Best German buttery cake. My discerning wife loved it The service was great Nice small bakery with tons of delicious fresh goodies read more

Fritzsche's is celebrating 100 years in business in 2026. Your to-go box is likely to be wrapped in the string hanging from the original holder from the ceiling. Fritzsche's is rather bare bones in the interior but focuses on quality and efficiency in serving customers. The folks behind the counter were knowledgeable and welcoming. Generations of my family have gone here, and I finally went myself. The baking techniques are true to French cuisine. You will have a small upcharge for using a credit card. read more

See all

Albeit & Truth be told... Baker Mr.Fritzsche himself may be long gone but his legacy in and with itself has been an achievement in the world of the local bakery's fair that Mr. Fritzsche has transpired what the ole time Bakery's represent not to just the remediate and underlying nieberhoods in Sayville on Long Island be it in the State of Ny... but including and beyond the underlying area..!. No in actuality his underlying with His Bakery achievement has put in place competitions that to this day some 50 something years after his door primarily opened up ... His legacy has continued and will into the millennial futures to behold... Et al and etc etc etc Albeit I fair him Well - for Heaven needed great bread as well... read more

Fritzsche's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Sayville, New York

This is a fabulous bakery with a great variety of goodies!! Their rolls, pastries and cookies are always fresh and so yummy! If you haven't visited this bakery, give them a try! You won't be disappointed! Karen .......Bayport read more

Everything is always super fresh. From their pastries to their cakes, park in the back and go through the back entrance, kind of hard to find, but behind to the east of the garage. read more

We have been back a few times now and all I can see is we have found our new go-to bakery spot! The highlights: The Boston cream is the best I've ever had. The perfect ratio of doughnut to cream. It's a dream. We loved the black and white cookie cake. The strawberry Boston cream cake is divine. My husband loves their leaf cookies which they get bonus points for carrying. My daughter's favorite are the small rainbow cookies. Staff is always so friendly. I'd love to see some gf cake options too in the future! read more

This is an amazing old school bakery. I was living in Sayville during Covid and LOVED walking to this bakery. They have amazing pastries, donuts, cookies and breads. It is a family run bakery and it shows in the love and care they give to their customers. read more

Rude staff. Got some donuts, they were ok. They yell at you if you touch or lean on the counter and they shove a sign in your face!

My favorite bakery to go to the moment I visit home. This is located on the cute Main Street of Sayville. I grew up in the area and having these baked goods my whole life. The best cookies and donuts I've ever had. I can't recommend how great everything tastes and the quality of the ingredients. There is a ton of different flavors and types of all baked goods for you to choose from! read more

Fritzsche's Bakery - Entrance - Bakeries Near Me - Sayville, New York

Exceptional freshly baked breads, rolls,pastries, cookies, cakes, etc. You can enjoy the smells upon entry. Staff are mostly friendly. Pricing is competitive, and there is ample parking in front as well as rear of the building with a rear entrance. They also brew up fresh hot coffee. We prefer our holiday bread and cakes here. They are some with expertise and dedication to your liking. A must try if your visiting town.they have so many take away items for a quick sweet treat. Centrally located to LIRR,parking. read more

Super cute bakery. Loved the Dream bar and German butter cake. Operation was sparkling clean and efficient. Would definitely go back as I was limited in what I could purchase because I have so much bakery at home already. read more

See all

Goodness, after the 30 years plus I have been going there, it is still one of the best bakeries around! The German butter cake is my favorite! I love the unique building and the workers are so helpful and nice. When my kids were younger, on half days during school, afterwards I would take them there to purchase cupcakes, then drive to the airport to watch the planes take off, when you were allowed to on Ronkonkoma Avenue. Great memories when I hear this bakery's name! I hope this gem stays around for many years. Bless you for have amazing and delicious items to purchase! read more

I come here almost every Sunday for rainbow cookies. They have the best rainbow cookies I have ever had. Everything is super fresh and the staff is always so pleasant if I could give 100 stars I would read more

