Dulce de Leche Cake Shop

91

191

1138

3 years ago

I have never been inside of this bakery, however it is right around the corner from my grandma's house. She walked there the other day to get me a birthday cake. Oh my goodness it was delicious!!! It was a vanilla ice cream cake which was better than any ice cream cake ive had before!!! The ice cream was was fresh and creamy and delicious. The frosting was amazing and it was decorated beautifully. My grandma said the people in the bakery were super friendly and she has gotten other treats there before. I look forward to going there sometime with her to check out other treats. read more

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - Amazing birthday ice cream cake! - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Theresa S.

47

232

1742

5 years ago

This is an exceptionally fantastic bakery , located in the town of Brightwaters . I've been to this bakery several times and have enjoyed many of their delicious treats . Their cheese cake is so delicious and creamy , they also make scrumptiously , flaky scones and they even make empanadas! Everything is made to perfection with great care and friendly service . Today for Mother's Day my daughter brought over a variety of Mini cakes ... each one more fresh, light and delicious than the next ! The chocolate raspberry was divine ! There was also red velvet , carrot cake , cannoli, chocolate caramel and cheese cake ! A great way to please everyone's craving ! read more

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - Chocolate Raspberry - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - a close up of a dessert - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - Carrot cake - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

See all

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Social Fetish ..

0

48

33

2 years ago

FANTASTIC!!! From the service, to the design, to the taste ... this was one of the best cakes I've ever seen and tasted. & my guests agreed! Everyone was asking for extras! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nydia F.

2

7

2

2 years ago

Beautiful and delicious cake for my daughter's baby sprinkle! They made the cake exactly as the picture I provided. My daughter and everyone loved it! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cary R.

503

368

1586

6 years ago

Due to all the closures it setback our wedding plans, I was a little disappointed but we went ahead got married and decided to celebrate next year. It was a lovely surprise when my sister in law surprised me with a cake and appearance wise I just loved the cake so much!!!! Following that I thought ok now is it going to be good? I tried the macaroons and yum!!!! Absolutely delicious!!!! At this point my expectations were high. Once I cut into the cake it was my favorite red velvet! I'm very picky when it comes to my fav!! Holy moly! It was delicious!! Moist,fresh,tasty rich in taste!! My husband couldn't get over how good it was! 8 days later still fresh and delicious!!! I of course asked my sister in law where did she get it. I look forward to coming to this bakery and ordering all my future cakes!!!! read more

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - Our mini wedding cake! Delicious! Red velvet - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - Inside the red velvet! Yum - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

See all

Helpful 22

Thanks 0

Love this 17

Oh no 0

Bridget P.

134

279

289

4 years ago

Fantastic experience from start to finish. After researching custom cake bakers in the area, I stumbled upon this bakery and loved everything I saw online. I ordered a custom 10" round cake for my daughter's 2nd birthday with the theme of "Under the Sea." I was able to text over my inspiration photo while on the phone so we could discuss more specifics. Once the cake flavor and decorations were finalized, I received an invoice directly to my phone. I chose to have the cake delivered so we didn't have to rush around the morning of the party. On the day of the party, the cake arrived on time, looked spectacular and tasted fantastic. So many people asked where the cake was from so they could use the bakery for their next parties. Can't wait to use them again. read more

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - Under the Sea themed custom cake - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Daniella L.

0

60

27

2 years ago

Very expensive but worth it, especially the chocolate chip large cookies (very soft and gooey)! I no longer go here because I have cut out all sugars for a healthier lifestyle! However, I do recommend this small business for treating your sweet tooth! Oh and the staff always has a smile to greet you when walking into their shop. Yes smiling is a plus for me it speaks volume..... read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

rose g.

9

69

13

3 years ago

A lot has changed - not good anymore unfortunately - if you don't mind shopping around stale .....

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carolyn W.

3

2

0

1 year ago

Ordered a birthday cake for my daughter's birthday with fresh fruit inside and on top and a blue color icing. The fruit on the top was not fresh at all and had gone bad. It was fruit that should have been thrown out, not on put on the top of a cake, and the writing on top was so close in color to the icing that you couldn't see it. My daughter was so upset she started crying. They offered to fix it but I shouldn't have to bring the cake back to have them fix issues that shouldn't have happened to begin with. It was the morning of my daughter's birthday, and it was a big inconvenience, to bring it all the way back and wait for them to fix it. Additionally, the custard filling was so thin you couldn't even taste it. This was the first time I tried this bakery, and I was very disappointed. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Maria C C.

