I feel deprived, I've never had a donut from here before. Our buddy told us that we had to give them a try and we were next door so we decided to stop in. The donuts are filled, soft, and delicious. Our fave was the cannoli filled donut. Wow! Staff is super friendly, and they offered to prepare any donuts that weren't in the case. Can't wait to come back for sandwiches, we heard they are delicious too. There's plenty of parking outside and lots of space inside for waiting. read more

See all

Today I ventured in for my very favorite Boston Cream doughnut. It's fluffy and soft, filled with just the right amount of that overflowing light yellow cream. OMG, heaven on earth. Enticing you as soon as you walk through the doors with those amazing smells. The service was very friendly with a smile. read more

Prestano Bakery - Boston Cream - Bakeries Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

See all

What happened to this bakery used to have the best Italian bread on Long Island used to go to the one in Selden since 1960 also, this one in Ronkonkoma for many years the bread is no better than supermarket right now very disappointed. I made a special trip when I came up from Florida just to get the bread again buried disappointed. read more

First let me say they used to be an Italian bakery. They now sell bagels and Boars head sandwiches, more like a Deli. Ordered Biscotti and other cookies, Biscotti had no taste at all waste of money. La Roma Pastry Shop on Sunrise Hwy is the best. read more

1 pumpernickel bagel with light cream cheese and a med coffee for $7.00 and the bagel was an average bagel. Won't be back.

The young lady behind the counter (sorry I didn't get your name but you had dark wavy hair & glasses) was so kind after I explained I had never been there before. It was Christmas Eve and the whole crew was happy and giggling! The place smelled amazing, I was overwhelmed by all the choices, the breads looked heavenly and overall the name of this bakery has been in my head for years but I could never find it. Finally I did and it was so worth it! Ask a question and it's like you are the only customer in the room! What was even nicer was the fact she was kind enough to tell me about all the cookies! I felt a sugar rush standing there hearing about them! But I only got 1&1/2 pounds of three kinds: jelly filled butter cookies dipped in chocolate with holiday sprinkles , Pfeffernüsse clouds from heaven and another chocolate crispy favorite I ate on the way home in traffic. I have to also admit I am very picky about my rainbow cakes and this one - pictured - was worth hiding from my husband as I walked in the door. I didn't care how much it was, I wish I could have one every day of the week! The fudge, the right amount of filling and the airy layers made it the best I have ever had. Considering I've had a few even ones sent to me from outside the US. Not only was it a gift I gave my waistline, I'd go again in a heartbeat to see the crew, enjoy the atmosphere but most of all pick up a treat or two! If you have not been here - get here asap! Traditions are alive in this hometown gem! Happy Holidays! read more

Prestano Bakery - The greatest Rainbow Cookie Cake this side of heaven! - Bakeries Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

Came in asked for a bacon egg and cheese spk on an egg everything... received an egg everything with scrambled eggs and a half a bottle of ketchup... called got pushed off like it was nothing came back for my replacement sandwich its burnt eggs with a plain bagel crusty old cheese no spk ... Pretty disappointed been a customer here for 10 years read more

I Jared Troccoli had spent $78 on a cake to be prepared for a friend's party and it was a 2 layer half Cannoli and half butter cream filled cake the bakery did not have the appropriate size box for it and due to unstable fitting the top part of the cake and the flowers decorated on it were ruin which caused major embarrassment for me at the party very unprofessional and I will never buy from bakery again read more

You need to have their donuts. If you like jelly donuts this is the spot. I've never been disappointed by their tasty goods but it's all about the donuts for me. read more

Absolute best egg sandwiches in the area, come here everyday and the egg sandwich tastes the exact same every time. The donuts are just as good as well. Do not pay attention to the bad reviews on here, probably just some mope having a bad day being pissed off at the world. Really awesome customer service too. read more

Worst bakery/bagel store Ive ever been too. I waited 10 minutes on line because there were 2 employees making deli sandwiches and egg sandwiches at which I thought was a bakery but apparently its a deli too. Anyway, my wife had a cake from there a few years ago which she loved so I thought id surprise her with a cake from there for her birthday. I got a cake and some pastries and since they sold bagels I got one of those too. Let me tell you, everything was hard and disgusting. Cinnamon raisin bagel was a square and hard. The cake stale, tasted like it was sitting around for weeks same as the pastries, now I dont know if this is a bakery, a bagel store a deli or what but seems like its horrible at all 3. The owner should be embarrassed. I spent over $70 there for a bunch of garbage. read more

