This is our absolute favorite local bagel spot. The inside is no frills; there is a long line during prime weekend hours but they always move through patrons quickly. The egg sammies hold up against any deli around - they always cook eggs perfectly to your liking and their rolls are super fresh. I don't bother to try any other local bagel places anymore because this place simply never misses. read more

I go in at least once a week. Every time I go there, the bagels are fresh and the coffee is hot. I normally get them with cream cheese - which is also very good. In short - a very nice, cozy friendly local bagel shop serving its best food. read more

PopppyseeeeeedDdDDdssssss M M Mmm Yo! so this is the place you wanna be at, Crack a dawning sun shining Ready to start your day With the chefs and g's at the poppyseeds Talkin small town history right here Savor the flavor Masterchef creations Exceptional customer service Anytime the day Anytime the year The bagels are fresh & the coffee is hot welcome to poppyseeds read more

We love poppy seed ! Get their bagels all the time. Their bagels are so good and consistent and my husband loves their egg sandwiches. Best bagels in centereach/selden. read more

A very community/family oriented bagel place! It's a great location. I have to bring my own almond milk, but I don't mind. They don't offer dairy free spreads, but we got this avocado on the bagel that was really fresh! read more

Poppy Seeds Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Centereach, New York

Service is slow. I asked for fried eggs I got scrambled eggs. Bagel wasn't that great. Not for nothing the owner should not be making bagels. read more

Growing up locally, Poppy Seeds has been my lifetime bagel store. A few months ago, new management took over and my experiences since haven't been great. Completely out of egg everything bagels before 10:30? I've never had that happen to me in the many years prior until last week. Sounds a tad silly, but the employee didn't mention "they'll be out in 5 minutes" or anything, and asked if I'd like something else. Shortly after, I heard a member of management (I presume) say 45 minutes. A bit mind-boggling when that's one of your most popular selections. I've heard former employees have transferred to another shop on Portion Road / Cenacle Road. I can assure you, the bagels, baked goods and sandwiches are identical. Sad to see a Centereach staple decline so rapidly. This is my first time leaving a yelp review, and had to make an account to let local customers know. read more

Great bagels, horrible coffee. Do yourself a favor and drive anywhere else for coffee. I went with a whole wheat bagel with jalapeño cream cheese. Bagel was delicious but I just can't get past the coffee. read more

Super clean & organized. Great service and food. Been going there for years. Never have we had a bad experience

Great bagels, usually fresh, warm, soft, and tasty. However, I wouldn't recommend getting anything else though sadly. Cream cheese tasted kinda sour the last 2 times and bacon egg and cheeses are severely lacking egg. Get a dozen bagels from here, bring it home and get your own cream cheese or eggs is my recommendation. Its kinda sad this isn't a 5 star review because years ago i swore this was the best bagel place on the island. read more

I've been giving this place a second chance lately, and perhaps I was too harsh before when it was undergoing management changes. They do have a lot of new items that they didn't have before. I still think it's a little pricy, and I miss when all the sandwiches came with a small juice, but the rolls are soft and my eggs are cooked the way I like them. All in all, it's a good place, the staff is very friendly and courteous, and the establishment is always clean and has a good atmosphere. read more

The person behind the counter had no one else on line and yet managed to get my order almost completely wrong. She did not toast the bagel, add salt pepper or butter and looked put off to have to work at the bagel store. P.s. just moved into the area and am looking for a local bagel shop, this is NOT the place. read more

Poppy Seeds Bagels - No salt, no pepper, no butter and the bagel wasn't toasted. Women behind the counter didn't give a crap - Bagels Near Me - Centereach, New York

I wish I would have written a review about a year ago for poppyseed, because this was always our number one go to for egg sandwiches and bagels. The first stop before any road trip or city adventure! I have noticed quite a change in quality recently and sandwiches today are pretty slim and had hardly any egg. The bagels are still good, but our favorite sandwiches are missing that special something they once had. read more

Poppy Seeds Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Centereach, New York

Place opens at 530, and has nothing available. You'd think the bagels would be ready or at the very least the coffee. I believe the staff is from the old Starthmore bagels on portion, same food taste. read more

My favorite bagel store. It beats nyc and other li bagels. Lots of staff. The line really moves.

