I was disappointed with the service and icecream. It was my first time here and a friend recommended. I got the impression that the person helping me was not too thrilled to be there. I asked her if I could have two flavors in a Small. I did not ask if I could have it on a cone. I just asked if I could order a small scoop and have two flavors. She said yes. She did not say it had to be in a cup if I wanted two flavors in a small scoop. When I ordered I told her which two flavors I wanted and then said I wanted a sugar cone. She proceeded to scoop a nice sized scoop onto the cone, then went to put another same sized scoop of the second flavor but that's not what I wanted. And I was charged for two scoops on a cone. The icecream was so soft, I had to put it in a cup after all that. It was disappointing and I would not come back. read more

Best ice cream , and soft serve we ever had. Wish that you were close by in Nassau county . Worth the wait.

Calling all vegans or dairy-free folks to try out this spot!! They have some of the best vegan ice cream options on Long Island. They rotate their options, but they usually carry vegan vanilla soft serve and a second option like strawberry or pistachio. These are so creamy and delicious. They have occasionally have dole whip as well. They have vegan chocolate covered bananas. They can also make those mini sundaes or chocolate saucers dairy-free/vegan ahead of time for birthday parties. They have a variety of vegan toppings like sprinkles, nuts, chocolate/strawberry dip, etc. please support this spot if you're ever in the area. read more

Have been here well over 100 times in my life, and I've never been disappointed!! Best soft serve ever.

5+++ stars for Old Fashioned Ice Cream. The ice cream is so delicious and they have many flavors to pick from, some seasonal so if ya snooze ya lose! I'm partial to the chocolate flavors but I've tried vanilla based here as well and they are all very good. They also have soft serve and rotate flavors. They also have dairy free which has a coconut milk base and I think I saw sugar free. Besides the ice cream, the people who own the store are the nicest people on earth! The place itself is take out only, no seating but who cares. Go check it out! read more

Old Fashioned Ice Cream - There is a crowd tonight - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

Alright, not the quaintest location to pack the kids up & go for ice cream BUT.....it certainly is Old Fashioned & good! We stop here for their sundae cups to bring to parties & their ice cream pies for ourselves! Quality is top notch & quantity is fair. Staff is typically young but respectful & efficient. They offered cool merchandise for sale on my past visits. Conveniently located a block south of the Southern State Parkway. Parking lot is large and surrounds business. I absolutely recommend if you love ice cream and are in the neighborhood. read more

Old Fashioned Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

We got an ice cream cake for a party. The pre-made ones are chocolate on bottom and vanilla on top with cookie crumbles in between. If you want different flavors you need to order in advance. They also have hard ice cream to scoop. And soft serve, about 4 flavors everyday. When we were there only one machine was ready. They're know for their Pineapple whip soft serve. Will go back for that. read more

See all

Best ice cream ever would highly recommend you should definitely check it out. Even if you don't live close, the drive is worth it.

While seeing some cool Halloween decorated homes in the area, I was like let's stop for ice cream! Service was quick though a long line, and ice cream was delicious. read more

I love their ice cream & we come here often at least twice a week and you get more for your money. The staff is friendly and personable. I like that they have flavors of the day. They're giving carvels competition & I love Carvel. Old Fashion ice cream tastes more like a custard. My husband always gets the banana split barge, you 4 choices of ice cream, Carvel you get 2. Try it, and you will not be disappointed. read more

I discovered this over the summer really nice place. The service is good. They have a lot of options 32 flavors of ice cream. Everyone that I have tried never disappoints read more

Old Fashioned Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Babylon, New York

This is one of the best ice cream parlors on Long Island, that sells soft and old fashion ice-cream and there are so many flavors to choose from. They have little sampler cups so that you can taste before you buy them. I got the hot fudge sundae with the works totally delicious and wifey got soft mango ice cream in a cone and she loved it. The staff are very helpful and friendly and I will definitely be back. read more

The ice cream is phenomenal!! I've been coming here for years and just can't get enough! And it's all made fresh in store! The service is always fast & friendly! & all of the workers there are super super nice!! My favorite flavor is their chocolate Oreo with whip and a cherry. Definitely stop by if you're in the area :) read more