Got a chocolate fudge cake for my brother's 75th Birthday celebration dinner. Not only was it tasteless but stale. Paid $26 for it and $4 each slice for restaurant to serve it. I wouldn't mind the $32 to serve if the cake was delicious. Next time I'll take the trip to Dortoni or Alpine. Maureen Ronkonkoma read more

Very clean bakery. But also offers breakfast, great food, service is usually very quick. Eggs sometimes not cooked to order but overall great place read more

Why is so much lost in conversation, it's like they're not even paying attention. Called and ordered a birthday cake, called twice after to confirm. When we drove 25 min to get to this bakery the cake we ordered was not there according to the staff. Then after about 20 min we're told no the cake is there just not the special decorations that we ordered and paid for. We were very sad and disappointed. It was a lot of aggravation which if they were honest and upfront could have been overlooked. The cake tasted nice enough. Was way smaller then ordered and in a box that didn't fit so it was sliding around and the sides smooshed before we even got to the party. They called a half hour after we left to say they found our cake? At this point we'd wasted more then an hour. So sad I was so hopeful read more

The pastries where extremely stale.. the fruit was dried out, the cream and pastry itself was hard..and if that wasn't enough, there were fingerprints in 2 of my eclairs. when I called there were no managers around and the girl "wasn't sure" if the owner was there. After a brief hold a guy came on to ask what was wrong (acting like the owner perhaps) it was actually just the other coworker. read more

I've been to a lot of bakeries before but this is one of the best ones! The donuts are off the charts and the staff was awesome. I can't wait to go back read more

I don't even like cannolis, but I love theirs! They have a great variety of items it's hard to choose without buying everything. It keeps you coming back to try the next item, there all very good. Fresh & good quality read more

Tried their donuts would have to say some of the best i ever had.Would highly recommend and enjoy.

So yummy. Wish the cookies were a tad bit bigger with more jelly but as far as an italian bakery goes, it's a winner

Went in this morning to pick my order up. Staff is rude I must say. I called up ahead of time for a pick up order it was only one item a bagel with cream cheese the man who picked up the phone said thats it and I said yes he seemed annoyed and made a huff . Ok well I go in to pick my bagel up and the man says "your bagel isn't ready yet he's still making it. It takes him about 25 min to make a bagel" we both workers laugh. So obviously these 2 who were working had their balls in a twist tht I called in a bagel and made a sarcastic joke . I didn't rlly appreciate that comment as it was unnecessary and I got bad vibes already on the phone . For the workers to indirectly say something about the customer is disgusting! The pastries aren't even that good please don't waste your time . read more

For what it's worth... this Prestano is pretty solid. I mean the one by me closed and there's really no bakery around which kinda sucks. I mean really sucks! Every time I come in hardly ever do I have to wait too long if at all and I'm in and I'm out. I still have yet to try their Cheesecake but we've had their cookies and Italian bread and it takes care of our needs. He he. I feel like bakeries are dying which is ridiculously upsetting to me. I know call me old fashioned but bakeries in food stores and Costco and BJs don't cut it for this old soul. Nothing beats a pot of fresh sauce, raviolis, some meatballs, braciole or sausage and some crusty Italian bread. So for now I can only hope that this Prestano's stays open and doesn't close up shop anytime soon. If they do close... we're screwed!!! read more

Last year we went there to specifically order a Buttercream Sheet Cake with Choc cake and Rasberry filling for my daughters Graduation Party. My daughter drove 30 min each way to pick it up. We had over 100 people and after she cut the cake we realized it was not Buttercream but a fake Whip Cream called "Better Cream." We had no choice but to serve it although no one enjoyed it but we had no other option. The next day when I called them to complain The owner told me "bring it back" otherwise he couldn't do anything about it. The worst Customer Service ever! Avoid at all costs! I will never go back! read more

I have been coming here for years & I have never had a problem Until the NEW STAFF came to work here. the woman wit the black hair "what rude woman Rolling her eyes like im annoying her just because i'm ordering bagels c'mon lady next time be nice you are rude and I will never come back ! read more

I enjoy apple pies, turnovers, etc. My daughter bought an apple horn pastry at Prestano's yesterday. It was excellent. Flaky pastry, some sugary crumbs on top, and best of all plenty of apple filling. I find most bakeries skimp on the filling so you get a little bit of apple but mostly pastry crust. This one was truly the best I've ever had. read more

Horrible horrible horrible!!!!! We live about 4 min walking distance and every dessert I have eaten from there is either taste SPOILED, it's not baked thorough or the it's running of water. They say they bake their stuff everyday, BS!!!! Will never order from there again read more