Seriously the best bagel store. When you want a true NY Bagel store.. this is it. I was living in NH for nine years and I utterly missed this place. I'm glad I returned and the same people work the store. read more

Ordered pancakes & a breakfast bagel. Food was decent. Not bad if your looking for fresh bagels

Poppy Seeds is HANDS DOWN my favorite bagel store of all time. I have been coming here since I was a kid, and the bagels have only gotten better. This place is a hole in the wall in a strip mall that is completely hidden. The inside is definitely a little grungy, but the management is working to change that. They've recently added an ATM machine, a mounted flatscreen TV (unnecessary if you ask me), more signs to show the variety of menu options have popped up recently as well. The staff is always friendly, even when I show up at 6:15 in the morning. The bagel selection is tremendous- they've got all sorts of flavors and varieties. I always order the same thing; an egg bagel with scallion cream cheese and a medium coffee little half and half and sugar. The egg sandwiches are always perfectly cooked to order, too. If you're looking to try something new here, order a bagel with bacon and cream cheese (just trust me on this one). Overall, Poppy Seeds will always be my hometown favorite breakfast spot. read more

Poppy Seeds Bagels - Inside the restaurant. - Bagels Near Me - Centereach, New York

This is the best deli I've ever eaten at. Great service and great food. By far my favorite bagels and every other deli I go to I compare their bagels to Poppy Seeds and some come close but none are better. Even with a line out the door, I've still gotten my food in a few minutes and when there's no line it's almost right away even for large orders. When I call my order in for everyone at work is always ready by time I'm there and I work less than a mile away. read more

The Bagels are Huge and Delicious. We were traveling through from Virginia and stopped in for some authentic NY bagels and we were Highly Satisfied. Will be back when in NY again.Youngest daughter Loved the Rainbow colored bagels. Pumpernickel is always my Favorite. read more

Asked my husband to get me some home fries. He found this place on yelp and because the reviews were pretty decent he decides to try them out. I understand it was a bit later in the day but if fresh home fries were not available then the burnt dried ends you had available should not have been sold. These home fries were so dry, greasy, and tasted old and they were hard. It's so disappointing that an establishment would even consider selling these. This was literally what was left at the bottom of the barrel and should have been thrown away. read more

Poppy Seeds Bagels - Disgusting dry and oily. The darker parts are bits of dried potato. These home fries were not edible or salvageable - Bagels Near Me - Centereach, New York

I normally wouldn't get too heart felt over a bagel place. But this seems touching. I shall share my experience with y'all. I've gone into this bagel shop perhaps 5 times so far. Its always early morning and when I'm in the area. Every time I walk in, there seems to be a homeless person sleeping in the corner booth of the bagel shop. Now.. I have not asked anyone about it.. but I have just made the assumption. It seems that this individual stands outside all night, and when the bagel place opens, they allow this lady to come in and sleep in some heat in the corner? She seems to have just enough for a coffee to enjoy before her nap. Like I said, this is a complete assumption. Only reason I'm saying homeless is because she is always wearing the same clothing and carry's around a black plastic garbage bag. If this all being true, I have to say that is really sweet of the owners to allow an individual to stay in comfort. On the flip side, reviewing food wise. I've never had a problem with this place, minus the fact when you get eggs on your bagel, they default to Folded eggs. Kinda the same style eggs you'd get on a Egg sandwich from a fast food restaurant. Nothing wrong with the eggs. I mean I do watch as they crack the eggs and scramble them. Its just if you want Fried, Over Med, Sunnyside ETC. make sure you order the eggs that way. The bagels always seem to be fresh. Never had an awkward stale or harden bagel from there. They seem relatively quick on service. Yet I've only been in when they had a MAX of 3 extra orders ahead of mine. Still speedy. **THEY NOW ACCEPT DEBIT OR CREDIT** ($5.00 or more!) I'll continue to come to this place. You should try them out. I'm a sucker for egg sandwiches in the mornings. So for me to approve of this one is pretty extraordinary. read more

I've been coming to this bagel store for a VERY long time. Just recently I think they either have changed owners or had someone come in to cut down on things in order to save money because their egg sandwiches are very plain and thin now they used to be the best egg sandwiches on the island. They raised their prices on EVERYTHING and now charge you if you don't have cash. A year ago I would have given this place 5 stars but ever since the price increase and the food not being what it used to be I had to rate it 3 stars. The staff is always very friendly and quick with your orders which I always appreciate. I still come here on occasion because it is convenient but am looking for another go-to bagel spot that isn't over priced or just worth the money! read more

When I eat a bagel anywhere else, I compare it to poppyseeds. I've been coming here for at least 15 years and it is by far the best bagel I've ever had. Their service is great and I've never disappointed. They make a damn good BLT too. Recently they made the switch to accept credit cards which was a smart move. read more

