This location seems to be a little older than the one on Main Street in Bay Shore, but one thing it definitely has going for it is the variety of flavors. There is also a convenient parking lot, which makes stopping by much easier. The pricing seems to be about the same and is a little high in my opinion, but since the ice cream is homemade, you can truly taste the quality. Another thing I enjoyed about this location is that they have seating inside, so you can relax and enjoy your treats. There was a long line when I arrived, but it moved smoothly. The worker was friendly and patient, allowing me to sample a few flavors before making my selection. I ended up sticking with our favorites, Brownie Nut Fudge and Banana Oreo, but next time I'll definitely have to try one of the new flavors I sampled. Definitely recommend! If you're going to treat yourself to ice cream, it might as well be creamy, delicious and made with care. read more

Yum!! This homemade ice cream was awesome. Their specialty sundaes really hit the spot. The fudge and peanut butter sauce are amazing, and I loved the Mississippi mud flavor ice cream! read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Old school ice cream shop. Such a very very cute place. Yummy ice cream. Customer service was great. Loved the cannoli ice cream & the cookies & cream with a peanut butter drizzle and walnuts on top. read more

See all

My son and his friend wanted to go for ice cream and we usually go to Old Fashioned Ice Cream Shop on Straight Path. But they don't have indoor seating and I just got a new car 2 days ago. No way was I letting 3 teens in my car with ice cream. His friend recommended Coyle's off Sunrise Highway. I can't believe we've never stopped here before! It was all decorated for Christmas and had friendly old ice cream shop / diner vibes with plenty of booths and counter seats. It was empty because it was 5 pm on one of the coldest days of the year. They have a wide selection of homemade ice cream flavors, plus soft serve, waffle cones, waffle bowls, their own sundae creations, and ice cream cakes and other treats to take home. I got a cannoli and Irish cream cup, my son got pistachio, and his friend got mint chip and Nutella. My daughter got a hot chocolate that she also enjoyed. I'd say it's easily comparable to OFICS, but the seating and atmosphere takes it to the next level. We will definitely be back -- ideally when the weather warms up! read more

See all

Where has this place been all my life! Now it is the most economical but it is delicious! & they don't skimp on the scoops! They have sooo many options! I tried a few and ultimately went with the cookies and crème with crunchies! My daughter went basic as well with chocolate and sprinkles. They do allow you to taste flavors so if you are feeling adventurous , I saw go for it! You likely will not be disappointed. I typically go to carvel for ice cream cakes, but this might by new go to! Oo and they have two different types of ice creams. Hard ice cream and soft ice cream. I asked what the difference is and they said soft ice cream is soft serve the artificial stuff that you get from the ice cream truck. The hard Ice cream is the ice cream made in house . Aka the good stuff. You're gonna wanna go for the hard ice cream! read more

See all

Not fresh - sold me freeze burnt sundae looks like it's been sitting in the freezer for years read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Yummy ice cream! So many flavors! Just a bit pricey, but the blackout of '65 is my favorite.

I would consider myself the world's foremost leading expert on Cookies 'n Cream...and this place knocked it out of the park. The key thing you look for is the color and the Oreo volume (the more Oreos, the grayer the ice cream). This place has the perfect shade of gray (no pun intended). As a point of comparison, think of all those places where it's completely white except for a few micro particles of Oreo. Oh and hats off to the staff for a nice healthy portion. read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Stopped by this place last weekend. At first, we thought they also served frozen yogurt but we were wrong. Instead of walking out, our eyes were locked onto the abundant homemade ice cream flavors they have in stock. Anything you wish you try, they will give you a sample spoonful. My wife ordered a small ice cream in a cup for about $6.50 and the portion was literally a scoop and a half. I had a waffle cone which comes in 3 scoops and that was around $10. Definitely flavorful and the portion is to be applauded for. If you happen to opt for their waffle cone dipped in either chocolate or rainbow sprinkle, there is zero up-charge. The service was impeccable and we enjoyed the whole interior vibe of a diner feel. Definitely a high recommend for me and deserving of 5 stars. read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Honeycomb flavor scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Excellent. Vanilla chocolate chip is very creamy with a good amount of chocolate chips.

We try to come by when on Long Island. (We live in Brooklyn) the banana Oreo ice cream is just out of this world. I usually get the shake. I wish there was one closer to us. Highly recommend read more

Coyle's of Bayshore always delivers a wonderful ice cream experience. All of the employees are cheerful, helpful, and friendly. Anna, the manager, has created a welcoming and family-feeling environment. To top it all off, all of their ice cream is homemade on premises, and you simply can't find better. This place is a must-visit for any ice cream fan; my family travels all the way from Huntington for it!!! read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Coyles is a lovely old-fashioned ice cream shop that my kids and I love coming to! It's clean, tons of flavors, great friendly employees!

