We've been to Alpine Pastry Shop several times over the years, and it has never disappointed. The bakery is located in a large shopping center with a huge parking lot, but finding a spot close to the store can still be challenging during busy times. The prices are definitely on the higher side, but the quality has always justified the cost in our experience. One thing that stands out is how helpful the staff is. They're always willing to answer questions and help you choose something based on your preferences, which is especially helpful given the large selection. On this visit, we tried four Rainbow Cookie Donuts and four Cannoli Rainbow Cookie Donuts. While both were delicious, the clear favorite among our group was the Cannoli Rainbow Cookie Donut. The regular Rainbow Cookie Donuts were very tasty but extremely sweet, while the cannoli version had a better balance of flavors and was more enjoyable overall. Whether we're picking up pastries for a special occasion or just stopping in for a treat, Alpine consistently delivers fresh, high-quality desserts. It's become one of our go-to bakeries on Long Island, and we look forward to coming back. read more

See all

Had to try the Rainbow Cookie Donut ! The anticipation was killing me. It is a bit pricey at $9.50 for its size but it was absolutely delightful . The inside Rainbow cookie is moist and dense. The chocolate outside was one of the best chocolate hardened glaze I have had in quite some time. **This is a weekend item** The inside is full of temptation. I also grabbed Easter bread and a Crumb Cherry Pie. You can order ahead of time and slip past the line to pick up inside on the right side. read more

See all

Alpine Pastry Shoppe has been a staple in my family for years--every holiday you can imagine and even for those random "just because" moments. A coworker recently asked me to bring back some cookies since she knew I was flying home to New York. When she said she wanted good quality cookies, I already knew exactly where I was headed: Alpine. Every time I walk into this place it somehow feels like the first time. Maybe it's the nostalgia from going there with my family for so many years, or maybe it's because it's still family-owned and truly has that warm, welcoming vibe. The people who work there are always so sweet, accommodating, and kind, which just adds to the experience. When anyone brings up rainbow cookies, Alpine is honestly the first place that comes to mind for me. They're the only ones I really go to for them. For my coworker, I picked up a pound of assorted cookies so she could try a little bit of everything. Selfishly, I was definitely thinking I should've ordered a box for myself too! She absolutely loved them, which came as no surprise. If you want truly great Italian cookies and pastries, Alpine Pastry Shoppe is the only place that comes to mind for me. I'm so happy to see that they're still open, and I truly hope they remain a neighborhood staple for many years to come. read more

See all

Sorry to leave such a poor review. On Super Bowl Sunday the line was out the door. It's a neighborhood place and on a "holiday" it's to be expected. I ordered some rainbow cookies and a Nutella cro-nut. My husband loved the rainbow cookies but my Nutella cro-nut was nothing but cream. It went in the garbage. The young lady helping me behind the counter was very friendly and very sweet and I'll tell it here just like I told her: the owners of this establishment are making a big mistake by making it public who they support politically. People come for baked goods, not to see who you're a fan of. Had I seen that before I ordered, I would have walked out. read more

Came here to pick up a few items for a birthday party and everything was great. We got the cannoli chipwich cake, rainbow cookie cupcake, cookie butter cupcake and some other assorted cookies. Everything was very tasty and very fresh. Staff was super friendly and quick. There is a large selection of different items and everything was both clean and presentable. Would absolutely come back. read more

Alpine Pastry Shoppe - Rainbow Cookie Cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

If you're from Long Island, you probably already know Alpine Bakery. And if you don't... this is your sign to go. This family-owned spot has been a go to in Smithtown forever, and it's where my family gets cakes and pies for pretty much every holiday. Birthdays, Christmas, Thanksgiving, Easter ... Alpine is just part of the tradition. You walk in and instantly feel like you're in a classic neighborhood bakery that's been doing things right for years. The selection is huge! Cakes in every flavor, cookies, pastries, pies, crumb cake, cheesecakes .... basically anything you could want. Everything is packed into the cases, and it's one of those places where you end up grabbing more than you planned because it all looks so good. The jelly donuts deserve their own shoutout. They're honestly incredible. Super soft, perfectly filled, and not overly sweet. If you like jelly donuts, these are a must-m order and worth the trip alone. Service is quick and so friendly, even when it's busy around the holidays. They know what they're doing, they move the line along, and everything comes out consistently great Alpine Bakery isn't fancy or trendy, it's just solid, dependable, and really good. The kind of place you grow up going to and keep coming back to as an adult. If you need a dessert for a holiday, a birthday cake, or just want a really good donut, Alpine is always a safe bet. read more