14

49

1

3 years ago

Very delicious. I purchased a Tres Leches cake for my daughter's birthday. It was delicious and they decorated it with real flowers nice touch. Presentation is always important especially when it's so PrettyAlso purchased 2 mini pastries, one was peanut butter cake and the other was a chocolate mousse cake, both also delicious. Bakery is very neat and clean. read more

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - Birthday cake Tres Leches - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Julie R.

0

41

29

2 years ago

The most delicious and beautiful cake I've ever seen!!!!! The owner was so accommodating and her staff was wonderful! Thank you so much!!! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ellisha H.

1042

244

1521

8 years ago

Only four stars cause I'm bringing my "SPECIAL" order there..that will be my make it or break it review.The bakery is very close to places I go regularly and I was just at Gemaginations across the street so..hey I'm parked let's grab some treats.Upon entering there has never been a time I was n ok...i t fully greeted with a welcoming smile.It was hard to decide but the young lady behind the counter loves lemon meringue too so I got one small lemon meringue tart,a cannoli cream tart(mmm) and a dolce de leche tart.Ya,ya I'm am going to share with my Sweetheat why sugar coma alone.I also asked about having a cake made and she was so sweet and kind..plus other reviews on Yelp,I will be there next week.Stop in you wont regret it.. PS,super clean..I know bakeries get flies but this had none and did not smell of vinegar.I like that personally. read more

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - Nicest staff,park on the side - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

Helpful 12

Thanks 0

Love this 14

Oh no 0

Christine V.

0

5

7

2 years ago

I ordered a cake/cupcakes/cake pops for my daughter's bridal shower and oh my! This is the place to get it from!! We had gone over pictures of how the cake would look and it came out even better than I hoped! They packaged it so carefully for the transport to the venue and came to my car to help. Now for the taste- WOW!!! Most people don't even eat the cake at events but guests were RAVING at how delicious and fresh it was. Thank you for making this event extra special!! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Noe F.

Elite 22

7

89

78

5 years ago

Their cakes are absolutely gorgeous! Very happy with my cake. They did a beautiful job decorating! The outside is so perfectly smooth it looks like fondant but it's buttercream. Just excellent work. 8 layers of pure deliciousness read more

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - Anniversary cake - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - Chocolate cake with raspberry mousse - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Terri M.

326

102

254

2 years ago

Incredible cakes, pastries, bread and cookies! Staff is kind and everything is delicious! What more do you need???

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Fredrika C.

140

208

664

4 years ago

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop is extremely professional, reliable, and downright delicious! I first visited them last year to order a custom cake for a surprise birthday brunch. I had no idea what design, flavor, or shape I wanted for the cake, but I just knew it had to be memorable and enjoyable. The ladies here were incredibly patient, helpful, and knowledgeable. They conceptualized a beautiful cake and everyone just had to know where it was from. I was enthusiastic in sharing about this place and made sure to visit again this year for a batch of cupcakes and rainbow cookies to celebrate my boyfriend's birthday once again. This will certainly be my go to bakery for all occasions! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Judy C.

0

6

3

4 years ago

I took a chance with this location. Found it online, needed a cake for my son's 3rd birthday. Timing was very thin. Staff was very nice over the phone and helped me with suggestions for my cake. Everyone at the party loved the cake. My son especially read more

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - a display case full of cakes - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stacy B.

2

22

19

7 years ago

Came here for the first time to have a cake made for my husbands birthday. I showed them some pictures of what I wanted and picked the cake up a week later. I was blown away! Not only did they do an amazing job, the Cake was delicious!! I will definitely use them again when I need another special occasion cake made I didn't try any of there bakery goods but they looked really yummy! I can't wait to stop in and try a few :)) read more

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - Birthday cake - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Daii G.

0

2

8 years ago

This is my favorite cake shop in town!!!! My son's baptism cake was delicious and beautiful, better than I expected.... I told them what I wanted, and they made it!!!! read more

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dawn M.

0

45

31

9 years ago

A little bakery off the beaten path but so worth the trip . My husband got a valentine cake and some little treats there. The cake was very fresh not too rich . It was called death by chocolate chocolate is my favorite food and I lived to tell the tale . Totally delicious. The treats in The shop were inviting as well . Mini black and whites mini chocolate chip plus traditional Italian cookies Macaroons crumb cake. All the treats you would expect in A bakery . Looking forward to going back The prices are reasonable as well :) read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Karen Porcella ..

0

21

0

3 years ago

Delicious ice cream cake. Friendly and quick service. Will definitely be back. Even helped me put the cake in the trunk of the car. Very kind and caring staff. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christina S.