The staff were very helpful explaining my options for the birthday cake in stock that was closest to the flavors my daughter likes. I had forgotten to order in advance and they were happy to write on the one I chose. They even included some free candles! When we served the cake, everyone raved about how good it was. Several asked where I got it. When I want something that pleases a big crowd, I only go to Coyle's. No other ice cream cakes come close to the quality and look of Coyle's cakes! read more

I've been wanting to try Coyle's for a while and finally did! Unfortunately it was disappointing when all 3 flavors we ordered had ice crystals and icy crunch texture. The flavors were ok - the raspberry chocolate was lacking raspberry flavor. And definitely overpriced in comparison to other homemade ice cream stores. read more

delicious fresh tasting will definitely be back. Brunette Girl was super kind and sweet would 100% come back for for some ice cream and her number!! read more

In Bay Shore looked for ice cream place. Islip location and Bay Shore nearby but as the Bay Shore location was on the way, we stopped there after asking a store merchant on Main Street if they cold tell us where an icecream store was. The merchant did mention to call this location as she had heard they might be closing. I did call and they were open. I noted and bought frozen peanut butter dog treats 4 in a bag for 2 dollars. They have a1950s style bar seats and tables. Marilyn Monroe picture along with other of the error images, along with a few halloween decors. (see pix) Icecream is home made from the products they get, some specialty items in freezer case as tortonis. They happened to have cherry pistachio, a flavor I seldom see and after 3 try flavors I opted for that. Many waffle cone and waffle cups to choose from. Ice cream was creamy but did seem to have an after taste. They do accept credit cards with 4% fee. 3 girls working there at time of visit. An ok place to get some icecream. read more

Great old fashioned ice cream spot. I love that they have tons of pre-packed icecream to bring home for the freezer. Whenever I go I get a hot fudge sundae with the cannoli ice cream. It's a must try flavor. Love Coyle's! read more

the ice cream is bussin. I got a free sundae from my school. and the ice cream was so good

Wow this place is old school and AMAZING! Hands down the best ice cream I've ever had. Staff was very helpful and informative as well. Great ice cream spot. This place has been a staple in West Bayshore for along as I remember . Ice cream is very good. I bought an ice cream cake and it was also good. Service is great. Highly recommend. Excellent staff! And the ice cream of course is delicious. They have every kind of ice cream you could possibly imagine. Five stars This place reminded me of the ice cream shop when I was a child. It brought back so many memories that I was able to share with my girlfriend. The cherry vanilla ice cream is to die for! My gf thoroughly enjoyed her chocolate shake! Well worth the trip!! This place has some of the best ice cream I've ever had. They're friendly too and the service is always great! Large variety of flavors. Excellent ice cream. read more

My ice cream tasted phenomenal and my server was very very nice and cheerful her name was Erin. Your server, Teagan was super nice when I asked for a water after I was thirsty from eating your amazing ice cream. read more

My server Jaslene was amazing along with the ice cream!! Erin went above and beyond to make the coyles experience so special, would definitely recommend Coyles homemade ice cream in bayshore. read more

Great ice cream and toppings and friendly owner and staff. I had the blackout of 65 Sunday with vanilla fudge and chocolate brownie ice cream. It comes with two toppings and added hot fudge and marshmallow topping with whipped cream. read more

Erin is the best worker. She made me the best milkshake and she is so kind and I had a great experience because or her.

Coyle's , located In Bayshore , is a 50's style ice cream parlor with a fun old fashioned atmosphere! The ice cream is high quality and homemade ! They have an amazing selection of ice cream flavors and toppings... you can get pretty much anything you want there! I am partial to the chocolate raspberry chip . It's rich and creamy and filled with an abundance of chips ! So good ! Check out their website you'll want to run right down and get some .. but check out the store hours first !! read more

See all

Good ol' fashioned ice cream in an ol' fashioned setup. They have all the good flavors and good quality ice creams and shakes. Sampled couple and got a small cup with two flavors. They also have some of the colorful ice sticks. A good portion of the people went with some custom sundaes. This is a very friendly neighborhood ice cream store. read more

I ordered this on Uber eats and had good expectations based on reviews. The ice cream I received was freezer burnt and had mixes of different flavors mixed in. I ordered s'mores and had bites of mint chocolate ice cream and peanut butter mixed in. My spouse had chocolate peanut butter pieces in his plain strawberry ice cream and his was freezer burnt as well with large ice crystals in it. The taste was immediately freezer burn taste. I would not choose this place again as a go to ice cream shop. read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - S'mores ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

The best ice cream ever, staff is friendly, and place is very clean. My fav is their Rocky Road ice cream read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I've been going to Coyle's since it was John's in the 80s. Every time it changed hands, the ice cream remained consistently good. I'm a full-fledged ice cream addict! And I like all flavors - except strawberry bc that's gross. Every year we will get a special order cake for a birthday. Yesterday, my daughter wanted a mint chocolate chip with vanilla, fudge, and crunchy es. A classic. It was just not good. The mint chocolate chip was way too green - it looked unnatural. One bite and I was out! It tasted like medicine. I was really disappointed. The new owner needs to turn this around. Get the recipe back or if you're ordering your ice cream - change distributor. Coyle's is a staple of Bay Shore - we can't afford to lose it. read more

