy the same cone in the same size with the same ice cream it's a different price. I've gotten a cone a few days ago. It was $10.80 two days later, it was $12 and change. I think that's an extreme amount of money also for an only eight with crunchies. Before that it was anywhere from seven or eight dollars, so I'm not sure why the price differential was so extreme. I will add that they also have candy which looks like it's homemade as well as chairs to sit outside and plenty of parking. read more

Had a $10 gift certificate and was able to get a sundae with toppings for $10. It looked great, but I was expecting more, particularly since the store was so crowded. The ice cream was okay, needs a higher cream content, but expensive. I might go back if I have to take my niece or nephew for ice cream run, otherwise... probably not. read more

Going downhill rapidly. Used to have good counter service. Now, at least on weekends, the service is lazy and surly. And today hit the jackpot. First, no chocolate hard ice cream of any type. Keeping in mind that the two top flavors around here are vanilla and chocolate, that's not good. And in recent visits, most of multiple chocolate ice creams were peanut butter variations - something that many people are highly allergic to. But another big problem - most of the ice cream bin holders were empty, and supposedly, according to the surly woman with black hair at the counter, there was nothing in back even though the place would be open for several more hours. Add to this, when one of our party asked for a milk shake, same woman told us the machine was broken. One more thing; the sign with the current flavors suddenly went out of use in the last few weeks. We used to love this place. There would usually be a few flavors that we liked, and they would be very good. Sounds like the owners and chef have abandoned the place and left it in the hands of a few lazy kids. read more

Quality of the ice cream is still good as when it was Granny's. Not the potions you get pales in comparison to what it used to be. The mini cup used to pack and overflowing from the cup. How you barely get enough to fill the cup and they charge you $5 for it. As good as the ice cream is, it's not worth the price for what you get. read more

Amazing gourmet ice cream, must stop if you're in the area. So many options, including vegan options. The toasted coconut was so good. Super cute inside for insta photo ops. Even if you're not in the area it's worth the drive read more

See all

you get that craving for ice cream and not that supermaket stuff or chain stuff Boy is Granny GOOD I had to taste coconut because I love coconut and rare good coconut is hard to fine Granny did well hers is awesome generous portion at reasonable cost rich and creamy ice cream everything appears to be made in small batches by the look of the freezer There is even a freezer of vegan ice creams interesting to add they have CANDY and its kosher I had to leave with some yummy pecan turtles and cherry cordials this candy was really good so Granny is really an ice shop and candy shop read more

See all

Loved the Cinnabon flavor so much. It was delicious. The staff were very friendly. Couldn't ask for a better ice cream spot on a hot summer day. This was a great place! I would definitely recommend it to others and return myself if I'm back in the area. The quality was great! read more

Ice Cream Social - Cinnabon flavor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Commack, New York

Came here for the vegan ice cream,I got regular and my wife got vegan. It was out of the way for vegan but my regular was good But I could get that anywhere. read more

Stopped by this place with some friends @ 10:03, and the store hours posted was 10:30 for Sunday night. The workers closed the door on us as we approached the door, and began to laugh amongst themselves. Will never give my patronage, you lost about 7 customers. read more

Ice cream is insanely good! My favorite is double chocolate chip (for anyone who likes chocolate)but J would recommend anything! A great place with great ice cream, and very quick service. Definitely would come again, and if you are in the area, this is a must-have. read more

Ice Cream Social - Double chocolate chip ice cream Cookies and cream ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Commack, New York

Great local ice cream spot. Homemade and delicious. Lived near it for over 5 years and first tried it. Was pleasantly amazed. The pistachio has tons of pistachio ground up so every bite has good texture. The ice cream is very creamy as well. I look forward to going back for different flavors. read more