Elite 26 All-Star

135

390

1496

9 years ago

I have been frequenting this local bakery for several months now. Everything I have gotten has been delicious and very fresh. They offer traditional bakery items as well as unique treats that are delicately prepared and each one a work of art. To celebrate several milestone birthdays in my family and presented to them on Thanksgiving when they'd all be together, I custom ordered a cake. I took the bakers recommendations on flavor combinations and together we came up with chocolate cake, a chocolate mousse and ganache filing topped with chocolate ganache frosting. Together we decided on fall-themed decorations and placement. It was amazing! The cake was moist and fresh, the filling was to die for, and the overall presentation was simple yet elegant. I will continue to stop in to pick up a treat for myself and will definitely use them when I am in need of another custom cake. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Cj J.

67

15

12

7 years ago

This was my first time ordering a cake from this bakery and it was an overall amazing experience. I was throwing a gender reveal party for my sister and the young girl at the counter was so helpful. With her help, we decided to do a half choc/van cake with cannoli filling... amazing! The cake was beyond beautiful and I even called twice to change up what I wanted on top of the cake. The price was also reasonable for what I was asking of them. Everyone at the party absolutely loved it!! read more

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Stefanie S.

50

4

0

5 years ago

If you want old refrigerator tasting pastries this is the place to go! FYI as per the cashier pastries are made every 3 days.. I had a bad experience with the pastries called up and explained how the pastries were not fresh and was told by the cashier that the pastries are made every 3 days but usually Saturdays are made in the morning. They must not have had sales the 3 days prior so kept selling the old pastries instead of making new ones. I was told I would receive a call to see what can be done about that. 4 days later I get a call saying nothing can be done that the owner made sure the pastries were done the night before. Moral of the story don't buy from here if you want to take to work or parties because you will be embarrassed. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Mauricio A.

6

113

95

7 years ago

Personal, sweet little family joint. Beautiful little specialties of all sorts. The bread is great too. Famous for their Tres Leches cake. Love to see a small family business doing well. It's the personal attention and details that can only be delivered in a place like this. It's like going into a different part of the country, in a small cozy town (Brightwaters). I go when ever I pass the area and grab something different for people I love, everything is very good. Family is awesome and humble. You'll be pleasantly surprised by this little Gem. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carmen L.

0

7

0

3 years ago

We live very close to the bakery and after purchasing a cake from them for a barbecue, we definitely will be returning more often. The cake was chocolate with strawberry filling and it was Amazing!! The cake was so moist and the frosting was light and creamy. Yum Yum!!! Highly recommend. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Priscilla N.

0

1

0

3 years ago

I ordered a cake for my daughters graduation. The cake was beautiful and delicious. Everybody at the party asked me where was the cake from? My guests loved the cake. I highly recommend Dulce de leche Bakery read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Beatriz L.

11

18

16

8 years ago

Today finaly was able to come early in the morning and try out these delicious delicacies!!!!t They were the original facruras that I remembered from Argentina! Th empanadas were to die for! Th correct daugh and I had corn cheese and caramelized onions!!!! WOW!!! I will be coming a lot here! For Argentinians and from Uruguay! Cuernitos de gras Medialunas de grasa Libritos de grasa Empanadas: Carne Pollo Choclo con queso y bacon Choclo con queso y cebolla Tortas y masas Tortas heladas de cumpleaños Sandwiches de miga los fines de semana Reservaciones They also serve coffee! And tables to sit down!!! Dint miss this place! Highly recommended!!! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jaime O.

4

67

32

8 years ago

Everything I have gotten from here has been so delicious. I decided to get my daughters bday cake from here and try their ice cream cakes I gave them a pic of what I wanted and they nailed it, not only in appearance but taste as well. I have Dulce de Leche and chocolate ice cream w chocolate cake, it was some of the best ice cream I've ever had! They are so friendly and accommodating every time we go in. We highly recommend this bakery! read more

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kevin S.

14

72

15

8 years ago

Amazing amazing amazing!!!! Everything we asked for was exactly how our cake came out! One of my favorite things was the cannoli filling. Most cakes will only have one thin layer of cannoli on the inside. They had SEVEN!!! Loved every bite! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Paul P.

18

12

0

6 years ago

We had loved this place. We got our son's first and second birthday cake there. We've gotten cookies there. Everything was amazing. Then something happened. On Father's Day we got a cake and the frosting tasted like old refrigerator. Then on Independence Day we brought cookies to a friends house, and again it tasted like old refrigerator. A week ago I wanted sandwiches de miga, and thought I would mention my experience. I wanted them to know, so maybe they would fix the problem. They were unaware of any complaints. Yesterday I bought a pound of cookies to bring to a friends house. They tasted like refrigerator again. My friend and wife, tasted the same thing. I just can't go back there anymore. It's a real shame. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Paul A.

4

61

19

5 years ago

Awesome bakery! Everything is delicious from the ice cream cakes, pinata cakes to empanadas! They are also very friendly!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Pa M.