See all

Picked up pastries using too good to go. Very spacious bakery with a great variety of options, even on the walls. Some weird line-forming set up that isn't quite clear, but not worth taking a star away. Super great value using too good to go and great way to try pastries I wouldn't have tried before. Will definitely buy stuff from the store regularly read more

Alpine Pastry Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Sorry to leave a negative review......all the cases were filled with beautiful looking desserts ......The rum babka looked beautiful, but it was stale, dry, no rum and cannoli cream was dry along with the decorative icing. It was discarded shortly after tasting.......I was very disappointed...... my advice is that having the showcases filled is fine if the products are fresh and move fast, otherwise you are doing a disservice to your customers and your business. Freshness and taste is what makes customers return....and I have cancelled my order for the cannoli cake I will shop elsewhere. read more

After reading a mix of reviews, I had to try Alpine Pastry Shop for myself--and I'm glad I did. Everything I tasted, from the cookies to the pastries, was absolutely delicious. The service was friendly and efficient, making the experience even better. I noticed some controversy in the comments about the owner selling Trump and Melania cookies. Honestly, it didn't bother me in the slightest. In fact, I respect the owner for standing by his decision, even when some customers expressed outrage--I overheard one man in line saying he wouldn't return because of it. To me, it's just a cookie. I wouldn't be upset if they were selling Biden, Harris, or even Wallz cookies if that's what they chose to do. Some people are always going to be upset about something. But if you're there for quality pastries and solid service, this bakery delivers. I'd definitely recommend giving Alpine a try. read more

See all

When you go somewhere twice on a trip, it must mean it's a very good thing. It's like heaven when you walk in there. The bakery has anything you could imagine in the way of a cookie, pastry, or cake. I could have got one of everything if it didn't have calories..lol! The kids had vanilla cake pops and I shared a cinnamon cannoli crois-nut with my husband. It was soooooo good! We ended up going back and got a few different kinds of pastries the next day to share with our family. There was a strawberries and champagne cake we split among all of us that everybody enjoyed as well. The staff and service was wonderful when we went both times. They are so helpful and packaged our orders carefully. I will plan to go there if I'm in the area again. read more

See all

Stale cake horrible service. Don't waste your time Costco sells better cakes for 1/4 the price

This review is for a gluten free carrot cake. We have a cousin who can't eat gluten, and who loves carrot cake. My feeling was that the cake was good, not great. read more

Alpine Pastry Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

The service is terrible, always a line and the line moves very very slow. I went to place an order, stood on line for about 20 minutes, got to the counter and the lady who took me said you need to wait for the other lady since I don't take special orders, waited another 10 to 15 minutes before I could be helped. I placed my order and then a week later I picked it up, ordered 25 mini carrot cupcakes and several of these cupcakes were on its side so the presentation was not good at all. Will not be returning after years of going here. Disappointed with both the customer service and the presentation of my special order. Will find another bakery for my future occasions. read more

See all

The best, for miles around. Great recipes, truly incredible variety of baked goods. Reasonable prices. Good ingredients. Not garbage ingredients. I would've given 5 stars but Alpine (to my knowledge) isn't offering lower sugar versions of the offerings. I'd LOVE to see some baked goods with Stevia in them...and not so much sugar. Not everyone can handle the high amounts of sugar in many baked goods (not just at Alpine). But on the positive side, great staff, quick service and they're a local business (keeps the money in the community, I feel). Alpine doesn't disappoint. read more

Good bakery selection. Rainbow cookie cheesecake is my favorite here. Can get crowded.