Old Fashioned Ice Cream - Chocolate oreo ice cream with whip (I ate the cherry) (tastes better than it looks lol) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Babylon, New York

A childhood favorite ice cream parlor. Even as an adult I still love it and so does my family. Although it's been sold to a family member they still have the same vibe. read more

Great old fashioned ice cream with a variety of flavors. I asked the staff for their best sellers and sampled the two flavors, rum raisin and grape berry or something like that. Both were phenomenal, so creamy and old fashioned. Service was great too. read more

This is the best ice cream I've ever had. I am salivating while writing this review. I think I'm going to get some of their ice cream tonight! I haven't ever had ice cream this good. read more

Soursop AKA Guanabana Ice Cream. Where else are you going to get that? Also mango ice cream, delicious!!! Friendly staff. Glad I found this place. read more

Old Fashioned Ice Cream - Soft serve guanabana "soursop" and mango I've creams. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Literally the best ice cream in New York! Pistachio soft serve is the bomb, the rainbow sherbet is out of this world. All of the hard ice cream flavors are incredible, the staff are awesome, I highly recommend them! read more

This ice cream is way better than the others posted as local options. And their pricing is reasonable

I grew up right up the road from this ice cream shop, and Old Fashioned has only gotten better with age. Recently they had a whole redesign that looks awesome, and their ice cream somehow gets better every time I go. They carry so many different flavors, and always have fun seasonal flavors, which is usually where I live. I never want to eat the same thing twice. Plus my family has bought my birthday cakes there for years. read more

Wide variety of icecream to choose from. Clean place and super friendly staff. They make these awesome icecream pies that are a-mazing! No place to sit and chill but plenty of parking in the back lot. Right off main road on Straight Path. read more

Absolutely love this neighborhood ice cream joint. Been coming for years and never disappointed. The soft serve flavors are always abundant and I love that strawberry is almost always offered. The hard ice cream flavors are plentiful with creative concoctions keeping the menu updated. The to-go sundaes, saucers and ice cream pies make it easy to bring a last minute sweet to any party. read more

So many flavor to choose from both hard and soft serve. And Italian ice They even offer samples if you'd like. I'm a pistachio person, just wish there were more nuts in the ice cream. They have some wild flavors. A must go to read more

I got a custom flavor birthday cake recently, and it was so good my daughter wanted one for her birthday too. In order to give them the 48 hrs. advance notice they need, I called Thursday at 5:00 for a cake I needed Saturday. The person on the phone said, "If you want it Saturday, you can't pick it up until after 5:00. I said, "Could I please just get it 2 hours earlier, at 3:00? "No. You would have had to call at 3." No explanation, like, "that's a busy day," or whatever. Just,"Our policy is 48 hours, you called 2 hours too late. 2 hours? Would it really have made that much of a difference to their routine if I had called at 3? I always try to patronize small businesses in my community, and this just makes me wonder why I bother. I guess they are old-fashioned ice cream, not old-fashioned service! read more

Ice cream is delicious. The service is top notch. Their ice cream pies are the best. If you call in advance to can have one custom made. It's not cheap but than again what is these days. I highly recommend this business read more

I visited Old Fashioned Ice Cream in August, during one of those heatwave Sunday's that you needed to be by the beach or pool, except we happened to be in the next town over visiting relatives we missed, and we needed a "pick-me-up" afterward - Old Fashioned Ice Cream was PERFECT for that! The flavors are so awesome and that coffee-cookie one was by far what I "zero'd in" on...I would absolutely return, hands-down! PS- my Mom says she would return too read more

Great ice cream, good amount of flavors and options, soft and hard ice cream. Staff are frequently . I read that the ice cream is made there! Only reason I gave. 4 stars instead of 5 is that there is nowhere to sit outside. There is plenty of space to put a Bench or two or some chairs, even during this covid period . They have two parking areas . I would return for the ice cream however. read more

Sweet group of gals working and the two flavors I tried were both divine. The hand scooped coffee was delicious, I had it in a cup with chocolate sprinkles. The soft serve strawberry was also creamy amazing. Cheapest ice cream around, hand made and the place looks clean and well kept. Perfect experience. Update: Maple walnut is incredible. The butter pecan is very good as well. Another homerun here. read more