0

46

3

4 years ago

I bought 1 pastry because the woman acted like I was interrupting her from whatever she was doing.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Callan L.

66

9

0

5 years ago

We order our daughter's communion cake and they did not disappoint! The cake was beautiful and tasted delicious. Support small local businesses and check them out! We will definitely be back for the empanadas and other treats read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Liz E.

64

25

22

8 years ago

My friend had previously gotten a cake for her daughters birthday which was really nice. I ended up needed a cake last minute for my son's christening. They were very accommodating and the cake was delicious. I will definitely be returning. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kery S.

1

15

1

9 years ago

I ordered a cake for my daughter's communion last week. It was $130 - and I made the mistake of paying for the bill in advance. Dulce de leche was supposed to deliver the cake to the Jon Thomas Inne (aprox 5 blocks away) at 1:30. When I arrived at the restaurant at 2:30 the cake was not delivered. Neither I, nor the restaurant could get in touch with the bakery. The waiter then offered to drive there and see what was going on with the cake- if possibly he could pick it up- When the cake arrived at the restaurant it was falling - it looked melted and was warm to the touch. When I received the $130 cake it was inedible. As the host I continued with the party and contacted the bakery the next day. The owner was extremely unprofessional - she admitted that they forgot to deliver it, then instead of delivering themselves, released it to the waiter- and insisted that he was at fault for the cake falling. It is her product! She was paid for it! It was her responsibility to deliver it - I received an inedible cake, and she kept insisting it was perfect. The best part is she offered to do NOTHING for us, claiming her cake was perfect. So if anyone is looking to waste their money, buy a cake from Dulce de leche cake shop! read more

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - $130 'perfect' cake - melting. - Desserts Near Me - Brightwaters, New York

Helpful 8

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 1

Page 1 of 2

See more reviews

More info about Dulce de Leche Cake Shop

346 N Windsor Ave
Brightwaters, NY 11718
Directions
(631) 647-9007
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.dulcedelechecakeshopny.com

Hours

What time does Dulce de Leche Cake Shop open?

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop opens at 7:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Dulce de Leche Cake Shop close?

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop closes at 4:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Dulce de Leche Cake Shop closes at 2:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon-Sat 7:00 AM - 4:00 PMSun 7:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Dulce de Leche Cake Shop take credit cards?

Yes, Dulce de Leche Cake Shop takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Dulce de Leche Cake Shop have catering options?

No, Dulce de Leche Cake Shop does not have catering options.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Dulce de Leche Cake Shop have bike parking?

No, Dulce de Leche Cake Shop does not have bike parking.

Does Dulce de Leche Cake Shop have parking?

Yes, Dulce de Leche Cake Shop has parking options. Street Parking

Other Amenities

Is Dulce de Leche Cake Shop wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Dulce de Leche Cake Shop is wheelchair accessible.

From the Business

Specialties

We specializes in fondant cakes for all ocassions pastries,cookies and desserts. We also have Argentinian empanadas

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop Reviews in Other Languages

Spanish
1 Review

You might also consider

Aestheticakes

5.0(7 reviews)

2.9 mi

•$$$$

Daniel is a genius, First off all he caters to the gf that…read moreneeds everything right. The choices of fillings and cake types are many and they all sounded so good. Daniel's communication is perfect and he made sure that everything went smooth for the poor fumbling boyfriend. The cake came out beautiful. The details on the cake were perfect and he even color coded it to the specific occasion. The cake was the best tasting cake I have ever tried in my life....ever. We opted for cannoli crime inside and marble cake. The fondant was thing and actually tasted decent. Stand up job to this talented gentleman. I will use Aestheticakes for a long time

My husband and I heard about Aestheticakes from our wedding venue, The Vineyards. We met with Dan,…read morethe owner, about six months before our wedding day. Dan was an absolute pleasure to work with - he is very talented, professional, and such a nice person. At our first meeting, he provided us with samples of cakes and various fillings. It was all so delicious, we knew immediately that he was the baker we wanted for our wedding cake! His attention to detail on his designs is impeccable. We also had a rather large Lenox cake topper, and Dan made sure that the top of the cake could accommodate it with no problems. We chose yellow cake with cookies and cream filling. Our cake was amazing and looked absolutely stunning! We received nothing but compliments on it the day of the wedding, with many guests asking who our baker was. Dan was also able to bake a small vegan cake to accommodate those few guests who had dietary restrictions. They all raved about it, and I even heard that at the end of the night they fought over who would take home the extra slices! Thank you so much to Dan for a wonderful wedding cake that exceeded our expectations. We highly recommend Aestheticakes for any cake needs and hope to work together again in the future! S&S 07.15.16

The stunning wedding cake that Dan made for us!