Fritzsche's Bakery - the front of the bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Sayville, New York

Wonderful apple-pear gallette. Also, wonderful Italian bread. I'm going back to get more. And I'm driving from Queens. That should tell you everything. read more

The Quick: Buttery, doughy, heavenly desserts that sell out quickly on weekend mornings. The Details: The jelly donuts are probably some of the best I've ever had. Even better is this fantastic butter bun cake (not the official name) covered in brown sugar. Everything taste as good as it looks, so try a few different items. Crumb cake is great, cinnamon twists are a hit... I've never been disappointed. Long live carbs! The Damage: Very reasonable read more

The staff was incredibly rude--I was completely taken aback. Further, the pastries were dry, stale, and didn't taste any better than grocery store-bought items. Very disappointed and would not recommend. read more

Love it there. Not the cheapest but definitely worth it. The jelly donuts are unreal.

While the food is outstanding at this bakery, the service is awful. I will never go there again. It's as if you are bothering the woman at the counter when you ask for something. In order for this business to be successful, I think it's best that the woman who is always behind the counter move to a back end position that doesn't deal with people because she is quite rude. I have seen her treat others this way on previous visits, and this weekend I experienced it firsthand. SO disappointed. read more

A must place for anything that they have here !!!! Anything we have tried has been absolutely awesome, their butter cookies are second to none. read more

Honestly you can't go wrong with anything from here. I love that you can really tell everything is homemade and the workers are always great and friendly. We come about once a week to get a fresh loaf of bread and some fun pastries! read more

See all

Most amazing local bakery. Everything looked so delicious when I walked in - on just kept ordering: dozen donuts, crumb cake, black & white cookies, huge chocolate chip & sprinkled butter cookies.. Everything was amazing! I especially loved the Boston cream donut & tollhouse style, oversized cookie. read more

A great bakery! Great friendly service and fresh options. We couldn't decide so got one of most and they were all great!

WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE EVER. I called about a donation to a scholarship that would go to a Sayville HS Senior that's pursuing a "helping profession." So I've been canvassing businesses and calling to see who would be interested in donating either merchandise or a gift card. I call and ask for the manager, a woman says can I take your name and number down and have her call you back? and I said sure, so she says hold on one second and puts me on hold, then another woman gets on and says hello? so I said "Is this the manager?" and she said "Yes" so then I get into my conversation about the scholarship, she cuts me off and says "Can we cut to the chase? I have a long line and don't have time for this!" I was appalled and immediately said "You know what, never mind, have a great day" and she said "Yeah, thanks bye!" Totally as if I was an inconvenience to her. The original girl said she would take my name and number which was fine but then you put the manager on so I was expecting she wanted to hear what I had to say. Meanwhile, we are handing out the business cards of those that donate at our basket raffle event so she lost herself free press. Whoever the owner or manager is I will pray for you because you have a very mean spirit. Just look at the other comments complaining about the service. Never was a customer here and NEVER WILL BE. Audrey's Bakery for the win. read more

One if my co-workers brought in a butter cake from the place and it phenomenal. I think I ate half of the thing. It had like a sweet butter glaze on top of a soft flakey cake. So delicious. I had to go look at this place on my own. I will admit that I came here kind of late, but being from New York City I knew most of the stuff was gonna be gone. I got a cinnamon twist donut, boston cream, and a coconut pastry. Ohhhh my God. These were good if not better than the butter cake. They were all soft, sweet and delicious. It wasn't overly sweet but just the right amount. They were definitely cooked the morning of and had a quick turn over. Which means this place is amazing. The Boston cream was soft and creamy. They could've added more of the cream but it was perfect for the amount of soft pastry they had. The cinnamon twist was good. Same as previously stated it was soft and tasty. The coconut pastry was sooooooo good. It had a similar pastry but on top of that pastry was like a roasted coconut icing that was the perfect icing to pastry ratio. Definitely worth the try. Hopefully next time I will have the opportunity to drop by and get a fresh butter cake. Just an FYI, to the other reviewers that gave this place a bad score. These bakery owners come in early in the morning and bake their stock of goods for the day. What ever they have left towards the end of the day is what they have. They are not cooking during the day so they will not churn out new stuff just to waste their fresh stuff they just baked. read more