See all

The kids love it. The ice cream is fresh and delicious. I can't say no and it's definitely a weekly visit. Worth it if you're in the area, passing by, lost, bored... treat yourself. OH and their mini pies (in the freezer, pack of 4- Reese's/oreo flavor) you better buy em. Thank me later. read more

Best ice cream in town! Highly recommended they always have new flavors amazing ingredients and vegan options

Great service, open a lot, and great flavors. They definitely give you what you pay for, and it's not even that expensive! The small is a little big (the size I have in the picture) but other than that, they are perfect and I would recommend for anyone in the west babylon area. read more

Delicious homemade ice cream and cakes. They also have ices and assorted varieties of soft serve ice cream,frozen yogurt and low fat ice cream. Tons of toppings, lots of sizes and choices of sundaes and even pints and quarts. Prices are average for Long Island these days, but the quality is much better quality than other choices around! read more

I've been wanting to try this place for quite some time and I finally did! It's local and I was looking forward to it, especially after reading all of the reviews. What a disappointment! I bought a pint with 4 different flavours. I didn't like any of them, they didn't even get simple chocolate right. All four flavours tasted like ice milk and not at all like ice cream. Tasteless, at best. I honestly don't understand the high ratings and newspaper recommendations for this place. I really wanted this to become my new go to place for ice cream. It isn't cheap either but I have no problem paying for a quality product. I actually threw 2/3 of the pint in the garbage, that's how bad I found it. I will now return to Cafe Italia on Deer Park Ave. Their gelato is the real deal. It's exactly like the super high quality gelato you get in Italy. It's not cheap, but it's worth every penny. I love that little place! I've learned my lesson - when you find something that you really like, stick with it. It's not really that far and it means that I don't have to go to Little Italy or Europe to get authentic gelato. (Not that I wouldn't like to go back to Italy, I would actually love to go back - the sooner the better too! I'm so ready to head back to NYC too!) read more

I ALWAYS make a point to stop here no matter what time of the year it is when I come to Long Island to visit family. My usual is either a soft vanilla cone with rainbow sprinkles, but I like to mix it up sometimes and get strawberry. Their ice cream is BY FAR the best. The ice cream is made fresh and the strawberry that I had was the creamiest and most flavorful then any other ice cream stores and the toppings of fruit are fresh fruits. With the family friendly staff and the amazing flavors, some invented by the owner this is a definite must go to for the BEST ice cream on Long Island. read more

I love this ice cream place! It has all the classics, soft serve too! They have it all! Will definitely be coming back!

I usually feel very "stanky" against this establishment because they can be cheap and overpriced (this is the closest to me to hit that icecream spot.....), but today they screwed up on my banana split and made it right no problems. I am 100% for customer service and righting your wrongs. The ladies that handled it were great I was on "stanky" when I called because of the money I spent. I will be back because I know if I have an issue my patronage will be respected. This occured around 9:30pm today, thank you ladies for being so pleasant in the face of an upset customer! read more

Now when it comes to ice cream, I typically order whatever coffee flavor they have, but on this particular day I was feeling adventurous so I went with chocolate chip and strawberry. Alex D. got coffee and Nutella. I was instantly jealous when I had a bite of his. Don't get me wrong, my choice selections were delicious, but the coffee flavor was so rich and distinct that I wanted to switch right away. Definitely recommend the coffee flavor!! Their ice cream is soft and very creamy, which I'm not normally a fan of, but I am willing to push that aside to order my own coffee ice cream next time. read more

I went for a chocolate thick shake and it was a pile of water down crap no taste what so ever of chocolate. Spent $10 bucks on shit. In business 50 years and you don't know how to make a shake. Going to krishers ice cream parlor in massapequa they know what there doing read more

Old fashioned Ice Cream is the best Ice Cream that i have ever had! I have been going to them for 50 years and they haven't changed!

Best ice cream around! Smooth and flavorful! They have a large selection of flavors plus great soft serve that the rotate flavors between. I love the soft serve frozen hot chocolate and the banana. They give large portions and are not over priced like other places. Their ice cream pies are excellent too! read more