ALPINE PASTRY SHOPPE 59 Route 111 Smithtown NY has TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE!!! I WILL NOT SHOP HERE EVER AGAIN. They shipped me the wrong cookies & then wanted to charge me to send the "Correct Cookies" with a "Discount". Complete Lack of Accountability & Customer Service. I will not be going to Alpine Pastry Shop ever again. There are plenty of other pastry shops that provide good customer service. This happened on May 14, 2026 read more

I would give zero stars if I could. Girl behind the counter wasnnot very knowledgeable about items.She had to keep going in back room to ask questions. I bought a cannoli chipwich cake a a very small crumb cake maybe 9x9. It cost $62.00. I would say both items were stale. The cannoli cake was falling apart as I cut it. Crumb cake extremely dry and loaded with powdered sugar. I will not be going back to Alpine. read more

Yet another cake ordered and it was not what I asked for. I have come here on and off for 50 years because of the cake variety but the few times it was wrong I got nowhere. All I asked was for the cake to be redone and it was refused. So why do I bother this time? I ordered an expensive cannoli cake w HEAVY rum for Mother's Day. I was embarrassed because family and guests said the cake was dry and there was zero rum. I tasted a slice and it was dry. A small speck of rum at the center bottom of the cake. I will find another bakery. I spend a lot of money at bakeries so perhaps o find someone to take my money who can make a cake to order and not give me a hard time if they get it wrong. Generally good cakes but poor service when they get it wrong. read more

I came to this shop because it was highly recommended to me. I was looking for pastries for my sisters bridal shower. The lady up front was not friendly at all. She rushed me and kept saying "what else" instead of giving me a minute, it being my first time there. She grabbed the cupcakes and ruined their shape, threw them in the box instead of placing them in there so they wouldn't jam up against each other. Her hands were covered in the frosting, that the box is so dirty. Very disappointed as a first time visitor and I'm not sure I'd like to come back. read more

See all

I was going somewhere in the area where Alpline was. I decided to go in. I ordered cupcakes and they were awful. They cake was dry like it was made a few days ago. They also had Trump cookies. That was a turn off. I will stick with Benkerts for now on. read more

Be still my beating heart.... Alpine still has the cronuts that everyone still seems to obsess over. Alpine still has great baked goods and they never miss the mark. The reason for the 4 is sometimes they're too busy chatting with each other and not helping customers OR moving at a snail's pace around the bakery. Such is life and it's still a good bakery. Still the same look for god knows how long but still good bakery goods. If you need some pastries or Italian bread or a cake from a bakery look no further when you're in the area. read more

Giving 4 stars bc only have tried the chantilly cake. Was next store at the jbbq and came to get a get for a bday celebration. The writing wasn't fancy like other places but the cake was good. Would def go back for other goodies next time read more

BEST DESSERTS EVER !!!!! The rainbow cookie donuts are amazing and I love the cronuts

The variety of delicious pastries is unbelievable. If only I had more time on Long Island, I'd be 10 pounds heavier because I need to work my way through trying everything at least once! Of the items I tried; lobster tail, cannoli, Napoleon, black and white cookie and lemon coconut cupcake, the cannoli and lobster tail were the best! These items were so good that I hauled them back to Cali. The bakery sold me unfilled shells and put the filling in a pastry bag for me. I had planned to bring some goodies back so I packed a small cooler with ice packs for the plane ride. It worked out perfectly! The filling for the lobster tail was lusciously creamy which is our favorite. The cannoli filling is also perfect for us; not too sweet, a few chocolate chips and a hint of nutmeg. Maybe that's the spice? The cannoli shell was also nice and thin. If only I lived closer! read more

See all

I've been going to this bakery for years. Everything is always fresh and the staff is always nice and very efficient. The cakes and cookies are excellent as is the jelly and glazed donuts. They also make fantastic Italian pastries in both large and small sizes. The bakery has 3 large counters to display everything as well as bread racks and an area for "breakfast stuff". The lines can be long at holiday times but you never have to wait as long as the line looks. read more

Omg do I really have words not really because my mouth is stuffed!! Ugh the custom Trump cake AMAZING!! But the cookies the cupcakes the cake pops ugh I can't!! A million stars drove 45 min but worth every minute! read more

Alpine Pastry Shoppe - 3 yr old nephew obsessed with Trump so this was one of the cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

This place always seems to have a line out the door no matter what time you go. Based off of that alone you know it's gonna be worth the wait! There are so many things to love at this bakery but my personal favorites are the cannoli cronut and the brownies. Both are dangerous!!! read more

This place really fell off. I went there a couple months ago and was very disappointed with their pastries. I figured it was just a bad day for them. Well, I went there last week and it wasn't any different. I've literally had better pastries from Stop & Shop for a fraction of the cost. read more

Birthday cake was completely overpriced. They kept adding to the original price. Even $6.00 extra for chocolate fudge on the outside. Think I will switch to another bakery next time. read more