Not very friendly or accommodating. Not a great selection. Bakery items left out on counter for anyone to sneeze on. Drive a few minutes down the road to Audrey's. read more

Great pastries and bread! So fresh and delicious! Ugh! Wish it were open 24/7 honestly

One of my favorite bakery's on Long Island. Try their Pecan Danish! The onion rolls are also awesome. It's cash only and they sell out of things quick. Definitely go early in the morning. read more

Fritzsche's Bakery - Pecan Danish!!! SO GOOD! - Bakeries Near Me - Sayville, New York

Worth the 45 minute drive to pickup some donuts. Some people think I am crazy, but they are fantastic!! read more

All around amazing! Such great pastries and amazing service!! I find myself going here a little too often ;)

What is available is great, needs more cakes, the breads and doughnuts are fantastic. German butter cake....mmmm

VERY disappointing.... What's the point of having your doors open until 3pm, if there's nothing on your shelves after Noon? The place looked horrible - every case was empty... a few tired, sad, lonely loaves of bread on the back shelves... I'm sure their pastries are very good (based upon reviews), but that's not helpful if you don't have any to sell - I get that it's popular, but good business says you make enough product. If they don't want to produce a larger inventory, they should just close the doors at noon. Wasted 45 minutes trying to find them, only to walk out completely empty handed 3 hours before closing time. read more

I mean anyone on the island knows Briermere has the best pies. I went to Fritzches and was proven wrong. The Apple pie is unreal and it is under $10. It's almost impossible to believe. Can't wait to grab some pastries before breakfast tomorrow and just be warned...get there early or you will miss out. These things go like wildfire! read more

So happy it has reopened, and the baked goods are beyond delicious. We used to drive all the way to Stanley's for our rolls and cakes, and now we have a classic bakery right in town. Best of luck to the new owners. read more

An institution. Best Jelly Donuts in the world. Support this long time local business. Walk over with your Starbuxxx from across the street if you must, and at least buy your pastries here. read more

I've been coming here every so often for 20 plus years and the service has generally been slow. It reminds me of bakeries in the former Soviet Union where you're forced to wait on a long line in stark surroundings and then take whatever is available. While their products are pretty good, they usually run out of bread and rolls before noon and haven't given thought to baking a second run like the other bakeries manage to do. So when Fritzsche's customers come in and find the shelves bare, then they go to Audrey's, Mondello's or Panera Bread, right? read more

Guess I got there too late....there wasn't even a layer cake in the store I got there around 1:00...but I read the reviews I guess I have to get there earlier! Dosen't look like much from the outside but Ill go earlier and check it out read more

Went in to get directions for a nearby restaurant for a luncheon and was overcome by heavenly bakery scents! They are a cash only business and was thrilled when I realized I had some cash on me since I knew I didn't want to leave empty handed! I had a sugared jelly doughnut that was exactly how I remembered them from my childhood - can't believe I ate it before my luncheon - it was so worth it and I'll will be back for more! The staff was incredibly helpful and so nice! So happy I got lost in Sayville! read more

Just had pecan ring which used to be a favorite from here. It used to be fluffy but plain with great texture and taste. The top had large pecans and just enough glaze. Now it's flatter, inside is dense with artificial taste of cinnamon and has small pecans that don't have much taste. Truly disappointed. If you can't keep the perfected recipe, you should change name on store also. By the way, 1st time a hair was found in pecan ring in all these years. Will not crave this one any more read more

Best bakery around by far! Get there early, the good stuff goes quick!

Whenever I visit my family in Sayville a morning visit to Fritzche's is a MUST! There's nothing like their jelly donuts and fresh rolls. All of their products are fantastic but those two are a must! The location is small and it can get very crowded after Sunday mass gets out or on a holiday, so get there early! read more