Sweet 16 cake

See all

A & G Bakery

4.0(90 reviews)

3.4 mi

The cookies by the pound! That's all i got to say. The best you will ever have I've been here…read moremultiple times and the food and service is always the same.

This place is now called The Ultimate Bakery and located in one of those strip malls. Hubby was…read morecraving some sweets from here the other night so we stopped by and he specifically wanted to come to THIS place. He said he's been coming to this bakery for quite some time and his brother always buys a bunch of things when he visits. There was plenty of free parking on a Saturday night and the store itself was brightly lit. Very spacious inside and very clean. I was surprised at the variety and amount of items for sale! Everything was stocked pretty full, especially the cookies and individual pastries. I believe everything goes by weight when you're purchasing the cookies and pastries but if you have any questions, the staff were super sweet, patient and helpful! Hubby purchased an assortment of items like eclairs, cookies, rainbow cookies, cannolis and some sort of Napoleon looking pastry. Although some were a bit on the sweeter side (I have a sweet tooth too), everything was very delicious! I was very surprised that the butter cookies were really good because those are usually my least favorite anywhere I go. The rainbow cookies were also very good! There were no tables and chairs for customers so if you were planning on sitting down to enjoy something, sorry! I did see a small round table with two stools next to it but the table contained their cake binder so I'm assuming it's used for cake related orders.

Very clean, brightly lit and spacious interior.

Cake ordering binder area.

See all

Sweet Sensations

4.1(52 reviews)

3.4 mi

•$

Like fancy lee and really babylon village as a whole I hadn't been to sweet sensations in YEARS! My…read morefriends and I went in to an empty store which was great so we could really look around and figure out what we wanted, when I saw the dubai sundae on the specials menu I immediately went for it and it did not disappoint! the pistachio sauce was smooth and nutty the katafi pieces light and crispy and the chocolate shell pieces were the cherry on top! the chocolate ice cream was well balanced in and of itself not too much/ overpowering like some chocolate ice creams can be , you can also get whipped cream and a cherry on top but I didn't feel that this needed that and wanted to try it as is for what it is, very enjoyable!

Lots of good options in this ice cream shop . A lot of hard ice cream including vegan options and…read moregluten free cones ! Also soft serve, vanilla, chocolate and swirl. However they have 50 flavored syrups that they can add to the soft serve to give you different flavors . Got the cherry hard bonnet. Gotta say it was not that hard and def didn't taste like cherry. Didn't take bad, just didn't have a flavor. Asked for a little water and they said it would cost 50 cents! Thought that was not great. 3 benches outside and parking lot in front of the store. Staff were friendly.

Dubai chocolate sundae

Colorful soft ice cream image

See all

Many flavors of soft ice cream served

Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bakery

4.2(141 reviews)

2.9 mi

I've seen a lot about this place and wanted to give them a try. They are not your conventional…read morebakery but have many different and interesting items sure to please almost anyone. There is street parking and multiple municipal lots within walking distance. The shop is long with many cases and displays of baked goods. Everything is labeled clearly and the packaging they use to wrap your purchases is very visually pleasing. Better looking wrapping if you are looking to bring something to someone's house. They have gluten free options and quite a few items you don't typically see other places. The employees working were friendly and knowledgeable. They were also extremely patient with the more indecisive customers. Overall I would recommend this bake shop for a fun change to your typical bakery.

We always visit this bakery when in town and bring back goodies. This trip we purchased a rainbow…read morecake (delicious) and got decorated cookies, plus some pink/whites. The decorated cookies were terrible, like biting into a brick. For paying close to $5 dollars per cookie, the freshness should be on par and it clearly was not. They were decorated beautifully, but quality/taste was not good. We bought six decorated cookies, so to spend that much and be a brick texture is no good.

Rainbow Cookie Cupcake

Rainbow Cookie Gift Box! Shipping Nationwide!

See all

Manhattan Sweets Seltzer Butter Cookies

Torta Fina Bakeshoppe

4.0(105 reviews)

3.4 mi

They always have the best goods even for the gluten free peeps out there. And you can't beat a nice…read morecup of coffee too which they'll always make! Everyone inside is super nice and friendly and you always get served quickly. You walk in and get that old school bakery vibe and there's o many choices to stare at while you order.

This is a very cute shop with lots of different dessert options. Inside reminds me of a grandmas…read moresitting area. I ordered a bicenza, (hot chocolate with espresso and a biscotti) which although it was good, was very expensive and there are no prices posted any where. Service was slow and we were ignored for quite a while before being helped. I think I'd go back to pick up sweet treats but unlikely to get another beverage there.