The winter is as good a time to eat ice cream as any. Coyle's has that old time ice cream parlor feel. The red seats at the counter, the pumps for the sauces. The ice cream is delicious. The service is great! The young woman that served us was great. I had the rum raisin and chocolate fudge peanut butter. They were both delicious. Tons of raisins and fudge in the latter. This is definite stop for anyone in the area. That area being 20 miles. It's that good. read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

that girl Giana is amazing and beautiful. literally the best ice cream plus being serviced by her?? Amazing

Very cute old fashioned, homemade ice cream. I have visited in the past but never took the time to review. Many flavors and the girl behind the counter let me try a few before ordering. Chocolate peanut butter is what I chose but not enough peanut butter for me. Maybe I'll choose differently next time. And bring cash! They charge more for a card. read more

After reading about the LI Ice cream tour, which I sadly missed, I made a list of places to check out. When I realized I was near Coyle's I had to give it a try. My first impressions: Very cute, well decorated and lots of flavors to choose from! I didn't know where to begin. I was so optimistic that the ice cream would live up to the expectations.... and it did! We all got something different and all of the flavors were awesome! I personally enjoyed the banana Oreo and the Mississippi mud. But the real winner was the hot fudge. Delicious, thick, rich homemade fudge was the perfect topping. At the end I sampled the silly silly flavor, which is a coffee cake crumble and wish I would have had it earlier. Excellent flavors! Can't wait to return and try more. read more

See all

Absolutely LOVE Coyle's Smores Ice Creams sandwiches!!! They are fun AND so delicious!!!

Ran in for a quick two scoops on a cold Sunday night in January. They young lady who was behind the counter let me try a few flavors with no problems at all. The service was perfect. I ended up getting their peanut butter fudge flavor and it did not disappoint. It is quite evident that this shop uses very high quality ingredients when they make their homemade ice cream. Very cute 1950's inspired decor. Plenty of tables to sit at and enjoy your ice cream, as well as a fun counter seating. Overall, this place is exactly what I'd expect from a homemade ice cream shop. $6.50 for two scoops, which is par for the course when it comes to high quality ice cream. Highly recommended. read more

These employees are so sweet and the ice cream here is over the top amazing. So many flavors and choices. If you are on your way back from Robert Mosses they are just a hop, skip and a jump away. Definitely worth the trip. read more

See all

Coyles have been around for a long time. They have many different locations. The variety of ice cream is great . They even let you taste test ice cream by request. Meet the owners awesome people. Prices can be a bit steep but it is worth every penny of it. Variety of flavors are great. Very clean place and the young gentlemen behind the counter was so sweet and helpful. This will be my summer place to go to. read more

See all

Ordered a soft serve twist in a Waffle cone. Ice cream was delectable. Made on premise using an old school way and you taste the difference. The environment has the old school feel with the retro style tables and bar stools. There are a lot of options on the menu including ice cream, cakes, cannolis, icee's, banana splits, etc. read more

I had one of the weirdest experiences in this ice cream shop today. I don't know how they train their management, but I watched an older woman who is definitely a manager totally demean a child who you could tell was no more than in high school for giving me a fork. I even tipped the young woman $14 to cover the fork when I paid. It made me debate on whether I would ever use the store again. I don't know if that's how they train their management to speak to the high school staff who are working there but it's definitely not how I would want someone speaking to my child. She really did nothing wrong but give me a fork which her manager made sure to say SHE THE MANAGER PAYS FOR HERSELF AND THEY ARE NOT FOR CUSTOMERS they were in the back so I guess the rude manager didn't realize how loud she was and that I could hear her, but I heard every word When the young woman came out to give me the fork I smiled at her and thanked her. She was nothing but professional you could not even tell that she had just gotten her ass chewed out. She should've been in the manager's position. She was the one more qualified in my personal opinion to run that store. I tipped her $14 because I heard every word that went on in the back your manager is very unprofessional and I personally would not ever hire anyone like her. I don't know if it's even legal how she spoke to that child. It wouldn't surprise me if she took the tip to cover her fork purchases. That's the kind of woman she struck me as never have I ever seen a woman do that to someone who is her employee and no older than 16. It was really disturbing. I'm glad the young lady made my ice cream. I don't like that kind of hate being pushed into my food. The young woman who waited on me was nothing but kind she was wearing hoop earrings with little hearts on them. I did not get her name, but she was as sweet as could be even after her boss treated her like crap. read more

Solid ice cream spot. I forgot the name of what I ordered but consisted of rocky road, maraschino cherries, crunchies, and brownies. What a decadent treat! I felt it wasn't overwhelmingly sweet for all that I had in there. Definitely a place that has something for everyone :) read more

Coyle's Ice Cream - a chocolate sundae with a cherry on top - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bay Shore, New York