What happened to this place?! Once my favorite .. pastries aren't fresh!! I'm not overpaying for 2 days old pastries!! It's unacceptable !! I'm seeing other similar complains Not cool making all that money with no quality!! You should be embarrassed It's criminal!! read more

URGENT!!! 9/23/24 - About 6 hrs. after I wrote the review below. I failed to MENTION THAT WE JUST ATE The VERY BEST COOKIES THAT WE EVER HAD!!! Pls See the Pics!! The red ones were stellar Thank Goodness for Alpine Bakery! They are always there when you need them ~ great hours for the customers. I've been a customer for over 25 years? - or for as long as they've been open. They are always working so hard and that's why they never Disappoint! Every single dessert is Amazing. Beware: Their Rainbow cookies can be addictive. Today I ran in to grab a slice of their flourless chocolate cake for my man! lol It's almost his birthday.. I finally figured out why he loves that from Alpine... It's because without the flour you get a lot more chocolate!! read more

Alpine Pastry Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Amazing amazing amazing service! I was helped by Sylvester and my interaction with him alone was more than enough for me to fall in love with this adorable bakery. He really is a gem--so patient and so kind. Glad to know that the people working are just sweet as the delicious treats sold here! read more

Alpine Pastry Shoppe - counter - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I do not purchase cannoli as they are usually too sweet and very dry. The Alpine's cannoli were delicious. The texture and the taste are perfect. I can't wait to have them again. read more

Never been inside the location, but for a recent dinner someone brough over the rugelach and it was the best I ever had. They told me the line to get in the place during holidays can be intimidating but based on product they bake, I can definitely see why. On my list for an in person visit. read more

I honestly didn't know what the hype was about this Bakery, and especially after my first experience with customer service here I vowed to never return. I never wanted to write a negative review based on customer service and some cupcakes so I didn't. Which brings me to today. I was in need of a Sugar Free Cheesecake and my first choice was Cheesecake Factory, who made it very clear they do not have the best Sugar Free Cheesecake so I started searching for a last minute Sugar Free Cheesecake and Alpine is the one who had it, it was so close to home and I had no other options but to support this business, that I vowed not to. Well I'm glad that I did. Customer Service was better this time around, the aroma of sweets when you walk in was breath taking and the line was moving fast. I ordered this Sugar Free Cheesecake not knowing what it was going to taste like, and when I tell you that this Sugar Free Cheesecake taste better then any regular cheesecake I have ever had in my life. I knew I had to write a review to rave and brag about this delicious Sugar Free Cheesecake. I will be returning in the near future to support this business when it comes to Sugar Free Cheesecake. read more

Alpine Pastry Shoppe - Sugar Free Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I would like to give it 5 stars but they were out of a few things I wanted, but I did go in late so it's understandable. The Apple Turnovers were delicious as well as the Blueberry and Raspberry Crumb Squares. Service was good and as far as decor. it's a bakery were you see Enron display. Ciao for Now. read more

Okay, STOP THE PRESSES! Because their vanilla and chocolate funfetti cakes are some of my favorite birthday cakes EVER! They are the perfect blend of sweet and flavor, and taste as a birthday cake should. I also absolutely love that this bakery allows you to order cakes through Door Dash at a reasonable price and will even write on them through the instructions in the app. Definitely helps in a pinch! I do love this bakery, but trying to come during a busy time or even a moderately crowded time and it's incredibly chaotic in there. It is worth it, though... give the funfetti cake a shot!!! read more

My family has been coming here since I can remember. Every holiday and birthday has been Alpine. They are always amazing. This year I had cake done for my daughter's Baptism! It was absolutely stunning, delicious and fresh! They did a fantastic job! Outstanding!!! read more

Alpine Pastry Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Always a line out the door, that's how you know it's good! Delicious cakes,pastries, and more, always a must!

I had to score higher because the issue was corrected immediately. I ordered a cupcake cake which was made of 50 cupcakes, and I provided a photo. This cake was for a baby shower. When I arrived, the photo was the size of a postage stamp and the cake was not decorated at all, no flowers, no trim, no nothing. I was about to freak out. I came all the way out from Bay Shore for this. I explained that this was not as expected and the staff offered decorative ideas and fixed the cupcake cake to my liking and saved the day. But I'll never go all the way out there again. read more

Alpine Pastry Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York