See all

Custom cake

Mario's Pasticceria

4.7(69 reviews)

3.2 mi

This is a hidden gem in Babylon Village. You've probably driven past it and didn't realize it was…read morethere, just look for The Pizzeria restaurant on Montauk Hwy and it's right next door. This is a family owned business created with love. Everything the son makes is delicious and fresh. Lots of bread, cookies, cakes, pies, tarts and other goodies. Plenty of Italian pastries and American baked goods. They even have soup! While they don't have a large social media presence like other bakeries I find the products here better and fresher. They even accommodate special requests.

Just don't bother... day old, dry cake...tried it on a couple of recommendations...never mind..,read more

Lobster tail with FRENCH CREAM!!

Fresh donut

See all

March 2026

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis

4.1(109 reviews)

3.1 mi

This was my first time trying The Dirty Cheesecake but my order was Uber Eats delivered as my…read morefamily and I are recovering from COVID! We are extremely lucky we did not lose any loss of taste because we would be missing out big time of these outrageously delicious treats we enjoyed immensely tonight!! The orders tonight were the S'mores Lava Cookie, Midnight Cookie and Cream Milkshake and the Strawberry Cheesecake Cup. The milkshake was devoured by my daughters BF. He said it was a perfect consistency, the Cookie and Cream were tasted in every sip but he said there was just a little too much chocolate syrup! He will absolutely order it again but with a little less syrup next time! The cookie was ordered by my daughter but she said it was gooey and a little too rich for her taste but still enjoyed some with a big glass of mik! My 5 stars goes to the Cheesecake that I ordered! It was literally perfection in every bite! The cheesecake was so creamy, decadent and layered with deliciousness! There was enough fresh strawberries in that little cup that it was present throughout! The graham cracker crumbs made up the last layer that completed this cheesecake masterpiece! The serving is big enough for 2 people so lucky me I have dessert for tomorrow night too! I am thrilled I found you Dirty Cheesecake! Next time I visit you in person as there are so many different types of desserts and variations of each kind, I need to see everything vs reading them off of a menu! I just know I will most probably have the same reaction as when a child walks into a candy store....intense excitement, awe, sensory overload, jumping up and down, shouting wow or look at this but the adult version of it all!!

Decided to try The Dirty Cheesecake last night as I was looking for a sweet after dinner treat…read more This is such a cute dessert place that i thought only served cheesecake but had so many more options! The brookie bar dessert that i got was absolutely delicious and satisfied my craving beyond what I could have imagined! The counter person Lyn was nothing short of amazing as well with her kindness to help me especially since it was my first time. I love that it is open till midnight daily! Definitely recommend and I will definitely be back.

My usuals. snickers bar cheesecake and Lilis cheesecake

See all

Madame Butterfly Cakes

3.7(9 reviews)

3.7 mi

Food. Service. Friendly. Goes above and beyond rhetoric perimeters of job. Tree hugger.read more

I'm surprised there have been a couple of negative reviews on here but I had nothing but…read moreoutstanding service and product from this business. It's currently VERY hard to find vegan dessert options on Long Island (or anywhere, really). Last week, my girlfriend's Mom and I made a tag team effort to find the best vegan birthday cake we could find, and Terry at Madame Butterfly Cakes came through perfectly. We ordered a Vegan Red Velvet Birthday Cake and a half-dozen "shuga pies" - I picked them up yesterday and Terry's service and product were both EXCELLENT. We surprised her with them today and both the cake and the shuga pies were otherworldly good. I have had a LOT of vegan desserts over the past few years, and I have to honestly say, this were the best vegan desserts I have ever had. I would give them more stars if I could. Thank you Madame Butterfly Cakes!!!

See all

Vegan Shuga Pies

Familia Bakery

4.5(13 reviews)

5.0 mi

Delicious tres leches and nice size portions. We try different flavors each time. Today it was…read morecoconut for me and passion fruit for my husband m. Both excellent. There are so many good things in here and fresh coffee always.

I've passed this bakery countless times and finally decided to stop in. Upon entry, I couldn't help…read morebut notice how clean and organized everything was, along with the appealing aroma of fresh baked goods. I initially stopped in to purchase bread, and after hearing about a variety of options from the very friendly and knowledgeable woman at the counter, I bought a loaf of pan de queso, which I usually refer to as Colombian bread. I also couldn't help but notice the different flavors of tres leches cakes available. SO, I got a hefty slice of caramel tres leches and IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT! I definitely want to go back to try a slice of their strawberry tres leches ASAP. Overall, I had a great experience and will certainly be back soon.