With the word "bakery" over the door, I didn't expect my $10 ham sandwich to be on a stale roll. The potato salad that came with it? Tasted horrible AND was room temperature. They don't refrigerate salads with mayonnaise? Dangerous and disgusting. Even the ordering and paying process was disjointed. My first time there, and the last. I hope the deli in that shopping center re-opens REAL soon. In the meantime? Skip this place for lunch... read more

I never saw this bakery open and running until this week. Of course, I gotta check it out (even if I'm not a baked goods lover - just a devoted ice cream enthusiast) The place is small, but it has the typical bakery cookies, breads, and such. I decided to go for a vanilla cupcake and red velvet cupcake. I was pretty hesitant because they didn't look that delicious. I also got this humungO horse shoe shaped cheese strudel. How good? or bad? Let's have a taste: Cupcakes - I've had wayyyy better cupcakes in my life. Including week old unrefrigerated stale cupcakes. Strudel - first bite was forgettable, but after a couple bites you keep reaching for it? Not very sweet and kind of addicting. Something good with coffee in the morning. I will return to have another try at other goodies. Hope is still there! read more

See all

This bakery is known for its cookies, bread and cheesecake not its cupcakes so if you venture here for the right items you will love it. I have been going to this bakery since I was 3 and always love to visit it now and again. The chocolate-chip butter cookies, whole wheat italian bread (Tuesdays only) and apple crumb are delicious. Happy eating! read more

Relatively small selection in my opinion. Bagels, rolls, cookies are all pretty good. Cakes are just mediocre. Average bakery, I wish they had more to choose from. Also, I sometimes question the freshness of some items. read more

Went there twice recently. First purchased cake was ok. Next was disgusting. Chocolate pudding pie. Brought it for a dessert and was embarrassed as it went into the garbage. Didn't taste like chocolate but did taste like lemon. It had something seriously wrong with it. I thought we'd have food poisoning from tasting it. NEVER AGAIN will I deal with them. read more

My friend that is a good customer of this Prestano bakery on Johnson Ave was very upset because while she was being responsible wearing a mask and gloves and the store had signs up about social distancing they let the small store fill up with people instead of only letting 2 people in at a time. She was very upset and when she said something the guy behind her started laughing and the store owner did nothing about it. Shame on them. The sweets are good but not that good that I want to die for. Poor management won't go back read more

A great bakery especially for Suffolk County! ! Alpine in Smithtown is #1. Prestano may be #2. The breads are great. Cakes are really good. Best Jelly Doughnuts in New York!!!! Prices very reasonable. read more

This is by far the best bakery on Long Island!!! Every time we drive back to LI to visit we have to stop and get their food!!

My sons 5th Birthday cake came out awesome! They also have great breakfast pastries and their prices are very reasonable.

Bought 2 grilled cheese with bacon on an everything bagels an it came out to $17.00 wtf are they insane an when I brought it up they didn't know what to say one girl agreed with me the others just look at me like I had 3 heads read more

I love this bakery. I love how they make fresh products every morning. They are really fast to help their customers with what exactly they want and need. They are very clean and respectful. I love this bakery. And their new renovation was much needed. Looks amazing! read more

This is a small mom and pop shop with all baking done on premise. You make your own coffee. They serve breakfast and lunch. The bake goods are good! read more

Terrible tasting bakery cookie trays, also rainbow cookies, and small cake bites, subpar and expensive, pick rolls and bread instead.

Delectable cheesecake! Small and a little pricey but still very good.

I was in a last minute rush last week to find something sugar free for my boyfriend's birthday and he was only diagnosed diabetic a month and a half ago. So I dont know the best places yet. I called local bakeries and most had some cookies, but I wanted a cake, it was his birthday after all! I called Prestanos and they said they didnt have cakes but had cookies, apple turnovers and cheesecake. Well cheesecake is a cake right?! So I ran down there and first off all of their desserts look amazing. I had to stop myself from buying a cute 4 pack of meringue cookies. Purchased the cheesecake, which at $18 I thought was a bit expensive since it wasnt full size. BUT let me tell you, the taste of that sugar free cheesecake is out of this world. My bf was convinced I bought him a regular cake and I had to show him the sugar free note on the platter it came on. There's no crust, just a ny style cheesecake that is perfectly molded with no cracks, nice and firm but super creamy. And the flavor is just scrumptious!! I will absolutely start purchasing from them more often as I never really had before last week. I plan to get those meringues first lol read more