Just moved to the area and found this place. It's great! Food is great. Bagels are delicious and Heros are great. Stuff was friendly. Took my credit card( $10 min) everything was good. The only thing I didn't like was the chicken cutler hero. Way too much bread on the chicken. Anyway, a great local place and I will for sure be back read more

One of the better bagel places around! Good service, good selection of bagels, and they're always fresh. Neither the hot nor the iced coffee taste burnt (like at most bagel places). Just got an egg sandwich from here for the first time, and it did not disappoint. read more

Decided to pop in here while waiting for my car to be inspected. The food is just meh...nothing special. I got the ham and cheese omelet with whole wheat toast and hubby got the hungryman. The woman at counter had to be told that hungryman comes on a hero which is pretty amazing because anyone who knows delis knows thats standard. The food lacked the basic necessesity of salt and pepper. To me this place is ok if you just need a quick bite for breakfast but honestly i'd rather go across street to Burger King for breakfast. read more

I've been coming here for over 10 years. Old owners were amazing. New owners not so much. No idea what's going on here. Workers are pathetic. After multiple visits and them constantly messing up I still come. Today is the final time. After the employee gave my sandwich to the wrong person, that man came back in with it all opened. She proceeded to just hand it to me. Absolutely not. That is against every food code there is. Plus that's disgusting and even the man who gave it back told me demand a new one. After they remake it they completely got the order wrong. It's terrible. And I will make it know to multiple people that this place turned into a dump that doesn't even deserve one star. read more

I was very disappointed on my last visit to this bagel place. The bagels that I bought were undercooked and really doughy. I purchased a dozen and more than half did not even get eaten which is unusual when I bring bagels home. read more

Delicious bagel, friendly staff and clean establishment. Their competition doesn't seem to think it's that important to clean! I'll be back here for sure. read more

Idk. I want to like it. But every time I "try it again" the bagel isn't good, or the cream cheese, and today they handed me a hot bagel w cream cheese on it. Ew. My boyfriend loves them. Maybe its me. read more

Very consistent egg sandwiches which makes a big difference to me. Good prices. Soft bagels. Seems to be the staple bagel store in the neighborhood. read more

Every time we come to visit family on Long Island, we make multi visits to poppy seeds! So worth the drive! The everything eggs are a personal favorite! read more

Had bacon and egg on a bagel. It was made exactly to order, but was average at best. The service was excellent. A little dirty.

Delivery is horrible , they never get everything right ! I ordered two orders of food and a coffee and they assumed I wanted my ice teas to be in replace of my coffee in response to there error they are charging me me for the ice teas and told me to be more clear when I order , if I'm not mistakened the ice teas come with the order regardless . Do not deliver it's your fault if it's wrong ! read more

This place was better before it was sold to the new owner. The prices on everything have gone up, while they give you less for your money. Breakfast sandwiches used to come with a small OJ, now you have to pay extra for that. Their coffee isn't very good, so we usually just don't get anything with the sandwich. I used to go in there everyday, but not any more. They also leave the packaged goods out for sale way beyond their expiration date. Makes you wonder what else is being used past the expiration date... Although I used to be a daily customer, if I needed to use my credit card to pay but my order was under 10.00, they charged me an additional .50 cents... really?? I'm in here EVERY DAY! Or at least I used to be... The employee's are all very nice, to bad the owner is so greedy. read more

Love their variety of bagels and freshness. Has great sandwiches! Definitely the number one spot for me!

Stale Food! Want proof? Check out the cookies on the counter. If you see a date on them, it is fresh, if instead you see smeared ink where the date should be - then you know they are past the "Best By" date. That is so wrong! Also, take a look at the chocolate bars - they melted during the summer (there's no A/C in there, so it gets very hot) - you can see someone handled them, and when it got colder again, the chocolate re-hardened in a "smushed" form. Gross! Make you wonder what else they serve that's past it's expiration date... things that you don't get to see (ingredients for the bagels, perhaps the cream cheese??) I used to go here everyday, but got turned off by the new owners idea of selling bad food to make a dollar. read more

The last 3 times I've gone, the same girl helped me and my food has been burnt to a crisp each time. I am never going back. 3 times my food has been inedible. read more

First time here it was a friendly environment but my order didn't come the way i asked which included hash browns and instead they gave me home fries which is a big difference considering i dont like those but other than that everything was fine read more