See all

Mademoiselle Patisserie

4.3(63 reviews)

13.6 mi

I stopped in to buy a dessert for Easter and they had exquisite cupcakes which I purchased. I also…read moregot two supposedly custard and cherry rolls for coffee when I got home. The rolls had about one cherry piece inside and were quite dry like day old or more pastry. These rolls were $8 each and for that price, I expected something filled with cherries and fresh but instead, they tasted like a prepackaged roll from the grocery store. I am including a picture of the cherry custard roll which is sliced open to show the lack of fruit..... I hope the cupcakes for tomorrow will be much better!

Let me start with their service...the ladies that work here, as well as the owner, are over the…read moretop, as far as customer service! The patisserie is bright, clean, and delightfully decorated. Now, where do I begin regarding the food? The baguettes are sooo good, freshly baked, perfectly crunchy on the outside and light and airy on the inside. The pastries are incredible, and there is always a wide variety of choices! The only downside, if you can call it that, is that you need to get there early because they sell out quickly! I'm a longtime happily satisfied customer!

Things to do in Brightwaters

Cupcakes

Cupcakes and macaroons

See all

Disappointing $8.00 dry cherry custard roll...minimal cherries

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Agustina B.

191

2

2 years ago

I ordered a cake for an engagement, and it was absolutely perfect! The design was stunning, exactly as I had envisioned, and the flavors were incredible--moist and so flavorful. It truly made the celebration even more memorable. I received so many compliments from guests who loved it!! Highly recommend for any occasion! read more

Jenny C.

17

1

0

9 years ago

I love this place everything is so delicious and fresh very professional staff I love the decorator

Dulce de Leche Cake Shop - desserts - Updated August 2026

Best of Brightwaters

People found Dulce de Leche Cake Shop by searching for…

People who viewed Dulce de Leche Cake Shop also viewed

The Rolling Pin

3.8

(114 reviews)

Still over 10 years later I can't look at my wedding photos or hear a wedding story and not…read moreimmediately think how awful the Rolling Pin Bakery. The owner was rude and dismissive when I asked for refund of the profit she made. I really really suggest you go somewhere else. The fact they treat your wedding day like just another day, no care, no love, nothing but disappointment, disrespect, and distain if they screw up and you'd like it to be corrected. Rolling Pin is awful in all aspects. DO NOT ORDER ANY CAKE FROM THEM!!!!!

I had my wedding last Sunday 4/6 and had our cake made by Rolling Pin. They sent us a tasting a few…read moremonths before and we picked vanilla sponge cake with strawberry jam. Absolutely delicious and was even better in the actual wedding cake. The one blemish on a perfect cake was that we ordered lilac or light purple icing for flowers on the cake, they turned out to be a dark blue. But great tasting cake nonetheless.

Benkert's Bakery

3.2

(131 reviews)

i would 100% recommend checking out this bakery. i placed a custom cupcake order and they totally…read morehit the mark. the decorations were superb. i gave some flexibility on what i wanted along with a few inspiration pictures, and they did an incredible job. i ordered 10 jumbo cupcakes, funfetti flavor with vanilla icing, and honestly the taste was exceptional. everyone was raving about how fresh, moist, and delicious the cupcakes were. it was really easy to order. i called about a week in advance, and they were very accommodating. service was exceptional. when i went inside, they individually boxed the cupcakes for me. overall, i couldn't recommend this bakery more. cost-wise, it was also the best deal out of the local bakeries i had looked into.

We went in to purchase a variety of donuts for our guests this evening. We were very disappointed…read moreand embarrassed when we served them. The Cheese Claw shredded as we cut into it, and as you can see from the picture, was basically empty. The Boston Cream had the consistency of bread. All the donuts that were filled only had filling one side of the donut and were dry. They weren't tender or fresh. I'm questioning how long these donuts have been sitting on the shelf. The only thing that was fresh and delicious was the Rye with seeds. Great crust and soft, fresh bread. This used to be a great bakery but over the years the quality and consistency has really gone down.

Jonathan Lord Cheesecake

4.9

(9 reviews)

TOOOOO GOOD. This place is a must try. Try the Raspberry…read moreFudge Cheese cake!! It melts in your mouth... Highly recommended

I received a Jonathan Lord cheesecake (the classic) as a get well gift after some surgery…read more I have had cheesecake from all over , one of my favorite desserts To put it simply, it is the best - by far- slice of cheesecake that I have ever eaten. The texture and taste were equally smooth and bold , not overpowering nor underwhelming. The cheesecake was perfect, as was the crust (ok, especially the crust which was buttery Graham perfection. It was a delightful,unexpected knock on my door that brought pure joy and decadence. Cannot wait to reward my self and aid my recovery again this evening.

Stanley's Bakery

3.7

(105 reviews)

•$

Just bought a lobster tail & mini cannolis . All of it was amazingly delicious. The cream tastes…read morefresh not super sweet like from other places I've bought from. The only downside was the lobster tail was only 1/4th filled.

Best jelly Donuts in the world ! Just the right amount of jelly soft and a decent size. Even though…read moreI think they used to be bigger.

Villa Bella Bakery

4.0

(78 reviews)

This used to be a great Italian family owned bakery. My kids grew up on the cookie every…read moreholiday.... then it all stopped. The prosciutto bread is salami bread, but still $7 for a small loaf. Ok but dont says its prosciutto! In the just year or so new owners took over and it really sucks more than just the bread. Everything is smaller, less flavor .. but higher prices? Come on you replace real butter with lard, dont try to object it's obvious in your mouth! Do yourself a favor and accept villa bella is dead and the replacement isn't italian and knows no quality!

This is nothing like the quality of product the old owners gave to customers - was unaware it was…read morebought about a year ago - stale cartucci such a tiny amount of cannoli filling in stale pastry - 5 bucks each - not worth 50 cents to be honest - cookies the large one 5 dollars everything grossly overpriced and underwhelming ! A woman came in for a small tray of cookies 1 lb she told her 36 dollars - come on !! The bread was small - better going to uncle Giuseppe's for at least bread - sad that this place was bought out ! We miss them ! Plus the new owners very cold and not embracing of customers !

Alpine Pastry Shoppe

4.1

(495 reviews)

We've been to Alpine Pastry Shop several times over the years, and it has never disappointed…read more The bakery is located in a large shopping center with a huge parking lot, but finding a spot close to the store can still be challenging during busy times. The prices are definitely on the higher side, but the quality has always justified the cost in our experience. One thing that stands out is how helpful the staff is. They're always willing to answer questions and help you choose something based on your preferences, which is especially helpful given the large selection. On this visit, we tried four Rainbow Cookie Donuts and four Cannoli Rainbow Cookie Donuts. While both were delicious, the clear favorite among our group was the Cannoli Rainbow Cookie Donut. The regular Rainbow Cookie Donuts were very tasty but extremely sweet, while the cannoli version had a better balance of flavors and was more enjoyable overall. Whether we're picking up pastries for a special occasion or just stopping in for a treat, Alpine consistently delivers fresh, high-quality desserts. It's become one of our go-to bakeries on Long Island, and we look forward to coming back.

I wish we had a spot like this in south Florida. I definitely bought more than I needed but it was…read moreso worth it to bring these tasty treats back to Florida with me. I tried their viral rainbow cookie donut and rainbow pignoli nut cookie. They seriously were the best of both worlds, the rainbow cookie and donut combo is perfection. While everything was so delicious and I wanted one of everything, I couldn't for the prices. They are on the higher end but it was worth it for a one time experience. Also, the staff was not the friendliest. They seemed they didn't want to be bothered when I asked for recommendations. We were the only customers until 1 other came in after us. Otherwise everything was great.

The Cake Don

4.5

(57 reviews)

•$$$$

Pop on over to The Cake Don for some yummy cookies , order a specialty cake or buy some of his cool…read moreart pieces! Love his vibe, the store is cool and Mia was a sweetie ! Check out my video on Instagram @thegoodfoxlife !

Best cupcakes in town. I come all the way from Queens and it's well worth the commute. Anytime I…read morebring these to a party people are always blown away. Delicious and unique flavor pairings that are worth every penny.

Catalina's Bake Shop

4.8

(39 reviews)

I stopped in to Catalina's Bake Shop over the weekend to pick up a cake for my best friend's…read morebirthday. It was a cute space with many wonderful baked goods, drinks, and even empanadas. I wanted a funfetti cake and the one they had readily available had lovely sunflowers on it. The woman working was so sweet and put some writing on the cake for me. The 6" cake was about $50 dollars which seemed a bit high, but I think its pretty standard for a bakery. The cake itself was very moist and absolutely delicious and I would give it an A+. The cake I purchased for her birthday from another local bakery last year was really dry, so I was pleasantly surprised by this cake. The buttercream frosting was where I felt the cake fell a bit short. It tasted like pure unsalted butter and had almost no sweetness to it, so we ended up just eating the cake center and leaving the frosting. Unfortunate for an expensive cake but based on the other reviews I'm wondering if it was just a one time error. I don't think I would get another cake from there, but the rest of the baked goods and empanadas looked awesome so I will definitely be bake to try those!

I tried the chicken empanada and beef empanada. The beef empanada reminds me of the exact flavor of…read morethis Chinese pork bun we have in my culture. Really loved the beef empanada paired with the green sauce!

Baking My Heart Out

4.9

(15 reviews)